How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
In 2025 a feasibility study was prepared for the replacement of a critical access hospital in Mountain Home, Arkansas, to be financed with a USDA Community Facilities (CF) direct loan of more than $25 million. USDA was the lender. The study was prepared with service-area demand and financial sustainability analysis. This page works through what that kind of study has to prove, using a modeled 25-bed replacement hospital, public rules for critical access hospitals, and Census data for Baxter County and the five counties around it.
Three conclusions run through the model. A critical access hospital's Medicare revenue follows its costs, so the new building's interest and depreciation are partly paid back through the cost report; the rest has to come from other payers. Coverage is far more sensitive to volume and commercial rates than to the interest rate. And a ten-year view matters, because costs that grow faster than non-Medicare rates squeeze a hospital slowly, after the first-year numbers look comfortable. Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
| Published record | Detail |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Community Facilities direct loan |
| Asset | Rural hospital: critical access hospital replacement |
| Location | Mountain Home, Arkansas (Baxter County) |
| Loan size tier | Greater than $25 million |
| Year | 2025 |
| Lender | USDA direct |
| Outcome | Prepared with service-area demand and financial sustainability analysis |
Source: this site's engagement index [17]. The scope, budget, volumes, payer mix and projections below are a model.
The engagement card on the index also carried a longer summary. This page keeps what the regulations and data on file support and marks the rest.
| Statement in the engagement card | Status on this page |
|---|---|
| Critical access hospitals are paid by Medicare at 101% of allowable cost | Kept; 42 CFR 413.70 [8] |
| A critical access hospital has 25 inpatient beds or fewer and sits at least 35 miles from the nearest hospital (15 miles in mountainous terrain) | Kept, with the full rule: more than a 35-mile drive on primary roads, 15 miles in mountainous terrain or where only secondary roads exist, unless the state certified the hospital as a necessary provider before 1 January 2006; plus an annual average acute stay of 96 hours or less (42 CFR 485.610, 485.620) [7] |
| Emergency services around the clock | Kept as the card's statement; the CMS condition was not read for this page |
| Arkansas requires a certificate of need for hospital construction, and the study package included the documentation | Kept as the card's statement; Arkansas hospital rules were not read for this page. CF direct loans do need a state statement on the State Medical Facilities Plan [3] |
| Above $25 million the engagement required "the highest CF feasibility tier", a CPA-examined "Financial Feasibility Study with Examination Opinion" | Corrected. The examination-opinion tier belongs to CF guaranteed loans (5001.304(b)) [1][2]. A CF direct loan needs a financial feasibility report by a qualified firm or individual, independent of the facility's management and construction where facility revenue repays the debt (1942.17(h)(1)) [3]. Loan size does not set the report type |
| CF direct market rate option applies; terms up to 40 years | Kept; 1942.17(f) sets poverty, intermediate and market rate tiers and a term of up to 40 years [3] |
| Rural Health Transformation Program as a federal capital backdrop | Kept in part: this site's Arkansas page records a $208,779,396 FY2026 award to Arkansas from CMS and treats the money as grant funds, not a source of debt service [14]. The card's $50 billion national figure is not used |
| 768 rural hospitals at risk nationally (315 imminently); six Arkansas conversions to Rural Emergency Hospital; a named hospital bankruptcy; commercial premiums up more than 20% in 2025 | Not used; no source in this site's data |
| Service-area utilization from AHRQ HCUP data and a rural Medicare plus Medicaid share of 70% to 80% | Kept as the card's description of the work; the model uses its own payer assumptions (Medicare 55% and Medicaid 20% of volume, inside that range) |
| A ten-year financial sustainability analysis | Consistent with the published outcome; this page shows a ten-year coverage and liquidity table |
The question USDA needed answered
When USDA is the lender, the State Office is both underwriter and program manager. Before it issues a letter of conditions for a replacement hospital it needs to know four things: that the applicant and the town are eligible; that the replacement keeps the hospital's critical access status, on which its Medicare revenue depends; that the service area will use the new building at the volumes projected; and that the hospital can operate, build the required reserve and pay the loan for its full term without draining its cash.
The CF direct rule makes the evidence explicit. Every applicant provides a financial feasibility report by a qualified firm or individual, and the preparer must have no interest in the facility's management or construction when the project depends on its own revenue to repay the loan and significantly affects the applicant's finances [3]. A replacement hospital meets both conditions. The same report has to carry the appendix B content Rural Development uses for Community Facilities: the need for the facility, the service area and its population trends, similar facilities, usage trends, community support and regulatory approval [2].
| Financing route for a rural hospital | What must be submitted | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| CF direct loan (this engagement) | Financial feasibility report by a qualified, independent preparer when facility revenue repays the loan | 1942.17(h)(1) [3] |
| CF guaranteed loan, existing facility up to $25 million or strong audited history | Financial feasibility analysis under appendix B | 5001.304(a) [1][2] |
| CF guaranteed loan, other cases | Financial feasibility study with a CPA examination opinion | 5001.304(b) [1][2] |
| CF guaranteed over $1,000,000 to a new entity or activity | Independent feasibility study | 5001.304(a)(4)(i) [1] |
| CF grant | Grant limited to the minimum needed for feasibility | 3570.61(d) [4] |
Eligibility and program fit
| Test | Rule | Mountain Home result |
|---|---|---|
| CF direct population limit | City or town of 20,000 or less under the latest decennial census (1942.17) [3] | Eligible: 12,820 residents in the Census Bureau's April 2020 estimates base, 13,373 in July 2025 [10] |
| CF grant | 20,000 or less with a service-area income test; up to 75% of cost at 5,000 or less, 55% at 12,000 or less, 35% at 20,000 or less (3570.53, 3570.63) [4] | Above 12,000, so the 35% tier at most, and only if service-area income is below the higher of the poverty line or 80% of the state non-metro median |
| Borrower | Public body, nonprofit with significant community ties, or tribe [3] | Modeled as a nonprofit hospital with a community board |
| Credit elsewhere | Applicant certifies it cannot get credit elsewhere at reasonable rates and terms; a CF direct borrower must refinance privately when it can [3] | Documented in the application |
| Critical access status | CMS location, distance, bed and length-of-stay tests (42 CFR 485.610, 485.620) [7] | Must be confirmed for the new site before design |
| County setting | Non-metro proxy | Baxter County is non-metro in the OMB July 2023 delineation [11] |
Mountain Home is comfortably inside the CF direct population limit, which matters because CF direct is the cheapest long-term money available to a nonprofit hospital. Its size still has costs. It earns none of the population points the CF direct scoring system gives to towns of 5,500 or fewer, and at more than 12,000 people it can reach at most the 35% grant tier [3][4]. Health care projects earn up to 25 points when they correct a health or sanitary problem or meet a standard, and 5 points otherwise; service-area income can add 20 to 25, and joint financing 5 to 10 [3]. A replacement that brings an old building up to current standards should document that it meets a standard, because the difference is 20 points.
Other routes exist, and the study compares them. A CF guaranteed loan from a commercial lender can sit beside CF direct money for the balance of a large project, with an 80% guarantee and a 1.25% fee in FY2026 [5]. A CF guarantee can also refinance a rural hospital's existing debt when annual payments fall and historical coverage is at least 1.1 times [1]. B&I applies only to a for-profit hospital and charges 3.0% [5].
Project description (modeled)
The model replaces an older hospital with a new 64,000 square foot, 25-bed building on a new site: an inpatient unit for acute and swing-bed patients, an eight-bay emergency department, two operating rooms and an endoscopy room, imaging (CT, X-ray, ultrasound, mammography), laboratory, pharmacy, rehabilitation and a specialty clinic suite for visiting physicians.
| Modeled scope | Old building (Year 0) | New building |
|---|---|---|
| Licensed inpatient beds | 25 | 25 (critical access maximum) |
| Acute inpatient days a year | 3,100 | Grows with recaptured services |
| Swing-bed days a year | 1,900 | Same mix |
| Average daily inpatient census (acute and swing) | 13.7 | 15.7 by Year 5 |
| Adjusted patient days (inpatient days scaled up for outpatient work) | 17,000 | 17,680 in Year 1 |
| Building area | Older, smaller plant | 64,000 sq ft |
| Modeled timeline | Months | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Preapplication to the area office | 0 | Review notice within 45 days [3] |
| Feasibility report, preliminary architectural report, environmental review | 1 to 6 | Environmental review under 7 CFR part 1970 [3] |
| Full application, letter of conditions | 6 to 12 | Depends on the State Office's CF direct allocation |
| Design completion, bids, loan closing | 12 to 18 | Applicant funds deposited before loan funds [3] |
| Construction | 18 to 48 | 30 months |
| Move, dual operation and opening | 48 to 50 | Transition costs in the budget |
Project cost and sources and uses
No construction-cost database sits behind this page. Each line is an assumption with a range and the document a real study would use: the construction manager's estimate, equipment quotes and the architect's report.
| Use of funds (modeled) | Amount | Share | Assumption range and source in a real study | Funded by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Land for the replacement site (about 30 acres) | $1,200,000 | 1.6% | $600,000 to $2,000,000; purchase contract and appraisal | Loan |
| Site work, utilities, parking, ambulance and helipad access | $4,100,000 | 5.5% | $3.0 million to $6.0 million; civil engineer's estimate | Loan |
| Hospital building, 64,000 gross sq ft at $620/sq ft | $39,680,000 | 52.8% | $540 to $760 per sq ft; construction manager's estimate and bids | Loan |
| Central utility plant, generators and medical gas | $3,000,000 | 4.0% | $2.4 million to $4.0 million; mechanical engineer's estimate | Loan |
| Construction contingency, 8% of site, building and plant | $3,742,000 | 5.0% | 6% to 10%; design stage dependent | Loan |
| Architecture, engineering and construction management, 8% | $3,742,000 | 5.0% | 7% to 10%; design and CM contracts | Loan |
| Owner's representative, commissioning, permits, surveys, environmental | $1,350,000 | 1.8% | Quotes and fee schedules | Loan |
| Feasibility study, appraisal, legal and closing | $450,000 | 0.6% | Engagement letters | Loan |
| Demolition or repurposing of the old hospital | $1,000,000 | 1.3% | $0.5 million to $2.0 million; reuse plan | Loan |
| Transition: dual operation, training, move and start-up costs | $1,400,000 | 1.9% | Operator budget; CF direct may fund initial operating expenses | Loan |
| Interest during construction, 30 months, average draw 50% at 4.75% | $3,690,156 | 4.9% | Draw schedule; CF direct allows up to three years | Loan |
| Major medical equipment (CT, imaging, surgery, lab) | $7,400,000 | 9.8% | Vendor quotes; 5 to 10 year useful life | Hospital funds |
| IT, electronic health record migration, nurse call, telecom | $2,500,000 | 3.3% | Vendor quotes | Hospital funds |
| Furniture, fixtures and equipment | $1,900,000 | 2.5% | Vendor quotes | Hospital funds |
| Total project cost | $75,154,156 | 100.0% |
At $75,154,156, the modeled project costs about $3,006,166 per licensed bed, a figure that means little on its own because most of a critical access hospital's space serves outpatients, the emergency department and diagnostics. Two CF direct rules shape the budget. Interest during construction can be financed until the facility is self-supporting, for up to three years, and initial operating expenses can be financed, ordinarily for up to one year [3]; the transition line uses that room. And the loan term may not run past the useful life of what it finances, the limit in state statute or 40 years, whichever is less [3]. Equipment, IT and furniture wear out in five to ten years, so the model pays for them with $11,800,000 of the hospital's own money and keeps the 40-year loan for land, building, site and long-lived soft costs.
| Source of funds (modeled) | Amount | Share | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| USDA Community Facilities direct loan | $62,150,000 | 82.7% | 40 years at an illustrative 4.75%; long-lived assets only |
| Hospital unrestricted cash | $9,004,156 | 12.0% | Deposited before loan funds, as CF direct closings require |
| Hospital foundation campaign | $4,000,000 | 5.3% | Collected gifts only |
| Total | $75,154,156 | 100.0% |
The modeled CF direct loan is $62,150,000, inside the published tier of more than $25 million. The hospital and its foundation put in $13,004,156, 17.3% of cost. Part 1942 sets no fixed equity percentage in the sections this site has read; the State Office looks at whether the loan can be repaid from the facility's revenue with the applicant's own funds in, and the letter of conditions requires those funds to be deposited before loan money is spent [3].
Market analysis
Arkansas physician supply and the state picture
This site's state data module for medical clinics covers physician offices; it is the closest public measure of the referral base a rural hospital depends on [6][9][11]:
Arkansas: physician offices, supply and rural footprint
| Measure | Arkansas | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 2,099 → 1,991 (-5.1%) | 222,880 → 218,066 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 64.9 | 64.8 |
| Average employees per establishment | 11.6 | 12.7 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $101,608 | $104,929 |
| Share of establishments in non-metro counties | 27.7% (544 in 44 counties) | |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 38.0% |
Non-metro counties with the most physician offices (2023): Baxter County (54); Jefferson County (53); White County (40); Boone County (38); Union County (34); Pope County (33).
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
Baxter County has more physician offices than any other non-metro county in Arkansas: 54, or about 126 per 100,000 residents against 64.9 statewide. That is the profile of a regional medical center for the north-central Ozarks, not of an isolated town. For a hospital replacement it cuts two ways. A deep physician base supports referrals, surgery and specialty clinics in the new building. It also means competition for outpatient work, and it makes the critical access distance test something the study must document rather than assume.
Regional comparison
| State | Physician offices, 2019 | Physician offices, 2023 | Change | Per 100,000 residents | Average pay | Share of offices in non-metro counties | Share of population in non-metro counties |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arkansas | 2,099 | 1,991 | -5.1% | 64.9 | $101,608 | 27.7% | 38.0% |
| Missouri | 3,409 | 3,248 | -4.7% | 52.3 | $120,032 | 14.4% | 24.4% |
| Oklahoma | 2,548 | 2,492 | -2.2% | 61.3 | $105,151 | 18.2% | 31.8% |
| Tennessee | 4,483 | 4,471 | -0.3% | 62.5 | $100,396 | 14.2% | 21.1% |
| Mississippi | 1,588 | 1,514 | -4.7% | 51.5 | $91,775 | 41.8% | 50.0% |
| Louisiana | 3,589 | 3,156 | -12.1% | 68.6 | $97,885 | 10.1% | 15.5% |
| Texas | 22,185 | 22,601 | 1.9% | 73.6 | $104,773 | 4.8% | 9.4% |
| United States | 222,880 | 218,066 | -2.2% | 64.8 | $104,929 |
Source: this site's state data modules [6][9][11]. Arkansas matches the national density of physician offices but lost 5.1% of them between 2019 and 2023, more than any neighbor except Louisiana. Its offices are concentrated in metro counties: 27.7% of them sit in non-metro counties that hold 38.0% of the state's people. Rural Arkansas hospitals therefore recruit against a shrinking and urbanizing physician base, which is why a replacement study tests a scenario in which a key physician leaves.
SBA lending to Arkansas practices shows the scale of private medical borrowing next to a hospital loan [13]:
Arkansas: SBA lending to physician offices and outpatient care centers (NAICS 6211 and 6214)
| Period | 7(a) loans | 7(a) dollars | 504 loans | 504 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2010 to FY2016 | 24 | $8.4 million | 3 | $3.6 million |
| FY2017 to FY2019 | 11 | $8.9 million | 2 | $1.9 million |
| FY2020 to FY2023 | 14 | $3.4 million | 1 | $1.5 million |
| FY2024 to FY2026 | 12 | $11.4 million | 1 | $1.7 million |
Average 7(a) loan, FY2020 to FY2026: $567,792. Average 504 loan: $1.6 million. Arkansas had fewer than 30 seasoned 7(a) loans for physician offices and outpatient care centers (NAICS 6211 and 6214); nationally, 4.8% of 6,596 FY2010 to FY2016 loans were charged off, on average 67 months after approval.
Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).
These figures describe physician practices and outpatient centers, not hospitals; SBA does not lend to nonprofits. They matter here because the clinic suite in a replacement hospital competes with, and depends on, practices of this size. The modeled CF direct loan is more than a hundred times the average Arkansas 7(a) practice loan.
The service area: Baxter County and five neighbors
The modeled primary service area is Baxter County and the five Arkansas counties around it, all served by USDA Rural Development's Harrison area office [14]. A real study defines it from patient-origin data: the home ZIP codes of the hospital's own inpatients, emergency patients and outpatients.
| County | Population, April 2020 base | Population, July 2025 | Change | Births, 2025 | Deaths, 2025 | Net migration, 2025 | Physician offices (6211) | Outpatient care centers (6214) | Nursing homes (623110) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baxter County | 41,634 | 42,982 | 3.2% | 359 | 835 | 599 | 54 | 18 | 5 |
| Marion County | 16,821 | 17,593 | 4.6% | 112 | 267 | 175 | fewer than 3 | fewer than 3 | fewer than 3 |
| Fulton County | 12,072 | 12,492 | 3.5% | 123 | 241 | 58 | 3 | fewer than 3 | fewer than 3 |
| Izard County | 13,579 | 14,405 | 6.1% | 129 | 223 | 201 | fewer than 3 | 4 | fewer than 3 |
| Stone County | 12,356 | 12,703 | 2.8% | 110 | 229 | 91 | 6 | 4 | fewer than 3 |
| Searcy County | 7,833 | 7,848 | 0.2% | 70 | 127 | 62 | fewer than 3 | 4 | fewer than 3 |
| Six-county area | 104,295 | 108,023 | 3.6% | 903 | 1,922 | 1,186 |
Sources: Vintage 2025 county estimates [9]; County Business Patterns 2023, county file [6]; OMB July 2023 delineation [11]. The county extract used here lists industry cells with at least three establishments; "fewer than 3" means two, one or none. All six counties are non-metro.
The area grew 3.6% from the April 2020 base to 108,023 in July 2025, entirely through migration: in 2025 deaths outnumbered births 2.1 to 1 (1,922 against 903), while net migration added 1,186 people. Baxter County alone recorded 4,286 deaths and 1,755 births from 2021 to 2025. That pattern, older residents arriving and few children being born, points to a large and growing Medicare population. It supports inpatient, swing-bed, imaging and emergency demand, and it makes Medicare's payment method the most important line in the financial model.
| Incorporated place | County | Population, April 2020 base | Population, July 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mountain Home city | Baxter | 12,820 | 13,373 |
| Gassville city | Baxter | 2,170 | 2,205 |
| Bull Shoals city | Marion | 1,954 | 1,888 |
| Flippin city | Marion | 1,345 | 1,290 |
| Yellville city | Marion | 1,170 | 1,095 |
| Cotter city | Baxter | 889 | 946 |
| Lakeview city | Baxter | 775 | 783 |
| Summit city | Marion | 543 | 526 |
| Salesville city | Baxter | 473 | 524 |
| Norfork city | Baxter | 470 | 482 |
Source: Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [10]. In Baxter and Marion counties, Mountain Home is the only town above 2,500 people; the next largest, Gassville, has about 2,200.
Demand model (assumptions)
The inputs hold no hospital discharge or emergency visit data, so the demand model runs on stated use rates. A real study takes them from state discharge data and the hospital's own patient-origin files.
| Scenario (assumptions) | Acute inpatient days per 1,000 residents | Area acute days | Share kept at the replacement hospital | Acute days at the hospital | ED visits per 1,000 residents | Area ED visits | Share at the hospital | ED visits at the hospital |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low | 380 | 41,049 | 5.0% | 2,052 | 360 | 38,888 | 24% | 9,333 |
| Base | 450 | 48,610 | 6.0% | 2,917 | 400 | 43,209 | 27% | 11,666 |
| High | 520 | 56,172 | 7.0% | 3,932 | 450 | 48,610 | 30% | 14,583 |
The modeled old building's 3,100 acute days equal about 6.4% of base-case area demand, and its emergency department is assumed to see about 27% of area visits. The low share is expected. A 25-bed critical access hospital with a 96-hour average acute stay keeps short, lower-acuity admissions, observation, swing-bed rehabilitation and most emergency care; complex surgery and cardiac care go to larger hospitals. The study's job is to show which services the new building can bring back, and how many patient days that recapture is worth. The model assumes volume rises 4% in each of the first two years and 3% in the third, then 1.5% a year.
USDA Community Facilities activity in the region
| State | CF loan awards | CF grant awards | CF awards, total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arkansas | 0 | 36 | 36 |
| Missouri | 8 | 24 | 32 |
| Oklahoma | 10 | 37 | 47 |
| Tennessee | 38 | 31 | 69 |
| Mississippi | 5 | 25 | 30 |
| Louisiana | 7 | 15 | 22 |
| Texas | 3 | 37 | 40 |
Source: USAspending, award counts by place of performance, 1 October 2023 to 30 September 2026 [12]. Counts are by program, not facility type. USAspending shows 36 CF awards in Arkansas in that window, all grants and no loans; Tennessee recorded 38 CF loans. On this site's Arkansas page, the most recent CF loans named are a $5,000,000 loan for a replacement clinic in Pocahontas and $223,000 of Emergency Rural Health funds in Clinton, both in 2023 [14]. A CF direct loan of more than $25 million for a hospital is therefore large by Arkansas's recent standards, and the State Office's allocation is part of the feasibility question.
Financial feasibility
How critical access hospitals are paid, and the payer assumptions
Medicare pays a critical access hospital 101% of the reasonable cost of its services rather than fixed prospective rates [8]. In a model this means Medicare revenue is computed from cost: total allowable cost, including depreciation and interest on the new building, times Medicare's share of the hospital's volume, times 1.01. Every other payer pays per service.
| Payer (modeled share of volume) | Share | Payment assumption | How a real study sets it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Medicare (cost-based) | 55% | 101% of allowable cost for the Medicare share | 42 CFR 413.70; Medicare cost report |
| Medicaid (Arkansas Medicaid and managed care) | 20% | $2,250 per adjusted patient day (Year 1 dollars) | Payer contracts, state rate schedules, collection history |
| Commercial insurance | 18% | $4,300 per adjusted patient day (Year 1 dollars) | Payer contracts, state rate schedules, collection history |
| Self-pay and uninsured | 5% | $350 per adjusted patient day (Year 1 dollars) | Payer contracts, state rate schedules, collection history |
| Other (VA, workers' compensation) | 2% | $2,800 per adjusted patient day (Year 1 dollars) | Payer contracts, state rate schedules, collection history |
| Weighted non-Medicare rate | 45% | $2,883 per adjusted patient day | Computed |
The shares and rates are assumptions; a real study takes them from the hospital's Medicare cost reports, payer contracts and remittance history. The model also assumes 6% of costs are not allowable on the cost report, and $1.6 million a year of other operating revenue. Grant awards such as the state's Rural Health Transformation money are left out of the revenue available for debt service, as this site's Arkansas page advises [14].
The cost-based method gives a replacement hospital a partial cushion. In Year 1 the new building and its equipment add about $6,151,453 of depreciation and interest. With Medicare carrying 55% of volume, 6% of cost unallowable and the 101% factor, Medicare pays back about $3,212,104 of that (52.2%), and the remaining $2,939,349 has to come from other payers and margin. A study that models a critical access hospital on fee-for-service rates misses that cushion; one that assumes Medicare pays for the whole building overstates it.
Five-year pro forma
| Line (modeled) | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adjusted patient days | 17,680 | 18,387 | 18,939 | 19,223 | 19,511 |
| Medicare, cost-based at 101% of allowable cost (Medicare share of volume 55%) | $29,250,425 | $30,433,785 | $31,586,559 | $32,644,713 | $33,744,285 |
| Medicaid, commercial, self-pay and other payers | $22,939,800 | $24,334,540 | $25,565,868 | $26,468,343 | $27,402,675 |
| Other operating revenue | $1,600,000 | $1,632,000 | $1,664,640 | $1,697,933 | $1,731,891 |
| Total operating revenue | $53,790,225 | $56,400,324 | $58,817,067 | $60,810,988 | $62,878,852 |
| Fixed cash operating costs (staffing, plant, administration) | $32,400,000 | $33,534,000 | $34,707,690 | $35,922,459 | $37,179,745 |
| Variable cash costs ($920 per adjusted patient day, escalated) | $16,265,600 | $17,423,711 | $18,484,815 | $19,324,950 | $20,203,268 |
| Total cash operating expenses | $48,665,600 | $50,957,711 | $53,192,505 | $55,247,409 | $57,383,014 |
| Operating cash flow (EBIDA) | $5,124,625 | $5,442,614 | $5,624,562 | $5,563,580 | $5,495,838 |
| EBIDA margin | 9.5% | 9.6% | 9.6% | 9.1% | 8.7% |
| Depreciation | $4,410,833 | $4,410,833 | $4,410,833 | $4,410,833 | $4,410,833 |
| Interest on the CF direct loan | $2,940,620 | $2,914,744 | $2,887,612 | $2,859,162 | $2,829,332 |
| Net income | -$2,226,829 | -$1,882,964 | -$1,673,883 | -$1,706,416 | -$1,744,327 |
| CF direct debt service (principal and interest) | $3,473,622 | $3,473,622 | $3,473,622 | $3,473,622 | $3,473,622 |
| Debt service coverage (EBIDA / debt service) | 1.48x | 1.57x | 1.62x | 1.60x | 1.58x |
| Reserve deposit (one tenth of an annual installment) | $347,362 | $347,362 | $347,362 | $347,362 | $347,362 |
| Unrestricted cash at year end | $11,803,641 | $11,925,270 | $12,228,848 | $12,471,443 | $12,646,297 |
| Days cash on hand | 89 | 85 | 84 | 82 | 80 |
All figures are modeled. Coverage is operating cash flow before depreciation and interest (EBIDA) divided by the annual installment on the CF direct loan. Year 1 is the first full year in the new building.
In Year 3 the hospital earns $58,817,067 of revenue and $5,624,562 of EBIDA, a 9.6% margin, and covers its installment 1.62x. Medicare provides 53.7% of revenue. Net income is negative in every year shown, because the new building's depreciation is larger than the old one's; a reviewer will expect the study to say so and to show that cash, not accounting income, carries the debt. Days cash on hand drift down from 89 to 80, because routine capital spending of $1.5 million a year and the reserve deposit absorb most of what remains after debt service.
Debt service on the CF direct loan (illustrative rate)
The rate is an assumption: 4.75% fixed over 40 years with level annual installments, close to the rate this site's other case studies model for late 2026 [15]. Rural Development sets CF direct rates at least quarterly in three tiers: a poverty rate of not more than 5% where service-area median household income is below the poverty line or 80% of the state non-metro median (for health care facilities only the income test applies), an intermediate rate of not more than 7% where income is no more than 100% of that median, and a market rate tied to the Bond Buyer index for everyone else [3]. The applicant may ask for the lower of the rate at approval or at closing [3].
| Loan year | Opening balance | Interest | Principal | Annual installment | Closing balance | Reserve built at one tenth a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $62,150,000 | $2,940,620 | $533,002 | $3,473,622 | $61,616,998 | $347,362 |
| Year 2 | $61,616,998 | $2,914,744 | $558,878 | $3,473,622 | $61,058,121 | $694,724 |
| Year 3 | $61,058,121 | $2,887,612 | $586,010 | $3,473,622 | $60,472,111 | $1,042,087 |
| Year 4 | $60,472,111 | $2,859,162 | $614,460 | $3,473,622 | $59,857,651 | $1,389,449 |
| Year 5 | $59,857,651 | $2,829,332 | $644,290 | $3,473,622 | $59,213,361 | $1,736,811 |
The annual installment is $3,473,622. CF direct borrowers that pledge facility revenue build a reserve of at least one average installment, at one tenth of it a year [3]; here that is $347,362 a year until the reserve reaches $3,473,622 in Year 10. Over 40 years the loan costs $138,944,883 in installments, $76,794,883 of it interest at the assumed rate.
| Illustrative CF direct rate (40 years) | Annual installment | EBIDA needed for 1.25x | Year 3 coverage | Year 5 days cash |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.25% | $3,233,939 | $4,042,424 | 1.69x | 84 |
| 4.75% (model) | $3,473,622 | $4,342,028 | 1.62x | 80 |
| 5.25% | $3,720,575 | $4,650,719 | 1.56x | 77 |
| 5.75% | $3,974,276 | $4,967,845 | 1.50x | 73 |
Each half point of rate moves the installment by about $240,000 to $255,000 a year and Year 3 coverage by about 0.06. Rate matters, but less than the operating lines below.
Ten-year sustainability view
| Year after opening | Adjusted patient days | Revenue | EBIDA | Debt service | Coverage | Loan balance at year end | Debt service reserve balance | Days cash on hand |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 17,680 | $53,790,225 | $5,124,625 | $3,473,622 | 1.48x | $61,616,998 | $347,362 | 89 |
| Year 2 | 18,387 | $56,400,324 | $5,442,614 | $3,473,622 | 1.57x | $61,058,121 | $694,724 | 85 |
| Year 3 | 18,939 | $58,817,067 | $5,624,562 | $3,473,622 | 1.62x | $60,472,111 | $1,042,087 | 84 |
| Year 4 | 19,223 | $60,810,988 | $5,563,580 | $3,473,622 | 1.60x | $59,857,651 | $1,389,449 | 82 |
| Year 5 | 19,511 | $62,878,852 | $5,495,838 | $3,473,622 | 1.58x | $59,213,361 | $1,736,811 | 80 |
| Year 6 | 19,804 | $65,023,443 | $5,420,900 | $3,473,622 | 1.56x | $58,537,791 | $2,084,173 | 78 |
| Year 7 | 20,101 | $67,247,655 | $5,338,302 | $3,473,622 | 1.54x | $57,829,425 | $2,431,535 | 75 |
| Year 8 | 20,402 | $69,554,490 | $5,247,560 | $3,473,622 | 1.51x | $57,086,668 | $2,778,898 | 72 |
| Year 9 | 20,709 | $71,947,069 | $5,148,156 | $3,473,622 | 1.48x | $56,307,852 | $3,126,260 | 68 |
| Year 10 | 21,019 | $74,428,629 | $5,039,551 | $3,473,622 | 1.45x | $55,491,227 | $3,473,622 | 64 |
The published outcome describes a financial sustainability analysis, and the ten-year view is where it earns its name. Coverage peaks at 1.62x in Year 3 and falls to 1.45x by Year 10, and days cash fall to 64, although nothing goes wrong in the base case. The cause is built into the assumptions: fixed costs, mostly wages, rise 3.5% a year while non-Medicare rates rise 2.0%. Cost-based Medicare payment follows costs up, but the commercial and Medicaid share does not. A study that stopped at Year 3 would miss the squeeze; one that runs ten years shows the board how much rate negotiation or cost control the plan needs.
Break-even volume
| Volume as a share of the base case (Year 3) | Adjusted patient days | Revenue | EBIDA | Coverage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 70% | 13,257 | $48,251,642 | $604,582 | 0.17x |
| 80% | 15,151 | $51,773,450 | $2,277,908 | 0.66x |
| 90% | 17,045 | $55,295,258 | $3,951,235 | 1.14x |
| 100% | 18,939 | $58,817,067 | $5,624,562 | 1.62x |
| 110% | 20,833 | $62,338,875 | $7,297,889 | 2.10x |
| Break-even at 87.1% | 16,504 | 1.00x | ||
| 1.25x at 92.3% | 17,487 | 1.25x |
The hospital covers its installment down to 87.1% of base-case volume in Year 3 and reaches 1.25 times at 92.3%. Volume is the steepest line in the model. Each adjusted patient day lost removes $2,883 of non-Medicare revenue but saves only about $1,000 of variable cost, while fixed staffing for a 24-hour emergency department and inpatient unit stays.
Sensitivity and stress tests
| Scenario (modeled) | Year 1 coverage | Year 3 coverage | Year 5 coverage | Year 5 days cash | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base case | 1.48x | 1.62x | 1.58x | 80 | |
| Volume 10% lower | 1.04x | 1.14x | 1.07x | 29 | |
| Volume 20% lower | 0.60x | 0.66x | 0.56x | -27 | |
| Medicare share of volume 50% instead of 55% | 1.44x | 1.61x | 1.58x | 79 | |
| Medicare share of volume 60% | 1.51x | 1.63x | 1.59x | 82 | |
| 30% of Medicare volume in Medicare Advantage plans paying 92% of cost | 1.25x | 1.38x | 1.32x | 54 | |
| CAH status lost: Medicare pays 88% of cost instead of 101% | 0.39x | 0.45x | 0.33x | -49 | |
| Non-Medicare payment rates 10% lower | 0.81x | 0.88x | 0.79x | 0 | |
| Fixed costs (mostly wages) rise 5.5% a year instead of 3.5% | 1.48x | 1.43x | 1.18x | 56 | |
| Construction overrun of 10% of site, building and plant, added to the loan | 1.40x | 1.53x | 1.50x | 75 | loan $67,120,000 |
| Rate 5.75% instead of 4.75% | 1.37x | 1.50x | 1.47x | 73 | |
| Combined: volume 10% lower, Medicare Advantage shift, fixed costs 5.5% a year | 0.82x | 0.71x | 0.40x | -20 |
Five results matter for the State Office:
- Critical access status is the project. If the new site failed the distance test and Medicare paid 88% of cost instead of 101%, coverage would fall to 0.45 times. The distance and bed tests have to be documented for the new site before design, and the study should say how.
- Volume is the main operating risk. A 10% shortfall leaves coverage at 1.14 times in Year 3 and only 29 days of cash by Year 5. A 20% shortfall breaks the plan.
- Commercial and Medicaid rates matter more than the interest rate. Rates 10% lower take coverage below 1.00; a full point on the loan rate costs about 0.12.
- Medicare Advantage is a slow leak. If 30% of Medicare patients are in Advantage plans that pay 92% of cost rather than the cost-based rate, Year 3 coverage falls to 1.38 times and days cash to 54 by Year 5; the study reads the hospital's Advantage contracts.
- Wage growth compounds. Fixed costs rising 5.5% a year instead of 3.5% leave Year 3 coverage at 1.43 times but Year 5 at 1.18 times.
A 10% construction overrun added to the loan raises it to $67,120,000 and costs less coverage than any of these. The combined downside, lower volume with an Advantage shift and faster wage growth, does not survive, and that is the scenario the board and the State Office should discuss before the letter of conditions.
Equity and contribution test under the CF direct rule
| Test | Modeled result | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Applicant and other funds in the project | $13,004,156, 17.3% of cost | No fixed percentage in the Part 1942 sections read; joint financing earns 5 to 10 points [3] |
| Funds deposited before loan money | Hospital cash and foundation gifts at closing | Letter of conditions [3] |
| Short-lived assets kept out of the 40-year loan | $11,800,000 of equipment, IT and furniture paid by the hospital | Term no longer than useful life (1942.17) [3] |
| Reserve | $347,362 a year to one installment | 1942.17(i)(2) [3] |
| Security | Pledge of hospital revenue and a lien on the facility | 1942.17(g)(3)(iii) [3] |
| Liquidity after closing | 89 days cash in Year 1 | Lender and State Office judgment |
Technical and environmental feasibility
- Critical access status on the new site. CMS requires a critical access hospital to be outside a metropolitan statistical area or treated as rural, more than a 35-mile drive on primary roads from another hospital or critical access hospital (15 miles in mountainous terrain or on secondary roads), or certified by the state as a necessary provider before 1 January 2006; to keep no more than 25 inpatient beds; and to hold its annual average acute stay to 96 hours or less [7]. A replacement on a new site has to show it still qualifies. In Baxter County, with the most physician offices of any non-metro county in the state, that documentation is the first item in the technical section.
- Rural Emergency Hospital as the alternative. A hospital that was a critical access hospital on 27 December 2020 may convert to a Rural Emergency Hospital, which gives up inpatient care [19]. The study models the inpatient replacement against that alternative so the board can see what each costs.
- State approvals. The card states Arkansas requires a certificate of need for hospital construction and that the documentation was in the study package; CF direct loans also need a state statement on the State Medical Facilities Plan and on health facility standards [3].
- Design and construction. A preliminary architectural report, a cost estimate, a schedule and an environmental review under 7 CFR part 1970 come with the application [3]. Construction obligations entered before approval can make costs ineligible (1942.17(d)(1)(v)) [3]. Moving an operating hospital needs a transition plan, which the budget funds at $1,400,000.
- Site. Flood zone, wetlands, historic properties and access for ambulances and helicopters are screened before the site is bought. A site on prime or unique farmland raises the CF direct rate by two percentage points [3].
Management and governance feasibility
The State Office looks at three things. The first is the board: a nonprofit borrower needs significant ties to the community, through association with a public body or broadly based local membership [3], and the board must adopt the resolutions the loan requires. The second is the management team: the chief executive, chief financial officer and chief nursing officer, their record with cost reports and payer contracts, and the plan for running two buildings during the move. The third is the medical staff: a roster with ages and contract terms, a recruitment plan, and the specialists who will use the clinic suite and operating rooms. CF direct security rules prefer assured income and, where liens rest on facility income, an operator with five successful years; a newer operator needs National Office concurrence [3].
Process and documents for a CF direct hospital loan
| Step | What happens | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Preapplication | Filed with the area office (Harrison serves Baxter County); USDA returns a review notice within 45 days | 1942.2 [3][14] |
| Feasibility and design | Financial feasibility report, preliminary architectural report, environmental review under 7 CFR part 1970 | 1942.17(h) [3] |
| Public steps | Public information meeting with ten days' notice where no vote is required | 1942.17(j) [3] |
| Letter of conditions | Sets the loan amount, rate tier, reserve, security and any covenants | 1942.17 [3] |
| Closing | Applicant funds deposited before loan funds; construction under USDA's construction rules | 1942.17(n), 1942.18 [3] |
Documents the State Office will look for, and that the feasibility report draws on:
- Three to five years of audited statements and Medicare cost reports, with interim statements for the current year.
- Patient origin by ZIP code, volume by service line, payer mix history and the hospital's community health needs assessment.
- The critical access distance analysis for the new site, state approvals, and the State Medical Facilities Plan statement for CF direct.
- The preliminary architectural report, cost estimate, schedule and environmental information.
- Board resolutions, organizational documents, local government support letters, the medical staff roster and any affiliation agreement.
On this site's schedule a Community Facilities study takes 6 to 8 weeks from the engagement letter, with a data request within 48 hours, and every proposal quotes a firm fixed fee [16][18]. For a hospital replacement the critical path is rarely the study; it is the architect's report, the environmental review and the State Office's funding calendar, so the study should start early enough that its numbers can be updated when bids come in.
Economic and community impact (modeled)
| Impact measure (modeled) | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Construction spending on site, building, plant and contingency | $50,522,000 | Budget above |
| Total project investment | $75,154,156 | Budget above |
| Year 3 cash operating spending, most of it payroll | $53,192,505 | Pro forma |
| Inpatient beds (acute and swing) | 25 | Critical access limit, 42 CFR 485.620 |
| Six-county population, July 2025 | 108,023 | Census Vintage 2025 |
| Deaths to births in the six counties, 2025 | 2.1 to 1 | Census Vintage 2025 |
| Emergency department open around the clock | Yes (modeled) | Card's statement; CAH condition to confirm |
The impact the State Office weighs most is access. A 25-bed hospital with an emergency department open around the clock serves a six-county area of about 108,000 people, older than average and growing through migration, where the next tier of hospital care means a long drive. The hospital is also likely to be among the area's largest employers; in the model its Year 3 cash operating spending is $53,192,505, most of it payroll.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | How it shows up in the model | Mitigant the study tests |
|---|---|---|
| Critical access status not kept on the new site | Coverage 0.45x if Medicare pays 88% of cost | Distance and bed analysis before design; necessary-provider history [7] |
| Volume below plan | 10% lower gives 1.14x and 29 days cash by Year 5 | Patient-origin evidence; service recapture plan; physician commitments |
| Commercial and Medicaid rates | 10% lower gives 0.88x | Contract terms; payer mix stress; Medicaid policy watch |
| Medicare Advantage growth | 30% at 92% of cost gives 1.38x | Advantage contracts that reference cost |
| Wage growth | 5.5% a year gives 1.18x by Year 5 | Staffing plan; contract labor scenario |
| Physician loss | Volume and referral risk | Medical staff plan; recruitment budget |
| Construction overrun | 10% overrun raises the loan to $67,120,000; 1.53x | Contingency; guaranteed maximum price; owner's representative |
| Liquidity | Days cash fall from 89 to 64 over ten years | Cash covenant; rate and cost plan in the board's budget |
| State Office allocation | Large loan against recent Arkansas CF loan activity | Early preapplication; pairing with a CF guarantee for the balance [1] |
What the five Part 5001 components showed
The CF direct rule asks for a financial feasibility report, but a replacement hospital study is usually organized around the five components Part 5001 uses for feasibility studies, with the appendix B need-for-facility content added [2]:
| Component | What the model shows | What a reviewer still asks |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | $75,154,156 of investment; a large local payroll | Construction labor and local purchasing |
| Market and need | 108,023 people in six counties; deaths twice births; strong migration | Patient origin, service recapture and outmigration by service line |
| Technical | 64,000 sq ft, 25 beds, 30-month build | Critical access distance analysis; state approvals; site screens |
| Financial | Coverage 1.48x in Year 1, 1.62x in Year 3, 1.45x in Year 10 | Cost report reconciliation; Advantage contracts; ten-year cash |
| Management | Board, leadership and medical staff plan | Recruitment evidence; transition plan |
Why hospital studies are sent back
- Critical access status assumed without a distance and length-of-stay analysis for the new site.
- Medicare revenue projected on fee-for-service rates for a cost-based hospital, or cost-based payment assumed to cover the whole building.
- Service area defined by radius rather than patient origin, with no age detail for the Medicare population.
- Payer mix taken from metro hospital benchmarks.
- Grant funds counted as a source of debt service.
- A projection that stops at the third year and misses the slow cost squeeze.
- A report prepared by the architect, construction manager or anyone with a stake in the project [3].
Program terms that applied
| Term | CF direct rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Population limit | City or town of 20,000 or less (latest decennial census) | 1942.17 [3] |
| Lender | USDA | Part 1942 [3] |
| Interest rate | Set at least quarterly: poverty (not more than 5%), intermediate (not more than 7%) or market (Bond Buyer index); lower of the rate at approval or closing | 1942.17(f) [3] |
| Term | Useful life, state statute or 40 years, whichever is less; principal deferral up to 36 months | 1942.17(f)(7) [3] |
| Construction interest and start-up | Interest until self-supporting for up to three years; initial operating expenses ordinarily up to one year | 1942.17(d)(1)(iv) [3] |
| Reserve | At least one average installment, built at one tenth a year | 1942.17(i)(2) [3] |
| Feasibility evidence | Financial feasibility report by a qualified, independent preparer | 1942.17(h)(1) [3] |
| Guarantee and fees | None; USDA is the lender | |
| Size limit | None stated in the rule | [3] |
| Companion funding | CF grant up to 35% at this population if the income test is met; CF guaranteed loan for the balance (80%, 1.25% fee in FY2026) | 3570.63; 91 FR 11272 [4][5] |
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Prove critical access status for the new site first. Every other number depends on it.
- Model Medicare from cost, and only for Medicare's share. The cost report pays back part of the new building, not all of it.
- Keep short-lived assets out of the 40-year loan. CF direct terms cannot exceed useful life, so equipment and IT need their own money.
- Run ten years, not three. Costs that grow faster than non-Medicare rates erode coverage and cash slowly; the board needs to see it before it signs.
- Leave grants out of debt service. Transformation and other grant money helps the project, but the State Office will not count it toward repayment.
- Document the standard the project meets. Up to 25 CF direct scoring points depend on it.
Related pages
- The CF direct engagement page lists this program's engagements, including this one.
- The national healthcare feasibility study page sets out critical access, clinic and senior care rules and a $20 million hospital example [15]; the medical clinic feasibility study page covers outpatient projects.
- The Arkansas state page carries the State Office, area offices and precedents, and the Arkansas medical clinic feasibility study page carries the state's physician data.
- The Community Facilities feasibility study page explains the program, and the case studies page lists long-form work, including the rural hospital case study for Iowa.
If your board is weighing a hospital replacement and needs a USDA feasibility study consultant, the engagement index describes the process: a fifteen-minute scoping call, a written proposal inside one business day and a firm fixed fee before you sign [17]. Request a proposal for your study.
Data current as of November 2026.
USDA Feasibility, Inc.