How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
This engagement assessed refrigeration energy-efficiency upgrades at a food-processing operation in Hermiston, Oregon. It was prepared in 2024 for a regional community bank, and its defining feature was energy-savings verification. That feature matters more now than when the study was written. Under the REAP rule effective 16 October 2026, a grant application must show 12 months of actual savings against 12 months of pre-installation data [1]. USDA also rescinded the FY2025 to FY2027 REAP funding notice in April 2026 [2]. This page describes the engagement type and models an Umatilla County food plant's refrigeration upgrade. It then shows how such a project is financed and verified under the rule in force.
| Item | Published record |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Rural Energy for America Program (REAP) |
| Asset class | Food manufacturing |
| Project | Food-processing refrigeration efficiency |
| Location | Hermiston, Oregon (Umatilla County) |
| Region | Pacific Northwest |
| Loan size tier | Under $5M |
| Year prepared | 2024 |
| Lender type | Regional community bank |
| Outcome | Prepared with energy-savings verification |
Sources: the site's engagement index [12]; county from Census place files [6].
The record describes the method. An energy audit established pre-upgrade consumption, verified that savings were measurable and fixed the eligible project cost. A post-installation monitoring plan then met USDA's savings-verification standard. The record also lists the grant cap, cost share and guarantee terms of the notice in force at the time. Those terms were superseded by the April 2026 rescission and the 2026 rule, and none of them is used here.
The question the lender and USDA needed answered
Refrigeration upgrades in a food plant are among the most reliable energy projects a rural lender sees. The compressors and fans run most of the year, and the measures are proven. The questions are about proof and timing:
- How much will the plant actually save? The audit has to split refrigeration from the rest of the plant's load and estimate each measure's saving. It also has to allow for measures overlapping, since a fan saving shrinks once the compressors run more efficiently.
- How will anyone know? A food plant's energy use rises and falls with production and weather. A raw comparison of bills before and after can show savings that are not there, or hide savings that are. The verification plan must normalise for both.
- Do the savings carry the loan? Unlike most solar, a well-chosen efficiency package can cover its own debt service. The study shows whether it does, and how fast.
- Can it be installed without disrupting production? Work has to fit the processing calendar.
Under 7 CFR part 5001, the lender evaluates the project's credit and any feasibility study in writing [3]. Since 16 October 2026, a REAP grant for an efficiency project above $80,000 needs an energy audit, and projects of $200,000 or more need two years of pro forma statements and an engineer's completion certificate [1]. The rule also makes simple payback an eligibility test: it must not exceed the useful life [1].
What changed for this engagement type on 16 October 2026
| Topic | Rule effective 16 October 2026 [1] | What it means for a refrigeration upgrade |
|---|---|---|
| Timing | Project Period must end 12 to 24 months before the grant application | The loan builds the project; a grant follows a year of verified savings |
| Data | 12 months of actual savings plus 12 months of pre-installation data | The M&V plan becomes the grant application's evidence |
| Award size | At most 25% of cost and $250,000 for energy efficiency | On a $1.17 million project the $250,000 cap binds |
| Combined funding | Grant plus REAP guaranteed loan at most 75% of project cost | A 75% loan leaves no room for a grant |
| Loan alone | A REAP guaranteed loan without a grant is capped at 75% of eligible costs, with at least 25% from the borrower (7 CFR 5001.406(d)) | The plant funds a quarter even without a grant [3] |
| Economics | Simple payback must not exceed useful life | An easy test for this package; each measure is still checked |
| Locations | Projects at more than one location ineligible | One plant per application |
| Applicant | One application per federal fiscal year from each highest-level owner | A multi-plant processor chooses which plant goes first |
| Gambling | Any gambling income bars a grant; the loan keeps the 15% test in 5001.127(b) | A revenue screen of the company and affiliates |
Project description (modelled)
The modelled plant is an existing vegetable and potato freezing operation near Hermiston with an ammonia refrigeration system. It runs screw compressors, evaporative condensers, a spiral freezer and frozen storage. It uses 14 million kWh of electricity a year, 62% of it for refrigeration, and 180,000 therms of natural gas for sanitation hot water. It freezes 160,000 tons of finished product a year. The project is a package of six measures that the energy audit ranks by payback, installed over about four months in the off-season.
Baseline
| Baseline input (model) | Value | How the energy audit sets it |
|---|---|---|
| Plant electricity use | 14,000,000 kWh a year | Twelve or more months of bills and interval data |
| Refrigeration share | 62% (8,680,000 kWh) | Submetering or compressor logs |
| Lighting in refrigerated areas | 700,000 kWh | Fixture inventory and hours |
| Natural gas for sanitation hot water | 180,000 therms | Gas bills; boiler logs |
| Finished product frozen | 160,000 tons a year | Production records |
| Refrigeration energy per ton | 54.2 kWh | Computed; the M&V normaliser |
| Avoided electricity value | $0.068 per kWh | Assumption; the cooperative or utility tariff |
| Demand charge / share of saved demand at the monthly peak | $9 per kW-month / 50% | Assumption; interval data |
| Natural gas price | $0.85 per therm | Assumption; gas bills |
The efficiency measures
| Measure (model) | Year-1 savings | Year-1 value | Installed cost | Simple payback | Useful life assumed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Compressor sequencing controls and a variable-speed trim compressor | 607,600 kWh | $46,785 | $185,000 | 4.0 years | 15 years |
| Floating head pressure with variable-speed condenser fans | 484,344 kWh | $37,294 | $140,000 | 3.8 years | 15 years |
| Variable-speed evaporator fans and controls | 303,522 kWh | $23,371 | $165,000 | 7.1 years | 15 years |
| High-speed doors at freezer and dock openings | 145,691 kWh | $11,218 | $120,000 | 10.7 years | 12 years |
| Desuperheater heat recovery to sanitation hot water | 39,600 therms | $33,660 | $210,000 | 6.2 years | 20 years |
| LED lighting with controls in refrigerated areas | 420,000 kWh | $32,340 | $160,000 | 4.9 years | 15 years |
| All measures (refrigeration savings applied in sequence) | 1,961,157 kWh and 39,600 therms | $184,669 | $980,000 | 5.3 years |
The package saves 1,961,157 kWh a year, 14.0% of plant use, and cuts refrigeration energy by 17.8%. Heat recovery saves 39,600 therms a year. At full realisation the year-one value is $184,669 against an installed cost of $980,000, a 5.3-year payback before soft costs. The refrigeration measures are applied in sequence so that the package does not count the same kilowatt-hour twice. The compressor controls take their share first, and each later measure saves a share of what remains. The high-speed doors are the weakest measure, at 10.7 years against a 12-year life. A sponsor could drop them to strengthen the package, or keep them for product quality and dock safety.
The engagement record cites Energy Trust of Oregon incentives for refrigeration controls, variable-speed drives, electronic expansion valves and high-speed doors, and an Oregon Department of Energy technical-assistance program for rural food processors. Utility efficiency programs in Oregon depend on which utility serves the plant. The Oregon hub names Umatilla Electric Cooperative among the state's rural cooperatives [13]. The model counts no incentive until a program confirms the plant's eligibility. Both record claims are in VERIFY.
What each measure does in a freezing plant
Compressor sequencing and a variable-speed trim compressor. Large screw compressors are least efficient at part load, and a freezing plant spends much of the year at part load: between shifts, in cool weather and outside the peak harvest weeks. Sequencing controls run the fewest machines at their best loading and let a single variable-speed machine follow the swings. The audit sets the saving from compressor logs of suction pressure, slide-valve position and motor current. Nameplate ratings do not show it.
Floating head pressure with variable-speed condenser fans. Many plants hold condensing pressure high all year as a precaution. Letting it fall with the outdoor wet-bulb temperature cuts compressor work in the cooler months, which in eastern Oregon is much of the year. The engineer sets the minimum pressure the expansion devices and hot-gas defrost still need, and the study's saving follows that limit, not a theoretical one.
Variable-speed evaporator fans. Fans in freezers and cold rooms often run at full speed whatever the load, and every watt they use becomes heat the compressors must remove. Slowing them when the space is at temperature saves fan energy and compressor energy together. The audit's challenge is to count that interaction once, which is why the package applies savings in sequence.
High-speed doors. Strip curtains and slow doors let warm, moist air into freezers. That adds load and frost, and frost means more defrost energy. The saving is real but smaller than the controls measures, and its value partly lies outside energy, in less ice on floors and coils.
Heat recovery. A desuperheater takes the hottest part of the compressor discharge and uses it to preheat sanitation water. The plant would otherwise heat that water with natural gas. The study checks that the recovered heat matches when and how much hot water the sanitation shifts use.
LED lighting with controls. In refrigerated space, a lighting watt saved is also a watt of heat the refrigeration system no longer removes. The model counts only the lighting saving, which keeps it conservative.
Energy-savings verification
The record's outcome, energy-savings verification, is now the core of a REAP grant file. A verification plan defines the baseline period, the meters, the variables that drive energy use and the method for adjusting the baseline when those variables change. For a freezing plant the main driver is tons of product frozen, with outdoor wet-bulb temperature second, because it sets condensing pressure. The example below shows why normalising for production matters.
| Reporting-year case | Tons frozen | Metered refrigeration kWh | Savings by raw bill comparison | Savings normalised to production | Error in the raw comparison |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Production as in the baseline year | 160,000 | 7,138,843 | 1,541,157 | 1,541,157 | 0% |
| Production 10% higher in the reporting year | 176,000 | 7,852,727 | 827,273 | 1,695,273 | -51% |
| Production 10% lower | 144,000 | 6,424,959 | 2,255,041 | 1,387,041 | 63% |
If the plant freezes 10% more product in the reporting year, a raw comparison of bills understates savings by 51%. If it freezes 10% less, the raw comparison overstates them by 63%. Normalising to refrigeration energy per ton removes both errors: the plant moves from 54.2 to 44.6 kWh per ton frozen. A real plan uses monthly or weekly regressions against production and weather, submeters the compressor room and keeps the raw data for the reviewer. That evidence lets an application show "12 months of actual savings" that a reviewer can trust.
Project cost and sources and uses (modelled)
No construction-cost database sits behind these figures. Each line is a labelled assumption, and a real study replaces it with refrigeration contractor bids, vendor quotes for drives and doors, the auditor's proposal and the controls integrator's scope.
| Line item | Model amount | Source in a real study |
|---|---|---|
| Compressor sequencing controls and a variable-speed trim compressor | $185,000 | Contractor and vendor bids |
| Floating head pressure with variable-speed condenser fans | $140,000 | Contractor and vendor bids |
| Variable-speed evaporator fans and controls | $165,000 | Contractor and vendor bids |
| High-speed doors at freezer and dock openings | $120,000 | Contractor and vendor bids |
| Desuperheater heat recovery to sanitation hot water | $210,000 | Contractor and vendor bids |
| LED lighting with controls in refrigerated areas | $160,000 | Contractor and vendor bids |
| Controls integration, commissioning and M&V metering | $75,000 | Controls contractor |
| Contingency (8% of installed cost) | $84,400 | Engineer judgment |
| Energy audit (required for an efficiency grant above $80,000) | $18,000 | Auditor proposal |
| Feasibility study (within the cost page band for REAP loans above $600,000) | $8,500 | Fixed-fee proposal |
| Loan closing and legal | $6,500 | Lender estimate |
| Total eligible project cost (model) | $1,172,400 |
| Cost outside the eligible budget | Model amount | Note |
|---|---|---|
| REAP guarantee fee (1.0% of the guaranteed portion) | $7,034 | FY2026 REAP rate [4] |
| Interest during a four-month installation (half drawn on average) | $10,625 | Installed in the off-season |
| Annual retention fee, year 1 (0.25% of guaranteed principal) | $1,759 | [4] |
| Utility or state efficiency incentives | Not counted | Treated as upside until a program confirms eligibility |
Two ways to finance it
| Uses | Amount | Structure A: REAP loan only | Amount | Structure B: smaller loan, later grant | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Efficiency measures, integration and contingency | $1,139,400 | REAP guaranteed loan from the community bank (75%) | $879,300 | REAP guaranteed loan | $629,300 |
| Energy audit | $18,000 | Owner contribution (25%) | $293,100 | Owner cash at construction | $543,100 |
| Feasibility study, closing and legal | $15,000 | REAP grant | $0 | REAP efficiency grant after 12 months of verified savings | $250,000 |
| Owner cash returned if the grant is awarded | -$250,000 | ||||
| Total eligible project cost | $1,172,400 | Total | $1,172,400 | Total net of grant, if awarded | $1,172,400 |
| Grant test (rule effective 16 October 2026) | Model | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 25% of project cost | $293,100 | [1] |
| Energy efficiency maximum | $250,000 | [1] |
| Largest possible grant | $250,000 | Lower of the two |
| Room left under the 75% combined cap if the loan is at 75% | $0 | [1] |
| Structure B: loan plus grant | $629,300 + $250,000 = 75.0% | [1][3] |
| Energy audit required | Yes: efficiency project above $80,000 | [1] |
| Data for the application | 12 months of verified savings and 12 months of pre-installation data | [1] |
The efficiency cap of $250,000 binds before the 25% limit ($293,100). Structure B therefore borrows $629,300 and asks the plant for $543,100 at construction, returning $250,000 if the grant is awarded after a year of verified savings. The grant is competitive, decided in one national competition for requests over $20,000 [1], and as of 7 November 2026 no funding notice under the rule had appeared. The community bank should underwrite Structure B on its own debt service. For a plant with strong cash flow, Structure B is a reasonable bet. For one with thin liquidity, Structure A is safer.
Market analysis
The market for an efficiency project is the plant's own future: whether it will run long enough, and at enough volume, to earn the savings. The study therefore looks at the regional processing base, the plant's raw-product supply and customer contracts, and the energy prices that set the value of each kilowatt-hour saved.
The site and the rural test
| Measure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Hermiston city population, April 2020 estimates base | 19,422 | Census Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [6] |
| Hermiston city population, July 2025 estimate | 19,906 | [6] |
| Umatilla County population, July 2025 estimate | 81,119 | Census Vintage 2025 county estimates [6] |
| Umatilla and Morrow counties, OMB status (2023) | Both non-metropolitan | OMB list1_2023 [7] |
| Oregon places above 50,000 in the April 2020 base | 12, none east of the Cascades except Bend | [6] |
| Nearest places above 50,000 | Kennewick (83,957), Pasco (77,324) and Richland (60,580), Washington | [6] |
Hermiston had 19,422 residents in the Census April 2020 estimates base, below the 50,000 line in 7 CFR 5001.3. Umatilla County is non-metropolitan; Hermiston and Pendleton anchor a micropolitan area. The nearest places above 50,000 are Kennewick, Pasco and Richland across the state line in Washington. The rule's urbanized-area exclusion follows their contiguous urbanized area, which a dated USDA eligibility map determination will confirm for the parcel. The Oregon hub lists eastern Oregon, including Umatilla County, among the state's eligible regions [13].
The Columbia Basin processing economy
| County | Population, July 2025 | OMB status (2023) | Manufacturers (employees), 2023 | Food manufacturers (employees), 2023 | Food manufacturing pay per employee |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Umatilla County, OR | 81,119 | Non-metropolitan | 61 (2,858) | 17 (1,356) | $60,310 |
| Morrow County, OR | 12,602 | Non-metropolitan | 10 (1,466) | 6 (1,411) | $58,656 |
| Union County, OR | 25,900 | Non-metropolitan | 27 (1,263) | Not shown | n/a |
| Benton County, WA | 221,722 | Metropolitan | 152 (4,346) | 20 (1,354) | $54,794 |
| Franklin County, WA | 102,612 | Metropolitan | 43 (3,604) | 16 (3,192) | $54,537 |
County Business Patterns 2023 (establishments with paid employees); OMB 2023; Vintage 2025 county estimates [5][6][7].
Umatilla County's 17 food manufacturers employ 1,356 people at an average of $60,310. Neighbouring Morrow County's 6 employ 1,411, a sign of a few very large plants. Across the river, Franklin County's 16 food plants employ 3,192. The Columbia Basin is one processing region split by a state line, and a Hermiston plant competes for labour, raw product and freight with plants on both sides. For an efficiency study that is reassurance and a caution. The plant's market is deep, but its cost position against large neighbours is what the project defends.
Oregon: food manufacturing (excluding meat), supply and rural footprint
| Measure | Oregon | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 642 → 625 (-2.6%) | 24,589 → 27,414 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 14.7 | 8.1 |
| Average employees per establishment | 37.8 | 42.0 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $54,991 | $58,248 |
| Share of establishments in non-metro counties | 16.1% (102 in 11 counties) | |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 15.0% |
Non-metro counties with the most food manufacturing (excluding meat) (2023): Clatsop County (15); Coos County (13); Lincoln County (13); Umatilla County (13); Hood River County (12); Tillamook County (11).
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
| State | Food plants 2019 (excluding meat) | 2023 | Change | Per 100,000 residents | Employees per plant | Average pay | Share in non-metro counties |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oregon | 642 | 625 | -2.6% | 14.7 | 37.8 | $54,991 | 16.1% |
| Washington | 760 | 828 | 8.9% | 10.6 | 37.8 | $58,203 | 13.6% |
| Idaho | 193 | 231 | 19.7% | 11.7 | 75.3 | $57,841 | 34.2% |
| California | 3,506 | 3,855 | 10.0% | 9.8 | 39.4 | $60,463 | 2.4% |
State data packs, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023, food manufacturing excluding meat [5].
Oregon has more food plants per resident than any of its neighbours (14.7 per 100,000), but it lost 17 plants between 2019 and 2023 while Washington, Idaho and California added plants. Consolidation and cost pressure are the backdrop. A plant that cuts 14% of its electricity and most of its hot-water gas is better placed to stay in the group that survives. Note one data point: the pack counts 13 non-metro Umatilla County food plants excluding meat, while the county file above counts 17 including meat.
Financing benchmark: SBA lending to Oregon food manufacturers
Oregon: SBA lending to food manufacturing (excluding meat)
| Period | 7(a) loans | 7(a) dollars | 504 loans | 504 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2010 to FY2016 | 70 | $26.5 million | 3 | $960,000 |
| FY2017 to FY2019 | 29 | $10.1 million | 5 | $4.4 million |
| FY2020 to FY2023 | 37 | $25.0 million | 4 | $2.5 million |
| FY2024 to FY2026 | 27 | $8.6 million | 2 | $2.9 million |
Average 7(a) loan, FY2020 to FY2026: $524,492. Average 504 loan: $904,167. Of the 70 7(a) loans approved in FY2010 to FY2016 for Oregon food manufacturing (excluding meat), 5.7% were charged off (national: 7.4% of 3,150), on average 42 months after approval.
Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).
Oregon food manufacturers have a better seasoned loss record than the nation (5.7% against 7.4%). The modelled REAP loan of $879,300 is larger than the average Oregon 7(a) food loan of $524,492, which is typical of an equipment package for an established plant.
REAP activity in Oregon and its neighbours
| State | REAP grants | REAP grant dollars | Average grant | Dollars per resident | Rank: dollars / per resident (of 53) | REAP guaranteed loans | B&I guaranteed loans |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oregon | 106 | $21,311,544 | $201,052 | $5.03 | 17 / 17 | 1 | 14 |
| Washington | 156 | $16,076,249 | $103,053 | $2.09 | 25 / 36 | 0 | 14 |
| Idaho | 93 | $21,643,985 | $232,731 | $11.77 | 16 / 7 | 0 | 10 |
| California | 93 | $28,847,015 | $310,183 | $0.73 | 11 / 50 | 5 | 35 |
| Nevada | 10 | $2,780,525 | $278,053 | $0.90 | 49 / 48 | 0 | 4 |
USAspending prime awards by place of performance, FY2024 to FY2026, for REAP (10.868) and B&I (10.768) [9]. These awards were made under the pre-2026 rules.
Oregon took 106 REAP grants worth $21,311,544, averaging $201,052, and recorded one REAP guaranteed loan in the period. That one loan is a small precedent, but a precedent. Under the 2026 rule the guaranteed loan becomes the way to build an efficiency project, so the regional bank's familiarity with it matters. The Oregon hub reports that USDA revoked approved-lender status for ten OneRD lenders on 12 May 2026 [13]. A sponsor should confirm that its lender remains approved before the study is commissioned.
Financial feasibility
Five-year pro forma
| Line (Structure A) | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Savings realised while controls are tuned | 85% | 95% | 100% | 100% | 100% |
| Electricity savings (energy and demand, tariff +3% a year) | $128,358 | $147,762 | $160,206 | $165,012 | $169,962 |
| Natural gas savings (+2% a year) | $28,611 | $32,617 | $35,020 | $35,720 | $36,435 |
| Total energy savings | $156,969 | $180,379 | $195,225 | $200,732 | $206,397 |
| Added maintenance, M&V reporting and insurance | -$23,165 | -$23,165 | -$23,165 | -$23,165 | -$23,165 |
| Net project benefit (project NOI) | $133,804 | $157,214 | $172,060 | $177,567 | $183,232 |
| REAP loan debt service (7.25%, 10 years) | -$123,877 | -$123,877 | -$123,877 | -$123,877 | -$123,877 |
| Retention fee | -$1,759 | -$1,634 | -$1,501 | -$1,357 | -$1,203 |
| Project-level coverage | 1.07x | 1.25x | 1.37x | 1.42x | 1.46x |
The package covers its own debt service from year one, even with 85% of savings realised while the controls are tuned. Coverage rises to 1.25 times in year two and 1.46 times by year five as tariffs escalate. This is the key contrast with a solar project: a well-ranked efficiency package can be underwritten largely on its own savings.
Global coverage
| Year | Plant cash flow before project (model) | Project NOI | Existing debt service (model) | New REAP debt service and fee | Coverage before | Global coverage after |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $3,200,000 | $133,804 | $1,600,000 | $125,635 | 2.00x | 1.93x |
| Year 2 | $3,200,000 | $157,214 | $1,600,000 | $125,511 | 2.00x | 1.95x |
| Year 3 | $3,200,000 | $172,060 | $1,600,000 | $125,377 | 2.00x | 1.95x |
| Year 4 | $3,200,000 | $177,567 | $1,600,000 | $125,234 | 2.00x | 1.96x |
| Year 5 | $3,200,000 | $183,232 | $1,600,000 | $125,079 | 2.00x | 1.96x |
The plant's cash flow and existing debt service are modelled placeholders. On them, the loan moves global coverage from 2.00 times to 1.93 times in year one and back toward 1.96 times as savings grow. For a regional bank, the project is a modest add-on to a strong existing credit.
Term choice
| Term at 7.25% | Annual debt service | Project coverage, year 1 | Project coverage, year 3 | Useful-life check (5001.402) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 years | $160,545 | 0.82x | 1.06x | Within the shortest measure life (12 years) |
| 10 years | $123,877 | 1.07x | 1.37x | Within the shortest measure life (12 years) |
| 15 years | $96,322 | 1.36x | 1.75x | Longer than the door life; within controls and LED life |
A 10-year term sits inside the shortest measure life (the doors' 12 years) and covers the debt from year one. Seven years is too short for year-one coverage. Fifteen years would outlast the doors, so 5001.402's useful-life limit [3] points to a blended term or to dropping the doors from the package.
Payback: the grant eligibility test
| Payback test | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Total project cost | $1,172,400 | Budget |
| Year-1 dollar value of energy saved at full realisation | $184,669 | Measures table |
| Simple payback | 6.3 years | Cost / annual value [3] |
| Shortest measure life | 12 years (high-speed doors) | Assumption |
| Passes the grant eligibility test? | Yes, with a wide margin | Payback must not exceed useful life [1] |
Break-even and stress tests
| Break-even test (full realisation, today's prices) | Value | Model base | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Share of modelled savings needed for 1.00x | 81% | 100% | 19% |
| Share of modelled savings needed for 1.25x | 98% | 100% | 2% |
| Electricity value needed for 1.00x | $0.052 per kWh | $0.068 | -24% |
| Payback limit: savings share at which payback equals 12 years | 53% | 100% | 47% |
The project covers its debt if it delivers 81% of the modelled savings, and reaches 1.25 times only at 98%. That gap is why verification and commissioning matter. A package that delivers four-fifths of its promise still pays, but the margin above 1.25 times depends on the controls being tuned and kept tuned. The payback test is far from binding: payback would reach the doors' 12-year life only if savings fell to 53% of plan.
| Savings realised | Electricity at $0.055 | At $0.068 (base) | At $0.085 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60% | 0.56x | 0.70x | 0.88x |
| 75% | 0.75x | 0.92x | 1.14x |
| 90% | 0.93x | 1.14x | 1.41x |
| 100% | 1.06x | 1.29x | 1.59x |
| 110% | 1.18x | 1.43x | 1.76x |
| Fixed rate (10 years) | Budget as modelled: coverage at full savings; owner 25% | Overrun 10% | Overrun 20% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6.25% | 1.34x; owner $293,100 | 1.22x; owner $322,410 | 1.12x; owner $351,720 |
| 7.25% | 1.29x; owner $293,100 | 1.17x; owner $322,410 | 1.07x; owner $351,720 |
| 8.25% | 1.23x; owner $293,100 | 1.12x; owner $322,410 | 1.03x; owner $351,720 |
| 9.25% | 1.18x; owner $293,100 | 1.07x; owner $322,410 | 0.98x; owner $351,720 |
| Delay case | Base year 1 | Installation slips into the processing season; half the measures deferred a year |
|---|---|---|
| Project NOI, year 1 | $133,804 | $66,902 |
| Debt service and fee | $125,635 | $125,635 |
| Project coverage | 1.07x | 0.53x |
| Global coverage | 1.93x | 1.89x |
| Grant clock (Structure B) | 12 months of savings after completion | Starts only when the last measure is complete |
If installation slips into the processing season and half the measures are deferred a year, project coverage falls to 0.53 times in year one. Global coverage barely moves (1.89 times), but any grant is delayed, because the 12-month savings period starts only when the last measure is complete. Scheduling the work into the off-season, with equipment ordered early, is the mitigation.
Equity and loan-size tests
| Test | Requirement | Model result (Structure A) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| REAP guaranteed loan size | $5,000 to 75% of eligible project costs | $879,300 = 75.0% of $1,172,400 | 5001.406(d) [3] |
| Borrower contribution | At least 25% of eligible project costs | $293,100 = 25.0% | 5001.406(d) [3] |
| Grant plus loan | At most 75% of Project Cost | Structure B: $879,300 = 75.0% | 4280.122(b)(20) [1] |
| Studies, reports and audits inside the loan | At most 10% of the loan | $26,500 = 3.0% | Part 5001 [3] |
| Equity certification | Lender certifies at closing against a closing balance sheet | Pro forma closing balance sheet in the study | 5001.306(a)(2) [3] |
Technical and environmental feasibility
- Refrigeration engineering. The audit reviews compressor curves, suction and condensing pressures, evaporator defrost practice and part-load operation, and confirms each measure's saving from logged data. Controls changes on an ammonia system are made by qualified refrigeration contractors, and the study confirms the contractor's experience.
- Process safety. Ammonia systems are subject to process safety requirements. The study confirms that the changes fit the plant's process safety management documentation and that controls changes go through its management-of-change procedure. It names the regulators involved without assuming their findings.
- Food safety and production. High-speed doors and evaporator controls must hold product temperatures. The study confirms that temperature logs will be kept through commissioning.
- Heat recovery. The desuperheater must meet sanitation water temperatures without starving the condensers. The engineer sizes it against the hot-water demand profile.
- Equipment. New, commercially available equipment. The 2026 rule's foreign-adversary bar applies to solar and wind components [1], so it does not reach refrigeration controls, though the study records origins anyway.
- Environmental. Work inside an existing plant disturbs no ground. REAP grants carry environmental review requirements [1], and the study places them in the schedule.
Management and governance feasibility
The study confirms who owns the plant and its energy data, who runs the refrigeration system, and who is responsible for keeping the controls tuned after commissioning, which is the main driver of persistent savings. It names the M&V lead and the reporting cycle. It confirms that the applicant qualifies as a rural small business under SBA size standards, as the record notes was checked, and screens the company and affiliates under 5001.127 and, for a grant, under the 2026 rule's bar on any gambling income [3][1]. If the company owns several plants, the one-application-per-year rule means it must choose which plant applies first [1].
Economic and community impact (modelled)
| Measure (modelled) | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Electricity saved a year at full realisation | 1,961,157 kWh (14.0% of plant use) | Measures table |
| Refrigeration energy saved | 17.8% | Measures table |
| Natural gas saved a year | 39,600 therms | Heat recovery |
| Energy cost avoided over five years | $939,702 | Pro forma |
| Refrigeration energy per ton frozen, before and after | 54.2 to 44.6 kWh | M&V normaliser |
| Permanent jobs added | None claimed | Protects an existing employer's cost base |
The community case is a rural processor's lower cost base and a smaller load on a regional grid. The plant keeps its jobs and its raw-product purchases from local growers. REAP's 2026 scoring rewards energy saved per award dollar, the share of energy saved and environmental benefits [1], and the verified savings are the evidence for those points.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | Effect | Mitigant the study documents |
|---|---|---|
| Savings below plan | Coverage below 1.25x under about 98% realisation | Audit from logged data; commissioning; savings tracked against the M&V baseline |
| Controls drift after commissioning | Savings fade over time | Named owner of controls; alarms; annual retro-commissioning |
| Production changes distort results | Savings misreported | Normalised M&V by tons and weather |
| Installation runs into the season | Half-year of savings lost; grant delayed | Off-season schedule; early equipment orders |
| Electricity price lower than assumed | Lower savings value | Tariff sensitivity; demand savings shown separately |
| Ammonia system safety | Work must fit process safety rules | Qualified contractor; management of change |
| Lender approval status | Guarantee unavailable | Confirm the lender's OneRD approval before engagement |
| Grant not awarded | Bridge not repaid | Structure A as base case |
| Plant closure or consolidation | Savings lost | Global credit review; supply and customer contracts |
| Gambling or other ineligible income in an affiliate | Grant bar | Screen all entities |
What the five Part 5001 components showed
| Component [10] | What it tests here | What the modelled study shows |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Baseline, measures, cost against benefit | $184,669 a year from $980,000 of measures; payback 6.3 years on total project cost |
| Market | The plant's future and energy prices | A non-metro processing region with deep competition; tariff tested from $0.055 to $0.085 |
| Technical | Engineering, safety, commissioning | Proven measures applied in sequence; ammonia and food-safety checks |
| Financial | Coverage, equity, sensitivity | Project coverage 1.07x in year 1 rising to 1.46x; global 1.93x |
| Management | Controls ownership, M&V, reporting | Named owner of savings persistence and verification |
Why efficiency studies are returned
- Savings estimated from nameplate ratings instead of logged operation.
- Measure savings added together instead of applied in sequence.
- No verification plan, or one that compares raw bills with no production adjustment.
- Energy prices taken from the average bill rather than the tariff's energy and demand components.
- Incentives counted before a program confirms eligibility.
- A loan above 75% of eligible cost, or a grant planned on top of a 75% loan.
- An audit, study and engineer's report that disagree on cost or savings.
Program terms that applied
| Term | REAP guaranteed loan (FY2026) | B&I guaranteed loan under $5 million (FY2026) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guarantee | 80% | 85% | 91 FR 11272 [4] |
| Upfront guarantee fee | 1.0% of the guaranteed portion | 3.0% | [4] |
| Annual retention fee | 0.25% | 0.55% | [4] |
| Extra fee if the guarantee issues before construction is complete | 0.50% | 0.50% | [4] |
| Loan size | $5,000 to 75% of eligible project costs; $25 million per borrower | Up to $25 million per borrower | 5001.406(c), (d) [3] |
| Borrower money | At least 25% of eligible project costs | 10% for an existing business | 5001.406(d); 5001.105(d) [3] |
| Term | Useful life, at most 40 years, no balloon | Same | 5001.402 [3] |
| Rate | Negotiated; fixed, variable or both | Same | 5001.401 [3] |
| Rural test | Outside cities over 50,000 and their contiguous urbanized areas | Same | 5001.3 [3] |
| Gambling screen | More than 15% of gross revenue from gambling bars the loan | Same | 5001.127(b) [3] |
| Feasibility study | When the lender or Agency deems it necessary | Required over $1,000,000 to a new business | 5001.306(a)(3), 5001.307 [3] |
These FY2026 rates apply to loans obligated in FY2026 unless a later appropriation changes them [4]. The Oregon hub also lists REDLG pass-through loans through rural electric cooperatives and state programs as possible companion sources [13]. The study should confirm any of these before counting them, and check how non-REAP funds count against the rule's cost-share and funding caps.
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Rank the measures. In the model, controls, condenser and fan drives, lighting and heat recovery pay back in roughly four to seven years, while the doors take nearly eleven. Build the package from the audit's ranking, not a vendor's catalogue.
- Apply savings in sequence. Overlapping measures cannot each claim their stand-alone saving. Sequenced savings are the honest number and the one a reviewer will check.
- Verify against production. Normalise to tons and weather. A raw bill comparison can halve or inflate the savings.
- Install in the off-season. The grant clock and the year-one savings both depend on finishing before the processing season.
- Keep the controls tuned. Coverage above 1.25 times depends on near-full realisation, and controls drift without an owner.
- Plan for 25% of your own money. The REAP loan stops at 75% of eligible cost, and the efficiency grant is capped at $250,000.
- Treat the grant as a later rebate. It comes after a year of verified savings, through a national competition.
- Confirm your lender. Check that the bank is an approved OneRD lender before commissioning the study.
Related pages
- USDA REAP engagements: the program page for this engagement type.
- Food processing feasibility study for USDA loans: the national page for this asset.
- Renewable energy feasibility study for USDA loans and the USDA REAP feasibility study page: the 2026 REAP rule in full.
- Oregon USDA feasibility studies, with the Oregon food processing feasibility study and Oregon cold storage feasibility study pages.
- Case studies and the full engagement index.
- USDA feasibility study cost and timeline.
The site's cost page lists REAP studies at $4,900 to $8,500 over 4 to 5 weeks for loans under $600,000, and $7,500 to $11,500 over 5 to 7 weeks above it, each as a firm fixed fee in a written proposal [11]. For a food processor planning refrigeration, heat-recovery or lighting upgrades, an independent USDA feasibility study consultant can tie the audit, the verification plan and the lender's credit case together.
Request a scoped proposal for your REAP efficiency feasibility study at the contact page.
USDA Feasibility, Inc.