How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
In 2024 we prepared a feasibility study for a beet-sugar cooperative's processing equipment project in Crookston, Minnesota, financed through the USDA Business and Industry (B&I) guaranteed loan program with a regional agricultural bank as lender. The loan sat in the $5 million to $25 million tier, and the study was prepared to the five-component standard for lender submission.
| Field | Published record |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Business and Industry (B&I) guaranteed loan |
| Asset | Food manufacturing: beet-sugar cooperative processing equipment |
| Location | Crookston, Minnesota (Polk County) |
| Loan size tier | $5 million to $25 million |
| Year | 2024 |
| Lender type | Regional agricultural bank |
| Outcome | Prepared to the five-component standard for lender submission |
Everything after this table that carries a dollar figure, a tonnage, a rate or a coverage ratio is a model. It uses a cooperative of the size a factory in the Red River Valley might serve and public Census, SBA and USAspending data, and every assumption is stated next to the number it drives. Program terms are the FY2026 terms in force when this page was written; the notice in force for a 2024 study set that year's percentages and fees.
The question the lender and USDA needed answered
A sugar cooperative is not a start-up, so the rule that forces an independent study on every new business borrowing more than $1,000,000 under B&I (7 CFR 5001.306(a)(3)(i)) does not apply on its face [1]. The study was still needed, for three reasons that recur in cooperative equipment loans.
First, the Agency may require a feasibility study whenever the information in the application is not enough to judge the project, and the lender's own credit evaluation must address the feasibility study, market conditions and construction complexity under the "conditions" factor of the five Cs [1]. A processing upgrade installed between campaigns, with a fixed window and no second chance until the next harvest, is construction complexity of a particular kind.
Second, the repayment source is unusual. A sugar cooperative pays its members for their beets out of what is left after processing costs and debt service. The lender is therefore underwriting a board decision as much as a factory: will members accept a smaller beet payment, or a per-ton capital retain, to carry the new debt? Part 5001 requires a global credit evaluation, historical and projected debt service coverage, and attention to reserves and working capital [1]. For a cooperative those tests run through the membership.
Third, a sugar factory is a seasonal borrower. Part 5001 asks the lender for quarterly cash flow projections for seasonal borrowers and for projections that differ from history to be substantiated [1]. An equipment project that promises more sugar per ton and less fuel per ton departs from history by design, so the engineering claims behind those savings had to be tied to evidence the lender could cite.
| Rule | What it requires | Why it mattered here |
|---|---|---|
| 7 CFR 5001.306(a)(3) | The Agency may require a feasibility study when information is insufficient; required for loans over $1,000,000 to a new business | Existing cooperative: study at Agency and lender discretion, requested because savings drive repayment |
| 7 CFR 5001.202 (conditions) | Lender's written evaluation of the feasibility study, market study and construction complexity | Installation must fit an intercampaign window |
| 7 CFR 5001.202 (capacity) | Global historical and projected coverage; reserves; quarterly cash flow for seasonal borrowers | The campaign concentrates cash in a few months |
| 7 CFR 5001.202 (content) | Projections that deviate from history must be substantiated | Extraction and fuel gains are new, not historical |
| 7 CFR 5001.105(d)(1) | Existing business equity tests at closing | Cooperative equity sources must be documented |
| 7 CFR 5001.406(c) | B&I limit $25 million per borrower; up to $40 million for qualifying rural cooperatives processing value-added commodities, at the Secretary's discretion | Sets the ceiling for this and later phases |
Project description (modeled)
The modeled project replaces and upgrades equipment at one existing factory in two intercampaign periods, the months between the end of one slicing campaign and the start of the next. Nothing in it adds acres or members. It is a productivity loan: the same beets, sliced faster, with less sugar lost to storage piles and pulp and less fuel burned per ton.
| Phase | Window | Scope | What it changes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engineering and procurement | Months 1 to 8 | Heat and mass balance, equipment specification, long-lead orders, air permit review | Locks vendor guarantees before money is committed |
| Phase 1 installation | First intercampaign | Four slicers, two pulp presses, control system upgrade, electrical service | Slice rate up 4%; first part of pulp sugar recovery; dryer fuel savings |
| Campaign year 1 | First campaign after installation | Phase 1 in service | Partial benefits; interest-only debt service |
| Phase 2 installation | Second intercampaign | Diffuser rebuild, added falling-film evaporator effect with condensate heat recovery | Full pulp recovery; steam economy gain |
| Campaign years 2 to 5 | Following campaigns | Full scope in service | Full modeled benefits; level principal and interest |
The record states that capital investment at comparable cooperatives runs $24 million to $26 million per cycle for evaporators, slicers and diffusers. The modeled budget below lands at $25,628,000, inside that range, built from line items rather than taken from it.
Project cost and sources and uses
There is no construction-cost database behind this page, so every line is an assumption stated per unit or per component with a range. A real study replaces each with the document named in the last column: vendor quotes with performance guarantees for the slicers, presses, diffuser work and evaporator body; contractor bids for installation and electrical; an engineer's estimate for structural work; and a valuation of the equipment for the lender.
| Line item | Basis | Modeled cost | Assumption range | How a real study sources it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beet slicers with knife-change system | 4 x $650,000 | $2,600,000 | $500,000 to $800,000 per unit | Equipment quote |
| Diffuser rebuild (screens, drive, scroll sections) | 1 x $3,400,000 | $3,400,000 | $2,600,000 to $4,200,000 per unit | Vendor proposal and inspection report |
| Falling-film evaporator body (added effect) with condensate heat recovery | 1 x $4,800,000 | $4,800,000 | $3,800,000 to $6,000,000 per unit | Equipment quote and heat balance |
| Pulp presses | 2 x $1,100,000 | $2,200,000 | $900,000 to $1,400,000 per unit | Equipment quote |
| Process controls and instrumentation (DCS upgrade) | 1 x $1,250,000 | $1,250,000 | $900,000 to $1,600,000 per unit | Integrator proposal |
| Electrical: switchgear, motor control centres, drives | 1 x $1,150,000 | $1,150,000 | $850,000 to $1,450,000 per unit | Electrical contractor bid |
| Installation, mechanical and piping | 28% of equipment | $4,312,000 | 22% to 35% of equipment | Contractor bids |
| Structural steel, foundations, building changes | allowance | $900,000 | $600,000 to $1,300,000 | Structural engineer estimate |
| Hard cost subtotal | $20,612,000 | |||
| Contingency | 10% of hard cost | $2,061,000 | 7.5% to 15% | Lender and engineer review |
| Engineering and design | 7% of hard cost | $1,443,000 | 5% to 9% | Engineering proposal |
| Owner project management and commissioning | allowance | $350,000 | $250,000 to $500,000 | Owner budget |
| Air permit modification and other permits | allowance | $120,000 | $60,000 to $200,000 | Permit consultant |
| Feasibility study, equipment appraisal, legal and closing | allowance | $185,000 | $120,000 to $260,000 | Engagement letters |
| B&I guarantee fee (3.0% of guaranteed portion) | $18,000,000 x 80% x 3.0% | $432,000 | Fixed by FY2026 notice | 91 FR 11272 |
| Interest during installation | average 45% drawn for 9 months at 7.00% | $425,000 | Depends on draw schedule | Lender draw schedule |
| Total project cost | $25,628,000 |
Hard costs are $20,612,000, of which equipment is $15,400,000. Installation at 28% of equipment cost is the line most likely to move: work inside a running factory, around existing piping and in a fixed window, costs more than greenfield installation. The 10% contingency ($2,061,000) is a lender minimum for brownfield process work, not a comfortable margin, and the stress tests below show what happens if it is consumed. The guarantee fee ($432,000) and interest during installation ($425,000) are financed because the cooperative's equity is better kept for the campaign than spent on fees.
| Sources | Amount | Share | Uses | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B&I guaranteed term loan (80% guaranteed) | $18,000,000 | 70.2% | Equipment and installation | $20,612,000 |
| Cooperative equity: retained patronage and capital retains | $7,628,000 | 29.8% | Contingency | $2,061,000 |
| Engineering, management, permits, study, legal | $2,098,000 | |||
| Guarantee fee and interest during installation | $857,000 | |||
| Total sources | $25,628,000 | 100.0% | Total uses | $25,628,000 |
The cooperative's share, $7,628,000 or 29.8% of cost, comes from retained patronage and per-ton capital retains already on the balance sheet. That is well above the 10% minimum for an existing business, and it is deliberate: the lender's collateral position on specialised process equipment is thin (see below), and equity is the cheapest way to fix it. A REAP energy efficiency grant is not counted. Under the REAP rule effective 16 October 2026 a grant is applied for after the project has run for 12 to 24 months with metered data, is capped at $250,000 for efficiency projects and at 25% of cost, and is competitive, so a lender should underwrite without it [11].
Market analysis
Minnesota food manufacturing, the state supply base
Census does not publish beet sugar refining as a separate line in the files used here, so the state picture uses food manufacturing excluding meat (NAICS 311 less 3116), the class that contains sugar.
| Measure | Minnesota | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 559 → 571 (+2.1%) | 24,589 → 27,414 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 9.9 | 8.1 |
| Average employees per establishment | 56.7 | 42.0 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $64,888 | $58,248 |
| Share of establishments in non-metro counties | 32.1% (193 in 33 counties) | |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 21.9% |
Non-metro counties with the most food manufacturing (excluding meat) (2023): Rice County (16); Douglas County (14); Morrison County (13); Otter Tail County (13); Goodhue County (10); Kandiyohi County (10).
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
Minnesota has 571 food plants outside the meat sector, 9.9 per 100,000 residents against 8.1 nationally, and they are larger than average: 56.7 employees per plant against 42.0. Average pay of $64,888 is 11.4% above the national $58,248, a useful benchmark for the wage line in any Minnesota processing model. The count grew only 2.1% from 2019 to 2023 while the national count grew 11.5%, so Minnesota's food base is mature and concentrated in established, larger plants rather than new entrants. A third of the plants the county file places are in non-metro counties.
What a reviewer takes from this table for a sugar cooperative is narrow. It confirms a deep processing labour market and a wage level; it says nothing about sugar demand. For a cooperative, the market question is not whether the factory can find customers but whether its members' acres, yields and sugar content will keep the slicers full, and at what net price the sugar sells.
The regional processing belt
| State | Plants, 2023 | Change 2019 to 2023 | Per 100,000 residents | Employees per plant | Average pay | Non-metro share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Minnesota | 571 | 2.1% | 9.9 | 56.7 | $64,888 | 32.1% |
| North Dakota | 98 | 12.6% | 12.5 | 53.3 | $65,580 | 36.4% |
| South Dakota | 90 | 7.1% | 9.8 | 50.5 | $56,818 | 56.5% |
| Iowa | 354 | 5.7% | 11.0 | 66.3 | $76,247 | 54.6% |
| Wisconsin | 905 | 4.9% | 15.3 | 68.5 | $64,023 | 34.2% |
| Idaho | 231 | 19.7% | 11.7 | 75.3 | $57,841 | 34.2% |
| United States | 27,414 | 11.5% | 8.1 | 42.0 | $58,248 |
Among the northern plains and upper Midwest states, Minnesota has the most food plants after Wisconsin and pays above the regional middle. North Dakota, the other half of the Red River Valley sugar district, has 98 plants at 12.5 per 100,000 residents and pays slightly more than Minnesota. The comparison matters for labour: factories on both banks of the Red River recruit from the same towns, and a study that sets wages from a Minnesota average without looking across the river understates competition for maintenance and controls staff.
The Red River Valley counties
| County | OMB 2023 | Population, 2025 | Food plants (NAICS 311) | Food employment | Food average pay | All manufacturing plants | All manufacturing employment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Polk County, MN | Metro | 30,545 | 12 | 930 (high noise) | $68,415 | 33 | 1,648 |
| Clay County, MN | Metro | 67,734 | 5 | 431 (high noise) | $71,671 | 37 | 1,247 |
| Pennington County, MN | Non-metro | 13,686 | 4 | 111 (low noise) | $115,108 | 16 | 1,143 |
| Marshall County, MN | Non-metro | 8,798 | 3 | 76 (high noise) | $95,934 | 15 | 366 |
| Kittson County, MN | Non-metro | 4,031 | 3 | 53 (high noise) | $92,321 | 10 | 144 |
| Renville County, MN | Non-metro | 14,356 | 4 | 662 (low noise) | $90,437 | 18 | 990 |
| Grand Forks County, ND | Metro | 74,501 | 9 | 693 (high noise) | $53,447 | 55 | 2,692 |
| Cass County, ND | Metro | 201,794 | 30 | 1,722 (low noise) | $66,131 | 193 | 11,458 |
| Richland County, ND | Non-metro | 16,731 | 7 | 649 (high noise) | $77,276 | 38 | 1,696 |
County Business Patterns counts all food plants (NAICS 311, meat included) by county, and employment carries a noise flag where Census adds noise to protect individual employers. Polk County shows 12 food plants with 930 employees (high noise), a large processing payroll for a county of 30,545 residents. Renville County in southern Minnesota and Richland County in North Dakota show the same pattern: a handful of plants with hundreds of employees and high average pay, the signature of a sugar factory in a small county. Because the noise flags are high in several cells, a study treats these as orders of magnitude and takes actual headcount and wages from the cooperative's payroll.
Polk County is classed as metropolitan because it belongs to the Grand Forks metropolitan area. That is a county proxy, not the B&I test, and it is the first trap in a Crookston file.
Rural area test
| Place | Census base 2020 | Estimate 2025 | 5001.3 screen |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fargo, ND | 125,951 | 136,275 | Over 50,000: excluded with its contiguous urbanized area |
| Grand Forks, ND | 59,173 | 60,365 | Over 50,000: excluded with its contiguous urbanized area |
| Moorhead, MN | 44,507 | 46,533 | Under 50,000: passes on population; contiguity decides |
| East Grand Forks, MN | 9,189 | 8,906 | Under 50,000: passes on population; contiguity decides |
| Crookston, MN | 7,506 | 7,375 | Under 50,000: passes on population; contiguity decides |
B&I's rural area test excludes any city or town of more than 50,000 people and the urbanized area contiguous and adjacent to it, using the latest decennial census, and USDA will not approve an application subject to meeting the rural test later [1]. Grand Forks, North Dakota (60,365 in the 2025 estimate) is over the line, so East Grand Forks, which adjoins it, needs a map check. Crookston, with 7,375 residents, passes on population and is a separate town. The study recorded the site's status from the USDA eligibility map with a date, which a reviewer expects to see in the first pages of the report.
Sugar supply and price
The engagement record states that Minnesota is the largest sugar beet producing state, with 334,000 intended acres, and that the 2024 campaign set a Red River Valley yield record of 32.2 tons per acre. It also cites a FY2026 Commodity Credit Corporation refined beet sugar loan rate for the Minnesota and eastern North Dakota region of 32.70 cents per pound, about 30% above the FY2025 rate of 25.18 cents, attributing the increase to 2025 farm legislation, and treats it as the revenue floor for pro forma modeling. None of these figures could be confirmed against a primary source for this page, so the model uses its own labelled price assumptions and shows the record's loan-rate figure as one scenario.
The modeled net selling price is 36.0 cents per pound after freight and selling costs. A real study builds it from the cooperative's sales contracts and its marketing agent's reports, then tests it against the loan rate, because the loan rate (if confirmed) sets a level below which forfeiture becomes the cooperative's alternative to selling.
Financing benchmarks
| Period | 7(a) loans | 7(a) dollars | 504 loans | 504 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2010 to FY2016 | 101 | $42.8 million | 16 | $12.7 million |
| FY2017 to FY2019 | 51 | $15.5 million | 6 | $10.4 million |
| FY2020 to FY2023 | 54 | $33.4 million | 13 | $12.9 million |
| FY2024 to FY2026 | 42 | $16.5 million | 4 | $3.1 million |
Average 7(a) loan, FY2020 to FY2026: $519,526. Average 504 loan: $944,059. Of the 101 7(a) loans approved in FY2010 to FY2016 for Minnesota food manufacturing (excluding meat), 4.0% were charged off (national: 7.4% of 3,150), on average 63 months after approval.
Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).
SBA lending is a weak guide to a cooperative of this size: the average Minnesota food-manufacturing 7(a) loan since FY2020 is $519,526, and a sugar cooperative's equipment cycle is thirty to fifty times that. What the SBA record does show is that Minnesota food manufacturers have repaid well: 4.0% of seasoned 7(a) loans were charged off against 7.4% nationally. USAspending lists 5 B&I loans in Minnesota for FY2024 to FY2026 (counts may be incomplete) and 544 REAP grants, so B&I volume in the state is thin and a lender new to the program should expect a careful state office review.
Financial feasibility
Operating assumptions
| Operating assumption (modeled) | Value | Range tested or source a study uses |
|---|---|---|
| Beets sliced per campaign | 1,450,000 tons | Member acres x 5-year average yield; grower contracts |
| Slice rate before / after slicer replacement | 6,500 / 6,760 tons a day (+4%) | Factory slice logs; vendor guarantee |
| Campaign length before / after | 223 / 214 days | Computed: tons divided by slice rate |
| Share of crop stored in piles | 70% | Harvest and slicing schedule |
| Storage sugar loss | 0.25 lb sugar per ton per day | 0.15 to 0.40; pile temperature records |
| Sugar recovered from pulp after diffuser rebuild and presses | 2.0 lb per ton of beets | 1.0 to 3.0; vendor guarantee and lab data |
| Net selling price of sugar (after freight and selling cost) | 36.0 cents per lb | Sales contracts and marketing agent reports |
| Fuel use before project | 1.25 MMBtu per ton of beets | Utility bills for three campaigns |
| Delivered natural gas | $4.75 per MMBtu | Supply contract; stressed +40% |
| Fuel saved by added evaporator effect | 9% of factory fuel | Heat and mass balance by engineer |
| Dryer fuel saved by higher press solids | $300,000 a year | Press vendor data |
| Maintenance avoided on retired equipment | $400,000 a year | Maintenance records |
| Added electricity for new drives | $80,000 a year | Motor list x tariff |
Three of these assumptions carry most of the value. Sugar recovered from pulp depends on the diffuser vendor's guarantee and on lab data before and after; the fuel saving depends on the engineer's heat and mass balance; the storage gain depends on a pile loss rate that varies with weather. The study asks for each in writing from the party that will be held to it.
Debt terms
| Term (model) | Value | Rule or basis |
|---|---|---|
| Loan amount | $18,000,000 | Inside the $5 million to $25 million tier; B&I cap $25 million, up to $40 million for qualifying rural cooperatives (5001.406(c)) |
| Guarantee | 80%: $14,400,000 guaranteed, $3,600,000 held by the lender at risk | FY2026 notice, $5 million to $25 million tier |
| Guarantee fee | 3.0% of guaranteed portion: $432,000 | FY2026 notice; financed in the budget |
| Annual retention fee | 0.55% of guaranteed principal outstanding: $75,744 after year 2 | FY2026 notice; 5001.455 |
| Rate | 7.00% fixed (illustrative assumption) | Negotiated; not above the lender's rate on similar unguaranteed loans (5001.401) |
| Interest-only period | 12 months (installation and first campaign) | First full principal and interest within 3 years (5001.402) |
| Amortization after interest-only | 14 years; monthly payment $168,372 | Within the useful life of the equipment (5001.402) |
| Collateral | First lien on the new equipment and a lien on factory real estate | Appraisal and discounting under 5001.202 and 5001.203 |
The guarantee does not change the cooperative's obligation. It changes the lender's exposure: at 80%, $18,000,000 leaves the bank with its unguaranteed share at full risk, which is why the bank reads the coverage and collateral sections hardest.
Five-year pro forma: the project's own cash flow
| Campaign year | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sugar saved by shorter storage | $391,886 | $391,886 | $391,886 | $391,886 | $391,886 |
| Sugar recovered from pulp | $417,600 | $1,044,000 | $1,044,000 | $1,044,000 | $1,044,000 |
| Fuel saved, added evaporator effect | $0 | $794,215 | $814,070 | $834,422 | $855,283 |
| Dryer fuel saved | $300,000 | $307,500 | $315,188 | $323,067 | $331,144 |
| Maintenance avoided | $200,000 | $410,000 | $420,250 | $430,756 | $441,525 |
| Added electricity | -$80,000 | -$82,000 | -$84,050 | -$86,151 | -$88,305 |
| Cash benefit available for debt service | $1,229,486 | $2,865,601 | $2,901,344 | $2,937,980 | $2,975,533 |
| New B&I debt service (interest and principal) | $1,260,000 | $2,020,465 | $2,020,465 | $2,020,465 | $2,020,465 |
| Retention fee, 0.55% of guaranteed balance (charged to borrower in the model) | $79,200 | $75,744 | $72,039 | $68,066 | $63,806 |
| Project DSCR before retention fee | 0.98x | 1.42x | 1.44x | 1.45x | 1.47x |
| Project DSCR after retention fee | 0.92x | 1.37x | 1.39x | 1.41x | 1.43x |
The project pays for itself from year 2. In year 1, with only phase 1 in service and interest-only payments of $1,260,000, the modeled benefit of $1,229,486 covers interest only 0.98x. That shortfall is planned, not a failure: the study shows it so the cooperative budgets for it from general cash flow. From year 2, full benefits of $2,865,601 cover level debt service of $2,020,465 at 1.42x, rising to 1.47x by year 5 as fuel and maintenance savings inflate at 2.5% a year.
Break-even and per-ton economics
The project breaks even when it delivers 70.5% of the modeled year-2 benefit; benefits can fall 29.5% before the project stops covering its own debt. Expressed per ton of beets, the new debt costs members $1.39 a ton a year and the modeled benefits return $1.98 a ton, a net gain of $0.58 a ton ($845,136 across the crop) in year 2.
Because a cooperative can set its own capital retain, the study also tested coverage on a retain basis. A retain of $1.75 a ton on the modeled crop covers the new debt service at 1.26x without counting any project benefit, which is the coverage a lender can rely on if the engineering claims disappoint.
Sensitivity
| Scenario (one change at a time) | Cash benefit | Debt service | Project DSCR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base case (campaign year 2) | $2,865,601 | $2,020,465 | 1.42x |
| Rate 8.00% (+1 point) | $2,865,601 | $2,141,247 | 1.34x |
| Rate 9.00% (+2 points) | $2,865,601 | $2,265,705 | 1.26x |
| Benefits 25% below engineer estimate | $2,149,201 | $2,020,465 | 1.06x |
| Benefits 40% below engineer estimate | $1,719,361 | $2,020,465 | 0.85x |
| Crop 15% smaller (fewer tons sliced) | $2,481,120 | $2,020,465 | 1.23x |
| Natural gas 40% cheaper (less fuel saved) | $2,424,915 | $2,020,465 | 1.20x |
| Sugar price 20% lower | $2,578,424 | $2,020,465 | 1.28x |
| Cost overrun 15% financed with more debt | $2,865,601 | $2,367,514 | 1.21x |
| Rate \ benefits achieved | 100% | 85% | 70% | 55% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.00% | 1.51x | 1.28x | 1.05x | 0.83x |
| 7.00% | 1.42x | 1.21x | 0.99x | 0.78x |
| 8.00% | 1.34x | 1.14x | 0.94x | 0.74x |
| 9.00% | 1.26x | 1.08x | 0.89x | 0.70x |
No single change sinks the project. The weak point is the engineering estimate: if benefits come in 25% below plan, coverage falls to about 1.06x, and at 70% of plan with rates at 7.00% the project no longer covers itself. Combining a one-point rate rise, benefits 25% below plan and a crop 15% smaller gives 0.87x. A 15% cost overrun of $3,091,800 financed with more debt cuts coverage to 1.21x, which is why the lender asked for equity, not debt, to fund any overrun.
Delay stress
| Campaign year | Benefit on schedule | Benefit if phase 2 slips one campaign | Debt service | DSCR if delayed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $1,229,486 | $1,229,486 | $1,260,000 | 0.98x |
| Year 2 | $2,865,601 | $1,239,986 | $2,020,465 | 0.61x |
| Year 3 | $2,901,344 | $2,901,344 | $2,020,465 | 1.44x |
A one-campaign slip in phase 2, for example a late evaporator delivery, is the most damaging single event. In year 2 coverage falls to 0.61x and the cooperative must find $780,479 from general cash flow or a reserve. The study recommended either an interest-only period that runs through the second campaign (Part 5001 allows the first full payment up to three years from the note [1]) or a debt service reserve funded at closing.
The membership test
The project can pass every lender test and still fail if members stop delivering beets. The study therefore ran the whole cooperative, not only the project.
| Cooperative-level assumption (modeled) | Value | Source in a real study |
|---|---|---|
| Recoverable sugar | 290 lb per ton before project; +2.75 lb with project | Factory lab and polarisation records |
| Labour (year-round and campaign) | $14.00 per ton | Three years of cooperative statements |
| Energy | $5.94 per ton | Three years of cooperative statements |
| Lime, chemicals, packaging | $5.00 per ton | Three years of cooperative statements |
| Maintenance and repairs | $5.00 per ton | Three years of cooperative statements |
| Administration and insurance | $3.00 per ton | Three years of cooperative statements |
| Co-products (pulp, molasses) | $16.00 per ton | Co-product sales contracts |
| Existing cooperative debt service | $8,000,000 a year | Loan agreements; global debt schedule |
| Grower cost of production | $58.00 per ton | Extension budgets and member surveys |
| Net sugar price scenario | Beet payment per ton, no project | Beet payment per ton, with project and new debt | Change per ton | Margin over assumed grower cost ($58 a ton) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base (36.0 cents) | $81.95 | $82.50 | $0.56 | $24.50 |
| Record's FY2026 loan-rate figure (32.70 cents, unverified) | $72.38 | $72.84 | $0.47 | $14.84 |
| Price down 20% (28.8 cents) | $61.07 | $61.43 | $0.36 | $3.43 |
| Price down 30% (25.2 cents) | $50.63 | $50.89 | $0.26 | -$7.11 |
At the base price the modeled beet payment is $82.50 a ton with the project and its debt, about 56 cents more than without it, and well above the assumed grower cost of $58.00. At a price 20% lower the margin over grower cost shrinks to $3.43 a ton, and at 30% lower growers lose money with or without the project. That is the real risk in a sugar cooperative loan: price, not the equipment. The project slightly improves the payment in every scenario, so it does not add to the price risk, but the study had to show the board and the bank what a low-price year does to member loyalty and delivery contracts.
Equity and collateral
| Existing-business test, 5001.105(d)(1) (any one) | Required | Modeled | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10% of total eligible project cost invested | $2,562,800 | $7,628,000 | Pass |
| 10% balance-sheet equity (or debt to equity at most 9 to 1), modeled cooperative balance sheet after closing | 10% of assets | 43.3% ($142,000,000 of $328,000,000) | Pass |
| Collateral (modeled) | Value | Discount factor (assumption) | Discounted value |
|---|---|---|---|
| New process equipment (installed cost less contingency and soft costs) | $20,612,000 | 50% | $10,306,000 |
| Lien on factory real estate (modeled appraised value, as is) | $9,000,000 | 70% | $6,300,000 |
| Discounted collateral value | $16,606,000 | ||
| Loan amount | $18,000,000 | ||
| Discounted coverage | 0.92x |
The cooperative passes the existing-business equity tests easily. Collateral is the tighter test. Specialised process equipment has a thin resale market, so a 50% discount on installed cost is a conservative but realistic starting point, and with a lien on factory real estate the discounted coverage is 0.92x. Part 5001 lets the lender discount collateral and requires it to justify the discounts, and an appraisal of real estate over $250,000 must meet USPAP [1]. The study flagged the shortfall early so the bank could choose between a larger real estate lien, a smaller loan or more equity, rather than discovering it in credit committee.
Technical and environmental feasibility
The technical section tied every benefit in the pro forma to a document. For the slicers, the vendor's rated throughput and the factory's own slice logs; for the diffuser rebuild, a pre-project inspection report and the vendor's guarantee on sugar lost to pulp; for the evaporator, a heat and mass balance showing the steam economy gain and the condensate heat recovered; for the presses, guaranteed pressed-pulp solids, which drive dryer fuel. The study also checked electrical capacity for the new drives, structural loads for the evaporator body, and whether the work fits the intercampaign window with a realistic float.
Environmental review under Part 5001 is a separate Agency process from the five feasibility components. The study identified the items that review would ask about: whether the evaporator and pulp dryer changes require an air permit modification, wastewater and condensate handling, and whether any work disturbs ground outside the existing factory footprint. Equipment replaced inside an existing plant usually raises fewer environmental questions than new construction, but the permit schedule still belongs in the installation timeline.
Management and governance feasibility
A cooperative's management section has two layers. The first is the factory team: the plant manager, maintenance and controls staff, and the engineering firm and installers that will work inside a live plant. The study looked at their record on past intercampaign projects and at who signs off commissioning.
The second is governance. The board authorises the debt, sets the capital retain and decides how project benefits flow back to members. The study reviewed the bylaws and the growers' delivery agreements, because those documents, not the factory, guarantee the tonnage the model depends on. It noted the record's point that grower contracts sit at the centre of management feasibility. Members who are also borrowers on their own farm equipment feel price pressure first; the record notes that a single six-row harvester costs $500,000 to $700,000 new, which is part of why member payments and retains need careful setting.
B&I eligibility also depends on the borrower and its controlling owners. Under 5001.127, a borrower is ineligible if it or an owner of more than 20% (passive investors aside) has an outstanding federal judgment, delinquent federal tax or debt, or a debarment; the lender verifies this [1]. In a cooperative with hundreds of members no member usually holds 20%, so the check centres on the cooperative itself and any controlling entity.
Economic and community impact (modeled)
| Effect (modeled) | Amount | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Year-round jobs retained at the factory | 310 | Assumption for a factory of this size; a study uses payroll records |
| Campaign (seasonal) jobs retained | 240 | Assumption; campaign staffing records |
| New skilled jobs (controls, maintenance) | 6 | Assumption from the equipment scope |
| Average annual pay used for the factory | $64,888 | Minnesota food manufacturing average, CBP 2023 (pack) |
| Added value to members per ton, year 2 | $0.58 | Benefit less new debt service, divided by tons |
| Added value to members, year 2 | $845,136 | Same, total |
| Member-growers served (assumption) | 480 | Membership roll; delivery contracts |
The project's case for a rural guarantee is retention more than growth. A sugar factory in a town of 7,375 is one of the largest private payrolls in the county, and its members' farms depend on its slicing capacity. The modeled impact is the factory's jobs held at a Minnesota food-manufacturing average wage of $64,888, a handful of new skilled positions, and a net gain to members after debt service. A real study replaces each assumption with payroll records, membership rolls and the cooperative's own delivery data.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | Effect in the model | Mitigant the study proposed |
|---|---|---|
| Engineering benefits below guarantee | Coverage 1.06x at 75% of benefits | Vendor performance guarantees with remedies; capital retain set to cover debt without benefits |
| Phase 2 slips a campaign | Year-2 coverage 0.61x | Extended interest-only period or debt service reserve |
| Installation overrun | 1.21x if 15% overrun is debt-financed | Fund overruns with equity; fixed-price installation contracts |
| Sugar price falls | Member margin over cost shrinks to $3.43 a ton at -20% | Board policy on retains; loan-rate floor confirmed from the CCC notice |
| Short crop (weather, disease) | Coverage 1.23x at -15% tons | Multi-year yield history; retains per ton set on a conservative crop |
| Lower gas prices | Coverage 1.20x at -40% gas | Fuel savings valued at contract prices, not spot peaks |
| Collateral shortfall | Discounted coverage 0.92x | Larger real estate lien or more equity |
| Member attrition | Fewer tons, higher fixed cost per ton | Delivery agreements; membership trend analysis |
| Seasonal cash concentration | Debt due outside campaign months | Quarterly cash flow; payment dates matched to sugar sales |
What the five Part 5001 components showed
Part 5001 organises an acceptable feasibility study into economic, market, technical, financial and management feasibility [4]. The engagement record lists environmental work alongside them; environmental review is a separate USDA requirement, so this page treats it under technical feasibility.
| Component | What the modeled study found | What a reviewer would check |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Factory jobs and member farms depend on slicing capacity; the project protects both | Local employment share; member count |
| Market | Volume is bounded by member acres; price is the variable; the record's loan-rate figure gives a floor once confirmed | Price scenarios; sales contracts; loan-rate notice |
| Technical | Each benefit tied to a vendor guarantee or engineering balance; installation fits two intercampaign windows | Guarantees, heat balance, schedule float |
| Financial | 1.42x coverage from year 2; year 1 planned below 1.00x; break-even at 70.5% of benefits; delay is the main stress | Pro forma, quarterly cash flow, reserves |
| Management | Board authority, retains and delivery agreements underpin tonnage; factory team has to work inside a live plant | Bylaws, delivery contracts, project team record |
Studies like this one come back from lenders and state offices for predictable reasons:
- Savings stated as a single number with no vendor guarantee or engineering balance behind them.
- An annual model for a seasonal borrower, with no quarterly cash flow.
- Coverage computed on the project alone, ignoring the cooperative's existing debt and the membership's ability to absorb a lower payment.
- No delay scenario for work that must fit an intercampaign window.
- Collateral valued at installed cost rather than discounted resale value.
- The rural area test asserted from the county's non-metro status rather than the eligibility map.
- A sugar price assumption with no link to contracts or the loan rate.
Program terms that applied
| FY2026 B&I term | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Guarantee, loans of $5 million to $25 million | 80% | 91 FR 11272 [2] |
| Guarantee, loans under $5 million | 85% | 91 FR 11272 [2] |
| Guarantee fee | 3.0% of the guaranteed portion (1.0% under the reduced-fee criteria) | 91 FR 11272 [2]; 5001.454 [1] |
| Extra fee if the guarantee is issued before construction is complete | 0.50% | 91 FR 11272 [2] |
| Annual retention fee | 0.55% of guaranteed principal outstanding at 31 December | 91 FR 11272 [2]; 5001.455 [1] |
| Maximum loan | $25 million; up to $40 million for qualifying rural cooperatives | 5001.406(c) [1] |
| Term | Useful life, up to 40 years; no balloon | 5001.402 [1] |
| Interest rate | Negotiated; fixed, variable or both; not above the lender's rate on similar loans | 5001.401 [1] |
| Rural area | Outside cities over 50,000 and their contiguous urbanized areas | 5001.3 [1] |
| Feasibility study | Required over $1,000,000 for a new business; otherwise at Agency discretion | 5001.306(a)(3) [1] |
| Agricultural production | Only inside an integrated processing business that owns it; at most 50% of the loan or $5 million | 5001.105(b)(7) [1][3] |
Two of these deserve a note for cooperatives. The $40 million ceiling is not automatic; it applies to qualifying rural cooperatives that process value-added commodities and needs the Secretary's approval, so a cooperative planning a third phase should ask the state office early. And B&I does not finance members' beet growing: the agricultural production rule lets B&I fund production only when the borrower itself owns and operates it inside an integrated processing business, and caps that part of the loan [1][3].
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Underwrite the board, not only the factory. The lender is relying on the cooperative's power to set retains and payments. Put the bylaw provisions and the board resolution in the study.
- Get savings in writing from the people who will be held to them. Vendor guarantees and an engineer's heat balance turn an estimate into a number a credit officer can cite.
- Plan the year-1 gap. Projects installed in phases rarely cover debt in the first campaign. Show the gap and how it is funded.
- Model the slip. The intercampaign window is fixed; a late delivery costs a whole year of benefits. Price an extended interest-only period or a reserve before closing.
- Test collateral at resale value. Specialised process equipment rarely secures its own loan; decide early what else the lender can take.
- Check the map, not the county. Polk County is metropolitan; Crookston is not excluded on that account. A dated map determination ends the argument.
- Use the record's price figures only after confirming them. A loan rate or price index in the pro forma should come with its notice or contract.
Related pages
- USDA B&I engagements: the program page that lists this study with the firm's other Business and Industry work.
- Food processing feasibility study for USDA loans: national rules, data and a worked B&I example for food plants.
- Minnesota food processing feasibility study and the Minnesota USDA feasibility study guide: state data, eligibility and precedents.
- Case studies: other engagements written up in full.
- USDA feasibility study framework: how Part 5001 decides a file.
If your cooperative or processing plant is planning an equipment cycle with a guaranteed loan, a USDA feasibility study consultant can scope the study around your lender's credit memo before installation planning is final. Standard B&I studies take six to seven weeks and complex ones seven to nine, with fees listed on the cost page [12]. Request a proposal for a fifteen-minute scoping call and a written, fixed-fee proposal [13].
USDA Feasibility, Inc.