How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
This engagement supported a Value-Added Producer Grant (VAPG) working capital request for a winery in Sunnyside, Washington, in the lower Yakima Valley. It was prepared in 2024 for a working capital request above the size at which USDA requires a full feasibility study. A grant program, not a lender, was the funding party. This page describes the engagement type and models a Yakima Valley estate winery's request. It then shows how the grant, the match and the business's own cash flow fit together, and what the study must prove under the VAPG rule.
| Item | Published record |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Value-Added Producer Grant (VAPG), working capital |
| Asset class | Winery |
| Project | Value-added winery working capital |
| Location | Sunnyside, Washington (Yakima County) |
| Region | Pacific Northwest |
| Size tier | Under $5M |
| Year prepared | 2024 |
| Funding party | Grant program |
| Outcome | Prepared for a working capital request above the study threshold |
Sources: the site's engagement index [10]; county from Census place files [6].
The record lists what the study delivered:
- per-case cost of goods from grape cost through processing, bottling, labels, storage and direct-to-consumer fulfilment;
- a channel revenue model covering tasting-room visits and conversion, wine club retention, direct-to-consumer order value and wholesale net case price;
- a schedule verifying the 1:1 match;
- a five-year working capital deployment plan tying incremental revenue to the grant-funded activities.
The model below follows that structure.
The question USDA needed answered
A VAPG working capital grant pays a producer's costs of processing and marketing a value-added product [1]. It does not buy equipment or buildings. The reviewer's question is narrow but demanding. Will this producer, adding value to a commodity it grows and owns, build a viable value-added business, so that the grant funds a launch rather than a loss?
The rule makes the study mandatory at this size. A working capital application of $50,000 or more that does not qualify for the simplified application must include a business plan and a feasibility study (4284.931(g) and (h)) [1]. The study must come from a qualified consultant, defined as a third party without a conflict of interest who has the knowledge, expertise and experience to do the task efficiently, effectively and authoritatively (4284.903) [1]. It must state the consultant's name, credentials and completion date, and show a viable project with a likelihood of success by discussing strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats and the resources required [1]. USDA must concur in the adequacy of both the plan and the study [1]. That is the "study threshold" in the outcome line: this request sat above $50,000.
The rule defines a feasibility study as an analysis of the economic, market, technical, financial and management capabilities of a project in terms of its expectation for success (4284.903) [1]. These are the same five components a Part 5001 study covers for a USDA loan, and the study below is organised the same way.
The VAPG rules this study had to satisfy
| Requirement | Rule [1] | What the study documents |
|---|---|---|
| Commodity ownership | Applicant produces and owns more than 50% of the commodity to which value is added, from raw state through marketing (4284.920(d)) | Estate grape tonnage, weigh tags, and the share of the wine made from estate fruit |
| Emerging market | Group, cooperative and venture applicants, and producers marketing the product under two years, must show entry into an emerging market (4284.920(e)) | Marketing history of the product, and new channels where the rule requires them |
| Citizenship | More than 50% owned by citizens, nationals or lawful permanent residents (4284.920(f)) | Ownership schedule |
| One application | One application per cycle and one active award (4284.920(g), 4284.921(f)) | Prior awards and affiliates |
| Grant share and match | Grant up to 50% of project costs; matching funds at least equal to the grant, spent before or alongside grant funds (4284.928, 4284.903, 4284.931(e)) | Match verification schedule |
| In-kind limits | Own commodity up to 100% of match; third-party commodity up to 49%; applicant and family time up to 50% (4284.922(f)) | Valuation basis for each in-kind line |
| Period | Not over three years (4284.922(e)) | Three-year work plan |
| Unallowable costs | Over 10% of project costs makes the application ineligible (4284.926(b)); application preparation and industry-level templates are unallowable (4284.926(a)) | A budget with no equipment, buildings or preparation costs |
| Use of funds | Working capital funds pay processing and marketing costs of the value-added product (4284.925(b)) | Budget lines tied to the added production |
The FY2026 funding opportunity (RDBCP-VAPG-2026) listed $25,000,000 in program funding, 185 expected awards and a $200,000 award maximum. It was posted on 17 February 2026 and archived on 22 May 2026 [2]. The engagement record cites a $250,000 working capital cap and a 1:1 match, which matches the record's own year. This page models a $200,000 request at the FY2026 maximum.
Project description (modelled)
The modelled applicant is a Yakima Valley estate winery that grows all its own grapes on 32 acres yielding 3.8 tons an acre, or 121.6 tons a year. Before the project it makes and sells 4,000 cases from about 64.5 tons. It sells the remaining 57.1 tons as fruit to other wineries at a modelled $1,300 a ton. The value-added project turns 32.3 tons of that fruit into 2,000 more cases a year of its own wine, reached over three vintages (700, 1,300 and then 2,000 added cases). It sells them through a new wine club, the tasting room and a regional distributor.
The working capital need comes from the timing of wine. Grapes picked in September become white and rosé wine that sells within the year, but red wine ages 12 to 24 months before it earns a dollar. Bottling materials, cellar supplies, a coordinator's salary and the club launch are all paid long before the revenue arrives. That gap is what a working capital grant is for, and the five-year deployment plan below measures it.
Timeline: the application and the study come before the harvest that starts the project period. The grant period runs three years, across three crushes and the first sales of each vintage. Years four and five show the business after the grant, carrying the coordinator and marketing on its own.
Per-case economics
| Assumption | Model value | Range tested | How the study sources it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Estate vineyard | 32 acres at 3.8 tons an acre (121.6 tons) | 3.0 to 4.5 tons an acre | Vineyard block records and weigh tags |
| Grape value if sold as fruit | $1,300 a ton | $1,000 to $1,800 | Grape purchase contracts and the producer's own sales |
| Cases per ton | 62 | 55 to 70 | Winemaker yield records by variety |
| Cases sold before the project | 4,000 | n/a | Depletion reports |
| Tasting room price per bottle / average discount | $30.00 / 12% | -10% price | Point-of-sale data |
| Wine club price per bottle / member discount / shipping subsidy per case | $28.00 / 20% / $12 | -30% club volume | Club platform data, retention history |
| Wholesale price per bottle to distributor / freight per case | $10.50 / $6 | $9.00 to $12.00 | Distributor price sheets |
| Cellar supplies and lab per case | $15.00 | +/- 20% | Supplier quotes |
| Bottling: glass, closures, labels, capsules, cartons, mobile line | $27.30 | +/- 15% | Vendor quotes |
| Storage and handling per case | $4.00 | +/- 25% | Warehouse invoices |
| Excise and compliance per case (placeholder) | $3.50 | n/a | Federal and state excise schedules and licence fees |
| Card fees on direct sales | 3% | n/a | Processor statements |
| Per-case cost line (model) | Per case |
|---|---|
| Estate grapes (value if sold as fruit) | $20.97 |
| Cellar supplies and lab | $15.00 |
| Bottling materials and mobile bottling | $27.30 |
| Storage and handling | $4.00 |
| Excise and compliance (placeholder) | $3.50 |
| Cost per case including grape value | $70.77 |
Grape cost is entered at what the fruit would have fetched on the open market, not at its farming cost. That is the honest measure of value added: the winery gives up $20.97 of grape sales for each added case, and the case must earn more than that plus its processing cost. Excise and licence costs are a placeholder. A real study takes them from the federal and Washington schedules for the winery's volume and products.
| Channel | List price per case | Net revenue per case | Cost per case incl. grape value | Contribution per case | Contribution margin | Contribution per bottle |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tasting room | $360.00 | $307.30 | $70.77 | $236.53 | 77.0% | $19.71 |
| Wine club | $336.00 | $248.74 | $70.77 | $177.97 | 71.5% | $14.83 |
| Wholesale | $126.00 | $120.00 | $70.77 | $49.23 | 41.0% | $4.10 |
The channel table is the heart of a winery study. A case sold in the tasting room contributes $236.53. Through the wine club it contributes $177.97 after the member discount and shipping subsidy. Through a distributor it contributes only $49.23. A plan that grows mainly through wholesale grows volume, not cash. The modelled mix for the added cases is 45% club, 20% tasting room and 35% wholesale. The study must support that mix with club sign-up and retention data, tasting-room visitor counts and conversion rates, and a distributor's written interest.
From visitors and members to cases
The record says the study modelled tasting-room visits and conversion, wine club retention and average order value. The table turns the added cases into the customer counts a reviewer can test against evidence.
| Driver for the 2,000 added cases (year 4 run-rate) | Model value | Assumption behind it | Evidence a study collects |
|---|---|---|---|
| Added tasting-room cases | 400 | 20% of added cases | Point-of-sale history |
| Bottles bought per buying visitor | 2.5 | Assumption | Average transaction data |
| Visitors who buy | 35% | Assumption | Visitor counts against transactions |
| Added tasting-room visitors needed a year | 5,486 | Computed | Trail and visitor data for the valley |
| Added wine club cases | 900 | 45% of added cases | Club platform |
| Bottles per member a year | 12 | Assumption: four shipments of three bottles | Club terms |
| Average active members needed | 900 | Computed | Member list and growth history |
| Annual member churn | 25% | Assumption | Cancellation history |
| New members needed a year to hold that level | 225 | Computed | Sign-up conversion in the tasting room |
| Added wholesale cases | 700 | 35% of added cases | Distributor letter of interest and depletion plan |
At full run-rate, the added tasting-room cases need about 5,486 more buying and browsing visitors a year at a 35% purchase rate. The added club cases need about 900 active members, and at 25% churn the winery must sign up about 225 new members a year just to stay level. Those are the numbers a reviewer can check. Visitor counts on the valley's wine routes, the winery's own door counts, its history of club sign-ups per hundred buyers, and the cancellation rate on its platform either support them or do not. If the winery has no club history, the study should say so and lean on the tasting-room record it does have. Unsupported club growth is the most common weakness in winery plans. The wholesale share needs a distributor's letter that names the market, the price and the expected depletion rate. Without one, a reviewer will treat those 700 cases as unsold inventory.
The same arithmetic shows where the plan is most exposed. Each added club member is worth about $178 of contribution per case, or $178 a year at one case each. A churn rate of 35% instead of 25% means about 90 more sign-ups a year to hold the same membership. A study that tests churn, not just sign-ups, gives the reviewer a fair view of that risk.
Project cost and sources and uses (modelled)
The VAPG project budget covers only the costs of processing and marketing the added cases over the three-year period. Barrels, tanks, buildings and the bottling line are outside it. No equipment price appears in the budget, and the processing lines are per-case assumptions. A real study prices each line from supplier quotes, the mobile bottler's rate sheet, the agency's proposal and a pay survey for the coordinator role.
| Budget line (3-year project period) | Model amount | Funded as | Source in a real study |
|---|---|---|---|
| Processing: cellar supplies and lab for the added cases | $60,000 | Cash | Supplier quotes |
| Processing: bottling materials and mobile bottling for the added cases | $109,200 | Cash | Vendor quotes |
| Processing: storage and handling of the added cases | $16,000 | Cash | Warehouse invoices |
| Estate grapes used for the added cases (applicant-owned commodity) | $83,871 | In-kind match | Weigh tags at market value |
| Marketing: wine club launch, e-commerce and shipping compliance set-up | $12,000 | Cash | Vendor quotes |
| Marketing: digital and print campaigns, 3 years | $36,000 | Cash | Agency proposal |
| Marketing: tasting room events and promotions | $15,000 | Cash | Event budgets |
| Marketing: trade samples, distributor support and market visits | $15,000 | Cash | Distributor plan |
| Salary: wine club and DTC coordinator, 50% of time for 2 years | $72,000 | Cash | Job description and pay survey |
| Owner time on marketing and sales of the new product | $27,000 | In-kind match | Time records at a documented rate |
| Total project cost (model) | $446,071 |
| Uses | Amount | Sources | Amount | Share of project |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Processing of added cases (cash) | $185,200 | VAPG working capital grant | $200,000 | 44.8% |
| Estate grapes (in-kind) | $83,871 | Match: estate grapes (in-kind) | $83,871 | 18.8% |
| Marketing (cash) | $78,000 | Match: owner time (in-kind) | $27,000 | 6.1% |
| Coordinator salary (cash) | $72,000 | Match: cash from operations | $65,200 | 14.6% |
| Owner time (in-kind) | $27,000 | Match: cash from a 5-year bank term loan | $70,000 | 15.7% |
| Total | $446,071 | Total | $446,071 | 100.0% |
| VAPG test | Rule | Model result | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grant share of project cost | Up to 50% | 44.8% | 4284.928 [1] |
| Matching funds | At least equal to the grant | $246,071 = 1.23 times the grant | 4284.903, 4284.931(e) [1] |
| Applicant-owned commodity as match | Up to 100% of the match | $83,871 = 34.1% of the match | 4284.922(f) [1] |
| Applicant and family time as match | Up to 50% of the match | $27,000 = 11.0% of the match | 4284.922(f) [1] |
| Award size | FY2026 listing maximum $200,000 | $200,000 | FY2026 listing [2] |
| Lifetime grants to one recipient | Not over $500,000 | $200,000 (assumes no prior VAPG) | 4284.928 [1] |
| Unallowable costs | Over 10% of project costs makes the application ineligible | $0 (equipment, barrels and buildings kept out) | 4284.926(b) [1] |
| Paid preparation and grant management | Above 15% of the request loses Administrator priority eligibility | Threshold $30,000 | FY2026 listing [2] |
| Project period | Not over three years | 3 years | 4284.922(e) [1] |
| Commodity ownership | More than 50% of the commodity produced and owned by the applicant | 100% estate grapes (64.5 tons over the project) | 4284.920(d) [1] |
The feasibility study fee is not in the project budget. Grant funds cannot pay for application preparation or for costs incurred before the award [1], so the producer pays for the study itself. The site's cost page lists VAPG working capital studies at $6,500 to $9,500 over 5 to 6 weeks [9]. The FY2026 listing also requires applicants to disclose what they pay third parties to prepare the application or manage the grant. Above 15% of the request, the application loses eligibility for Administrator priority points [2]. On a $200,000 request that threshold is $30,000.
Choosing the request size
| Grant request | Minimum match | Minimum project cost at 50% | 15% paid-help threshold | FY2026 priority for requests under $125,000 | Owner share of the modelled $446,071 project |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $124,000 | $124,000 | $248,000 | $18,600 | Eligible (up to 5 points) | $322,071 (72.2% of this project) |
| $200,000 | $200,000 | $400,000 | $30,000 | Not eligible | $246,071 (55.2% of this project) |
A smaller request wins priority points for requests under $125,000 in the FY2026 listing [2], but it leaves the producer funding a larger share of the same launch. The study shows the reviewer that either size works and lets the producer choose with the numbers in front of them. In this model the $200,000 request is the better fit because the launch cash is the constraint, not the score.
Market analysis
Washington's winery base
Washington: breweries, wineries and distilleries, supply and rural footprint
| Measure | Washington | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 638 → 701 (+9.9%) | 9,424 → 11,122 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 8.9 | 3.3 |
| Average employees per establishment | 11.3 | 17.1 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $50,611 | $53,139 |
| Share of establishments in non-metro counties | 10.2% (67 in 11 counties) | |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 10.2% |
Non-metro counties with the most breweries, wineries and distilleries (2023): Klickitat County (12); Island County (10); Grant County (8); Jefferson County (6); Kittitas County (6); Whitman County (6).
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
Wineries alone (NAICS 312130), compared with other wine states:
| State | Wineries 2019 | Wineries 2023 | Change | Per 100,000 residents (2023) | Employees 2023 | Average pay | Employees per winery |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Washington | 355 | 392 | 10.4% | 5.0 | 4,519 | $55,307 | 11.5 |
| Oregon | 289 | 344 | 19.0% | 8.1 | 3,515 | $51,806 | 10.2 |
| California | 1,606 | 1,714 | 6.7% | 4.4 | 34,243 | $77,125 | 20.0 |
| New York | 203 | 234 | 15.3% | 1.2 | 2,551 | $46,411 | 10.9 |
| Idaho | 23 | 33 | 43.5% | 1.7 | 326 | $29,819 | 9.9 |
| Sum of all state rows | 4,078 | 4,558 | 11.8% | 65,468 | $58,240 | 14.4 |
County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023, establishments with paid employees; per-resident figures use Census Vintage 2025 state estimates for July 2023 [5][6].
Washington had 392 wineries with payroll in 2023, up from 355 in 2019 (+10.4%), employing 4,519 people at an average of $55,307. That is 8.6% of the 4,558 wineries in the state rows. Oregon has more wineries per resident (8.1 per 100,000 against Washington's 5.0), California far more in total. Washington wineries average 11.5 employees, so the typical competitor is a small business much like the modelled applicant. The Washington hub reports 985 licensed wineries in 22 AVAs [11]. The gap between that figure and Census's 392 is mostly producers with no payroll, which Census employer data leave out. For a tasting room, every licensed producer is a competitor for visitors, payroll or not.
The Yakima Valley and neighbouring wine counties
| Measure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Sunnyside city population, April 2020 estimates base | 16,388 | Census Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [6] |
| Sunnyside city population, July 2025 estimate | 16,430 | [6] |
| Yakima County population, July 2025 estimate | 259,185 | Census Vintage 2025 county estimates [6] |
| Yakima County OMB status | Metropolitan (Yakima, WA metro area) | OMB list1_2023 [7] |
| Yakima city population, April 2020 estimates base | 96,949 | [6] |
| Wineries with payroll in Yakima County, 2023 | 24 (308 employees) | County Business Patterns 2023 [5] |
| Wineries with payroll in neighbouring Benton County, 2023 | 47 | [5] |
| County | Wineries 2023 | Employees | Average pay | OMB status (2023) | Wineries per 100,000 residents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| King County | 87 | 1,343 | $67,643 | Metropolitan | 3.7 |
| Walla Walla County | 74 | 745 | $49,097 | Metropolitan | 118.7 |
| Benton County | 47 | 884 | $63,842 | Metropolitan | 21.2 |
| Chelan County | 36 | 289 | $39,962 | Metropolitan | 43.9 |
| Yakima County | 24 | 308 | $50,088 | Metropolitan | 9.3 |
| Snohomish County | 12 | 44 | $72,091 | Metropolitan | 1.4 |
| Klickitat County | 12 | 217 | $47,986 | Non-metropolitan | 49.3 |
| Spokane County | 11 | 126 | $32,849 | Metropolitan | 2.0 |
| Grant County | 8 | 163 | $52,632 | Non-metropolitan | 7.6 |
County Business Patterns 2023; OMB 2023 delineation; per-resident figures use Vintage 2025 county estimates [5][6][7].
Yakima County has 24 wineries with payroll employing 308 people, at an average wage of $50,088. Benton County next door has 47, and Walla Walla County 74, the state's densest cluster at 118.7 per 100,000 residents. For a Sunnyside winery, those neighbouring counties are both competition and draw. Visitors on a wine trip through Prosser, Zillah or Walla Walla pass the door, and every room on that trip competes for the same day. The study's market section therefore measures visitor flow to the valley, the number and pricing of tasting rooms within a short drive, and the club offers they make.
Yakima County is metropolitan under OMB's 2023 delineation, and Sunnyside had 16,388 residents in the April 2020 estimates base. The site's VAPG page notes that VAPG eligibility is not geographic: producers qualify wherever they operate, and the producer-ownership test governs [12]. Location still matters if the winery later borrows. The Washington hub screens Sunnyside as eligible for B&I under the Part 5001 rural-area test, while Yakima, Union Gap, Selah, Moxee and Naches sit in the Yakima urbanized area [11]. A future B&I or REAP loan for tanks or a solar array would need a parcel-level determination.
Industry figures cited in the engagement record
The record carries several industry figures that this page has not verified from its inputs. They are shown for context only and listed in VERIFY:
| Figure cited in the engagement record | Use in a study |
|---|---|
| Washington is the second-largest wine-producing state | Context; the Washington hub also states it [11] |
| Nearly 1,000 wineries, 35,000+ acres across 21 AVAs (the hub says 985 wineries in 22 AVAs) | Competitive density; reconcile with licence data |
| Washington winery case sales fell from 13.54 million (2021) to 11.1 million (2024), and 47% of wineries reported declines in 2024 | Demand headwind; test volume sensitivity |
| U.S. wine revenue fell 6.3% in 2024; top-quartile premium wineries grew 22% | Price tier matters more than category |
| Washington direct-to-consumer sales rose 5% from 2022 to 2023 while wholesale contracted | Supports a direct-to-consumer-led plan |
| 90% of Washington wineries produce fewer than 5,000 cases a year | Scale of the typical VAPG applicant |
Taken together, these figures argue for the plan modelled here: growth through the winery's own customers at premium prices, not through wholesale volume in a shrinking market. A study that leaned on category growth would be sent back.
Financing benchmark: SBA lending to the beverage sector
Washington: SBA lending to breweries and distilleries (SBA data exclude wineries, NAICS 312130)
| Period | 7(a) loans | 7(a) dollars | 504 loans | 504 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2010 to FY2016 | 63 | $26.5 million | 7 | $4.0 million |
| FY2017 to FY2019 | 33 | $9.9 million | 4 | $2.3 million |
| FY2020 to FY2023 | 35 | $29.1 million | 7 | $4.8 million |
| FY2024 to FY2026 | 14 | $4.3 million | 1 | $341,000 |
Average 7(a) loan, FY2020 to FY2026: $681,349. Average 504 loan: $644,125. Of the 63 7(a) loans approved in FY2010 to FY2016 for Washington breweries and distilleries, 3.2% were charged off (national: 5.3% of 1,462), on average 115 months after approval.
Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).
The SBA file does not identify wineries, so this table describes the neighbouring craft-beverage trades. Their seasoned loss rate in Washington (3.2%) is below the national figure (5.3%). That is useful context for the bank financing part of the cash match in this model.
Financial feasibility
Five-year working capital deployment plan
| Line (model) | Year 0 (before) | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cases sold | 4,000 | 4,300 | 5,000 | 5,600 | 6,000 | 6,000 |
| Wine revenue net of discounts, card fees, shipping and freight, plus tasting fees | $891,059 | $955,676 | $1,106,450 | $1,235,684 | $1,321,840 | $1,321,840 |
| Estate fruit sold as grapes | $74,209 | $59,532 | $46,951 | $32,274 | $32,274 | $32,274 |
| Variable cost of cases sold (excluding estate grapes) | -$199,200 | -$214,140 | -$249,000 | -$278,880 | -$298,800 | -$298,800 |
| Vineyard farming cost | -$108,800 | -$108,800 | -$108,800 | -$108,800 | -$108,800 | -$108,800 |
| Fixed winery and tasting room costs | -$443,000 | -$443,000 | -$443,000 | -$443,000 | -$443,000 | -$443,000 |
| Wine club and DTC coordinator (new) | $0 | -$72,000 | -$72,000 | -$72,000 | -$72,000 | -$72,000 |
| Added marketing | $0 | -$26,000 | -$26,000 | -$26,000 | -$20,000 | -$20,000 |
| EBITDA | $214,268 | $151,268 | $254,601 | $339,277 | $411,514 | $411,514 |
| Inventory build for added cases (cash tied up) | $0 | -$18,520 | -$13,890 | -$18,520 | $0 | $0 |
| VAPG grant reimbursements | $0 | $56,331 | $72,906 | $70,764 | $0 | $0 |
| Cash available for debt service | $214,268 | $189,078 | $313,616 | $391,521 | $411,514 | $411,514 |
| Existing debt service plus match term loan | -$130,000 | -$147,234 | -$147,234 | -$147,234 | -$147,234 | -$147,234 |
| Debt service coverage | 1.65x | 1.28x | 2.13x | 2.66x | 2.79x | 2.79x |
The pro forma is for the whole business, because the grant's purpose is to change the whole business. Year one shows the trough the grant is meant to bridge. The coordinator and the club launch cost $98,000 before the added cases sell, EBITDA falls from $214,268 to $151,268, and inventory absorbs another $18,520. Grant reimbursements of $56,331 keep cash available for debt service at $189,078 and coverage at 1.28 times. By year four, EBITDA has risen to $411,514. The added sales then carry the coordinator and the ongoing marketing on their own, and coverage reaches 2.79 times.
What the grant changes
| Year | Cash for debt service with grant | Coverage with grant | Without grant (same plan) | Coverage without grant | EBITDA change vs year 0 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $189,078 | 1.28x | $132,748 | 0.90x | -$63,000 |
| Year 2 | $313,616 | 2.13x | $240,711 | 1.63x | $40,332 |
| Year 3 | $391,521 | 2.66x | $320,757 | 2.18x | $125,009 |
| Year 4 | $411,514 | 2.79x | $411,514 | 2.79x | $197,245 |
| Year 5 | $411,514 | 2.79x | $411,514 | 2.79x | $197,245 |
Without the grant, the same plan drops coverage to 0.90 times in year one. The business would be launching on borrowed cash, or would have to slow the launch. With it, coverage never falls below 1.28 times. This table is the answer to "why a working capital grant": the grant does not make the venture profitable, it makes the launch survivable on the producer's balance sheet.
Timing matters as much as amount. VAPG pays approved costs as reimbursement, and the match must be spent before or alongside grant funds [1], so the winery pays first and claims afterwards. On the model, the grant-funded cash lines total $94,410 in year one, $122,190 in year two and $118,600 in year three: processing of the added cases, marketing and half the coordinator's pay in the first two years. Across the three years they come to $335,200. The $200,000 grant covers 59.7% of those cash lines, because the in-kind grapes and owner time carry the rest of the match. The heaviest outlays fall at harvest and at bottling, so the study shows a month-by-month cash schedule through the first year. It sizes the winery's operating line or reserve to the peak gap between spending and reimbursement, not to the annual average. A reviewer who sees reimbursement timing planned for will read the work plan as ready to run on award, which is what the rule asks of a working capital applicant [1].
Incremental revenue attributable to grant-funded activities
| Year | Added cases made | Added cases sold | Added wine revenue | Fruit sales given up | Variable cost of added cases | Coordinator and added marketing | Net contribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 700 | 300 | $64,617 | -$14,677 | -$14,940 | -$98,000 | -$63,000 |
| Year 2 | 1,300 | 1,000 | $215,390 | -$27,258 | -$49,800 | -$98,000 | $40,332 |
| Year 3 | 2,000 | 1,600 | $344,625 | -$41,935 | -$79,680 | -$98,000 | $125,009 |
| Year 4 | 2,000 | 2,000 | $430,781 | -$41,935 | -$99,600 | -$92,000 | $197,245 |
| Year 5 | 2,000 | 2,000 | $430,781 | -$41,935 | -$99,600 | -$92,000 | $197,245 |
| Five-year total | 8,000 | 6,900 | $1,486,194 | $496,832 |
The record describes a deployment plan that documents incremental revenue attributable to the grant-funded activities, and this table does that on the model. Over five years the added cases bring $1,486,194 of wine revenue and a net contribution of $496,832. That contribution is after the fruit sales given up, the processing cost and the full cost of the new coordinator and marketing. Year one is negative, year two roughly breaks even, and from year three the project pays its way.
Break-even
| Break-even test | Result | Plan | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Added cases a year to cover the coordinator and ongoing added marketing | 636 | 2,000 | 214% |
| Contribution per added case at the planned mix | $144.62 | ||
| Total cases sold for 1.00x coverage (year-5 cost structure) | 4,387 | 6,000 | 37% |
| Total cases sold for 1.25x coverage (year-5 cost structure) | 4,612 | 6,000 | 30% |
The added business covers its new fixed costs at 636 added cases a year, about a third of the plan's 2,000. The whole business covers its debt service at 4,387 cases and reaches 1.25 times coverage at 4,612, against a year-five plan of 6,000. Those margins are wide. The risk in this venture is less whether the added cases can pay than whether they can be sold at the planned prices and mix.
Sensitivity and stress tests
| Scenario (grant awarded) | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 | Five-year EBITDA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plan | 1.28x | 2.13x | 2.66x | 2.79x | 2.79x | $1,568,173 |
| Added sales at 80% of plan | 1.20x | 1.84x | 2.20x | 2.22x | 2.22x | $1,339,658 |
| Added sales at 60% of plan | 1.11x | 1.55x | 1.74x | 1.64x | 1.64x | $1,111,143 |
| Wine club volume 30% lower | 1.23x | 1.95x | 2.37x | 2.43x | 2.43x | $1,382,864 |
| Direct prices 10% lower | 0.81x | 1.57x | 2.03x | 2.12x | 2.12x | $1,123,078 |
| Wholesale price 15% lower | 1.04x | 1.85x | 2.36x | 2.47x | 2.47x | $1,352,429 |
| Direct prices 10% lower and added sales at 80% | 0.73x | 1.31x | 1.61x | 1.59x | 1.59x | $919,236 |
| Added wine from the year-2 vintage fails (smoke or quality); year-3 added sales lost | 1.28x | 2.13x | 0.36x | 2.79x | 2.79x | $1,303,228 |
| Price change | Tasting room contribution per case | Wine club | Wholesale |
|---|---|---|---|
| -15% | $190.43 | $138.86 | $30.33 |
| -10% | $205.80 | $151.89 | $36.63 |
| Plan | $236.53 | $177.97 | $49.23 |
| 5% | $251.89 | $191.01 | $55.53 |
Price is the variable to watch. A 10% cut in direct prices takes year-one coverage to 0.81 times, and combined with sales at 80% of plan, to 0.73 times. Volume shortfalls hurt less because the added cases are a small share of total sales in the early years. A failed vintage is the sharpest single shock: if the added wine from the year-two crush cannot be sold, year-three coverage drops to 0.36 times because the processing cost is spent with nothing to show for it. The study's mitigants are crop insurance and smoke-taint testing protocols, a cash reserve sized to one year's added processing cost, and a plan to blend or sell bulk wine rather than write it off.
| Funding case | Lowest annual cash for debt service | Lowest coverage | Inventory build, years 1-3 | Grant received |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grant awarded, $70,000 of the cash match from a bank term loan | $189,078 | 1.28x | $50,930 | $200,000 |
| Grant awarded, all cash match from the business | $189,078 | 1.45x | $50,930 | $200,000 |
| No grant; same plan funded by the business and the term loan | $132,748 | 0.90x | $50,930 | $0 |
Funding the full cash match from operations removes the term loan's $17,234 annual payment and lifts the lowest coverage to 1.45 times. Doing so also drains liquidity in the trough year. The study should show the producer's cash balance month by month through the first harvest so the reviewer can see the match will be spent "in advance of or alongside" grant funds, as the rule requires [1].
Equity and match test
The VAPG equivalent of an equity test is the match. On the model, the match of $246,071 is 1.23 times the grant, and the grant is 44.8% of project cost, inside the 50% ceiling [1]. Of the match, $83,871 (34.1%) is the winery's own grapes and $27,000 (11.0%) is owner time, both inside their caps. The remaining $135,200 is cash, $65,200 from operations and $70,000 from a five-year bank term loan at a modelled 8.5%. Cash match scores better than in-kind under the VAPG matching-funds criterion [1]. A plan that relied mostly on commodity value would give up points and show the reviewer less commitment.
Technical and environmental feasibility
A working capital project adds no building, so the technical questions are about capacity and process:
- Cellar capacity. Can the existing tanks, barrels and floor space take 2,000 more cases a year without new capital? The study tests tank turns and barrel cycles by vintage. If new capacity is needed, it must be funded outside the grant, and the study must say from where.
- Bottling and supply. A mobile bottling contractor's schedule and rate, glass and closure lead times, and label approval timing.
- Fruit. Weigh tags, block records and the yields of the varieties used. The study notes how a short or smoke-affected vintage would be handled.
- Compliance. The winery's federal and Washington licences and the excise and reporting obligations that come with higher volume, plus shipping compliance for wine club sales into other states.
- Environmental. Winery wastewater and pomace handling at higher volume. These are small at 2,000 cases, but the study should confirm that the existing permits and practices cover the increase.
Management and governance feasibility
VAPG gives up to 20 points for the qualifications of key personnel, and a working capital applicant must show a project ready to run on award [1]. The study names the winemaker, the owner responsible for sales, and the qualifications required for the new coordinator role, with a hiring timeline. It documents the ownership and control structure, since the applicant must own and control the product from raw state through marketing. It also screens for conflicts of interest: the study's author cannot be a family member, a vendor or anyone with a stake in the outcome [1]. Grant management needs systems too. The winery tracks grant-funded costs separately, documents match as it is spent, and reports against the work plan.
Economic and community impact (modelled)
| Measure (modelled) | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Added cases sold a year at full run-rate | 2,000 | Plan |
| Estate fruit kept in the valley as wine instead of sold as grapes | 32.3 tons a year | 2,000 cases at 62 cases a ton |
| Added wine revenue over five years | $1,486,194 | Incremental table |
| Net added contribution over five years | $496,832 | Incremental table |
| New position | One wine club and direct-to-consumer coordinator | Budget |
| Local purchases during the grant | Bottling, supplies, storage and marketing of about $263,200 | Budget cash lines |
The community case for a value-added grant is that more of the value of the valley's fruit is captured in the valley. In this model, 32.3 tons a year that left as grapes now leave as wine, and one new salaried position is added. Washington winery pay averages $55,307 [5], which sets the benchmark for the coordinator role in the budget.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | Effect on the plan | Mitigant the study documents |
|---|---|---|
| Wine demand keeps falling | Added cases sell slowly or at lower prices | Direct-to-consumer-led plan; volume and price sensitivity; ramp held to 2,000 cases |
| Price discounting to move inventory | Coverage falls fastest through price | Price stress table; club pricing policy; no wholesale-led growth |
| Wine club churn | Club volume below plan | Retention assumptions from platform data; club volume stress |
| Smoke or quality loss in a vintage | Processing cost spent without sales | Smoke-taint testing, crop insurance, bulk-sale fallback, cash reserve |
| Grant not awarded or delayed | Year-one trough uncovered | Launch paced to the award date; no-grant case shown |
| Match not available when needed | Grant draws held up | Match schedule; cash and bank commitment letters |
| Cellar capacity constraint | Unplanned capital spending | Tank and barrel turn analysis by vintage |
| Coordinator hire slips | Club launch late | Hiring timeline; owner covers the role in the interim |
| Paid help above 15% of the request | Loss of priority-point eligibility | Track and disclose all third-party fees |
| Unallowable costs creep into the budget | Over 10% makes the application ineligible | Budget review line by line |
What the five feasibility components showed
| Component | What it tests here | What the modelled study shows |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Fruit supply, grape value, processing cost and value added per case | 32.3 tons a year converted; cost $70.77 a case including grape value |
| Market | Channels, prices, competition for visitors and shelf space | Contribution of $236.53 (tasting room), $177.97 (club) and $49.23 (wholesale) a case; 24 Yakima County wineries with payroll and dense neighbouring clusters |
| Technical | Cellar capacity, bottling, compliance | No new capital needed for 2,000 cases, subject to tank and barrel turns |
| Financial | Cash trough, coverage, break-even, sensitivity | Lowest coverage 1.28x with the grant, 0.90x without; break-even at 636 added cases |
| Management | Personnel, ownership, grant administration | Named winemaker and owner, coordinator role defined, match tracked as spent |
Why VAPG studies and plans are sent back
- A study built from an industry template rather than the applicant's own numbers. Industry-level templates are an unallowable cost [1].
- Pro formas that do not show break-even or that disagree with the business plan.
- Revenue growth assumed from the category rather than from the winery's own channels.
- A match asserted but not committed, or in-kind values with no documented basis.
- Commodity ownership not shown from raw state through marketing.
- No opinion on the likelihood of success, or a consultant who is not independent.
- Budget lines for equipment or barrels inside a working capital request.
Program terms that applied
| Term | VAPG working capital | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Form of assistance | Grant, paid as reimbursement of approved costs | 7 CFR part 4284 subpart J [1] |
| Maximum award | $200,000 in the FY2026 listing; the annual maximum is set by notice | [2]; 4284.928 [1] |
| Grant share | Up to 50% of project costs | 4284.928 [1] |
| Match | At least equal to the grant; cash, loans, non-federal grants or in-kind within limits | 4284.903, 4284.922(f) [1] |
| Lifetime limit | $500,000 of VAPG grants to one recipient | 4284.928 [1] |
| Project period | Up to three years | 4284.922(e) [1] |
| Study and plan | Required for working capital requests of $50,000 or more outside the simplified application | 4284.931(g), (h) [1] |
| Scoring | Up to 100 points; general funds awarded in rank order down to a minimum score of 50 | 4284.940 [1] |
| Default window | Opens 1 November, closes 15 February unless a notice says otherwise | 4284.933(a) [1] |
| Location | Not a geographic program: producer ownership governs | Site VAPG page [12] |
VAPG scoring and where the study earns points
| Criterion (4284.940(c)) [1] | Points | What the study supplies |
|---|---|---|
| Nature of the venture: technological feasibility, operational efficiency, profitability, sustainability | 0 to 30 | Per-case costs, channel margins, break-even, pro formas |
| Qualifications of key personnel | 0 to 20 | Named people and the coordinator role's requirements |
| Work plan and budget | 0 to 20 | Three-year plan with costs, timing and sources |
| Matching funds commitment | up to 5 | Cash share of the match |
| Prior VAPG assistance | up to 5 | No prior award in the model |
| Priority categories | 0 to 10 | Documentation if the producer qualifies |
| Administrator or State Director priorities | 0 to 10 | FY2026: first-time applicants, requests under $125,000, geographic diversity [2] |
If the winery later borrows for tanks or an energy project, other USDA programs apply. B&I guarantees under 7 CFR part 5001 carry an 85% guarantee below $5 million in FY2026, with a 3.0% fee and a 0.55% annual retention fee [3][4], and they apply the rural-area test. Under the REAP rule effective 16 October 2026, a grant for refrigeration or solar comes only after twelve months of operation, and any gambling income bars an applicant from a REAP grant [13].
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Grow through your own customers. In this model a tasting-room case earns nearly five times what a wholesale case earns. A working capital plan that leans on distributors adds volume, not cash.
- Value your grapes at market. Converting fruit you could sell means giving up that sale. The study counts it, and the reviewer will look for it.
- Size the trough, not just the launch. Red wine ties up cash for a year or two. The grant's real job is to carry year one, so show the month-by-month cash.
- Keep equipment out of the request. Barrels, tanks and buildings belong in a loan or the owner's capital plan. Unallowable costs above 10% sink the application.
- Prefer cash match. It scores better and shows commitment. Document every in-kind value.
- Mind the 15% line. Know what you will pay for application help and grant management before choosing the request size.
- Hire an independent author. The study must come from a qualified consultant with no stake in the outcome, and USDA judges that consultant's qualifications.
- Plan for a bad vintage. A smoke or quality loss is the shock most likely to break a winery's launch year.
Related pages
- USDA VAPG engagements: the program page for this engagement type.
- USDA VAPG feasibility study and business plans and feasibility studies for USDA grants.
- Brewery, distillery and winery feasibility study for USDA loans: the national page for this asset.
- Washington USDA feasibility studies and the Washington distillery, winery and brewery feasibility study page.
- Case studies and the full engagement index.
- USDA feasibility study cost and timeline.
The site's cost page lists VAPG working capital studies at $6,500 to $9,500 over 5 to 6 weeks, quoted as a firm fixed fee in a written proposal [9]. For a winery or other value-added producer preparing a working capital request, an independent USDA feasibility study consultant can build the per-case costs, channel model and match schedule the rule asks for.
Request a scoped proposal for your VAPG feasibility study at the contact page.
USDA Feasibility, Inc.