Workforce and multifamily housing projects in Hawaii face the state's acute affordability gap, but B&I limits on residential uses narrow the program fit. An independent USDA feasibility study consultant models rents, absorption and construction cost; the independent USDA feasibility study company states the program-eligibility analysis up front.
Census counted 286 lessors of residential buildings with paid employees in Hawaii in 2023 (NAICS 531110), and 247 of the 285 in its size-class file (86.7%) employ fewer than five people. That count is a proxy, not a measure of the housing stock: it tracks landlord businesses that carry payroll, not apartments or buildings. For a Hawaii rental project, the more decisive facts are program fit and Maui's Bill 9, which could return up to 6,208 apartment-zoned units to the long-term market by 2031.
Data current as of November 2026.
Program Fit
B&I where the project qualifies as a business use; USDA housing programs use their own limits and are a separate track.
| Option | Fit for Hawaii workforce or multifamily housing | What to check first |
|---|---|---|
| USDA B&I guarantee | Rental housing only where the Agency accepts it as a business use, typically workforce housing tied to an employer or operating business | The hub flags B&I limits on residential uses; confirm eligibility with the Hilo state office before commissioning the full study |
| USDA rural housing programs (for example Section 538 guaranteed rental housing) | Affordable rural rental housing with rent and income limits | A separate program with its own rural definition and rules outside Part 5001; housing-program maps are not a guide to B&I (hub) |
| SBA 7(a) and 504 | Not available for passive rental property: SBA does not lend to passive real estate investors or landlords who do not occupy the property (13 CFR 120.110(c)) | Only an operating business that occupies the property qualifies; an apartment building held for rent does not |
| Community Facilities | Essential community facilities, not market rental housing | Does not fit an apartment project |
| REAP | Solar or efficiency for an eligible operating rural small business | Not a source for building the housing |
| LIHTC, state and county housing funds, conventional and agency lenders | The usual capital stack for affordable and market-rate rental housing | Outside USDA; the study must reconcile with them if layered |
Other ineligible income. Rental housing does not run into the gambling ceiling that other state hubs on this site quote from 7 CFR 5001.127(b); for apartments, the residential-use question is the one that matters.
Why there is no SBA table on this page. The Census pack includes no SBA lending block for residential lessors because SBA's rules exclude passive real estate businesses. A Hawaii sponsor building rental apartments should not plan on SBA 7(a) or 504 for the housing itself; an operating business that builds staff housing for its own use is a different case that needs its own eligibility review.
What the federal record shows. USAspending lists 4 B&I loans with a Hawaii place of performance in FY2024 to FY2026, and the hub names no rental-housing B&I deal among Hawaii's precedents. The USDA activity the hub records in housing is a memorandum of understanding with Hawaiʻi Community Lending, which runs a $16 million revolving fund, to expand rural home lending, a homeownership effort rather than rental finance.
When the study is required, and when it is only requested
| Situation | What Part 5001 or the lender says | How it lands on a Hawaii rental project |
|---|---|---|
| New business, guaranteed loan above $1,000,000 | Independent study by a qualified consultant acceptable to the Agency; the Agency sets the scope (5001.306(a)(3)(i)) | Nearly every new rental project held in a new entity |
| Guaranteed loan of $1,000,000 or less | The Agency may require a study when the file lacks information (5001.306(a)(3)(ii)) | Small conversions or additions |
| Guaranteed loan of $600,000 or less | Streamlined application (5001.306(b)) | Rare for multifamily |
| Any guaranteed loan | Lender's credit evaluation covers the feasibility and market studies (5001.202) | Rent, absorption and construction cost are tested |
| SBA | SBA does not finance passive rental real estate (13 CFR 120.110(c)) | Not an option for the housing itself |
Rental projects are almost always new single-purpose entities, so a B&I-guaranteed rental loan above $1,000,000 will usually trigger the mandatory study. The eligibility question comes first, though: the study's first chapter should set out why the Agency should treat the project as an eligible business use, and the sponsor should have the state office's view before paying for market work.
What the Study Covers
Framed to the scope required by 7 CFR Part 5001 Appendix A for OneRD guaranteed loan submissions.
- Market demand and competitive supply analysis
- Technical and site feasibility, including environmental considerations
- Five to ten year financial projections with DSCR, DCF, and sensitivity analysis
- Management and operational capacity assessment
- Economic feasibility and rural community impact
Hawaii Market Evidence
Maui's Bill 9 could return up to 6,208 apartment-zoned short-term rental units to the long-term market by 2029–2031 (Maui Department of Finance), and USDA RD signed an MOU with Hawaii Community Lending, which runs a $16 million revolving fund, to expand rural home lending. USDA's Honolulu determination treats only the Urban Honolulu and East Honolulu census-designated places as urban, so most of Oahu and all neighbor-island territory is B&I-eligible; every Hawaii study includes a dated, address-level USDA map determination.
Residential lessors in Hawaii: market evidence (a proxy)
Table: Hawaii: lessors of residential buildings, supply and rural footprint
| Measure | Hawaii | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 274 → 286 (+4.4%) | 71,800 → 74,459 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 19.9 | 22.1 |
| Average employees per establishment | 5.9 | 4.7 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $47,988 | $55,560 |
| Share of establishments in non-metro counties | 15.7% (45 in 2 counties) | |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 19.8% |
Non-metro counties with the most lessors of residential buildings (2023): Hawaii County (29); Kauai County (16).
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
What this table measures. NAICS 531110 counts establishments that lease residential buildings and carry paid employees. Owners whose buildings are run by a separate property manager, and small landlords with no payroll, are largely missing. The 286 Hawaii lessors are therefore the professionally staffed part of the rental business, a useful signal of who operates apartments, not a count of units.
Density and change. Hawaii has 19.9 such lessors per 100,000 residents against 22.1 nationally (22nd of 51), and the count rose 4.4% from 2019 to 2023 while the U.S. count rose 3.7%. Employment slipped from 1,744 to 1,696 (-2.8%).
Pay as a benchmark. On-site staff pay averaged $47,988, 86.4% of the national figure, and rose 11.6% since 2019 against a national 27.6%. Hawaii lessors average 5.9 employees, more than the U.S. 4.7, consistent with a few large Honolulu operators. For a pro forma, the payroll line should come from the property's own staffing plan, priced with this benchmark.
What a reviewer will challenge. Whether the project is an eligible business use, achievable rents against the households the project targets, construction cost and land tenure, and competition from units Bill 9 returns to the long-term market.
Where Hawaii residential lessors sit: islands, counties and size
| County (island) | OMB 2023 status | B&I screen (Hawaii hub) | Residential lessors, 2023 | Share | Per 100,000 residents | Avg. employees | Avg. pay |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Honolulu County (Oahu) | Metro (Urban Honolulu) | Mostly eligible; Urban Honolulu and East Honolulu CDPs excluded | 199 | 69.6% | 20.1 | 7.2 | $49,060 |
| Maui County (Maui, Molokai, Lanai) | Metro (Kahului-Wailuku) | Eligible; confirm sites in the Kahului-Wailuku urban area | 42 | 14.7% | 25.6 | 2.9 | $39,208 |
| Hawaii County (Hawaii Island) | Non-metro (Hilo-Kailua micro) | Eligible | 29 | 10.1% | 14.0 | 2.4 | $43,457 |
| Kauai County (Kauai, Niihau) | Non-metro (Kapaa micro) | Eligible | 16 | 5.6% | 21.7 | 4.5 | $45,667 |
| Total of county-coded establishments | 286 | 100.0% |
Source: Census County Business Patterns 2023 county file; Vintage 2025 population estimates (2023 column); OMB July 2023 delineation; B&I screen from the Hawaii hub. Maui County employment carries noise flag J (high noise). Computed in Python.
Honolulu County holds 199 of the 286 lessors (69.6%), averaging 7.2 employees, while neighbor-island lessors average fewer than five employees (2.4 in Hawaii County, 2.9 in Maui County). Professional rental operations outside Oahu are thin, so a new neighbor-island project usually needs a management plan that brings in an experienced operator, and the study should test that operator's capacity.
| Employees per establishment (2023) | Hawaii establishments | Hawaii share | U.S. share |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 to 4 | 247 | 86.7% | 74.4% |
| 5 to 19 | 29 | 10.2% | 22.8% |
| 20 to 99 | 6 | 2.1% | 2.6% |
| 100 or more | 3 | 1.1% | 0.2% |
Source: Census County Business Patterns 2023 state file, employment-size classes. Computed in Python. The size classes sum to 285 establishments rather than 286 because Census withholds some size-class cells. Only 3 Hawaii lessors employ 100 or more.
Bill 9 and the Maui rental market
Maui County's Ordinance 5909 ends transient vacation rental use for about 7,000 apartment-zoned units, including 6,208 listed as short-term rentals as of May 2024, from January 1, 2029 in West Maui and January 1, 2031 elsewhere (hub). Against Maui County's 2025 population of 160,592, those 6,208 units equal about 38.7 units per 1,000 residents. If even part of that stock enters the long-term market, it competes directly with new workforce rentals in West and South Maui, most likely on price for smaller units. Takings lawsuits were pending as of mid-2026 and a 2026 ordinance created a hotel-rezoning path, so a Maui rental study needs three cases: full conversion to long-term rental, a litigation delay, and partial rezoning to hotel use.
Demand drivers and how competition is measured
Demand for workforce rentals comes from employed households who cannot find or afford housing near work: resort, hospital, government and agricultural employers on the neighbor islands are the usual anchors, and employer letters or master leases are the strongest evidence. The study sizes the renter household pool by income in the commuting shed, subtracts existing and planned supply including Bill 9 conversions on Maui, and estimates capture and lease-up. The competitive set includes existing apartments, accessory units, and on Maui the converted short-term rentals.
Revenue model, operating costs and capital items
Revenue is units times achievable rent, less vacancy and concessions, plus parking, storage and utility reimbursements. Operating costs include management, on-site payroll (benchmarked above), repairs, insurance with hurricane exposure, real property tax, utilities at Hawaii rates (the hub's residential reference runs from 43.1 to 51.6 cents per kWh), and ground rent on leasehold land. Capital items are land or leasehold, site work and utilities, vertical construction, furniture for employer-leased units, solar, and replacement reserves. Construction cost and land tenure are the two items the hub lists alongside Bill 9 competition among a reviewer's tests.
Rural footprint and B&I eligibility in Hawaii
On the pack's proxy, 45 lessors (15.7%) sit in the non-metro counties, Hawaii County (29) and Kauai County (16), which hold 19.8% of residents. B&I geography is broader. Read against 7 CFR 5001.3, which bars places of more than 50,000 people and the urbanized land contiguous to them, the 2020 Census leaves only two Hawaii places outside B&I: the Urban Honolulu CDP (350,964 residents) and East Honolulu (50,922). Maui County is eligible by statute (sites in the Kahului-Wailuku urban area of 57,905 need a map check), and Oahu outside the two CDPs, including Kapolei, Ewa Beach, Mililani and the windward towns, screens eligible.
Two warnings apply to housing in particular. First, geographic eligibility is not program eligibility: an address can be inside B&I territory while the project still fails the Agency's view of residential uses. Second, the hub notes that housing-eligibility maps describing Kailua or Hilo as ineligible apply to USDA's housing programs and are not a guide to B&I, so a sponsor should not rely on one map for both. The Hawaii USDA feasibility study consultant hub explains both screens.
Financing benchmarks: USDA B&I next to SBA
There is no SBA lending table for this asset. SBA does not lend to passive real estate investors (13 CFR 120.110(c)), so the SBA FOIA data behind the other Hawaii pages contain no comparable residential-lessor loans, and the pack builder includes none. A B&I-guaranteed rental loan is benchmarked here against the FY2026 B&I terms alone.
| B&I term (FY2026) | Rule and source | What it means for a Hawaii rental project |
|---|---|---|
| Guarantee, loans under $5 million | 85% (91 FR 11272) | Smaller projects of a few dozen units |
| Guarantee, $5 million to $25 million | 80% (91 FR 11272) | Most new Hawaii rental construction, given building costs |
| Upfront guarantee fee | 3.0% of the guaranteed portion (91 FR 11272; 5001.454) | $192,000 on the $8,000,000 case below |
| Annual retention fee | 0.55% of the guaranteed share of the 31 December balance (91 FR 11272; 5001.455) | Fixed for the life of the loan |
| Loan note guarantee before construction is complete | Extra 0.50% fee; independent budget confirmation; equity in first (5001.454; 5001.205(e)(2)) | Applies to new construction funded under the guarantee |
| Term | Useful life, 40 years at most, no balloon (5001.402) | A long amortization lowers debt service |
| Equity at closing | 20% balance sheet equity or 25% of project cost for most new businesses; 25% with a construction-period guarantee (5001.105(d)) | Appraisal surplus does not count (5001.105(d)) |
| Appraisal | Real estate above $250,000; "as is" and "prospective" values for construction; USPAP; review before closing; going-concern value deducted (5001.203) | Rental real estate is the main collateral; little going-concern value to deduct |
| Guarantees | Owners of 20% or more, at least their share of the guaranteed amount (5001.204) | Investors in the ownership entity sign |
| Maximum loan | $25 million per borrower (5001.406(c)) | Larger projects need other senior debt |
What this means for a Hawaii rental project. A new rental entity is a new business under 5001.105(d)(4): 20% balance sheet equity (debt to equity no worse than 4:1) or 25% of project cost, rising to 25% balance sheet equity under 5001.105(d)(3) when the guarantee is issued before construction is complete. Appraisal surplus cannot count toward equity, which matters in Hawaii, where land appreciation is often a sponsor's main contribution. Whether a long-term master lease to an employer can serve like the sales contracts in 5001.105(d)(2), which lower a start-up's equity to 10%, is a question for the lender and Agency; the study should present the lease terms so they can decide.
Worked example (illustrative)
No SBA average exists for this asset, so both cases use stated illustrative sizes: Case A is a $3,000,000 loan on a 24-unit workforce rental, and Case B an $8,000,000 loan on a 60-unit project in the 80% tier. A 7.00% rate and 30-year amortization are assumed throughout, well within what 5001.401 and 5001.402 allow. Unit counts and loan sizes are assumptions chosen to show the arithmetic, not cost estimates.
| Input or result | A: 24-unit workforce rental | B: 60-unit workforce rental, 80% tier |
|---|---|---|
| Loan amount | $3,000,000 | $8,000,000 |
| Guarantee tier (91 FR 11272) | 85% | 80% |
| Guaranteed portion | $2,550,000 | $6,400,000 |
| Unguaranteed portion held by the lender | $450,000 | $1,600,000 |
| Upfront guarantee fee (3.0% of guaranteed portion) | $76,500 | $192,000 |
| First annual retention fee (0.55% x guaranteed share x balance after 12 payments) | $13,883 | $34,842 |
| Same fee on the full opening balance (upper bound) | $14,025 | $35,200 |
| Interest rate (illustrative; negotiated under 5001.401) | 7.00% | 7.00% |
| Term, fully amortizing (5001.402 allows up to 40 years) | 30 years | 30 years |
| Monthly payment | $19,959 | $53,224 |
| Annual debt service | $239,509 | $638,690 |
| Year-one interest / principal | $209,035 / $30,474 | $557,426 / $81,265 |
| NOI needed for 1.25x coverage | $299,386 | $798,363 |
| New business equity, 25% of project cost route (5001.105(d)(4)) | $1,000,000 | $2,666,667 |
| Implied total project cost on that route | $4,000,000 | $10,666,667 |
| New business equity, 20% balance sheet route, loan as only debt | $750,000 | $2,000,000 |
| Existing business, 10% of project cost (5001.105(d)(1)) | $333,333 | $888,889 |
| Stress case (NOI set at 1.25x in the base case) | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| NOI 10% below plan | 1.125x | 1.125x |
| NOI 15% below plan | 1.0625x | 1.0625x |
| NOI 20% below plan (break-even) | 1.00x | 1.00x |
| Rate 2.00 points higher, NOI at plan | 1.03x (debt service $289,664) | 1.03x (debt service $772,438) |
What rents must cover. Case A needs $299,386 of net operating income for 1.25x coverage, or $1,039.54 per unit per month; Case B needs $798,363, or $1,108.84 per unit per month. Gross rent must also pay operating costs and absorb vacancy. At a 5% vacancy allowance and three illustrative operating-expense ratios:
| Operating expenses as share of collected revenue (illustrative) | Gross rent needed per unit per month, A | Gross rent needed per unit per month, B |
|---|---|---|
| 35% | $1,683.46 | $1,795.69 |
| 40% | $1,823.75 | $1,945.33 |
| 45% | $1,989.54 | $2,122.18 |
The loan per unit is $125,000 in Case A and $133,333 in Case B. The study's core test is whether the target households, at their incomes, can pay rents at that level, and whether converted Bill 9 units on Maui would undercut them. Where they cannot, the project needs more equity, subordinate public funds, or an employer master lease that fixes rent.
The stress table shows coverage at 1.00x if NOI falls 20%, and at 1.03x if a variable rate rises two points; long amortization makes rental debt more rate-sensitive than shorter business loans. For a Hawaii rental, the 20% NOI shock to model is a lease-up that runs slower than planned, a property tax or insurance increase, or a wave of competing Bill 9 conversions.
What a lender-grade multifamily housing feasibility study in Hawaii must prove
- Program eligibility: why the project is an eligible business use under B&I, confirmed with the state office, or why a housing program or other source fits better.
- Geographic eligibility with a dated USDA map determination, kept separate from housing-program maps.
- Target households and rents: renter households by income in the commuting shed, and rents they can pay.
- Employer anchoring: letters, master leases or allocation agreements with named employers.
- Competing supply, including pipeline projects and, on Maui, Bill 9 conversions in three scenarios.
- Construction cost and schedule, with an independent budget check where a construction-period guarantee is used (5001.205(e)(2)).
- Land tenure: fee simple or a ground lease running past maturity.
- Operating costs at Hawaii levels, including insurance, utilities and payroll benchmarked at $47,988.
- Equity and appraisal under 5001.105(d) and 5001.203.
- Coverage under stress: slow lease-up, cost increases and a two-point rate rise.
Risks and mitigants specific to Hawaii rental housing
- Program fit. B&I limits on residential uses (hub). Mitigant: early state-office consultation and a fallback capital stack.
- Bill 9 competition on Maui. Up to 6,208 units could enter the long-term market by 2031. Mitigant: scenario testing and unit mixes that differ from converted condominiums.
- Construction cost. Mitigant: fixed-price contracts and contingency in the budget.
- Land tenure. Mitigant: ground lease terms past maturity.
- Storms and insurance. Mitigant: hurricane-rated construction and current insurance quotes.
- Policy. The President's FY2027 budget would terminate B&I; FY2026 terms run under a continuing resolution to December 11, 2026 (hub). Mitigant: identify non-USDA sources early.
Process, documents and why housing studies are sent back
The sponsor provides site control or a ground lease, the development budget and contractor bids, unit mix and floor plans, the proposed rent schedule, employer letters or master lease terms, the capital stack with any public funds, and the lender's term sheet. Once the state office in Hilo agrees the project is eligible, the lender files the study with its application. Housing studies are returned when program eligibility is assumed rather than established, when rents come from mainland or urban comparables, when competing supply such as Bill 9 conversions is ignored, and when construction costs lack a contractor's support.
Program example
The hub names no USDA-guaranteed rental housing project in Hawaii. The nearest USDA housing activity it records is the memorandum of understanding with Hawaiʻi Community Lending to expand rural home lending through its $16 million revolving fund, a homeownership program, not rental finance, and not an engagement of this firm. For the program structure behind rural rental housing nationally, see the site's USDA multifamily and workforce housing feasibility study page.
Hiring a USDA multifamily housing feasibility study consultant in Hawaii
When the rule requires one. A new rental entity with a B&I guarantee above $1,000,000 must commission an independent study from a consultant the Agency accepts (5001.306(a)(3)(i)); smaller loans may draw the same request (5001.306(a)(3)(ii)). The first step is eligibility, not market work.
What the engagement includes. The cost page describes the five Part 5001 components, multi-year projections with sensitivity analysis, the market area and demand, competitive supply and capture, operator benchmarks, a management review, PDF, Word and Excel deliverables, two calls, one revision round and the acceptance guarantee; appraisals, environmental and engineering work, legal work and grant applications are separate engagements.
What the sponsor provides. Site, budget, rent, employer and capital stack documents, and the lender's credit format.
Timeline and fee. Hawaii work generally takes four to eight weeks on the hub's estimate. The site's multifamily page puts multifamily engagements at $12,000 to $18,500 or more over seven to nine weeks, depending on the capital stack; a market-rate B&I project with a simple stack may fall nearer the standard B&I band of $6,900 to $12,500 on the cost page. A multifamily housing feasibility study consultant should be engaged after the state office has given an initial view on eligibility and before the design is fixed.
How to start. Outline the site, unit count, target renters and any employer partner in the free consultation form at the end of the page; the firm states a 24-hour response.
Last updated 2026-11-08
USDA Feasibility, Inc.