Rural Manufacturing Expansion Feasibility: South Dakota USDA Feasibility Study Case Study

    Last updated 2026-11-08

    How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.

    Data current as of November 2026.

    Engagement summary

    In 2023 we prepared a feasibility study for a rural manufacturing expansion in Watertown, South Dakota, for a new-business request under the USDA Business and Industry (B&I) guaranteed loan program with a community commercial bank as lender. The loan was under $5 million and above the $1 million threshold at which Part 5001 requires an independent study for a new business.

    FieldPublished record
    ProgramUSDA Business and Industry (B&I) guaranteed loan
    AssetManufacturing: rural plant expansion
    LocationWatertown, South Dakota (Codington County)
    Loan size tierUnder $5 million
    Year2023
    Lender typeCommunity commercial bank
    OutcomePrepared for a new-business B&I request above the $1M study threshold

    The engagement card says the study documented market demand through anchor customer analysis, supply-chain economics and competitive supplier mapping. The rest of this page models that work for a contract metal fabrication plant: a new 26,000 sq ft building with laser cutting, forming, robotic welding and machining, serving equipment makers in the region. The figures are assumptions built for the page; the method is what a lender-grade study does.

    The question the lender and USDA needed answered

    The study was required by rule. Part 5001 requires a feasibility study prepared by an independent qualified consultant acceptable to the Agency for any guaranteed loan over $1,000,000 to a new business, with the Agency setting the scope (7 CFR 5001.306(a)(3)(i)) [1]. Part 5001 treats a business as new if it has operated less than a full year, or longer without reaching stable operations, and that includes a new affiliate of an existing company moving into a new location with new market or labour areas [1]. An expansion carried out through a new operating company or at a new site therefore often triggers the rule even when the owners have run a plant before.

    The question behind the rule was practical. A community bank lending close to $5 million to a company with no operating history needed to know three things: whether named customers would actually buy the plant's output at prices that cover steel, labour and debt; whether Watertown could staff a plant in a county where manufacturing already employs about one resident in nine; and how much working capital the first year of receivables and steel inventory would absorb.

    RuleRequirementEffect here
    7 CFR 5001.306(a)(3)(i)Independent study required for loans over $1,000,000 to a new business; Agency sets scopeStudy mandatory
    7 CFR 5001.306(a)(1)Department of Labor concurrence for loans over $1,000,000 that create more than 50 jobsModel peaks at 44 jobs; a larger plan crosses the line
    7 CFR 5001.306(a)(2)Pro forma balance sheet at closingEquity and working capital shown at closing
    7 CFR 5001.202Projections that depart from history substantiated; reserves and working capital addressedCustomer evidence for revenue; working capital build
    7 CFR 5001.105(d)New-business equity at closing25% test with an early guarantee
    7 CFR 5001.3Rural area testSite screened on the eligibility map

    The engagement card cites "7 CFR 5001.304" for the study threshold; the correct citation is 5001.306(a)(3)(i).

    Why B&I rather than another route? A conventional loan of this size to a company without operating history would usually need more equity or more collateral than the owners can provide, because the bank carries the whole loss. SBA 7(a) caps a loan at $5,000,000 and would fit, but the plant's real estate and equipment would be split across a 7(a) loan and possibly a 504 structure with its own contribution rules for new businesses [14]. B&I lets the bank write one note on terms that follow the useful life of the building and the equipment, with an 85% guarantee below $5 million [1][2]. The price of that structure is the feasibility study, the equity test and the guarantee fee, which is why the study had to make the case in a form the state office reviewer would accept on first reading.

    Project description (modeled)

    ComponentModeled scopeNote
    Building26,000 sq ft pre-engineered steel plant with office, on about 6 acresRoom for a second bay
    CuttingFiber laserFeeds forming and welding
    FormingTwo press brakesBrackets, guards, panels
    JoiningTwo robotic welding cellsRepeat parts for anchor customers
    MachiningOne CNC machining centerBrackets, hubs, mounts
    Material handlingOverhead cranesPlate and assemblies
    ProductsFabricated components and weldments for agricultural, trailer and grain handling equipment makersUnder supply agreements and purchase orders
    PhaseTiming (modeled)Milestone
    Customer qualification and designMonths 1 to 6 before closingFirst-article approvals, supply agreements, design-build price
    ClosingNote month 0Equity spent first; guarantee issued before completion
    Construction and equipment installationNote months 1 to 10Monthly draws
    Start-upMonths 10 to 12Hiring, training, production part approval
    Operating year 1, interest-onlyMonths 11 to 22Anchor volumes ramp
    Full paymentsFrom month 23Within 3 years of the note (5001.402)

    Project cost and sources and uses

    No construction-cost database sits behind this page. Each line is an assumption with a range, and a real study replaces it with the document in the last column.

    Line itemBasisModeled costAssumption rangeHow a real study sources it
    Land (about 6 acres in an industrial park)allowance$280,000$150,000 to $450,000Purchase contract; appraisal
    Site work, paving, utilities, rail or truck accessallowance$420,000$280,000 to $650,000Civil engineer estimate
    Plant building, pre-engineered steel with office26,000 sq ft x $128$3,328,000$105 to $160 per sq ftDesign-build bid
    Fiber laser cutting system1 x $620,000$620,000$450,000 to $800,000Equipment quotes
    Press brakes2 x $260,000$520,000$180,000 to $340,000 eachEquipment quotes
    Robotic welding cells2 x $230,000$460,000$170,000 to $300,000 eachEquipment quotes
    CNC machining center1 x $320,000$320,000$220,000 to $420,000Equipment quotes
    Overhead cranes and material handling1 x $130,000$130,000$90,000 to $200,000Equipment quotes
    Hard cost subtotal (excluding land)$5,798,000
    Architecture and engineering6% of site and building$225,0005% to 8%Design contract
    Permits and connection feesallowance$45,000$25,000 to $90,000City fee schedule
    Legal, appraisal, feasibility study, title, closingallowance$95,000$70,000 to $140,000Engagement letters
    Contingency7% of site and building; 3% of equipment$324,0005% to 10%Lender review
    B&I guarantee fee, issued before construction completion (3.5%)$4,950,000 x 85% x 3.5%$147,262Fixed by FY2026 notice91 FR 11272
    Interest during constructionaverage 40% drawn for 10 months at 7.75%$128,000Depends on draw scheduleLender draw schedule
    Start-up: hiring, training, first-article trialsallowance$120,000$70,000 to $200,000Operating budget
    Working capital (receivables and steel inventory)from the working capital build below$900,000Sized from receivable and inventory daysCustomer terms; supplier terms
    Total project cost$8,062,262

    The modeled project costs $8,062,262, of which equipment is $2,050,000 and the building $3,328,000. Working capital of $900,000 is not a plug: it comes from the receivables and steel inventory build shown below, and it is the line most often understated in first budgets for a fabrication plant. The guarantee fee is 3.0% of the guaranteed portion plus 0.50% because the guarantee is issued before construction completion ($147,262); the reduced-fee option is not assumed [2].

    SourcesAmountShareUsesAmount
    B&I guaranteed loan (85% guaranteed)$4,950,00061.4%Land, site, building, equipment$6,078,000
    Owner equity (cash)$3,112,26238.6%Design, permits, legal, contingency, start-up$809,000
    Guarantee fee and construction interest$275,262
    Working capital$900,000
    Total sources$8,062,262100.0%Total uses$8,062,262

    Market analysis

    South Dakota manufacturing supply

    MeasureSouth DakotaUnited States
    Establishments, 2019 → 20231,022 → 1,034 (+1.2%)287,626 → 284,452
    Per 100,000 residents (2023)112.784.5
    Average employees per establishment45.843.4
    Average annual pay per employee$61,039$73,202
    Share of establishments in non-metro counties55.1% (562 in 42 counties)
    Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025)48.7%

    Non-metro counties with the most manufacturing establishments (all) (2023): Codington County (82); Brookings County (40); Brown County (39); Yankton County (37); Davison County (33); Lawrence County (32).

    Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.

    South Dakota has 112.7 manufacturing establishments per 100,000 residents against 84.5 nationally, and more than half of them (55.1%) sit in non-metro counties, a far higher rural share than most states. The count rose 1.2% from 2019 to 2023 while the national count fell. Plants are slightly larger than average, and average pay of $61,039 is 16.6% below the national $73,202, an advantage for a cost-competitive fabricator and a warning for recruitment against higher-paying plants nearby. Codington County, where Watertown sits, leads the state's non-metro counties with 82 manufacturers.

    The engagement record cites state figures from another source: 45,085 manufacturing workers at 1,086 establishments in 2024, 11.8% of private employment, with fabricated metal products the fastest-growing subsector from 2020 to 2024 (+760 workers, +20.8%). Those numbers were not confirmed for this page and differ from the Census count above (1,034 establishments and 47,333 employees in 2023), so they are shown with attribution.

    Regional comparison

    StateManufacturers, 2023Change 2019 to 2023Per 100,000Employees eachAverage payNon-metro share
    South Dakota1,0341.2%112.745.8$61,03955.1%
    North Dakota695-1.4%88.342.1$69,31042.1%
    Minnesota6,718-4.4%116.848.4$73,50626.8%
    Iowa3,418-0.4%106.365.6$69,57052.9%
    Nebraska1,7610.6%88.659.3$63,62045.8%
    United States284,452-1.1%84.543.4$73,202

    Among the northern plains states, South Dakota combines the highest rural share with the lowest manufacturing pay. North Dakota and Iowa pay about $8,000 to $8,500 more per worker, Minnesota about $12,500 more. A Watertown plant draws workers who can commute to plants in Brookings, Aberdeen and across the Minnesota line, so a wage plan built on the state average needs a local test.

    Codington County and the Watertown labour shed

    CountyOMB 2023Population, 2025ManufacturersManufacturing employees (noise)Per 100 residentsAverage pay
    Codington CountyNon-metro29,562823,322 (low)11.2$60,135
    Brookings CountyNon-metro37,635405,409 (low)14.4$59,611
    Brown CountyNon-metro37,561393,374 (moderate)9.0$58,306
    Hamlin CountyNon-metro6,90010449 (moderate)6.5$65,755
    Deuel CountyNon-metro4,4089229 (high)5.2$51,707
    Grant CountyNon-metro7,53417868 (low)11.5$60,910
    Clark CountyNon-metro4,03111175 (high)4.3$49,446
    Day CountyNon-metro5,48412174 (low)3.2$62,741
    Kingsbury CountyNon-metro5,28410283 (moderate)5.4$58,809
    Minnehaha CountyMetro212,69119212,407 (moderate)5.8$66,966

    Codington County has 82 manufacturers employing 3,322 people, 11.2 manufacturing jobs per 100 residents, more than twice the state ratio of 5.1. Average manufacturing pay in the county is $60,135, close to the state average. Brookings County, to the south, has 5,409 manufacturing workers, 14.4 per 100 residents. The rural counties around Watertown (Hamlin, Deuel, Grant, Clark, Day, Kingsbury) add smaller plants and a commuting workforce. The county's population grew 4.4% from 2020 to 2025, which helps, but the evidence in this table is that most people who want factory work in the area already have it.

    The engagement record cites roughly 33,000 open jobs against 10,000 unemployed statewide in early 2025 and calls the rural labour market acutely tight. That figure postdates the 2023 study and was not confirmed for this page; the Census ratio above makes the same point from 2023 data. The management section of a study like this one therefore has to show where 28 to 44 workers will come from: wage offers against local plants, training partnerships, shift design and automation that reduces headcount per dollar of output, which is what the robotic welding cells are for.

    Customers and competitive suppliers

    Customer (modeled; a real study names each)Year 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5
    Anchor A: agricultural equipment maker (supply agreement)38% ($2.51 million)33% ($2.77 million)30% ($2.88 million)28% ($2.91 million)27% ($3.02 million)
    Anchor B: trailer and truck body builder (supply agreement)22% ($1.45 million)20% ($1.68 million)18% ($1.73 million)17% ($1.77 million)17% ($1.90 million)
    Anchor C: grain handling equipment maker (purchase orders)12% ($0.79 million)12% ($1.01 million)12% ($1.15 million)12% ($1.25 million)12% ($1.34 million)
    Other customers (quoted work)28% ($1.85 million)35% ($2.94 million)40% ($3.84 million)43% ($4.47 million)44% ($4.93 million)

    The anchor analysis is the core of the market section. A real study names each customer, attaches the supply agreement or purchase orders, and reconciles the customer's stated volume with its own production and sourcing plans. It then maps the competing suppliers each customer uses today, by distance and capability, because a new plant wins volume by being closer, faster or cheaper than an incumbent. In the model the largest customer starts at 38% of revenue and falls to 27% by year 5 as quoted work grows; a reviewer will ask what happens if it leaves, and the stress tests answer.

    Rural area test

    PlaceCensus base 2020Estimate 2025Change5001.3 screen
    Sioux Falls192,737213,74810.9%Over 50,000: excluded with its contiguous urbanized area
    Aberdeen28,47927,961-1.8%Under 50,000: passes on population; contiguity decides
    Brookings23,37925,3558.5%Under 50,000: passes on population; contiguity decides
    Watertown22,65323,7364.8%Under 50,000: passes on population; contiguity decides

    Watertown had 23,736 residents in the 2025 estimate, up 4.8% since 2020, and passes the B&I population test; the only South Dakota places over 50,000 are Sioux Falls and Rapid City, neither contiguous to it [1]. The site's South Dakota guide lists Watertown among the towns that pass on population [11]. Codington County is non-metropolitan in the OMB delineation. The study still recorded a dated determination from the USDA eligibility map, which is the evidence a reviewer accepts.

    Financing benchmarks

    Period7(a) loans7(a) dollars504 loans504 dollars
    FY2010 to FY201676$42.8 million36$21.8 million
    FY2017 to FY201935$16.1 million15$16.2 million
    FY2020 to FY202342$12.5 million34$40.4 million
    FY2024 to FY202620$4.6 million9$10.6 million

    Average 7(a) loan, FY2020 to FY2026: $275,952. Average 504 loan: $1.2 million. Of the 76 7(a) loans approved in FY2010 to FY2016 for South Dakota manufacturing establishments (all), 1.3% were charged off (national: 6.4% of 27,078), on average 28 months after approval.

    Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).

    South Dakota manufacturers have one of the cleanest SBA records in the country: one charge-off among 76 seasoned 7(a) loans (1.3%) against 6.4% nationally. The average 7(a) loan since FY2020 is $275,952 and the average 504 loan $1.2 million, so a loan near $5 million is large for this market and above the size most local SBA lenders handle. USAspending lists 3 B&I loans in South Dakota for FY2024 to FY2026 (counts may be incomplete). For a community bank, the 85% guarantee on a loan under $5 million is what makes a loan this size fit its lending limit: the bank keeps 15 cents of risk on each dollar.

    Financial feasibility

    Operating assumptions

    Operating assumption (modeled)ValueEvidence a real study uses
    Revenue, years 1 to 5$6.6 million, $8.4 million, $9.6 million, $10.4 million, $11.2 millionCustomer purchase orders, supply agreements, quotes won
    Steel and purchased components43% of revenueBills of material; steel pass-through terms
    Staff (FTE), years 1 to 528, 34, 39, 42, 44Staffing plan by shift
    Wage$61,039 in year 1 (South Dakota manufacturing average), +3% a year, plus 24% benefitsCBP 2023 (pack); local wage survey
    Plant overhead5.5% of revenueUtility tariffs; consumables history
    Selling, general and administrative4.5% of revenue plus $380,000 fixedOrganisation chart
    Property tax and insurance$95,000 in year 1Assessor; insurance quote
    Maintenance capital1% of revenueEquipment maintenance schedules

    Debt terms

    Term (model)ValueRule or basis
    Loan amount$4,950,000Under $5 million tier (5001.406(c) cap $25 million)
    Guarantee85%: $4,207,500 guaranteed; the lender holds $742,500 at risk (15 cents on the dollar)FY2026 notice
    Guarantee fee3.0% plus 0.50% for a guarantee issued before construction completion: $147,262FY2026 notice; 5001.454
    Annual retention fee0.55% of guaranteed principal outstanding: $23,141 in year 1FY2026 notice; 5001.455
    Rate7.75% fixed (illustrative assumption)Negotiated (5001.401)
    Amortization, real estate portion$2,950,000 over 25 yearsUseful life of the building (5001.402)
    Amortization, equipment portion$2,000,000 over 10 yearsUseful life of the equipment (5001.402)
    Interest-onlyConstruction (10 months) and the first 12 operating months: $383,625 in year 1First full payment in month 23, within 3 years (5001.402)
    Combined payment from year 2$46,284 a month; $555,412 a yearLevel principal and interest
    CollateralFirst mortgage on land and building; first lien on equipment5001.202, 5001.203

    Five-year pro forma

    Operating yearYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5
    Revenue$6,600,000$8,400,000$9,600,000$10,400,000$11,200,000
    Steel and purchased components (43%)$2,838,000$3,612,000$4,128,000$4,472,000$4,816,000
    Production and support staff (FTE)2834394244
    Labour with 24% benefits$2,119,291$2,650,627$3,131,638$3,473,710$3,748,298
    Plant overhead: power, gases, consumables, tooling (5.5%)$363,000$462,000$528,000$572,000$616,000
    Gross margin$1,279,709$1,675,373$1,812,362$1,882,290$2,019,702
    Selling, general and administrative$677,000$767,500$831,238$877,218$923,449
    Property tax and insurance$95,000$97,375$99,809$102,305$104,862
    EBITDA$507,709$810,498$881,315$902,767$991,391
    Maintenance capital (1% of revenue)$66,000$84,000$96,000$104,000$112,000
    Cash available for debt service$441,709$726,498$785,315$798,767$879,391
    B&I debt service (year 1 interest-only)$383,625$555,412$555,412$555,412$555,412
    Retention fee (0.55% of guaranteed balance)$23,141$22,309$21,410$20,439$19,389
    DSCR1.15x1.31x1.41x1.44x1.58x
    DSCR after retention fee1.09x1.26x1.36x1.39x1.53x

    The plant covers interest-only payments 1.15x in year 1 on $6,600,000 of revenue, then full payments 1.31x in year 2 and 1.41x in year 3. EBITDA margins run from 7.7% in year 1 to 9.6% in year 2 and stay near 9% after that, normal for contract fabrication, where steel is passed through and the plant earns on labour and machine time. Coverage passes 1.25x from year 2 and reaches 1.58x by year 5.

    Working capital

    Year endReceivables (45 days)Steel inventory (50 days of materials)Payables (30 days)Net working capitalIncrease in the year
    Year 1$813,699$388,767$233,260$969,205$969,205
    Year 2$1,035,616$494,795$296,877$1,233,534$264,329
    Year 3$1,183,562$565,479$339,288$1,409,753$176,219
    Year 4$1,282,192$612,603$367,562$1,527,233$117,479
    Year 5$1,380,822$659,726$395,836$1,644,712$117,479

    A fabricator pays for steel before it is paid for parts. At 45 days of receivables, 50 days of steel inventory and 30 days of payables, net working capital reaches $969,205 by the end of year 1 and keeps rising with sales. The budget finances $900,000 of it; the balance comes from operating cash flow and a revolving line, which the study recommended sizing before closing so that growth does not starve the term loan.

    Break-even and sensitivity

    Break-even (year 3; 60% of labour flexes with volume)Revenue neededShare of base-case year-3 revenue
    Cash flow covers debt service (1.00x)$8,730,05490.9%
    Coverage of 1.25x$9,255,47096.4%
    Base case, year 3$9,600,000100.0%
    Scenario (year 3)Cash availableDebt serviceDSCR
    Base case, year 3$785,315$555,4121.41x
    Revenue 15% lower, labour 60% variable$404,762$555,4120.73x
    Anchor A lost, two-thirds of its volume not replaced$277,911$555,4120.50x
    Steel cost up 20% with half passed through$372,515$555,4120.67x
    Wages 10% higher$472,151$555,4120.85x
    Rate 8.75% (+1 point)$785,315$591,8231.33x
    Rate 9.75% (+2 points)$785,315$629,3111.25x
    Building overrun of 10% ($374,800) added to the loan$785,315$589,3841.33x

    Thin margins make the plant sensitive. Revenue 15% below plan, even with 60% of labour flexing down, takes coverage to 0.73x. A 20% steel price rise with only half passed through gives 0.67x, and losing two-thirds of the largest customer's volume gives 0.50x. Rate and construction cost matter much less: two points on the rate still leaves 1.25x, and a 10% building overrun added to the loan gives 1.33x. The study's recommendations followed from that ranking: full steel price pass-through in every supply agreement, minimum volume commitments from the anchors, and a debt service reserve.

    Ramp stress, year 1RevenueCash availableDebt serviceDSCRShortfall
    Plan$6,600,000$441,709$383,6251.15x$0
    Customer qualification takes six months longer (year-1 revenue 30% lower; labour 60% variable)$4,620,000-$87,619$383,625-0.23x$471,244

    Customer qualification is the ramp risk particular to contract manufacturing. If production part approvals take six months longer, year-1 revenue falls 30% and the plant needs $471,244 beyond its operating cash to meet interest. That amount should be held as a reserve or standby equity at closing.

    Equity test

    New-business testRequiredModeledResult
    5001.105(d)(3): construction, guarantee before completion: 25% of project cost$2,015,566$3,112,262Pass
    5001.105(d)(3) alternative: 25% balance-sheet equity (debt to equity at most 3 to 1)25% of assets38.6%Pass
    5001.105(d)(4) if the guarantee waits for completion: 20% balance-sheet equity or 25% of cost20% or $2,015,56638.6%Pass
    5001.105(d)(2): 10% if sales contracts cover debt service for at least the loan term$806,226Supply agreements run 3 to 5 years, shorter than the loanNot available

    The owners contribute $3,112,262 (38.6% of cost), above the $2,015,566 minimum for a new business with an early guarantee. Supply agreements that cover debt service for the whole loan term would cut the requirement to 10% [1], but agreements in this industry run three to five years, so the 25% test applies.

    Collateral

    Collateral (modeled)ValueDiscount (assumption)Lendable value
    Land and building, prospective value at completion$3,650,00080%$2,920,000
    Equipment, appraised value (55% of cost)$1,127,50070%$789,250
    Discounted collateral$3,709,250
    Loan$4,950,000
    Discounted coverage0.75x

    Discounted collateral covers 0.75x of the loan, typical for a new special-purpose plant whose equipment resells below cost. The guarantee covers 85% of the lender's loss, and owners of 20% or more give personal or corporate guarantees for the life of the loan [1]. The study shows the gap so the bank can document why it accepts it.

    Technical and environmental feasibility

    The technical section confirms that the site, building and equipment can produce the parts customers have ordered, at the rates the pro forma assumes. It reviews the equipment specifications against the parts mix (sheet and plate thickness, bend lengths, weld lengths), the electrical service for the laser, welding cells and cranes, the building's crane-rated structure, the layout's material flow, and the production part approval process each customer requires. It also checks the construction schedule against the start-up date that customers have been promised.

    Power is the utility line that most often surprises a fabrication budget. A fiber laser, two robotic welding cells and the cranes need three-phase service sized for simultaneous peaks, and the serving utility's letter should confirm capacity, any line extension cost and the demand charge structure. Shift design matters for the same reason: running the laser on a second shift spreads demand charges over more output, which the pro forma's overhead line assumes.

    Environmental review is a separate Agency requirement from the five feasibility components. For a fabrication plant its likely questions are site history (a Phase I environmental site assessment), stormwater, air permitting for welding fumes and any painting or powder coating, and waste handling for oils and metal fines.

    Management and governance feasibility

    A new company has no history, so management feasibility rests on the people. The study reviewed the owners' and plant manager's record in fabrication, the quality system and certifications the anchors require, the sales capability behind the quoted work, and the staffing plan. B&I eligibility also depends on the borrower and its owners: individuals must be U.S. citizens or lawful permanent residents, owners of more than 20% must be free of federal judgments, delinquent federal tax or debt and debarment, and loans must be secured by fixed assets that stay in the United States [1].

    The card's statement that management feasibility included a citizenship and foreign-adversary attestation under a January 2026 letter cannot describe a 2023 study and is not repeated here.

    Economic and community impact (modeled)

    Effect (modeled)AmountBasis
    Jobs, year 1 to year 5 (FTE)28 to 44Staffing plan
    Wages, year 5 (before benefits)$3,022,821FTE x South Dakota manufacturing average pay, +3% a year
    Purchases of steel and components, year 5$4,816,000Pro forma
    Construction spending (land, site, building)$4,028,000Budget
    Department of Labor concurrence threshold (5001.306(a)(1))Over $1,000,000 and more than 50 jobsModel peaks at 44 FTE; a larger plan crosses it

    The modeled plant creates 28 jobs in its first year and 44 by year 5, with wages of about $3,022,821 by then at the state's average manufacturing pay. It buys steel and components through regional service centres, and it shortens supply lines for equipment makers who source parts from further away today. A real study measures those effects from the customers' sourcing data and the owners' hiring plan.

    Risks and mitigants

    RiskEffect in the modelMitigant
    Revenue below plan0.73x at -15%Signed supply agreements; quoted pipeline; variable labour
    Loss of largest customer0.50x if two-thirds of its volume is lostMinimum volume commitments; diversification target
    Steel price spike0.67x with half passed throughFull pass-through clauses; inventory policy
    Labour shortage and wage pressure0.85x with wages 10% higherLocal wage survey; training partnerships; automation
    Slow customer qualificationYear-1 shortfall of $471,244Reserve or standby equity; early first-article work
    Working capital squeezeNet working capital $969,205 by end of year 1Revolving line sized before closing
    Rate1.33x at +1 pointFixed rate at closing
    Construction overrun1.33x if 10% is debt-financedDesign-build price; contingency
    CollateralDiscounted coverage 0.75xEquity; owner guarantees

    What the five Part 5001 components showed

    Part 5001 organises an acceptable study into economic, market, technical, financial and management feasibility [3].

    ComponentWhat the modeled study foundWhat a reviewer checks
    EconomicCodington County's manufacturing base is deep but fully employed; the plant adds jobs and local sourcingLabour shed, wage levels, job counts
    MarketThree anchors start at 72% of revenue and fall to 56% by year 5Supply agreements, purchase orders, competing suppliers
    TechnicalEquipment matches the parts mix; building and power fit; start-up depends on customer approvalsSpecifications, layout, approval schedule
    Financial1.31x in year 2 and 1.41x in year 3; break-even at 90.9% of year-3 revenue; working capital of $969,205 in year 1Pro forma, working capital, stresses
    ManagementFabrication experience, quality system and staffing plan carry the caseRésumés with plant results, certifications

    New-business manufacturing studies are sent back for recurring reasons:

    1. Revenue from market share estimates rather than named customers and their documents.
    2. Steel treated as a fixed percentage with no pass-through terms.
    3. No working capital build, so the first year runs out of cash while profitable on paper.
    4. A wage plan from a state average in a county where every plant is hiring.
    5. No ramp for customer qualification.
    6. The wrong citation or threshold for the study requirement, which makes a reviewer doubt the rest.
    7. A study written by the equipment vendor or the owners rather than an independent consultant.

    Program terms that applied

    FY2026 B&I termValueSource
    Guarantee, loans under $5 million85%91 FR 11272 [2]
    Guarantee, loans of $5 million to $25 million80%91 FR 11272 [2]
    Guarantee fee3.0% of the guaranteed portion91 FR 11272 [2]
    Extra fee, guarantee issued before construction completion0.50%91 FR 11272 [2]
    Annual retention fee0.55% of guaranteed principal outstanding at 31 December91 FR 11272 [2]; 5001.455 [1]
    TermUseful life, up to 40 years; no balloon; first full payment within 3 years5001.402 [1]
    RateNegotiated, not above the lender's rate on similar unguaranteed loans5001.401 [1]
    Equity, new business10% with long-term sales contracts; 25% for construction with an early guarantee; otherwise 20% balance-sheet or 25% of cost5001.105(d) [1]
    Feasibility studyRequired over $1,000,000 for a new business5001.306(a)(3)(i) [1]
    Department of Labor concurrenceOver $1,000,000 and more than 50 jobs5001.306(a)(1) [1]
    Rural areaOutside cities over 50,000 and their contiguous urbanized areas5001.3 [1]

    The FY2026 percentages took effect on 1 October 2025. A study prepared in 2023 worked under that year's notice; the terms above are what a new application would see today.

    Lessons for sponsors of similar projects

    1. Bring the customers' documents, not their enthusiasm. Supply agreements, purchase orders and first-article approvals are what a reviewer counts.
    2. Write steel pass-through into every agreement. Without it, a steel spike erases a fabricator's margin.
    3. Model working capital. A plant that grows fast needs cash for receivables and steel long before it earns it back.
    4. Show where the workers come from. In a county where manufacturing already employs one resident in nine, the staffing plan is part of the feasibility case.
    5. Check whether the expansion is a new business. A new affiliate at a new site usually is, which makes the study mandatory over $1,000,000.
    6. Watch the 50-job line. Above it, Department of Labor concurrence adds a step.
    7. Use the right citation. The study requirement is 5001.306(a)(3)(i).

    If your company is planning a new plant or a new-site expansion with a B&I guarantee, a USDA feasibility study consultant can build the customer, labour and working capital evidence your lender needs before the credit memo. Standard B&I studies take six to seven weeks, with fees on the cost page [12]. Request a proposal for a fifteen-minute scoping call and a written, fixed-fee proposal [13].

    David Miller, CPA

    USDA Feasibility, Inc.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    When is a feasibility study required for a USDA B&I manufacturing loan?

    When the loan is over $1,000,000 and the borrower is a new business. Part 5001 then requires a study by an independent qualified consultant acceptable to the Agency, with the Agency setting its scope (7 CFR 5001.306(a)(3)(i)) [1]. For smaller loans or established borrowers, the Agency and the lender may still ask for one. The engagement card cites 5001.304 for this rule; the correct section is 5001.306(a)(3)(i).

    Can an expansion by an existing manufacturer count as a new business?

    Yes. Part 5001 treats a business as new if it has operated less than a full year, or longer without reaching stable operations, and that includes a new affiliate of an existing company that moves into a new location with new market or labour areas [1]. An established owner opening a plant in another town through a new operating company is therefore often a new business, and a B&I loan over $1,000,000 then needs an independent study.

    What guarantee applies to a B&I loan under $5 million?

    Under the FY2026 notice, loans under $5 million carry an 85% guarantee, a 3.0% guarantee fee on the guaranteed portion and a 0.55% annual retention fee; the fee rises by 0.50% if the guarantee is issued before construction is complete [2]. On the modeled $4,950,000 loan the bank keeps 15% at risk. The terms change each fiscal year, so a 2023 study used that year's notice; a new application uses the notice in force when the loan is obligated.

    How does a study prove demand for a contract manufacturer?

    Through named customers and their documents. The study attaches supply agreements, purchase orders and first-article approvals, reconciles each customer's stated volume with its own production, and maps the suppliers it uses today. The engagement card describes this as anchor customer analysis, supply-chain economics and competitive supplier mapping. In the model three anchors start at 72% of revenue, and the stress tests show what happens if the largest one leaves.

    How much equity does a new manufacturing business need for B&I?

    Part 5001 sets the test at closing. A new business that builds and asks for the guarantee before completion needs 25% balance-sheet equity or 25% of project cost; other new businesses need 20% balance-sheet equity or 25% of cost; and 10% is enough only if sales contracts cover debt service for at least the loan term [1]. In the model the minimum is $2,015,566 and the owners put in $3,112,262.

    Why does the study include a working capital build?

    Because a fabricator buys steel and pays wages weeks before customers pay. In the model, 45 days of receivables and 50 days of steel inventory, less 30 days of payables, tie up $969,205 by the end of year 1. Part 5001 asks the lender to make sure working capital and reserves are adequate [1]. A plant that is profitable on paper can still run out of cash, so the study sizes the need and the revolving line before closing.

    Is Watertown eligible for B&I as a rural area?

    Watertown passes on population, with about 23,736 residents in the 2025 estimate, and the only South Dakota places over 50,000 are Sioux Falls and Rapid City, which are not contiguous to it [1]. Codington County is non-metropolitan in the OMB delineation, though that is a proxy rather than the B&I test. The study records a dated determination from the USDA eligibility map for the parcel.

    What happens if the project creates more than 50 jobs?

    For guaranteed loans over $1,000,000 that create more than 50 jobs, Part 5001 calls for Department of Labor concurrence (5001.306(a)(1)) [1]. The modeled plant peaks at 44 jobs, so it stays under the line, but a larger expansion would cross it. A sponsor planning a bigger plant should build that step into the application timeline, and the study's job counts should be the same ones used in the application.

    Can the same study support an SBA 504 loan instead?

    The market, technical and management work transfers. The financing sections do not: SBA 504 typically splits a project into a borrower contribution, a third-party first lien loan and a CDC loan of up to 40% [14], with contributions of 15% to 20% for new or single-purpose businesses. A study written for B&I can be adapted, but sources and uses, equity and coverage tests must be rebuilt for the 504 structure.

    What would a study like this cost and how long does it take?

    The site's cost page lists $6,900 to $12,500 for standard B&I studies, covering loans of $1 million to $10 million in an established asset class with one site, and $10,500 to $14,500 for complex engagements [12]. A single-site manufacturing expansion under $5 million usually falls in the standard band. Standard studies take six to seven weeks, and each includes all five Part 5001 components, sensitivity analysis and an Excel workbook [12][13].

    Sources

    [1] 7 CFR part 5001, OneRD Guaranteed Loans (CFR 2026 edition, title 7 vol. 15, revised 1 Jan 2026), govinfo; sections 5001.2, 5001.3, 5001.105, 5001.127, 5001.202, 5001.203, 5001.204, 5001.205, 5001.306, 5001.401, 5001.402, 5001.406, 5001.454, 5001.455. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2026-title7-vol15/xml/CFR-2026-title7-vol15-part5001.xml (accessed 11 Nov 2026)

    [2] USDA, OneRD Annual Notice of Guarantee Fee Rates, Periodic Retention Fee Rates, Loan Guarantee Percentage and Fee for Issuance of the Loan Note Guarantee Prior to Construction Completion for Fiscal Year 2026, 91 FR 11272 (9 Mar 2026). https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2026-03-09/html/2026-04581.htm (accessed 6 Nov 2026)

    [3] OneRD Guaranteed Loan Regulation, 85 FR 42494 (14 Jul 2020), appendix A to subpart D of part 5001, Elements of an Acceptable Feasibility Study, pp. 42556-42557. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2020-07-14/pdf/2020-13991.pdf (accessed 7 Nov 2026)

    [4] U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023, state and county files. https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/cbp/datasets/2023/cbp23st.zip ; https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/cbp/datasets/2023/cbp23co.zip ; https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/cbp/datasets/2019/cbp19st.zip (accessed 7 Nov 2026)

    [5] U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 county population estimates (co-est2025-alldata). https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/popest/datasets/2020-2025/counties/totals/co-est2025-alldata.csv (accessed 7 Nov 2026)

    [6] U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 city and town population estimates (sub-est2025). https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/popest/datasets/2020-2025/cities/totals/sub-est2025.csv (accessed 8 Nov 2026)

    [7] OMB metropolitan and micropolitan statistical area delineation file, July 2023 (list1_2023). https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/metro-micro/geographies/reference-files/2023/delineation-files/list1_2023.xlsx (accessed 7 Nov 2026)

    [8] U.S. Small Business Administration, 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026. https://data.sba.gov/dataset/7-a-504-foia (accessed 7 Nov 2026)

    [9] USAspending.gov, award counts by place of performance for Assistance Listings 10.768 (B&I), 10.766 (Community Facilities) and 10.868 (REAP), FY2024 to FY2026. https://api.usaspending.gov/api/v2/search/spending_by_award_count/ (accessed 7 Nov 2026)

    [10] usda-feasibility-study.com, Selected Engagements (site page). https://usda-feasibility-study.com/engagements (read 7 Nov 2026)

    [11] usda-feasibility-study.com, South Dakota USDA feasibility study guide (site page). https://usda-feasibility-study.com/south-dakota (read 10 Nov 2026)

    [12] usda-feasibility-study.com, USDA Feasibility Study Cost & Timeline (site page). https://usda-feasibility-study.com/usda-feasibility-study-cost (read 7 Nov 2026)

    [13] usda-feasibility-study.com, Contact & Request a Proposal (site page). https://usda-feasibility-study.com/contact (read 7 Nov 2026)

    [14] 13 CFR part 120, Business Loans (CFR 2026 edition), govinfo; sections 120.900, 120.910, 120.930. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2026-title13-vol1/xml/CFR-2026-title13-vol1-sec120-160.xml (accessed 6 Nov 2026)

    Ready to Start Your USDA Project?

    Get your free consultation today and take the first step toward securing USDA funding for your rural development project.

    Our USDA feasibility study consultants scope every engagement against the five Part 5001 components in a free consultation.

    Get Your Free Consultation

    Fill out the form below and we'll contact you within 24 hours to discuss your project.

    We'll respond within 24 hours