How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
In 2024 a feasibility study was prepared for a community childcare and family center in Worthington, Minnesota, financed with a USDA Community Facilities (CF) direct loan under $5 million. USDA was the lender, and the study was prepared with utilization and operating analysis. This page works through the questions that kind of study answers, using a modeled 104-space center with a family center wing and public data for Nobles County.
Childcare is the hardest community facility to finance from its own revenue. Staffing is fixed by licensed ratios, tuition is capped by what local families can pay, and the margin between full enrollment and break-even is a handful of children. The model shows how a CF direct loan, a grant-heavy capital stack and signed partner contracts can make a center bankable, and how quickly it stops being bankable when any one of them is missing. Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
| Published record | Detail |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Community Facilities direct loan |
| Asset | Community childcare and family center |
| Location | Worthington, Minnesota (Nobles County, Midwest region) |
| Loan size tier | Under $5 million |
| Year | 2024 |
| Lender | USDA direct |
| Outcome | Prepared with utilization and operating analysis |
Source: this site's engagement index [18]. The scope, budget, enrollment, rates, staffing and projections below are a model.
The engagement card on the index carried a longer summary. This page keeps what the regulations and data on file support and marks the rest.
| Statement in the engagement card | Status on this page |
|---|---|
| Child care centers and community centers are eligible CF direct facilities | Kept in substance: CF finances community, social and educational facilities, and Part 5001 treats not-for-profit childcare as not inherently commercial [1][3]. The card's specific citation to a list in 1942.17(d) was not checked |
| Under $5 million "the CF Financial Feasibility Analysis tier applies; no examination opinion required" | Corrected. Those tiers belong to CF guaranteed loans (5001.304) [1][2]. A CF direct loan needs a financial feasibility report by a qualified firm or individual, independent of management and construction when the facility's revenue repays the loan (1942.17(h)(1)) [3]. Loan size does not set the report type |
| CF direct "market rate option for all loans; terms up to 40 years" | Corrected in part. 1942.17(f) has three rate tiers (poverty, intermediate and market); the term runs to useful life, state statute or 40 years, whichever is less [3] |
| Greater Minnesota lost more than 20,000 childcare slots, including more than 35,000 family child care slots | Not used; no source in this site's data |
| Child Care Assistance Program waiting lists, families and children served, and the $1,710 average monthly payment | Not used; no source in this site's data |
| In 2023 maximum subsidy provider rates were raised "from 35% to 75% of market" | Not used as stated; it needs a primary source and may describe market-rate percentiles rather than shares of market |
| A rural child care innovation program run with the state agency as a companion funding stream | Kept as the card's statement; the model includes an assumed state or regional facility grant but does not name a program |
| Deliverables: enrollment by age cohort and fill rates at 18, 24 and 36 months, subsidy revenue analysis, cost per child-day, ratios under Minnesota licensing, five-year break-even and cash flow | Consistent with the published outcome; this page shows each in model form |
The question USDA needed answered
When USDA lends directly, the State Office needs to know that the borrower is eligible, that the town qualifies, that families will enroll at the rates the plan assumes, that the center can hire staff at the ratios its license requires, and that the operation covers its costs, the required reserve and the annual installment. For a new childcare center, every one of those is uncertain before opening.
The rule for evidence is in 1942.17(h)(1): every CF direct applicant provides a financial feasibility report by a qualified firm or individual, and where the project depends on its own revenue to repay the loan and significantly affects the applicant's finances, the preparer must be independent of the facility's management and construction [3]. A new center with its own building meets both conditions. The report also carries the appendix B content Rural Development uses for Community Facilities: need for the facility, service area, population trends, similar facilities, usage trends, community support and regulatory approval [2].
| Financing route for a childcare center | What must be submitted | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| CF direct loan (this engagement) | Financial feasibility report by a qualified, independent preparer | 1942.17(h)(1) [3] |
| CF grant | Grant limited to the minimum needed for feasibility | 3570.61(d) [4] |
| CF guaranteed loan, existing center up to $25 million or strong audited history | Financial feasibility analysis under appendix B | 5001.304(a) [1][2] |
| CF guaranteed loan, other cases | Financial feasibility study with a CPA examination opinion | 5001.304(b) [1][2] |
| CF guaranteed over $1,000,000 to a new entity or activity | Independent feasibility study | 5001.304(a)(4)(i) [1] |
| B&I over $1,000,000 to a new for-profit business | Independent feasibility study | 5001.306(a)(3)(i) [1] |
Eligibility and program fit
| Test | Rule | Worthington result |
|---|---|---|
| CF direct population limit | City or town of 20,000 or less under the latest decennial census (1942.17) [3] | Eligible: 13,937 residents in the Census Bureau's April 2020 estimates base, 13,979 in July 2025 [10] |
| CF grant | 20,000 or less with a service-area income test; up to 75% at 5,000 or less, 55% at 12,000 or less, 35% at 20,000 or less (3570.53, 3570.63) [4] | Above 12,000, so the 35% tier at most, and only if service-area median household income is below the higher of the poverty line or 80% of the state non-metro median |
| Borrower | Public body, nonprofit with significant community ties, or tribe [3] | Modeled as a local nonprofit with a community board; a city-owned building leased to the operator is an alternative |
| Credit elsewhere | Applicant certifies it cannot get credit elsewhere at reasonable rates and terms [3] | Documented in the application |
| County setting | Non-metro proxy | Nobles County is non-metro in the OMB July 2023 delineation [11] |
The program choice is not close, and the model shows why:
| Route for the same loan amount | Rate and term (illustrative) | Annual debt service | Up-front guarantee fee | Retention fee, Year 1 | Year 3 coverage on the model's cash flow |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CF direct (model) | 4.75%, 40 years | $155,377 | none | none | 1.36x |
| CF guaranteed from a bank (illustrative) | 7.50%, 25 years | $246,527 | $27,800 | $10,963 | 0.82x |
| B&I guaranteed, for-profit operator (illustrative) | 7.50%, 25 years | $246,527 | $70,890 | $12,812 | 0.81x |
On the same loan, a CF direct installment at an illustrative 4.75% over 40 years is about $91,000 a year lower than a lender-made guaranteed loan at an illustrative 7.50% over 25 years. The model center covers the direct loan 1.36 times and would not cover either guaranteed loan. A CF guarantee would still score well here: 15 priority points for a community under 20,000, 10 for an early education facility and 15 for other funds of 50% or more [1]. But points do not change the payment, and the guarantee would add a 1.25% fee and a 0.50% annual retention fee [5].
Project description (modeled)
The model is a new single-story building of 11,600 square feet: 9,800 for seven licensed classrooms with support space and 1,800 for a family center with a community room, a parent education and screening room and offices for partner programs. It sits on land contributed by the city.
| Modeled scope | Detail |
|---|---|
| Licensed spaces | 104 (16 infant, 28 toddler, 40 preschool, 20 school-age) |
| Classrooms | 7 |
| Family center | Community room, parent education and screening room, partner offices |
| Hours | About 11 a day, five days a week, 50 billed weeks a year |
| Staff | 21.8 full-time equivalents at stabilization |
| Employer partners | 30 reserved seats under seat agreements |
| Modeled timeline | Months | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Preapplication to the area office | 0 | Review notice within 45 days [3] |
| Feasibility report, architectural report, environmental review | 1 to 5 | Environmental review under 7 CFR part 1970 [3] |
| Partner agreements and grant commitments | 2 to 8 | Committed before the letter of conditions |
| Letter of conditions and closing | 6 to 11 | Applicant and partner funds deposited first [3] |
| Construction | 11 to 23 | 12 months |
| Licensing, hiring, opening | 21 to 24 | Pre-opening costs in the budget |
| Enrollment ramp | 24 to 42 | 11 to 18 months by age group |
Project cost and sources and uses
Every line is an assumption with a range. A real budget comes from the architect's estimate, contractor bids, vendor quotes and the appraisal of the donated land.
| Use of funds (modeled) | Amount | Share | Assumption range and how a real study sources it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Building, 11,600 gross sq ft (childcare 9,800 and family center 1,800) at $380/sq ft | $4,408,000 | 64.5% | $320 to $460 per sq ft; contractor bids |
| Site work, parking, drop-off loop and utilities | $380,000 | 5.6% | $250,000 to $550,000; civil estimate |
| Outdoor play areas with fencing and surfacing | $160,000 | 2.3% | $110,000 to $240,000; vendor quotes |
| Commercial kitchen equipment | $85,000 | 1.2% | Vendor quotes |
| Hard cost subtotal | $5,033,000 | 73.7% | |
| Construction contingency, 7% | $352,000 | 5.2% | 5% to 10% |
| Architecture and engineering, 8% | $403,000 | 5.9% | Design contract |
| Classroom furniture, equipment and family center fit-out | $210,000 | 3.1% | Vendor quotes |
| Permits, survey, geotechnical, environmental, testing | $110,000 | 1.6% | Fee schedules and quotes |
| Feasibility study, appraisal, legal and closing | $85,000 | 1.2% | Engagement letters |
| Land (contributed by the city, at appraised value) | $250,000 | 3.7% | Appraisal |
| Initial operating expenses: hiring, training, first months of operation | $320,000 | 4.7% | CF direct may finance initial operating expenses, ordinarily up to one year |
| Interest during construction, 12 months, average draw 50% at 4.75% | $66,025 | 1.0% | Draw schedule |
| Total project cost | $6,829,025 | 100.0% |
At $6,829,025 the center costs about $65,664 per licensed space. Two CF direct rules shape the budget. Interest during construction can be financed until the facility is self-supporting, for up to three years, and initial operating expenses can be financed, ordinarily for up to one year [3]. The model uses the second rule for $320,000 of hiring, training and early operating costs, which matters because a new center loses money while it fills; a CF guaranteed loan could not pay those costs [1].
| Source of funds (modeled) | Amount | Share | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| USDA Community Facilities direct loan | $2,780,000 | 40.7% | 40 years at an illustrative 4.75% |
| City land contribution (in kind) | $250,000 | 3.7% | Committed before the letter of conditions |
| City and county capital contributions | $700,000 | 10.3% | Committed before the letter of conditions |
| Employer partner capital contributions | $900,000 | 13.2% | Committed before the letter of conditions |
| State or regional childcare facility grant (assumed) | $600,000 | 8.8% | Committed before the letter of conditions |
| CF grant (assumes the service-area income test is met) | $1,000,000 | 14.6% | Committed before the letter of conditions |
| Capital campaign gifts collected | $599,025 | 8.8% | Committed before the letter of conditions |
| Total | $6,829,025 | 100.0% |
The modeled CF direct loan is $2,780,000, inside the published tier. Grants, land and partner money make up $4,049,025, or 59.3% of cost. That is the realistic shape of a rural childcare stack: the study's main financial task is not to justify the project cost but to find the debt the operation can carry, and the rest has to be raised. CF direct scoring awards 5 to 10 points for joint financing [3], and a CF grant, if the income test is met, is limited to the minimum needed to make the project feasible [4].
| Grant case (if the income test is met) | CF grant | Share of cost | CF direct loan | Annual installment | Cash flow needed for 1.25x |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No CF grant | $0 | 0.0% | $3,780,000 | $211,268 | $264,085 |
| CF grant of $1,000,000 (model) | $1,000,000 | 14.6% | $2,780,000 | $155,377 | $194,221 |
| CF grant at the 35% maximum | $2,390,159 | 35.0% | $1,389,841 | $77,680 | $97,099 |
Without the assumed $1,000,000 CF grant, the loan would rise to $3,780,000 and the center would need about $264,000 a year of cash flow for 1.25 times coverage; at the 35% maximum, about $97,000. The grant is the swing item in this stack, and its income test has to be confirmed before the plan relies on it.
Market analysis
Minnesota supply and the state picture
This site's Minnesota data module covers child care centers with paid staff [6][9][11]:
Minnesota: child care centers, supply and rural footprint
| Measure | Minnesota | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 1,423 → 1,473 (+3.5%) | 77,713 → 82,162 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 25.6 | 24.4 |
| Average employees per establishment | 13.8 | 12.7 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $29,990 | $29,695 |
| Share of establishments in non-metro counties | 13.6% (196 in 34 counties) | |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 21.9% |
Non-metro counties with the most child care centers (2023): Lyon County (13); Rice County (13); Crow Wing County (11); Itasca County (11); Douglas County (9); Goodhue County (8).
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
The rural gap is in the last two lines of the table. Non-metro counties hold 21.9% of Minnesota's people but only 13.6% of its centers. Nobles County is part of that gap: the county file shows 3 child care establishments with paid staff and 31 employees in 2023, about 13.4 per 100,000 residents against 25.6 statewide.
Regional comparison
| State | Centers, 2019 | Centers, 2023 | Change | Per 100,000 residents | Employees per center | Average pay | Share of centers in non-metro counties | Share of population in non-metro counties |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Minnesota | 1,423 | 1,473 | 3.5% | 25.6 | 13.8 | $29,990 | 13.6% | 21.9% |
| Iowa | 846 | 895 | 5.8% | 27.8 | 14.6 | $21,205 | 36.7% | 37.6% |
| South Dakota | 251 | 280 | 11.6% | 30.5 | 14.3 | $22,216 | 40.2% | 48.7% |
| North Dakota | 313 | 374 | 19.5% | 47.5 | 10.5 | $23,282 | 44.7% | 38.5% |
| Wisconsin | 1,584 | 1,588 | 0.3% | 26.8 | 12.0 | $28,585 | 15.5% | 25.4% |
| United States | 77,713 | 82,162 | 5.7% | 24.4 | 12.7 | $29,695 |
Source: this site's state data modules [6][9][11]. Minnesota pays childcare workers more than any neighbor, $29,990 per employee against $21,205 in Iowa and $22,216 in South Dakota, and it added centers more slowly than Iowa and the Dakotas. For a Worthington center the wage line is the first number a reviewer checks. The region's figures include part-time staff, so they are a floor for the full-time wage assumptions below, not a budget.
SBA lending as a benchmark
For-profit centers borrow from SBA lenders; nonprofits cannot, because SBA does not lend to nonprofit businesses [8]. The SBA record still shows the size of private childcare loans in the state [7]:
Minnesota: SBA lending to child care centers
| Period | 7(a) loans | 7(a) dollars | 504 loans | 504 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2010 to FY2016 | 85 | $48.8 million | 31 | $19.5 million |
| FY2017 to FY2019 | 59 | $42.4 million | 32 | $22.8 million |
| FY2020 to FY2023 | 41 | $21.8 million | 26 | $24.5 million |
| FY2024 to FY2026 | 42 | $42.0 million | 12 | $10.8 million |
Average 7(a) loan, FY2020 to FY2026: $768,510. Average 504 loan: $928,632. Of the 85 7(a) loans approved in FY2010 to FY2016 for Minnesota child care centers, 1.2% were charged off (national: 3.9% of 3,746), on average 74 months after approval.
Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).
Minnesota childcare loans have performed well: 1.2% of seasoned 7(a) loans were charged off against 3.9% nationally. The modeled CF direct loan of $2,780,000 is more than three and a half times the average Minnesota 7(a) childcare loan, because it finances a purpose-built building with a family center rather than a lease or an acquisition.
The service area: Nobles County
A childcare center's market is the commute of the parents who use it. The modeled primary service area is Nobles County, with the three Minnesota counties around it for context; a real study maps the home and work addresses of families on the sponsor's interest list and of the partner employers' staff.
| County | OMB 2023 | Population, April 2020 base | Population, July 2025 | Change | Births, 2021 to 2025 | Births, 2025 | Deaths, 2025 | Net migration, 2025 | Child care establishments with paid staff (624410) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nobles County | non-metro | 22,284 | 22,338 | 0.2% | 1,801 | 365 | 202 | -69 | 3 (31 employees) |
| Murray County | non-metro | 8,179 | 7,942 | -2.9% | 319 | 58 | 76 | -67 | fewer than 3 |
| Jackson County | non-metro | 9,988 | 9,857 | -1.3% | 440 | 92 | 100 | -7 | 5 (29 employees) |
| Rock County | metro | 9,697 | 9,524 | -1.8% | 439 | 85 | 115 | -8 | fewer than 3 |
Sources: Vintage 2025 county estimates [9]; County Business Patterns 2023, county file [6]; OMB July 2023 delineation [11]. The county extract used here lists industry cells with at least three establishments; "fewer than 3" means two, one or none. Rock County is part of a metropolitan area in the 2023 delineation.
Nobles County is the young county in its corner of the state. It recorded 365 births and 202 deaths in 2025, and 1,801 births from 2021 to 2025, while each neighbor had fewer births than deaths in 2025. Its population held steady from the April 2020 base (22,284) to July 2025 (22,338) despite net out-migration of -69 in 2025. A steady supply of births is the most direct demand signal a childcare study has: those children are the infant, toddler and preschool enrollment of the next five years.
| Place | Population, April 2020 base | Population, July 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Worthington city | 13,937 | 13,979 |
| Rural Nobles County (outside incorporated places) | 4,550 | 4,546 |
| Adrian city | 1,201 | 1,219 |
| Brewster city | 508 | 508 |
| Ellsworth city | 495 | 493 |
| Rushmore city | 371 | 373 |
| Round Lake city | 375 | 371 |
| Wilmont city | 332 | 329 |
Source: Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [10]. Worthington holds 62.6% of the county's people; Adrian, the next largest town, has about 1,200.
Demand model (assumptions)
The inputs hold births but not the share of children whose parents all work, so the model runs on stated assumptions. A real study replaces them with Census estimates of children under 6 with all parents in the labor force, the state's licensed capacity by county and age group, and the sponsor's interest list.
| Scenario (assumptions) | Children under 5 (births 2021 to 2025, less 3%) | All parents in the labor force | Families seeking licensed care | Licensed spaces needed, under 5 | Children aged 5 to 12 (assumed) | School-age spaces needed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low | 1,747 | 58% | 65% | 659 | 2,700 | 313 |
| Base | 1,747 | 65% | 75% | 852 | 2,900 | 471 |
| High | 1,747 | 72% | 85% | 1,069 | 3,100 | 670 |
| Licensed spaces for under-5s in the county, centers and family homes (placeholder) | Shortfall, low | Shortfall, base | Shortfall, high |
|---|---|---|---|
| 450 | 209 | 402 | 619 |
| 600 | 59 | 252 | 469 |
| 750 | -91 | 102 | 319 |
The supply column is a placeholder, not a count. Census business counts leave out licensed family child care homes, which carry much of rural Minnesota's capacity, so the real inventory comes from the state's licensing records, by age group. In the base case, the county needs about 852 licensed spaces for children under 5; the center's 84 under-5 spaces are a fraction of any plausible shortfall unless existing capacity is above about 770. Demand is not the binding constraint for this kind of project. Price and staffing are.
USDA Community Facilities activity in the region
| State | CF loan awards | CF grant awards | CF awards, total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minnesota | 22 | 26 | 48 |
| Iowa | 10 | 35 | 45 |
| South Dakota | 5 | 37 | 42 |
| North Dakota | 4 | 33 | 37 |
| Wisconsin | 6 | 35 | 41 |
Source: USAspending, award counts by place of performance, 1 October 2023 to 30 September 2026 [12]. Minnesota recorded 48 CF awards, 22 of them loans, more loans than any neighbor and tenth among the 51 states with data for awards overall. This site's Minnesota page records $1,000,000 of Rural Economic Development Loan and Grant funds that added care for 85 children at the Brainerd Family YMCA in 2023, and a $300,000 CF loan for assisted living in Bird Island [15].
How the study tests demand by age group
Total demand is the wrong test for a childcare center, because the license fixes capacity by age group and the shortage is rarely spread evenly. Infant and toddler care is scarce almost everywhere, because ratios of one adult to four infants make it the most expensive care to provide; preschool care is more often available through public prekindergarten and Head Start. A study therefore builds demand room by room:
- Infants and toddlers. Births in the last three years, the share of parents working, and the infant and toddler spaces licensed in the county. In the model, 44 of the 104 spaces are for children under 33 months, and those rooms fill first.
- Preschool. Children aged three and four, less those in public prekindergarten or Head Start, and the hours families need. A full-day center competes with part-day public programs on hours, not price.
- School-age. Children in kindergarten through sixth grade whose parents work past school hours, and the summer gap. School-age rooms fill more slowly and empty in some months, which is why the model holds them at 85%.
- Partner demand. The partner employers' staff with young children, their shifts and their commuting patterns. Shift work at a large employer can require early opening hours, which changes the staffing factor.
The interest list is the strongest single piece of evidence. A list with names, children's birth dates and preferred start dates lets the study build the ramp from real families rather than from rates; a list of names alone proves interest, not enrollment.
The family center: what it adds and how it is underwritten
The family center wing is 1,800 square feet, about 16% of the building, and in the model it brings in about $152,000 a year in Year 1 from program contracts and room rental. That is more than its share of the building's cost to operate, so it subsidizes the classrooms. A reviewer will look at it in three ways. Is the space part of an eligible community facility? Community, social and educational space for families is [1][3]; space used by public partners for family programs is part of that purpose, while commercial tenants are limited (under 25% of floor space for a CF guarantee, and only a minor part of a facility for a CF grant) [1][4]. Are the contracts real? The model counts only signed agreements with public partners, such as a school district or county, with a term and a price. And what happens if a partner leaves? Without the family center contracts, coverage falls to 0.40 times, so the study recommends staggered terms and more than one partner.
Financial feasibility
Revenue assumptions
| Revenue assumption (Year 1, modeled) | Value | How a real study sets it |
|---|---|---|
| Weekly tuition, infants | $335 | Tuition survey of licensed centers and family providers |
| Weekly tuition, toddlers | $300 | Tuition survey of licensed centers and family providers |
| Weekly tuition, preschool | $260 | Tuition survey of licensed centers and family providers |
| Weekly tuition, school-age | $180 | Tuition survey of licensed centers and family providers |
| Weeks billed a year | 50 | Center policy on closures and vacation credits |
| Share of children paid through the state subsidy program | 30% | County income data; operator history; 45% in stress |
| Subsidy payment as a share of the center's price | 94% | State maximum rates and co-payment collection; 85% in stress |
| Employer seat reservations | 30 seats at $3,600 a year | Signed reservation agreements |
| Family center contracts and room rental | $152,000 | Signed agreements with public partners |
| Food program reimbursement per enrolled child | $600 | Program rates and meal counts (assumption) |
| Annual increase: tuition / wages / other costs | 3.0% / 3.5% / 3.0% | Rate history; wage survey |
Two federal rules frame the subsidy line. States pay subsidy rates set from a market rate survey or an approved cost model, and since 13 July 2026 a federal final rule has removed the 2024 requirement to pay providers in advance and by enrollment; states must now pay either in advance or within 21 days of a complete invoice, and protect providers from occasional absences through the approach in their state plan [13][14]. A Minnesota study reads the state's current payment practice rather than assuming enrollment-based payment, and the sensitivity table tests subsidy receipts at 85% of price.
Staffing plan (modeled)
| Room or role | Rooms | Licensed spaces | Ratio (assumed) | Staff on the floor | FTE (11-hour day) | Year 1 wages |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Infants (6 weeks to 16 months) | 2 | 16 | 1:4 | 4.0 | 5.2 | $204,152 |
| Toddlers (16 to 33 months) | 2 | 28 | 1:7 | 4.0 | 5.2 | $204,152 |
| Preschool (33 months to kindergarten) | 2 | 40 | 1:10 | 4.0 | 5.2 | $204,152 |
| School-age (before and after school, summer) | 1 | 20 | 1:15 | 1.3 | 1.2 | $47,112 |
| Center director | 1.0 | $68,000 | ||||
| Family center coordinator (assistant director) | 1.0 | $52,000 | ||||
| Cook | 1.0 | $36,000 | ||||
| Office and subsidy billing | 1.0 | $40,000 | ||||
| Floating substitutes | 1.0 | $35,880 | ||||
| Total | 7 | 104 | 21.8 | $891,448 | ||
| Benefits and payroll taxes at 20% | $178,290 |
The ratios are model assumptions within the range of typical state rules; a real study takes them, with group sizes, from Minnesota's child care center licensing rule. Classroom staffing is the number of staff on the floor times 1.30 to cover an eleven-hour day, breaks and leave. Teachers average $39,260 a year in Year 1, well above the state's $29,990 per employee, which includes part-time staff. In Year 3, wages and benefits are 80.3% of operating expenses and 69.6% of revenue.
Enrollment ramp
| Age group | Licensed spaces | Enrollment at opening | Stabilized enrollment | Months to stabilize | Year 1 average | Year 2 average |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Infants (6 weeks to 16 months) | 16 | 60% | 97% | 11 | 81.2% | 97.0% |
| Toddlers (16 to 33 months) | 28 | 45% | 94% | 15 | 64.2% | 93.1% |
| Preschool (33 months to kindergarten) | 40 | 40% | 90% | 18 | 56.5% | 86.7% |
| School-age (before and after school, summer) | 20 | 30% | 85% | 17 | 49.2% | 82.4% |
Infant spaces fill first, because they are the scarcest care; preschool and school-age rooms take longer. The ramp is the assumption a reviewer questions most. A real study sets it from the interest list, deposits taken before opening and the fill rates of comparable new centers, and it shows enrollment at 18, 24 and 36 months.
Five-year pro forma
| Line (modeled) | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average enrolled children (full-time equivalent) | 63.4 | 92.7 | 94.8 | 94.8 | 94.8 |
| Enrollment as a share of 104 licensed spaces | 61.0% | 89.2% | 91.2% | 91.2% | 91.2% |
| Tuition and subsidy payments, net of subsidy shortfall | $854,170 | $1,264,428 | $1,329,092 | $1,368,964 | $1,410,033 |
| Employer seat reservation fees (30 seats) | $108,000 | $111,240 | $114,577 | $118,015 | $121,555 |
| Family center program contracts and room rental | $152,000 | $156,560 | $161,257 | $166,095 | $171,077 |
| Child care food program reimbursement (assumed) | $38,056 | $57,316 | $60,369 | $62,181 | $64,046 |
| Less uncollected tuition (1.5%) | -$12,813 | -$18,966 | -$19,936 | -$20,534 | -$21,150 |
| Total operating revenue | $1,139,413 | $1,570,578 | $1,645,359 | $1,694,719 | $1,745,561 |
| Salaries, wages and benefits | $951,015 | $1,107,178 | $1,145,930 | $1,186,037 | $1,227,549 |
| Food | $49,156 | $74,034 | $77,977 | $80,317 | $82,726 |
| Classroom supplies and curriculum | $28,542 | $42,987 | $45,277 | $46,635 | $48,034 |
| Utilities | $27,840 | $28,675 | $29,535 | $30,422 | $31,334 |
| Insurance | $28,000 | $28,840 | $29,705 | $30,596 | $31,514 |
| Repairs and maintenance | $12,760 | $13,143 | $13,537 | $13,943 | $14,361 |
| Cleaning contract | $17,400 | $17,922 | $18,460 | $19,013 | $19,584 |
| IT, child care software and administration | $26,000 | $26,780 | $27,583 | $28,411 | $29,263 |
| Audit and professional fees | $18,000 | $18,540 | $19,096 | $19,669 | $20,259 |
| Licensing, training and background checks | $12,000 | $12,360 | $12,731 | $13,113 | $13,506 |
| Marketing and enrollment | $15,000 | $6,180 | $6,365 | $6,556 | $6,753 |
| Total operating expenses | $1,185,713 | $1,376,639 | $1,426,197 | $1,474,713 | $1,524,884 |
| Net operating income | -$46,300 | $193,938 | $219,162 | $220,007 | $220,677 |
| Replacement reserve deposit | $8,000 | $8,240 | $8,487 | $8,742 | $9,004 |
| Cash flow available for debt service | -$54,300 | $185,698 | $210,674 | $211,265 | $211,673 |
| CF direct loan installment | $155,377 | $155,377 | $155,377 | $155,377 | $155,377 |
| Debt service coverage | -0.35x | 1.20x | 1.36x | 1.36x | 1.36x |
All figures are modeled. Coverage is cash flow after the replacement reserve divided by the annual installment.
In Year 3 the center enrolls 94.8 full-time-equivalent children, earns $1,645,359 and covers its installment 1.36x. The cost of care is about $15,038 per enrolled child a year, while tuition and subsidy bring in about $14,014. The gap is closed by the employer seat fees, the family center contracts and the food program, which is why those agreements are signed before the letter of conditions, not after opening. Year 2 coverage is 1.20x, still below a 1.25 times target while the preschool and school-age rooms fill.
Debt service and the required reserve (illustrative rate)
The rate is an assumption: 4.75% fixed over 40 years with level annual installments, close to the rate this site's childcare and healthcare pages use for late 2026 [16][17]. Rural Development sets CF direct rates at least quarterly: a poverty rate of not more than 5%, an intermediate rate of not more than 7%, or a market rate tied to the Bond Buyer index, depending on service-area income [3]. The term may not exceed the building's useful life, the state statute limit or 40 years [3].
| Loan year | Opening balance | Interest | Principal | Annual installment | Closing balance | Reserve balance (one tenth a year) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $2,780,000 | $131,535 | $23,841 | $155,377 | $2,756,159 | $15,538 |
| Year 2 | $2,756,159 | $130,378 | $24,999 | $155,377 | $2,731,160 | $31,075 |
| Year 3 | $2,731,160 | $129,164 | $26,213 | $155,377 | $2,704,947 | $46,613 |
| Year 4 | $2,704,947 | $127,892 | $27,485 | $155,377 | $2,677,462 | $62,151 |
| Year 5 | $2,677,462 | $126,557 | $28,819 | $155,377 | $2,648,643 | $77,688 |
The installment is $155,377. A CF direct borrower that pledges facility revenue builds a reserve of one average installment at one tenth a year [3], here $15,538 a year, paid from cash left after the installment. Over 40 years the loan costs $6,215,073, $3,435,073 of it interest at the assumed rate.
Break-even enrollment
| Enrollment as a share of the base case (Year 3) | Enrolled children | Share of licensed spaces | Revenue | Cash flow for debt service | Coverage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 80% | 75.9 | 73.0% | $1,371,454 | -$38,580 | -0.25x |
| 85% | 80.6 | 77.5% | $1,439,930 | $23,734 | 0.15x |
| 90% | 85.4 | 82.1% | $1,508,406 | $86,047 | 0.55x |
| 95% | 90.1 | 86.6% | $1,576,882 | $148,361 | 0.95x |
| 100% | 94.8 | 91.2% | $1,645,359 | $210,674 | 1.36x |
| Break-even, 95.6% | 90.6 | 87.1% | 1.00x | ||
| 1.25x, 98.7% | 93.6 | 90.0% | 1.25x |
The center breaks even at about 91 enrolled children, 87.1% of its licensed spaces and 95.6% of the base case, and reaches 1.25 times at about 94 children. The margin between the stabilized plan and break-even is four or five children. That is the defining fact of childcare finance: staff are set by room and ratio, so an empty space saves almost nothing while it costs a full tuition.
Sensitivity and stress tests
| Scenario (modeled) | Year 1 coverage | Year 3 coverage | Year 5 coverage | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base case | -0.35x | 1.36x | 1.36x | |
| Enrollment 10% lower in every room | -0.87x | 0.55x | 0.51x | |
| No employer seat reservations | -1.04x | 0.62x | 0.58x | |
| No family center contracts (room rental only) | -1.25x | 0.40x | 0.35x | |
| Subsidy share 45% instead of 30% | -0.40x | 1.28x | 1.28x | |
| Subsidy pays 85% of price instead of 94% | -0.50x | 1.12x | 1.12x | |
| Wages 8% higher (recruitment market) | -0.84x | 0.77x | 0.73x | |
| Tuition 5% lower | -0.62x | 0.93x | 0.92x | |
| One infant room closed for lack of staff | -0.49x | 1.08x | 1.07x | |
| Construction overrun of 10% of hard cost, added to the loan | -0.29x | 1.14x | 1.15x | loan $3,300,000 |
| Rate 5.75% instead of 4.75% | -0.31x | 1.19x | 1.19x | |
| No CF grant: the $1,000,000 is borrowed instead | -0.26x | 1.00x | 1.00x | loan $3,780,000 |
The tests separate what the plan can absorb from what it cannot:
- The contracts carry the debt. Without the employer seat agreements coverage falls to 0.62 times; without the family center contracts, to 0.40.
- Enrollment and wages are the operating risks. Enrollment 10% lower in every room takes coverage to 0.55 times, and wages 8% higher to 0.77. A center in a tight labor market should not plan for both full rooms and today's wages.
- Subsidy terms matter more than subsidy volume. A larger share of subsidized children costs little if the state pays close to the center's price (1.28 times at a 45% share); receipts at 85% of price cost more (1.12).
- One staffing gap is survivable. Closing an infant room for lack of staff leaves coverage at 1.08 times.
- Debt terms matter less. A 10% overrun added to the loan, or a rate a point higher, leaves coverage near 1.15 to 1.20; borrowing the CF grant amount instead leaves 1.00.
Start-up funds and the first year
| Year 1 scenario (modeled) | Cash flow for debt service | Installment | Year 1 shortfall | Start-up funds left ($260,000 after pre-opening) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base case | -$54,300 | $155,377 | -$209,677 | $50,323 | covered |
| Enrollment 10% lower | -$134,471 | $155,377 | -$289,848 | -$29,848 | not covered |
| No employer seat reservations | -$162,300 | $155,377 | -$317,677 | -$57,677 | not covered |
| Wages 8% higher | -$130,381 | $155,377 | -$285,758 | -$25,758 | not covered |
| One infant room closed | -$76,297 | $155,377 | -$231,674 | $28,326 | covered |
The budget's $320,000 of initial operating funds leaves about $260,000 after pre-opening hiring and training. That covers the base-case first-year shortfall of -$209,677 with about $50,000 to spare, and a closed infant room, but not lower enrollment, lost employer seats or higher wages. A study that finds this recommends a larger start-up line, a partner commitment to cover first-year losses, or an interest-only period; CF direct rules allow principal deferral of up to 36 months [3].
Equity and contribution test under the CF direct rule
| Test | Modeled result | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Other funds in the project | $4,049,025, 59.3% of cost | No fixed percentage in the Part 1942 sections read; joint financing earns 5 to 10 points [3] |
| CF grant | $1,000,000, minimum needed for feasibility, if the income test is met | 3570.61(d), 3570.63 [4] |
| Funds deposited before loan money | Partner and grant funds at closing | Letter of conditions [3] |
| Start-up costs | $320,000 financed as initial operating expenses | 1942.17(d)(1)(iv) [3] |
| Reserve | $15,538 a year to one installment | 1942.17(i)(2) [3] |
Technical and environmental feasibility
- Licensing. The building must meet the state's center licensing requirements for indoor space per child, outdoor play space, toilets, food service and infant areas, and the license sets capacity by age group. The study confirms the room plan against the licensing rule before the pro forma is final.
- Life safety and design. Childcare occupancies carry specific fire, egress and sprinkler requirements; the architect's code review sets them.
- Head Start partnership option. If a classroom hosts Early Head Start, the federal standard applies: two teachers with no more than eight children under 36 months, or three with no more than nine, with each teacher primarily responsible for no more than four [19]. The stricter of the federal and state rule governs.
- Environmental review and site. USDA completes an environmental review under 7 CFR part 1970 before it commits [3]. A site on prime or unique farmland raises the CF direct rate by two percentage points [3]; a city-contributed lot inside town usually avoids that.
- Construction timing. Construction obligations entered before approval can make costs ineligible (1942.17(d)(1)(v)) [3].
Management and governance feasibility
A new childcare center succeeds or fails on its director and its board. The study looks for a director with licensed center experience, subsidy billing capacity in the business office, and a board with significant ties to the community, which CF requires of a nonprofit borrower [3]. It reads the partner agreements as carefully as the budget: the employer seat agreements (number of seats, fee, term and what happens if a seat is unused), the family center contracts with public partners, and any grant conditions. A recruitment plan with wage evidence belongs in this section, because every room the center cannot staff is a room it cannot fill.
Process and documents
| Step | What happens | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Preapplication | Filed with the area office; review notice within 45 days | 1942.2 [3] |
| Feasibility and design | Financial feasibility report, preliminary architectural report, environmental review | 1942.17(h) [3] |
| Public steps | Public information meeting with ten days' notice where no vote is required | 1942.17(j) [3] |
| Letter of conditions | Sets loan amount, rate tier, reserve and conditions | 1942.17 [3] |
| Closing | Applicant and partner funds deposited before loan funds | 1942.17(n) [3] |
Documents the State Office will look for: the room plan and license application; the interest list or waiting list by age; tuition schedules of competing providers; partner agreements; grant commitment letters; the operator's budget and staffing plan; organizational documents, board resolutions and local government support letters. This site's cost page lists Community Facilities studies at $6,900 to $12,000 and 6 to 8 weeks from the engagement letter [16].
Economic and community impact (modeled)
| Impact measure (modeled) | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Licensed child care spaces added | 104 | Room plan |
| Infant and toddler spaces among them | 44 | Room plan; the scarcest care |
| Children enrolled at stabilization | 95 | Pro forma, Year 3 |
| Jobs (full-time equivalents) | 21.8 | Staffing plan |
| Year 3 payroll and benefits | $1,145,930 | Pro forma |
| Employer partners' reserved seats | 30 | Assumed agreements |
| Construction spending (hard cost and contingency) | $5,385,000 | Budget |
The impact that matters most to a State Office is care that lets parents work. In a county with about 365 births a year and three centers with paid staff in the Census count, 104 licensed spaces, 44 of them for infants and toddlers, are a large addition. The partner employers reserve seats because unfilled shifts cost them more than the seat fee.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | How it shows up in the model | Mitigant the study tests |
|---|---|---|
| Enrollment below plan | 10% lower gives 0.55x | Interest list and deposits; ramp by age group; marketing to partner employers' staff |
| Partner contracts end | Without employer seats 0.62x; without family center contracts 0.40x | Multi-year agreements; several employers; notice periods |
| Staffing shortage | One infant room closed gives 1.08x | Recruitment plan; wage evidence; substitute pool |
| Wage growth | 8% higher gives 0.77x | Wage plan in the tuition policy; partner wage support |
| Subsidy payment terms | 85% of price gives 1.12x | State payment practice under the 2026 federal rule [13] |
| CF grant not available | Loan rises to $3,780,000; 1.00x | Income test confirmed early; other grants |
| First-year losses | Base case covered with about $50,000 to spare; stresses not covered | Larger start-up line; partner loss guarantee; principal deferral |
| Construction overrun | 10% added to the loan gives 1.14x | Contingency; fixed-price contract |
What the five Part 5001 components showed
The CF direct rule asks for a financial feasibility report; a childcare study is usually organized around Part 5001's five components with the appendix B need-for-facility content [2]:
| Component | What the model shows | What a reviewer still asks |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | 104 spaces; 21.8 jobs; parents able to work | Partner employers' own evidence of the need |
| Market and need | 1,801 births in five years; base-case need of about 852 under-5 spaces | Licensed capacity by age from state records |
| Technical | Seven classrooms and a family center on donated land | Licensing review of the room plan |
| Financial | Coverage 1.36x at stabilization; break-even about 91 children | Signed partner agreements; start-up funds under stress |
| Management | Director, board and billing capacity | Director hired or named; recruitment plan |
Why childcare studies are sent back
- Enrollment assumed at capacity from opening, or in total rather than by room and age group.
- Staffing built from the state's average employees per center rather than ratios by room.
- Partner revenue counted from letters of support instead of signed agreements.
- Subsidy revenue assumed to be paid on enrollment without reading the state's current payment practice.
- No first-year operating funds, or start-up costs placed in a CF guaranteed loan that cannot pay them [1].
- A CF grant counted before the income test is confirmed.
Program terms that applied
| Term | CF direct rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Population limit | City or town of 20,000 or less | 1942.17 [3] |
| Interest rate | Poverty (not more than 5%), intermediate (not more than 7%) or market (Bond Buyer index); set at least quarterly | 1942.17(f) [3] |
| Term | Useful life, state statute or 40 years, whichever is less; principal deferral up to 36 months | 1942.17(f)(7) [3] |
| Start-up | Construction interest up to three years; initial operating expenses ordinarily up to one year | 1942.17(d)(1)(iv) [3] |
| Reserve | One average installment, built at one tenth a year | 1942.17(i)(2) [3] |
| Feasibility evidence | Financial feasibility report by a qualified, independent preparer | 1942.17(h)(1) [3] |
| Guarantee and fees | None; USDA is the lender | |
| CF grant | Up to 35% at this population if the income test is met; minimum needed for feasibility | 3570.61, 3570.63 [4] |
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Sign the partner agreements first. In this model the employer seats and family center contracts are the difference between 1.36 times and well under 1.00.
- Size the loan to the operation, not the building. The study's job is to find the debt the center can carry; grants and partners fund the rest.
- Use CF direct's start-up rule. Initial operating expenses can be financed for up to a year; a new center needs that room.
- Model by room and ratio. Staff follow rooms, not children, and the break-even is a few children below full.
- Confirm the grant's income test early. Without the grant, the same center barely covers its debt.
- Read the state's subsidy payment practice. Since July 2026 federal rules leave more to the state plan, and payment terms move coverage more than subsidy volume does.
Related pages
- The CF direct engagement page lists this program's engagements, including this one.
- The national childcare feasibility study page sets out CF, B&I and SBA rules, ratios, revenue streams and worked examples [17].
- The Minnesota childcare center feasibility study page and the Minnesota state page carry the state's data, office and precedents.
- The Community Facilities feasibility study page explains the program, and the case studies page lists long-form work, including the illustrative Maine childcare case study, which reaches a similar conclusion: there, a 113-slot center carries a $1.75 million CF direct loan only with 40 seats reserved by anchor employers [17].
If you are planning a rural childcare center or family center and need a USDA feasibility study consultant, the engagement index describes the process: a fifteen-minute scoping call, a written proposal inside one business day and a firm fixed fee before you sign [18]. Request a proposal for your study [20].
Data current as of November 2026.
USDA Feasibility, Inc.