How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
In 2025 we prepared a feasibility study for the construction of a boutique hotel in Walla Walla, Washington, financed through the USDA Business and Industry (B&I) guaranteed loan program by a non-bank, B&I-approved lender. The loan sat in the $5 million to $25 million tier, and the study was prepared with demand and ADR support for lender review.
| Field | Published record |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Business and Industry (B&I) guaranteed loan |
| Asset | Hotel: boutique hotel, new construction |
| Location | Walla Walla, Washington (Walla Walla County) |
| Loan size tier | $5 million to $25 million |
| Year | 2025 |
| Lender type | Non-bank B&I-approved lender |
| Outcome | Prepared with demand and ADR support for lender review |
The engagement card describes the work as RevPAR benchmarking against a defined six-property competitive set, a month-by-month occupancy ramp to stabilization (which it puts at typically 36 to 48 months for new boutique construction), an explicit justification of the interest-only period with monthly cash flow projections, ADR support documentation, and a five-year pro forma with debt service coverage analysis. The rest of this page builds a modeled version of that analysis: a 72-room hotel with a restaurant, bar and a tasting and event room, priced from labelled assumptions and tested against public data for Walla Walla County.
The question the lender and USDA needed answered
A new hotel built by a newly formed owning company is a new business, and Part 5001 requires a feasibility study by an independent qualified consultant acceptable to the Agency for any B&I loan over $1,000,000 to a new business, with the Agency setting the scope [1]. That rule alone made the study mandatory here.
Construction added a second set of tests. When a lender asks USDA to issue the loan note guarantee before construction is finished, Part 5001 requires a detailed timetable and budget confirmed by a qualified independent consultant, enough cash flow to complete construction including contingencies for overruns, working capital through the start-up period, a firm fixed-price construction contract with an independent general contractor, and borrower equity injected before any guaranteed loan funds [1]. The lender's credit evaluation must also include quarterly cash flow through start-up and a construction schedule in that case, and must substantiate projections that depart from history [1]. A new hotel has no history, so every number in the projection has to be supported from the market.
The question the lender put to the study was therefore specific: what occupancy and rate can a new independent boutique hotel in Walla Walla reach, how fast, and does the cash flow carry an interest-only period followed by full payments without exhausting the reserve?
| Rule | Requirement | Effect on this study |
|---|---|---|
| 7 CFR 5001.306(a)(3)(i) | Independent study required for a loan over $1,000,000 to a new business; Agency sets scope | Study mandatory |
| 7 CFR 5001.205(e)(2) | Guarantee before completion: confirmed budget and timetable, contingencies, start-up working capital, fixed-price contract, equity first | Budget, schedule and reserve sized in the study |
| 7 CFR 5001.202 | Quarterly cash flow through start-up; projections that depart from history substantiated | Monthly opening-year model; comp-set evidence for rate and occupancy |
| 7 CFR 5001.105(d)(3) | New business, construction, early guarantee: 25% equity test | Equity plan tested at closing |
| 7 CFR 5001.203 | As-is and prospective appraisal; going concern value deducted before discounting | Collateral tested on real property, not business value |
| 7 CFR 5001.3 | Rural area test | Site screened on the eligibility map |
Project description (modeled)
| Component | Modeled program | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Guest rooms | 72 keys: 54 kings, 12 doubles, 6 suites | Room mix set by the operator from comp-set demand |
| Gross building area | 51,840 sq ft (720 sq ft per key) | Includes public areas, restaurant and back of house |
| Restaurant and bar | About 90 seats, open daily | Serves guests and local diners |
| Tasting and event room | About 2,400 sq ft | Winery dinners, rehearsal dinners, small meetings |
| Parking | On site, sized to code | Rural guests arrive by car |
| Accessible rooms | Per 2010 ADA Standards for transient lodging | 28 CFR 36.406(c) [10] |
| Phase | Timing (modeled) | Milestone |
|---|---|---|
| Entitlements and design | Months 1 to 9 before closing | Land use approval, design development, guaranteed maximum price |
| Closing and equity draw | Note month 0 | Equity spent first; loan note guarantee issued before completion |
| Construction | Note months 1 to 18 | Monthly draws with an independent inspector |
| Pre-opening | Months 16 to 18 | Hiring, training, systems, launch marketing |
| Opening year, interest-only | Months 19 to 30 | Ramp from 54% occupancy; reserve absorbs seasonal troughs |
| Full payments | From month 31 | Within the 3-year limit of 5001.402 |
Project cost and sources and uses
There is no construction-cost database behind this page. Every line below is an assumption with a range, and the last column says what replaces it in a real study: a guaranteed maximum price contract for the building, designer and vendor quotes for FF&E, the operator's pre-opening budget, the appraisal and the city's fee schedule.
| Line item | Basis | Modeled cost | Assumption range | How a real study sources it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Land (about 1.6 acres) | allowance | $1,250,000 | $800,000 to $1,700,000 | Appraisal; purchase contract |
| Site work and utility extensions | allowance | $1,100,000 | $700,000 to $1,600,000 | Civil engineer estimate; utility letters |
| Building, 72 rooms, restaurant, bar, tasting and event room | 51,840 sq ft x $265 | $13,737,600 | $240 to $340 per sq ft | Guaranteed maximum price contract |
| Furniture, fixtures and equipment | 72 keys x $30,000 | $2,160,000 | $25,000 to $42,000 per key | Designer budget; vendor quotes |
| Kitchen and bar equipment | allowance | $450,000 | $300,000 to $700,000 | Kitchen consultant quote |
| Operating supplies and equipment | 72 keys x $5,500 | $396,000 | $4,000 to $7,500 per key | Operator budget |
| Technology, property management system, low voltage | allowance | $280,000 | $180,000 to $400,000 | Vendor quotes |
| Hard cost subtotal (excluding land) | $18,123,600 | |||
| Architecture and engineering | 6% of site and building | $890,000 | 5% to 8% | Design contracts |
| Permits, impact and connection fees | allowance | $420,000 | $250,000 to $650,000 | City fee schedule |
| Legal, appraisal, market study, title, closing | allowance | $325,000 | $220,000 to $450,000 | Engagement letters |
| Development and project management | 3% of site and building | $445,000 | 2% to 4% | Development agreement |
| Pre-opening (hiring, training, launch marketing) | allowance | $520,000 | $5,000 to $9,000 per key | Operator pre-opening budget |
| Contingency | 6% of site and building; 3% of FF&E and fit-out | $989,000 | 5% to 10% | Lender and cost consultant review |
| B&I guarantee fee, issued before construction completion (3.5%) | $15,500,000 x 80% x 3.5% | $434,000 | Fixed by FY2026 notice | 91 FR 11272 |
| Interest during construction | average 48% drawn for 18 months at 7.25% | $809,000 | Depends on draw schedule | Lender draw schedule |
| Working capital and ramp-up reserve | allowance | $700,000 | Sized from monthly cash flow below | Monthly year-1 model |
| Total project cost | $24,905,600 |
The modeled hotel costs $24,905,600, or $345,911 per key including land, fees, interest and the reserve. Hard costs excluding land are $18,123,600. The two lines a reviewer will press hardest are the building cost per square foot, because a boutique hotel with a full restaurant costs more than a select-service box, and contingency ($989,000), which at 6% of building and site is at the low end for new construction with a restaurant. The guarantee fee is 3.5% of the guaranteed portion ($434,000) because the guarantee is issued before construction is complete; the reduced 1.0% fee would apply only if the loan met the Agency's reduced-fee criteria, which this model does not assume [2].
| Sources | Amount | Share | Uses | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B&I guaranteed loan (80% guaranteed) | $15,500,000 | 62.2% | Land and hard costs | $19,373,600 |
| Sponsor cash equity | $9,405,600 | 37.8% | Soft costs, fees and contingency | $3,589,000 |
| Guarantee fee and construction interest | $1,243,000 | |||
| Working capital and ramp-up reserve | $700,000 | |||
| Total sources | $24,905,600 | 100.0% | Total uses | $24,905,600 |
The sponsor puts in $9,405,600 (37.8% of cost), above the 25% that Part 5001 requires for a new business with an early guarantee. The extra equity is not generosity; it is what keeps debt service coverage near 1.20x in the second operating year at a 7.25% rate.
Market analysis
Washington hotel supply
| Measure | Washington | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 1,207 → 1,211 (+0.3%) | 54,955 → 55,895 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 15.4 | 16.6 |
| Average employees per establishment | 27.4 | 26.8 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $42,624 | $39,374 |
| Share of establishments in non-metro counties | 23.5% (284 in 16 counties) | |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 10.2% |
Non-metro counties with the most hotels and motels (2023): Grays Harbor County (38); Grant County (36); Clallam County (35); Okanogan County (26); Pacific County (26); Kittitas County (25).
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
Washington's hotel count barely moved between 2019 and 2023 (1,207 to 1,211), and at 15.4 hotels per 100,000 residents the state has slightly less lodging per head than the nation (16.6). Its hotels are a little larger than average and pay more: $42,624 per employee against $39,374 nationally. Only 23.5% of the state's hotels are in non-metro counties, so most rural hotel lending in Washington happens in places like Walla Walla, which sit in small metropolitan counties but outside any city of 50,000.
Regional comparison
| State | Hotels and motels, 2023 | Change 2019 to 2023 | Per 100,000 residents | Employees per hotel | Average pay | Non-metro share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Washington | 1,211 | 0.3% | 15.4 | 27.4 | $42,624 | 23.5% |
| Oregon | 984 | 2.5% | 23.2 | 21.8 | $33,617 | 37.8% |
| Idaho | 387 | 6.6% | 19.6 | 27.0 | $28,819 | 40.9% |
| Montana | 531 | 1.3% | 47.0 | 21.1 | $31,540 | 49.8% |
| California | 6,020 | 4.4% | 15.4 | 34.5 | $47,787 | 6.8% |
| United States | 55,895 | 1.7% | 16.6 | 26.8 | $39,374 |
Against its neighbours, Washington has the slowest hotel growth and the highest pay. Oregon, Idaho and Montana have more hotels per resident and a much larger rural share. For a Walla Walla project, whose guests often cross from Oregon and Idaho, the regional table explains two things: the state's higher wage level, which a pro forma must carry, and the fact that rural lodging supply in the Pacific Northwest grows slowly, which supports a new hotel's occupancy only if demand is growing too.
Walla Walla County and its competitive region
| County | OMB 2023 | Population, 2025 | Hotels (721110) | Hotel employees | Hotels per 100,000 | Wineries (312130) | Wineries per 100,000 | Full-service restaurants |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Walla Walla County, WA | Metro | 62,361 | 14 | 303 | 22.4 | 74 | 118.7 | 53 |
| Umatilla County, OR | Non-metro | 81,119 | 21 | 338 | 25.9 | 5 | 6.2 | 64 |
| Benton County, WA | Metro | 221,722 | 34 | 802 | 15.3 | 47 | 21.2 | 154 |
| Franklin County, WA | Metro | 102,612 | 11 | 171 | 10.7 | 3 | 2.9 | 38 |
| Yakima County, WA | Metro | 259,185 | 39 | 585 | 15.0 | 24 | 9.3 | 170 |
| Chelan County, WA | Metro | 81,941 | 60 | 1,354 | 73.2 | 36 | 43.9 | 113 |
| Kittitas County, WA | Non-metro | 48,803 | 25 | 600 | 51.2 | not shown | n/a | 59 |
| Whitman County, WA | Non-metro | 48,512 | 10 | 181 | 20.6 | 3 | 6.2 | 35 |
This is the table that makes the Walla Walla case. The county had 74 wineries with 745 employees in 2023, 118.7 per 100,000 residents, more than five times Benton County's density and almost three times Chelan County's. Yet it had only 14 hotels, 22.4 per 100,000 residents, against 73.2 in Chelan County, the state's best comparison for a wine-and-recreation county. The county population is flat (62,361 in 2025, -0.4% since 2020), so hotel demand here is visitor demand, and the visitor attraction is wine.
Hotel employees in Walla Walla County averaged $34,703 in pay, 18.6% below the state average, and the average hotel had 21.6 employees. The study uses the local wage as a starting point and stresses it upward, because a boutique hotel with a restaurant competes for cooks and servers with 53 full-service restaurants and the wineries' own hospitality staff.
The Tri-Cities to the west (Benton and Franklin counties) hold 45 hotels and are the main alternative for visitors who will not pay Walla Walla rates. Umatilla County, Oregon, across the state line, has 21 hotels, mostly highway properties. A comp set for an upscale independent hotel draws from Walla Walla itself; the Tri-Cities matter as a ceiling on rate for price-sensitive segments.
Rural area test
| Place | Census base 2020 | Estimate 2025 | 5001.3 screen |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kennewick, WA | 83,957 | 88,366 | Over 50,000: excluded with its contiguous urbanized area |
| Pasco, WA | 77,324 | 82,848 | Over 50,000: excluded with its contiguous urbanized area |
| Richland, WA | 60,580 | 65,258 | Over 50,000: excluded with its contiguous urbanized area |
| Walla Walla, WA | 34,278 | 34,058 | Under 50,000: passes on population; contiguity decides |
| College Place, WA | 9,933 | 9,923 | Under 50,000: passes on population; contiguity decides |
| Milton-Freewater, OR | 7,155 | 7,029 | Under 50,000: passes on population; contiguity decides |
Part 5001 excludes cities and towns over 50,000 and the urbanized areas contiguous and adjacent to them, using the latest decennial census, and USDA will not approve an application subject to meeting the test later [1]. Walla Walla had 34,058 residents in the 2025 estimate, and the nearest cities over 50,000 are Kennewick, Pasco and Richland in the Tri-Cities, which are not contiguous. The site's Washington guide screens Walla Walla as eligible [11]. Walla Walla County is metropolitan in the OMB delineation, which is a county proxy and not the B&I test; the study recorded the parcel's status from the USDA eligibility map with a date.
Demand segments and the competitive set
| Demand segment (modeled, year 4) | Share of room nights | Room nights | Segment ADR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leisure: wine touring and weekend getaways | 52% | 9,566 | $293.22 |
| Events: weddings and winery events | 14% | 2,575 | $304.29 |
| Business and government travel | 18% | 3,311 | $243.43 |
| College and medical visits, relocations | 11% | 2,024 | $254.50 |
| Group tours and other | 5% | 920 | $235.13 |
| Total | 100% | 18,396 | $278.65 |
The segment mix is modeled. A real study builds it from lodging tax receipts, comp-set interviews, winery event calendars, the colleges' and hospitals' visitor programs and the hotel's own booking pace once it opens. Leisure carries half the room nights and most of the rate premium; events are the highest-rated segment but concentrated on weekends from spring to autumn.
| Competitor (modeled; a real study names each) | Rooms | Occupancy | ADR | RevPAR |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: upscale independent boutique, downtown | 48 | 71% | $278 | $197.38 |
| B: upscale independent inn, downtown | 34 | 68% | $248 | $168.64 |
| C: select-service branded hotel | 100 | 72% | $182 | $131.04 |
| D: select-service branded hotel | 80 | 70% | $172 | $120.40 |
| E: winery-area lodge | 24 | 60% | $315 | $189.00 |
| F: historic downtown hotel | 90 | 66% | $212 | $139.92 |
| Comp set (weighted) | 376 | 68.9% | $212.64 | $146.47 |
The six competitors are modeled to show the method, not taken from the engagement. A real study names each property, documents why it is in the set, and records its occupancy and rate by month and by weekday and weekend from operator interviews, rate shopping and any available benchmark data. The site's Washington guide records a 2022 B&I guarantee of $7,784,000 for the purchase of the Hampton Inn in Walla Walla [11], a reminder that branded select-service hotels in this market already use the same program and sit in the competitive set.
| Penetration test (modeled) | Value |
|---|---|
| Comp-set rooms / subject rooms | 376 / 72 |
| Subject fair share of rooms after opening | 16.1% |
| Comp-set occupancy and ADR today (modeled) | 68.9% at $212.64 |
| Subject occupancy penetration, year 4 (subject occupancy / comp-set occupancy) | 101.6% |
| Subject ADR index, opening-year dollars (subject ADR / comp-set ADR) | 119.9% |
| Comp-set demand growth assumed | 2.5% a year |
| Subject room nights, year 4 | 18,396 |
| Covered by comp-set demand growth over three years | 7,269 |
| Taken from competitors or induced by the new product | 11,127 |
The penetration test is where a reviewer decides whether the ADR is credible. The modeled hotel is priced at about 119.9% of the comp-set average and runs at 101.6% of comp-set occupancy by year 4. A boutique premium of that size is defensible only against the two upscale independents and the winery lodge, not against the branded select-service hotels, so the ADR support section compares the subject with properties A, B and E by season. The model also assumes the comp set's demand grows 2.5% a year; even so, about 11,127 of the subject's room nights in year 4 must come from competitors or be new demand the hotel creates, which is the number a lender should look at hardest.
Financing benchmarks
| Period | 7(a) loans | 7(a) dollars | 504 loans | 504 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2010 to FY2016 | 244 | $480.3 million | 62 | $111.3 million |
| FY2017 to FY2019 | 105 | $254.1 million | 25 | $69.2 million |
| FY2020 to FY2023 | 101 | $275.8 million | 19 | $53.3 million |
| FY2024 to FY2026 | 46 | $120.4 million | 12 | $37.0 million |
Average 7(a) loan, FY2020 to FY2026: $2.7 million. Average 504 loan: $2.9 million. Of the 244 7(a) loans approved in FY2010 to FY2016 for Washington hotels and motels, 1.2% were charged off (national: 3.0% of 4,928), on average 72 months after approval.
Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).
Washington hotels have borrowed heavily through SBA, with an average 7(a) loan of $2.7 million since FY2020, and seasoned losses have been low: 1.2% of FY2010 to FY2016 loans were charged off against 3.0% nationally. A $15 million-plus construction loan is above the SBA 7(a) maximum of $5,000,000 [15], which is one reason B&I is the guaranteed route for a hotel of this size. USAspending lists 14 B&I loans in Washington for FY2024 to FY2026 (counts may be incomplete).
Financial feasibility
Revenue and cost assumptions
| Revenue and cost assumption (modeled) | Value | Evidence a real study uses |
|---|---|---|
| Rooms | 72 keys, open 365 nights (26,280 room nights) | Plans; brand or operator standards |
| Occupancy, years 1 to 5 | 54%, 63%, 68%, 70%, 70% | Comp-set occupancy, monthly; ramp of new hotels in the set |
| Stabilized ADR, opening-year dollars | $255.00 | Comp-set rate shopping by season and day of week; OTA calendars |
| Opening discount to ADR, years 1 and 2 | 6% and 2% | Rate history of recent openings |
| ADR growth | 3.0% a year | Comp-set history; inflation |
| Food and beverage revenue | 30% of rooms revenue | Restaurant concept, seats, covers per day |
| Other revenue (events, tasting room hire, fees) | 4.5% of rooms revenue | Event calendar; winery partnership terms |
| Rooms department cost (incl. online travel agency commissions) | 25% of rooms revenue | Operator budget; channel mix |
| Food and beverage department cost | 74% of food and beverage revenue | Restaurant pro forma |
| Undistributed costs (A&G, sales, maintenance, utilities, IT) | 23.5% of revenue; +6% in year 1 | USALI-format operator budget |
| Management fee | 3.0% of revenue | Management agreement |
| Property tax and insurance | $205,000 and $118,800 in year 1, +3% a year | Assessor estimate; insurance quote |
| FF&E reserve | 2%, 3%, then 4% of revenue | Lender requirement; management agreement |
Debt terms
| Term (model) | Value | Rule or basis |
|---|---|---|
| Loan amount | $15,500,000 | $5 million to $25 million tier; B&I cap $25 million (5001.406(c)) |
| Guarantee | 80%: $12,400,000 guaranteed, $3,100,000 unguaranteed | FY2026 notice |
| Guarantee fee | 3.0% plus 0.50% because the guarantee is issued before construction completion: $434,000 | FY2026 notice; 5001.454 |
| Annual retention fee | 0.55% of guaranteed principal outstanding: $67,196 in year 2 | FY2026 notice; 5001.455 |
| Rate | 7.25% fixed (illustrative assumption) | Negotiated; not above the lender's rate on similar unguaranteed loans (5001.401) |
| Interest-only | 18 months of construction plus 12 months after opening; first full payment in month 31 of the note | First full principal and interest within 3 years of the note (5001.402) |
| Amortization | 25 years after interest-only; monthly payment $112,035; total term about 27.5 years | Useful life of building and FF&E, up to 40 years, no balloon (5001.402) |
| Early guarantee conditions | Fixed-price contract, independent inspector, equity in before loan funds, bonding or contractor vetting | 5001.205(e) |
Five-year pro forma
| Operating year | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Occupancy | 54.0% | 63.0% | 68.0% | 70.0% | 70.0% |
| Average daily rate (ADR) | $239.70 | $257.40 | $270.53 | $278.65 | $287.00 |
| RevPAR | $129.44 | $162.16 | $183.96 | $195.05 | $200.90 |
| Room nights sold | 14,191 | 16,556 | 17,870 | 18,396 | 18,396 |
| Rooms revenue | $3,401,631 | $4,261,568 | $4,834,470 | $5,125,961 | $5,279,739 |
| Food and beverage revenue | $1,020,489 | $1,278,470 | $1,450,341 | $1,537,788 | $1,583,922 |
| Other revenue (events, fees) | $153,073 | $191,771 | $217,551 | $230,668 | $237,588 |
| Total revenue | $4,575,193 | $5,731,809 | $6,502,363 | $6,894,417 | $7,101,249 |
| Departmental expenses | $1,682,106 | $2,107,345 | $2,390,646 | $2,534,787 | $2,610,831 |
| Undistributed expenses | $1,139,681 | $1,346,975 | $1,528,055 | $1,620,188 | $1,668,794 |
| Gross operating profit | $1,753,406 | $2,277,488 | $2,583,662 | $2,739,441 | $2,821,625 |
| Management fee (3%) | $137,256 | $171,954 | $195,071 | $206,833 | $213,037 |
| Property tax and insurance | $323,800 | $333,514 | $343,519 | $353,825 | $364,440 |
| FF&E reserve | $91,504 | $171,954 | $260,095 | $275,777 | $284,050 |
| Net operating income | $1,200,847 | $1,600,066 | $1,784,977 | $1,903,007 | $1,960,097 |
| Debt service (year 1 interest-only) | $1,123,750 | $1,344,421 | $1,344,421 | $1,344,421 | $1,344,421 |
| Retention fee (0.55% of guaranteed balance) | $68,200 | $67,196 | $66,117 | $64,957 | $63,710 |
| DSCR | 1.07x | 1.19x | 1.33x | 1.42x | 1.46x |
| DSCR after retention fee | 1.01x | 1.13x | 1.27x | 1.35x | 1.39x |
The modeled hotel opens at 54% occupancy and an ADR of $239.70, earns $1,200,847 of net operating income in year 1, and covers interest-only payments of $1,123,750 at 1.07x. Full payments of $1,344,421 a year start in year 2, when coverage is 1.19x; it reaches 1.33x in year 3 and 1.42x at stabilization in year 4. Gross operating profit settles near 39.7% of revenue and NOI near 27.6% after management fee, property tax, insurance and a 4% FF&E reserve. Coverage passes 1.25x from year 3, inside the card's 36 to 48 month stabilization window, and that is why the interest-only period matters: without it, year 1 would carry $1,344,421 of debt service on $1,200,847 of NOI.
Opening-year cash flow by month
| Opening year | Occupancy | Revenue | NOI | Interest-only payment | Cash after debt | Cumulative |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Month 1 (Jan) | 32.9% | $200,833 | -$5,003 | $93,646 | -$98,649 | -$98,649 |
| Feb | 37.3% | $210,365 | $548 | $93,646 | -$93,098 | -$191,747 |
| Mar | 45.0% | $296,813 | $50,890 | $93,646 | -$42,756 | -$234,503 |
| Apr | 53.7% | $365,432 | $90,850 | $93,646 | -$2,796 | -$237,298 |
| May | 61.4% | $453,354 | $142,051 | $93,646 | $48,405 | -$188,894 |
| Jun | 65.8% | $483,627 | $159,680 | $93,646 | $66,034 | -$122,860 |
| Jul | 66.9% | $512,826 | $176,683 | $93,646 | $83,037 | -$39,822 |
| Aug | 65.8% | $499,748 | $169,068 | $93,646 | $75,422 | $35,600 |
| Sep | 66.9% | $505,474 | $172,402 | $93,646 | $78,756 | $114,356 |
| Oct | 61.4% | $462,073 | $147,128 | $93,646 | $53,482 | $167,837 |
| Nov | 49.3% | $325,432 | $67,556 | $93,646 | -$26,090 | $141,747 |
| Dec | 40.6% | $259,215 | $28,995 | $93,646 | -$64,651 | $77,097 |
The monthly model is the evidence behind the interest-only request. Opening in January, the worst month in a wine-country hotel, the cumulative cash position after interest bottoms at -$237,298 in April before the summer and harvest months refill it, and ends the year at $77,097. The $700,000 reserve covers the trough with room for a weaker spring. Opening in May instead would avoid most of the trough, which is a scheduling recommendation the study can make to the sponsor and contractor.
Break-even and stress tests
| Break-even measure (year 4, stabilized) | Occupancy needed | Base-case occupancy |
|---|---|---|
| Cover debt service (1.00x) at base ADR $278.65 | 59.9% | 70.0% |
| Cover 1.25x at base ADR | 66.0% | 70.0% |
| Cover 1.00x with ADR 15% lower ($236.85) | 70.5% | 70.0% |
At stabilized rates the hotel covers its debt at 59.9% occupancy and 1.25x at 66.0%. If ADR is 15% lower than modeled, break-even rises to 70.5%, above the base-case occupancy. Rate, not occupancy, is the assumption that decides this file.
| Occupancy \ ADR | base ($279) | -10% | -15% | -20% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 70% | 1.42x | 1.13x | 0.98x | 0.84x |
| 65% | 1.21x | 0.94x | 0.81x | 0.67x |
| 60% | 1.00x | 0.76x | 0.63x | 0.51x |
| 55% | 0.80x | 0.57x | 0.46x | 0.34x |
| 50% | 0.59x | 0.39x | 0.28x | 0.18x |
| Scenario (year 4) | NOI | Debt service | DSCR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base case, year 4 | $1,903,007 | $1,344,421 | 1.42x |
| Rate 8.25% (+1 point) | $1,903,007 | $1,466,517 | 1.30x |
| Rate 9.25% (+2 points) | $1,903,007 | $1,592,870 | 1.19x |
| Construction overrun of 10% ($1,483,760) added to the loan | $1,903,007 | $1,473,117 | 1.29x |
| Ramp one year slower (year-4 occupancy at 68%) | $1,792,235 | $1,344,421 | 1.33x |
| Undistributed costs 10% higher (wages, utilities) | $1,740,988 | $1,344,421 | 1.29x |
| New competing hotel: occupancy -5 points, ADR -3% | $1,518,075 | $1,344,421 | 1.13x |
A one-point rate rise takes stabilized coverage to 1.30x; two points take it to 1.19x. A 10% building overrun of $1,483,760 financed with more debt gives 1.29x, and higher wages and utilities give 1.29x. The most damaging single event is a new competing hotel that costs five points of occupancy and 3% of rate, which leaves 1.13x. That is why the pipeline of planned hotels is part of the market section and not an afterthought.
| Six-month opening delay (modeled) | Amount |
|---|---|
| Extra interest on a fully drawn loan, 6 months at 7.25% | $561,875 |
| Property tax, insurance and retained pre-opening staff | $311,900 |
| Cash needed beyond the budget | $873,775 |
| Working capital and ramp-up reserve in the budget | $700,000 |
| Interest-only months after opening | 6 on the original schedule; at most 11 if extended to the 3-year limit of 5001.402 |
A six-month opening delay costs about $873,775 in interest and carrying costs, more than the $700,000 reserve. The study recommended that the sponsor hold a completion commitment or standby equity for that amount and that the construction contract carry liquidated damages, since the early guarantee requires a fixed-price contract with an independent contractor in any case [1].
Equity test
| New-business test | Required | Modeled | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5001.105(d)(3): construction, guarantee before completion: 25% of project cost | $6,226,400 | $9,405,600 | Pass |
| 5001.105(d)(3) alternative: 25% balance-sheet equity (debt to equity at most 3 to 1) at closing | 25% of assets | 37.8% | Pass |
| 5001.105(d)(4) if the guarantee waits for completion: 20% balance-sheet equity or 25% of cost | $6,226,400 (cost test) | $9,405,600 | Pass |
| 5001.205(e)(2): equity injected before any guaranteed loan funds | Timing test | First draws are equity | Structured |
Appraisal and collateral
| Appraisal and collateral (modeled) | Value | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| As-is value (land and approvals) | $1,250,000 | Required for construction loans (5001.203) |
| Prospective value at stabilization (income approach) | $22,400,000 | Year-4 NOI capitalized at 8.5% (assumption); the appraiser sets the rate |
| Less business value (going concern: brand, staff, booking history) | -$2,100,000 | Deducted before discounting (5001.203) |
| Less FF&E (valued separately) | -$1,400,000 | Separate chattel collateral |
| Real property value | $18,900,000 | |
| Real property discounted at 80% | $15,120,000 | Lender discount (assumption) |
| FF&E discounted at 40% | $560,000 | Lender discount (assumption) |
| Discounted collateral | $15,680,000 | |
| Loan amount | $15,500,000 | |
| Discounted coverage | 1.01x | Below 1.00x means the guarantee and equity carry the gap |
Hotel values include business value: the brand or reputation, trained staff, and booking history. Part 5001 requires the appraisal to give an as-is and a prospective value for construction and to deduct going concern value before the lender discounts collateral [1]. In the model the discounted collateral just covers the loan (1.01x), and the loan is 69.2% of prospective value. The point for the sponsor is that the equity, not the building, carries the lender through a weak opening.
Technical and environmental feasibility
The technical section confirmed the site before the market work: land use approval for a hotel and restaurant, utility capacity for a commercial kitchen and laundry, parking and access, and the eligibility map. It then reviewed the design against the operator's requirements and the 2010 ADA Standards, which set the number and type of accessible guest rooms for new lodging [10]. The construction budget was checked line by line against the contractor's guaranteed maximum price, and the schedule against the 18-month draw period and the opening season.
Environmental review is a separate Agency requirement rather than one of the five feasibility components. The study listed what that review would ask for on a greenfield hotel site: prior site use and any Phase I environmental site assessment, stormwater, and any cultural resources or floodplain questions. Each has a schedule effect that belongs in the timetable the early guarantee requires.
Management and governance feasibility
A new owning company has no operating history, so management feasibility rests on the people and contracts behind it. The study reviewed the operator's record at comparable independent hotels with restaurants, the management agreement (fee, term, termination and performance tests), the staffing plan at local wages, and the sponsor's construction experience. For an independent hotel, the sales and distribution plan stands in for a brand: website booking engine, online travel agency mix and commission cost, and partnerships with wineries for event business.
Part 5001 adds ownership tests. Owners of 20% or more give personal or corporate guarantees, at least in proportion to ownership, for the life of the loan [1], and the borrower and its 20% owners must be free of federal judgments, delinquent federal debt and debarment [1]. A hotel with a bar must also keep gambling income at no more than 15% of gross revenue [1]; the site's Washington guide notes that a hotel or restaurant with an attached house-banked card room usually exceeds that limit [11], so the revenue schedule shows any gaming separately.
Economic and community impact (modeled)
| Effect (modeled) | Amount | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Construction spending (hard costs and land) | $19,373,600 | Budget above |
| Permanent jobs at stabilization (FTE) | 58 | Staffing plan assumption: about 0.8 FTE per key with restaurant |
| Average hotel pay used | $42,624 | Washington hotels and motels, CBP 2023 (pack) |
| Annual payroll at that average | $2,472,205 | FTE x average pay |
| Guest nights a year at stabilization | 33,113 | Room nights x 1.8 guests (assumption) |
| Food and beverage sales, year 4 | $1,537,788 | Pro forma |
| Walla Walla County hotels today | 14 | CBP 2023 |
The modeled hotel adds about 58 permanent jobs and $2,472,205 of payroll at the state's average hotel wage of $42,624, plus construction spending concentrated in the 18-month build. Its larger effect is on the visitor economy: guests who stay in Walla Walla rather than the Tri-Cities spend their evenings and their dinner money in town, which is the economic case a rural development reviewer reads for.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | Effect in the model | Mitigant |
|---|---|---|
| ADR below plan | Break-even occupancy 70.5% at -15% ADR | Season-by-season ADR support against the three upscale comps; conservative opening discount |
| Slow ramp | 1.33x if the ramp runs a year behind | Interest-only through opening year; reserve sized from the monthly model |
| New competing hotel | 1.13x at -5 points of occupancy and -3% ADR | Pipeline review at the city; stress shown to the lender |
| Construction overrun | 1.29x if 10% is debt-financed | Guaranteed maximum price; contingency; overruns funded with equity |
| Opening delay | $873,775 of extra cost | Completion commitment or standby equity; liquidated damages |
| Labour cost | 1.29x with undistributed costs 10% higher | Local wage benchmark, stressed; staffing plan with housing and scheduling |
| Interest rate | 1.30x at +1 point | Fixed rate at closing; rate change before closing needs Agency approval (5001.401) |
| Seasonality | Cumulative cash low of -$237,298 in the opening year | Opening in spring; reserve; quarterly cash flow to the lender |
| Gambling income | Ineligibility above 15% of revenue | No card room; any gaming shown separately |
What the five Part 5001 components showed
Part 5001 organises an acceptable study into economic, market, technical, financial and management feasibility [3].
| Component | What the modeled study found | What a reviewer checks |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Walla Walla has the state's densest winery cluster and few hotels; visitor demand, not population, drives the market | Visitor data, lodging tax, winery and event calendars |
| Market | ADR at about 119.9% of the comp set and occupancy at the comp-set level by year 4; about 11,127 room nights must come from competitors or new demand | Comp-set selection, rate support by season, pipeline |
| Technical | Site, utilities, ADA room count and a guaranteed maximum price fit an 18-month build | Contract, schedule, inspector, permits |
| Financial | 1.19x in year 2, 1.42x stabilized; break-even at 59.9% occupancy; reserve covers the opening-year trough | Monthly cash flow, stress tests, equity timing |
| Management | Operator record, management agreement and distribution plan stand in for a brand | Operator results at similar hotels, agreement terms, staffing plan |
Rural hotel studies come back from lenders and state offices for recurring reasons:
- A comp set chosen by distance rather than product, mixing select-service rates into a boutique ADR without saying so.
- Annual averages that hide the winter trough an interest-only period is meant to cover.
- Occupancy at or above the comp set from year 1, with no ramp.
- No count of hotels planned or under construction.
- Wages taken from a state average when the local market is tighter or looser.
- Appraised value that includes business value as if it were real estate.
- A study written by the developer or the operator instead of an independent consultant.
- A rural-area claim based on city population alone, without the contiguity check.
Program terms that applied
| FY2026 B&I term | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Guarantee, loans of $5 million to $25 million | 80% | 91 FR 11272 [2] |
| Guarantee fee | 3.0% of the guaranteed portion | 91 FR 11272 [2] |
| Extra fee, guarantee issued before construction completion | 0.50% | 91 FR 11272 [2] |
| Reduced-fee option | 1.0% fee and 0.50% retention, 80% guarantee, only for loans meeting the Agency's criteria | 91 FR 11272 [2] |
| Annual retention fee | 0.55% of guaranteed principal outstanding at 31 December | 91 FR 11272 [2]; 5001.455 [1] |
| Maximum loan | $25 million per borrower | 5001.406(c) [1] |
| Term | Useful life, up to 40 years; no balloon; first full payment within 3 years | 5001.402 [1] |
| Rate | Negotiated, not above the lender's rate on similar unguaranteed loans | 5001.401 [1] |
| Equity, new business with construction and early guarantee | 25% balance-sheet equity or 25% of project cost | 5001.105(d)(3) [1] |
| Feasibility study | Required over $1,000,000 for a new business | 5001.306(a)(3)(i) [1] |
| Rural area | Outside cities over 50,000 and their contiguous urbanized areas | 5001.3 [1] |
Guarantee percentages and fees are set each fiscal year. FY2026 began on 1 October 2025, so a loan studied in 2025 may have been obligated under the FY2025 or the FY2026 notice depending on its date; this page shows the FY2026 terms.
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Price the hotel against the right competitors. A boutique premium is credible against other independents and winery lodging, not against the highway brands. Say which is which.
- Show the winter. A monthly opening-year model is what justifies interest-only payments and sizes the reserve.
- Open in spring if you can. The same hotel needs less reserve if it does not open into its worst months.
- Carry more equity than the minimum. At current rates the 25% floor leaves coverage too thin; equity is what made this model work.
- Count the pipeline. One new competitor is the single largest threat in the stress tests.
- Separate business value from real estate. The appraisal will, so the equity plan should assume it.
- Confirm the rural status with a dated map determination. A metropolitan county is not a bar, but the reviewer needs the parcel answer.
Related pages
- USDA B&I engagements: the program page listing this engagement with the firm's other Business and Industry studies.
- Hotel feasibility study for USDA loans: national rules, data, comp-set method and worked examples.
- Washington hotel feasibility study and the Washington USDA feasibility study guide: state data, eligible towns and precedents.
- Case studies: other engagements written up in full.
- USDA feasibility study framework: how Part 5001 decides a file.
If you are planning a hotel in a rural market with a B&I guarantee, a USDA feasibility study consultant can build the comp set and the monthly cash flow your lender and the state office will read first. Hotels are among the asset classes on the site's cost page; standard B&I studies take six to seven weeks and complex ones seven to nine [12]. Request a proposal for a fifteen-minute scoping call and a written, fixed-fee proposal [13].
USDA Feasibility, Inc.