How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
In 2023 this practice prepared a feasibility study for a fire and rescue station in Hereford, Texas, financed through a USDA Community Facilities (CF) direct loan in the under $5 million tier. USDA was the lender, and the study was prepared with capital and operating cost analysis. This page works through the questions that kind of study answers, using a modeled three-bay station with living quarters and public data for Hereford and Deaf Smith County.
A fire station is an unusual USDA credit. It earns almost nothing from the people it serves; the loan is repaid from property taxes. That moves the feasibility question away from market capture and toward three others: what the station will really cost to build, what it will cost to run once it is open, and whether the taxing unit's rate and tax base can carry both the operations and the debt for forty years without hitting its legal ceiling. The model below shows that the debt itself is the easy part. The staffing decision and the concentration of the tax roll are where a study earns its fee. Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
| Published record | Detail |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Community Facilities direct loan |
| Project | Fire and rescue station |
| Location | Hereford, Texas (Deaf Smith County, Southwest region) |
| Loan size tier | Under $5 million |
| Year | 2023 |
| Lender | USDA direct |
| Outcome | Prepared with capital and operating cost analysis |
Source: this site's engagement index [12]. The building program, budget, tax base, staffing and projections below are a model.
The engagement card on the index carried a longer summary. This page keeps what the regulations and data on file support, corrects what they contradict, and marks the rest as the card's own statement.
| Statement in the engagement card | Status on this page |
|---|---|
| Texas Emergency Services Districts (ESDs) are political subdivisions that may levy up to $0.10 per $100 of assessed value, which makes ad valorem tax the main debt service source and legal authority documentation a threshold requirement | Kept as the card's statement. The model uses the $0.10 ceiling as its legal limit test. The Texas statute and constitutional text were not read for this page |
| Texas ESD legal authority documentation was included in the study | Kept as the card's statement; CF direct applicants must show legal authority to borrow and pledge security [1] |
| Rural volunteer stations average 40 to 60 years old, are undersized for modern apparatus and do not meet ISO response-time standards | Kept as the card's general statement; no source in this site's data. The model does not depend on it |
| A station that improves the ISO class can reduce insurance premiums measurably | Kept in substance as a question the study tests. This page frames it as a break-even rather than a forecast, because no premium data are on file |
| Southwest commercial construction at $190 to $340 per square foot, fire stations at $300 to $500 for masonry or $150 to $250 for prefabricated steel (RSMeans/Gordian, Q1 2025) | Kept as the card's cited ranges, not verified here. The model's own assumptions sit inside them and are labelled |
| A 6,000 square foot three-bay station "ranges from $561,000 to $3M+" | Not used. The low end is inconsistent with the card's own ranges: 6,000 square feet at the lowest rate it quotes ($150) is $900,000 |
| Texas construction cost escalation of 3% to 6% a year | Kept as the card's statement; the model escalates at 4% a year and tests delay |
| CF direct "explicitly lists fire departments and public safety facilities as eligible under 7 CFR 1942.17(d)" | Kept in substance: CF finances essential community facilities, and the CF grant rule awards 10 points to public safety projects [2]. The exact wording of 1942.17(d) was not checked |
| "At under $5M, the CF Financial Feasibility Analysis tier applies" | Corrected. Analysis and examination-opinion tiers belong to CF guaranteed loans (5001.304) [3]. A CF direct loan needs a financial feasibility report by a qualified firm or individual (1942.17(h)(1)) [1]; loan size does not set the report type |
| Deliverables: capital cost documentation against Southwest RSMeans data, call volume analysis (incidents per 1,000 residents, response times), ISO rating impact, operating cost modeling under ESD tax revenue with 10-year tax base growth scenarios | Consistent with the published outcome. This page shows each in model form |
The question USDA needed answered
When USDA lends directly to a public body for a station, the State Office needs to know five things: that the borrower may legally build, borrow and pledge taxes; that the town is small enough for the program; that the facility is needed and sized for the area it serves; that the budget is complete; and that the taxes and other income pledged will cover operation and maintenance, the annual installment and the required reserve [1][15]. A fire district can answer the first two with documents. The last three need analysis.
The rule for that analysis is 1942.17(h)(1): every CF direct applicant provides a financial feasibility report by a qualified firm or individual. Where the facility's own revenue repays the loan and the project significantly affects the applicant's finances, or where Rural Development asks, the report must come from a preparer with no interest in the facility's management or construction [1][15]. A tax-supported station is not repaid from facility revenue, so the independence trigger is less automatic than for a hospital or a childcare center. In practice a new station with living quarters roughly doubles a small district's building costs and adds staff, which is the kind of effect on the applicant's finances the rule describes, and an independent preparer avoids the question.
| Financing route for a fire station | What must be submitted | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| CF direct loan (this engagement) | Financial feasibility report by a qualified firm or individual; independent preparer when facility revenue repays the loan and the project significantly affects the applicant's finances, or on request | 1942.17(h)(1) [1] |
| CF grant | Grant limited to the minimum needed for feasibility | 3570.61(d) [2] |
| CF guaranteed loan, loans secured by general obligation bonds or tax revenue | Financial feasibility analysis, which may be the lender's credit evaluation | 5001.304(a) [3][15] |
| CF guaranteed over $1,000,000 to a new entity or new activity | Independent feasibility study; the Agency sets the scope | 5001.304(a)(4)(i) [3][15] |
Eligibility and program fit
| Test | Rule | Hereford result |
|---|---|---|
| CF direct population limit | City or town of 20,000 or less under the latest decennial census | Eligible: 14,962 residents in the Census Bureau's April 2020 estimates base and 14,976 in July 2025 [5] |
| CF grant population tiers | Up to 75% at 5,000 or less, 55% at 12,000 or less, 35% at 20,000 or less, each with a service-area income test; a 15% tier at 90% of the state non-metro median income | Above 12,000, so 35% at most, and only if service-area median household income is below the higher of the poverty line or 80% of the state non-metro median [2] |
| Borrower | Public body, nonprofit with significant community ties, or tribe | A Texas taxing unit (ESD, city or county) is a public body [1] |
| Credit elsewhere | Applicant certifies it cannot get credit elsewhere at reasonable rates and terms | Documented in the application [1] |
| Facility type | Essential community facility; public safety earns 10 points in CF grant scoring | Fire and rescue station [2] |
| County setting | Non-metro proxy | Deaf Smith County is the Hereford, TX Micropolitan Statistical Area, which is non-metro in the OMB July 2023 delineation [7] |
Texas has many towns in the CF direct range. Of the state's 1,224 incorporated places in the Census file, 1,086 (88.7%) had 20,000 or fewer people in the April 2020 base [5]:
| Texas incorporated places, April 2020 base | Places | Residents, 2020 base | Residents, July 2025 | Places that lost population | CF program reach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5,000 or fewer | 867 | 1,237,903 | 1,402,778 | 213 | CF direct; grant up to 75% |
| 5,001 to 12,000 | 143 | 1,090,526 | 1,213,797 | 38 | CF direct; grant up to 55% |
| 12,001 to 20,000 (Hereford) | 76 | 1,198,965 | 1,456,056 | 16 | CF direct; grant up to 35% |
| 20,001 to 50,000 | 70 | 2,262,739 | 2,512,906 | 20 | CF guaranteed only |
| Over 50,000 | 68 | 15,331,040 | 16,248,628 | 9 | Outside CF and the 5001.3 rural area |
Source: Census Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [5]. The program tests use the decennial census count, which the estimates base approximates.
Hereford sits in the band where the program's most generous grant tiers have already fallen away. That shapes the capital stack: a town of 15,000 should plan the station on a loan and its own cash, and treat any CF grant as a reduction to be earned through the income test, not a planning assumption.
Project description (modeled)
The model is a replacement station on a new site: three drive-through apparatus bays, a support zone sized for modern contamination control, living quarters that allow a crew to stay on shift, and a training room the community can use. It is larger than the 6,000 square foot volunteer configuration the engagement card describes, because the living quarters are what change the station's operating budget and the study's conclusion.
Modeled building program
| Space | Square feet | Assumed hard cost per square foot | Building cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apparatus bays: three drive-through bays, about 20 by 70 feet | 4,200 | $285 (range $230 to $340) | $1,197,000 |
| Apparatus support: decontamination, turnout gear, SCBA, workshop, hose and storage | 1,200 | $330 (range $280 to $390) | $396,000 |
| Living quarters: six bunk rooms, kitchen and day room, fitness, restrooms and showers | 2,000 | $360 (range $300 to $430) | $720,000 |
| Administration and training: offices, watch room, training room for about 40 | 1,200 | $340 (range $290 to $400) | $408,000 |
| Total building | 8,600 | $316 blended | $2,721,000 |
The bays are priced as pre-engineered steel with a masonry base, which is why their rate is lower than the occupied rooms. The blended $316 a square foot sits inside the card's Southwest commercial range and near the low end of its masonry fire station range; that is a modeling choice, not a benchmark.
Modeled schedule
| Phase | Months from engagement | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Feasibility study and preapplication | 0 to 3 | Study, legal authority opinion, preapplication to the area office |
| Design development and environmental review | 3 to 9 | Architect's estimate; environmental review under 7 CFR part 1970 |
| Letter of conditions and bidding | 9 to 12 | Rate tier, reserve and conditions set; bids opened |
| Construction | 12 to 26 | Fourteen-month build with interim financing |
| Opening and Year 1 of operations | 26 to 38 | Crew moves in; old station closed or sold |
Project cost and sources and uses
Every line is an assumption. A real budget comes from the architect's estimate, the civil engineer, vendor quotes for the fixed equipment, the appraisal of the site and, at the end, the bids.
Modeled project budget
| Line item | Amount | Basis (all assumptions) | How a real study sources it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Building (8,600 sq ft) | $2,721,000 | Per-square-foot assumptions above | Architect's estimate, then bids |
| Site work: concrete apron and drive, parking, utilities, storm detention, fencing, lighting | $410,000 | Assumed; range $300,000 to $550,000 | Civil engineer's estimate |
| Vehicle exhaust capture system | $85,000 | Assumed equipment allowance | Vendor quotes |
| Turnout gear extractor and dryer | $28,000 | Assumed equipment allowance | Vendor quotes |
| SCBA air compressor and fill station | $72,000 | Assumed equipment allowance | Vendor quotes |
| Station alerting system | $45,000 | Assumed equipment allowance | Vendor quotes |
| Standby generator and automatic transfer switch | $95,000 | Assumed equipment allowance | Vendor quotes |
| Furniture, IT, radio and dispatch interface | $110,000 | Assumed allowance | Vendor quotes |
| Construction subtotal | $3,566,000 | ||
| Escalation to bid date | $142,640 | 4.0% for one year, inside the card's 3% to 6% | Cost consultant |
| Construction contingency | $259,605 | 7.0% of construction plus escalation | Design stage sets the percentage |
| Hard cost total | $3,968,245 | ||
| Architecture and engineering, design and construction administration | $278,148 | 7.5% of construction plus escalation | Qualifications-based contract |
| Geotechnical, survey, materials testing | $38,000 | Assumed | Proposals |
| Environmental review documentation (7 CFR part 1970) | $18,000 | Assumed | Environmental consultant |
| Legal, bond counsel, legal authority opinion | $40,000 | Assumed | Counsel's engagement letter |
| Financial feasibility report | $9,500 | Inside this site's published CF fee range of $6,900 to $12,000; not this engagement's fee | Fixed-fee proposal |
| Builder's risk insurance and miscellaneous | $15,000 | Assumed | Broker quote |
| Soft cost total | $398,648 | ||
| Land, 2.5 acres | $80,000 | $32,000 per acre, assumed | Appraisal |
| Interest during construction | $151,203 | 14-month build, 55% average draw, 5.75% interim rate | Interim lender term sheet |
| Total project cost | $4,598,095 |
Modeled sources of funds (base case, no grant)
| Source | Amount | Share | Terms |
|---|---|---|---|
| USDA Community Facilities direct loan | $4,098,000 | 89.1% | 40 years at an illustrative 4.75% |
| Sponsor cash from fund balance | $500,095 | 10.9% | Deposited before loan funds |
| Total sources | $4,598,095 | 100.0% |
Modeled uses of funds
| Use | Amount | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Hard costs, including contingency | $3,968,245 | 86.3% |
| Soft costs | $398,648 | 8.7% |
| Land | $80,000 | 1.7% |
| Interest during construction | $151,203 | 3.3% |
| Total uses | $4,598,095 | 100.0% |
The modeled loan of $4,098,000 sits inside the published tier with about $900,000 of room, which matters because the overrun cases below use some of it. Interest during construction is an eligible CF direct cost until the facility is self-supporting, for up to three years (1942.17(d)(1)(iv)) [1][15]; for a tax-supported station that means the construction period. The model carries no initial operating expenses, which CF direct can also finance for up to a year, because the district already operates and collects taxes.
There is no fixed equity percentage in the CF direct sections this site has read. The sponsor's $500,095 is a modeling choice that does three jobs: it shows the State Office that the district has fund balance and can bid without waiting for loan funds, it covers costs that arrive before closing, and it keeps the loan under the tier with room for overruns. Applicant funds go in before loan funds at closing [1][15].
Building cost per square foot: what the range does to the budget
| Case | Building cost | Construction subtotal | Cost per sq ft of building |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low end of each range | $2,250,000 | $2,985,000 | $262 |
| Model | $2,721,000 | $3,566,000 | $316 |
| High end of each range | $3,236,000 | $4,221,000 | $376 |
The difference between the low and high ends is $1,236,000 of construction cost on the same 8,600 square feet. That spread is why a study does not stop at a published range: the architect's estimate at design development, checked against recent Panhandle public bids, is the figure the State Office will rely on, and the contingency should shrink only as the design firms up.
Market analysis: the service area and its demand
A station's "market" is the population, property and risk it protects. The study measures three things: how many people and structures depend on the station now and over the loan term, how much demand they generate, and what the tax base that pays for it consists of.
Population and trend
Deaf Smith County had 18,626 residents in July 2025, against 18,592 in the April 2020 base, a gain of 0.2% [6]. Hereford holds 14,976 of them, about 80% [5]. The county's stability comes from a balance of forces: births exceeded deaths by 739 and net international migration added 365, while net domestic migration took away 1,051 [6]. A study treats that as a stable base with an outflow of residents that new jobs have to keep offsetting.
Regional comparison: the Texas Panhandle around Hereford
| County | County seat | OMB 2023 status | April 2020 base | July 2025 | Change | Births less deaths | Net international | Net domestic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Deaf Smith | Hereford | Non-metro | 18,592 | 18,626 | +0.2% | +739 | +365 | -1,051 |
| Parmer | Farwell | Non-metro | 9,874 | 9,678 | -2.0% | +310 | +341 | -855 |
| Castro | Dimmitt | Non-metro | 7,363 | 7,295 | -0.9% | +110 | +285 | -470 |
| Swisher | Tulia | Non-metro | 6,973 | 6,703 | -3.9% | -112 | +86 | -237 |
| Oldham | Vega | Metro | 1,759 | 1,783 | +1.4% | +6 | +47 | -28 |
| Hartley | Channing | Non-metro | 5,363 | 4,904 | -8.6% | +108 | +18 | -598 |
| Dallam | Dalhart | Non-metro | 7,135 | 7,508 | +5.2% | +575 | +625 | -837 |
| Potter | Amarillo | Metro | 118,622 | 114,453 | -3.5% | +704 | +2,828 | -7,736 |
| Randall | Canyon | Metro | 140,670 | 152,351 | +8.3% | +1,695 | +1,037 | +8,967 |
Sources: Census Vintage 2025 county estimates (components summed from April 2020 to July 2025) [6]; OMB July 2023 delineation [7].
Deaf Smith County held its population while most non-metro neighbours lost people, and every non-metro county in the table except Swisher grew naturally. Texas as a whole grew 8.8% over the same period, and its 168 non-metro counties grew 3.4% in total, so Deaf Smith is stable rather than growing [6]. For a forty-year loan that is the right base case: a station sized for today's population plus modest growth, with no expansion premium built into the budget.
Service-area population scenarios (Deaf Smith County)
| Scenario | 2035 | 2065 (end of a 40-year loan) |
|---|---|---|
| Decline, -0.5% a year | 17,715 | 15,242 |
| Observed 2020 to 2025 trend, +0.03% a year | 18,691 | 18,887 |
| Growth, +1.0% a year | 20,575 | 27,732 |
Even the decline case leaves more than 15,000 people in the county at the end of the loan. Population is not the station's credit risk; the tax base and the operating budget are.
Incident volume at assumed rates
No incident data are on file, so the model brackets demand with assumed incident rates. A real study replaces this table with the department's own incident records by type, hour and location, and with the dispatch center's response times.
| Incidents per 1,000 residents a year (assumed) | Incidents a year, 2025 population | Per day | With 10% growth in call demand |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60 per 1,000 | 1,118 | 3.1 | 1,229 |
| 85 per 1,000 | 1,583 | 4.3 | 1,742 |
| 110 per 1,000 | 2,049 | 5.6 | 2,254 |
At three to six incidents a day, a district is busy enough that response from home becomes the weak point for a volunteer roster during working hours. That is the operational case for living quarters and a duty crew, and it is also the most expensive decision in the model. The study's response-time work maps where incidents occur against drive times from the existing and proposed sites, because a station moved a mile toward the highway or the industrial area can shorten response to the calls that matter most while lengthening it elsewhere.
What the station protects: the county's economic base
| Deaf Smith County, 2023 | Establishments | Employees | Annual payroll |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing (all) | 22 | 2,631 | $142,982,000 |
| of which food manufacturing | 10 | 2,480 | $133,689,000 |
| Electric power generation and distribution | 3 | 72 | $6,563,000 |
| Gasoline stations with convenience stores | 10 | 88 | $2,040,000 |
| Full-service and limited-service restaurants | 21 | 351 | $7,459,000 |
| Hotels and motels | 5 | 48 | $1,111,000 |
Source: Census County Business Patterns 2023, private establishments with paid employees [8]. Government fire departments are not counted in this survey.
Ten food plants employ 2,480 people, 94% of the county's manufacturing jobs and the equivalent of 13% of its residents. Two consequences follow for the study. On the risk side, large food processing and refrigerated storage buildings bring hazards a residential volunteer company does not train for every week, which supports the decontamination room, the training room and a hazardous materials plan. On the credit side, a tax roll anchored by a few industrial properties is concentrated: if one of them closes, appeals its value or wins an abatement, the district's levy has to rise for everyone else. The model's sharpest stress case comes from this table.
USDA Community Facilities activity in Texas
USAspending lists 37 Community Facilities grants and 3 Community Facilities loans with a Texas place of performance in fiscal 2024 to 2026 (Assistance Listing 10.766) [9]. The count may be incomplete, and it does not separate public safety from other facility types. For a sponsor the signal is that CF direct money in Texas is competitive and that a complete, well-supported file moves faster than a thin one.
Financial feasibility
The model's question is simple to state: at a tax rate the district can legally levy, does income cover operations, the CF direct installment and the reserve, with room to absorb a bad year? CF direct asks for evidence that taxes and other income cover operation and maintenance, debt payments and reserves [1][15]. "Coverage" for a tax-supported borrower means net revenue after operations divided by the installment; the more useful number is the levy the district needs against its ceiling.
Inputs (all assumptions)
- Net taxable value of $2.2 billion in Year 1, growing 2% a year, collected at 97.5%. A real study uses the appraisal district's certified roll, its ten largest taxpayers and five years of history.
- An adopted tax rate of $0.096 per $100, held flat for five years, inside the $0.10 ceiling the engagement card describes.
- Existing fire and rescue operations of $1,380,000 in Year 1, rising 3% a year; other revenue (interlocal contracts, fees, small grants) of $85,000, rising 2% a year.
- Three added firefighter positions, one per shift, at $72,000 each including benefits.
- CF direct loan of $4,098,000 at an illustrative 4.75% over 40 years with level annual installments, and a reserve deposit of one tenth of an installment a year [1][15]. Rural Development sets CF direct rates at least quarterly; 4.75% is close to the rate this site's other case studies use for late 2026.
Year 1 operating budget build (assumptions)
| Item | Year 1 |
|---|---|
| Existing operations budget (personnel, volunteer stipends, apparatus maintenance and fuel, insurance, training, PPE, apparatus replacement fund, appraisal and collection fees) | $1,380,000 |
| New station utilities ($4.25 per sq ft) | $36,550 |
| New station building maintenance (1.0% of building cost) | $27,210 |
| New station property insurance (0.35% of building and site cost) | $10,958 |
| Less: old station utilities and maintenance no longer paid | -$18,000 |
| Three added firefighter positions, one per shift ($72,000 each, loaded) | $216,000 |
| Year 1 operating expenses | $1,652,718 |
Five-year pro forma (modeled)
| Line | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net taxable value (assumed $2.2 billion, +2% a year) | $2,200,000,000 | $2,244,000,000 | $2,288,880,000 | $2,334,657,600 | $2,381,350,752 |
| Tax levy at $0.096 per $100, 97.5% collected | $2,059,200 | $2,100,384 | $2,142,392 | $2,185,240 | $2,228,944 |
| Other revenue: interlocal contracts, fees, grants | $85,000 | $86,700 | $88,434 | $90,203 | $92,007 |
| Total revenue | $2,144,200 | $2,187,084 | $2,230,826 | $2,275,442 | $2,320,951 |
| Existing fire and rescue operations (+3% a year) | $1,380,000 | $1,421,400 | $1,464,042 | $1,507,963 | $1,553,202 |
| New station building operations, net of old station savings | $56,718 | $58,420 | $60,173 | $61,978 | $63,837 |
| Added staffing: three firefighter positions | $216,000 | $222,480 | $229,154 | $236,029 | $243,110 |
| Operating expenses | $1,652,718 | $1,702,300 | $1,753,369 | $1,805,970 | $1,860,149 |
| Net revenue available for debt service | $491,482 | $484,784 | $477,457 | $469,472 | $460,802 |
| CF direct loan installment | $230,704 | $230,704 | $230,704 | $230,704 | $230,704 |
| Debt service coverage | 2.13x | 2.10x | 2.07x | 2.03x | 2.00x |
| Reserve deposit (one tenth of an installment) | $23,070 | $23,070 | $23,070 | $23,070 | $23,070 |
| Surplus after debt service and reserve | $237,707 | $231,009 | $223,682 | $215,698 | $207,027 |
| Levy rate needed to break even (per $100) | $0.0849 | $0.0854 | $0.0860 | $0.0865 | $0.0871 |
| of which debt service and reserve (per $100) | $0.0118 | $0.0116 | $0.0114 | $0.0111 | $0.0109 |
Three readings matter. First, the debt is small against the base: the installment and reserve need about 1.2 cents per $100 of value, or $19.52 a year on a $165,000 home. Second, coverage falls slowly every year even with a growing roll, because operating costs grow at 3% and the rate is held flat; a district that never revisits its rate drifts toward its ceiling. Third, the break-even levy rises from $0.0849 to $0.0871 over five years, which leaves headroom of $0.0151 per $100 in Year 1 and $0.0129 in Year 5 under a $0.10 ceiling. That headroom, not the 2.13x coverage, is the number to watch.
Break-even
At the adopted rate of $0.096, the district covers operations and the installment as long as taxable value stays above about $1.92 billion in Year 1, and operations, installment and reserve above about $1.95 billion. That is a cushion of 12.7% and 11.5% against the assumed $2.2 billion roll. A study presents the cushion next to the share of the roll held by the largest taxpayers: if the top five properties hold more than 12%, the loss of a few of them is a break-even event at today's rate.
Interest rate and term sensitivity
| Rate | Term (years) | Annual installment | Debt levy incl. reserve, per $100, Year 1 value | Annual cost on a $165,000 home |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.75% | 30 | $229,847 | $0.0118 | $19.45 |
| 3.75% | 40 | $199,406 | $0.0102 | $16.87 |
| 4.75% | 30 | $259,032 | $0.0133 | $21.92 |
| 4.75% (model) | 40 | $230,704 | $0.0118 | $19.52 |
| 5.75% | 30 | $289,795 | $0.0149 | $24.52 |
| 5.75% | 40 | $263,825 | $0.0135 | $22.32 |
| 6.75% (prime farmland surcharge case) | 30 | $321,989 | $0.0165 | $27.25 |
| 6.75% (prime farmland surcharge case) | 40 | $298,504 | $0.0153 | $25.26 |
The CF direct term runs to the facility's useful life, the state statute or 40 years, whichever is shortest [1][15]. If the processing office weights the useful life down because the fixed equipment wears out sooner than the building, the 30-year rows apply. The last two rows matter in an irrigated county: this site's reading of 1942.17(f) is that a project that uses or builds on prime or unique farmland pays two percentage points more [15]. A site inside town avoids that cost; a greenfield parcel at the edge of town may not.
Cost overrun and delay, financed with added loan funds
| Case | Added cost | Loan | Installment | Coverage Year 1 | Coverage Year 3 | Break-even levy Year 1 (per $100) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model | $0 | $4,098,000 | $230,704 | 2.13x | 2.07x | $0.0849 |
| Hard cost overrun +10% | $396,824 | $4,494,824 | $253,044 | 1.94x | 1.89x | $0.0861 |
| Hard cost overrun +20% | $793,649 | $4,891,649 | $275,384 | 1.78x | 1.73x | $0.0872 |
| Bid delay of 6 months (escalation plus carry) | $111,765 | $4,209,765 | $236,996 | 2.07x | 2.01x | $0.0852 |
| Bid delay of 12 months (escalation plus carry) | $223,529 | $4,321,529 | $243,288 | 2.02x | 1.96x | $0.0856 |
Overruns hurt the tier before they hurt the budget. A 20% overrun financed with loan funds pushes the loan to about $4.89 million, close to the $5 million line, and leaves no room for a second surprise. The coverage effect is modest because the debt is a small share of the district's spending. The practical mitigant is design: a bid alternate list (training room finishes, a fourth bay rough-in, the generator size) that can be taken out if bids come in high.
Tax base scenarios at the adopted rate
| Scenario | Year 5 taxable value | Coverage Year 1 | Coverage Year 5 | Break-even levy Year 5 (per $100) | Headroom under a $0.10 cap |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model: +2% a year | $2,381,350,752 | 2.13x | 2.00x | $0.0871 | $0.0129 |
| Flat roll: 0% a year | $2,200,000,000 | 2.13x | 1.26x | $0.0943 | $0.0057 |
| Strong: +4% a year | $2,573,688,832 | 2.13x | 2.78x | $0.0806 | $0.0194 |
| Top taxpayer leaves in Year 2: -10%, then +1% | $2,060,395,940 | 2.13x | 0.70x | $0.1006 | -$0.0006 |
| Ag and industrial downturn: -15% in Year 2, then 0% | $1,870,000,000 | 2.13x | below zero | $0.1109 | -$0.0109 |
This is the table that decides the file. With a flat roll the district still covers its debt in Year 5, but its headroom shrinks to about half a cent. If a taxpayer holding 10% of the roll leaves, the break-even rate passes the $0.10 ceiling by Year 5, and in a broader downturn the district cannot fund its operating budget at the adopted rate at all. The debt is never the cause; operating costs growing faster than the roll are. A State Office will want to see what the district would cut, and in what order, before it reaches the ceiling.
Staffing decision: the larger cost driver
| Staffing plan | Year 1 operating expenses | Coverage at adopted rate | Break-even levy (per $100) | Headroom under a $0.10 cap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Volunteer and current staff only (no added positions) | $1,436,718 | 3.07x | $0.0748 | $0.0252 |
| Model: three added positions | $1,652,718 | 2.13x | $0.0849 | $0.0151 |
| Six added positions (two per shift) | $1,868,718 | 1.19x | $0.0950 | $0.0050 |
Three firefighter positions cost $216,000 a year, almost as much as the CF direct installment. Six positions cost nearly twice the installment and leave half a cent of headroom. That is the real finding of a capital and operating cost study for a rural station: the building is a forty-year decision financed at a low rate, but the crew that the living quarters invite is a recurring cost the tax base has to carry from the first year. A study that prices the building and not the staffing plan answers the wrong question.
Combined stress case
| Stress | Setting |
|---|---|
| Hard cost overrun | +15%, financed |
| Rate | 5.75% instead of 4.75% |
| Tax base | -10% in Year 2, then flat |
| Existing operations | +5% above plan |
| Result: loan | $4,693,237 |
| Coverage Year 1 / Year 5 | 1.40x / 0.02x |
| Break-even levy Year 5 (per $100) | $0.1128 |
| Headroom under a $0.10 cap | -$0.0128 |
Under combined stress the district's plan fails by Year 5 at the adopted rate, and the rate it would need is above the ceiling. The mitigants are operating ones: phase the third position in only when the roll supports it, keep the volunteer roster as the base, negotiate interlocal contracts that pay for service outside the district, and hold the apparatus replacement contribution flexible for a year. A study that shows those levers, with their dollar effect, gives the State Office a reason to approve rather than a reason to wait.
CF grant scenarios (only if the income test is met)
| Scenario | Grant | Loan | Installment | Debt levy incl. reserve, per $100 | Annual cost on a $165,000 home |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No grant (model) | $0 | $4,098,000 | $230,704 | $0.0118 | $19.52 |
| 15% grant tier | $689,714 | $3,408,000 | $191,859 | $0.0098 | $16.23 |
| 35% grant tier (most a town of 12,001 to 20,000 can receive) | $1,609,333 | $2,489,000 | $140,123 | $0.0072 | $11.86 |
A grant lowers the levy by between 0.2 and 0.5 cents per $100. The rule limits a CF grant to the minimum needed for feasibility (3570.61(d)) [2], and the base case is feasible without one, so a sponsor should expect the State Office to ask why a grant is needed. The honest answer, if there is one, lies in the stress cases: a district whose roll is concentrated and whose headroom disappears under a plausible loss can show that a grant protects operations. The income test still comes first, and service-area median household income is not in this site's data.
Same loan, two USDA routes
| Route | Rate and term (illustrative) | Annual debt service | Up-front guarantee fee (80% x 1.25%) | Retention fee, Year 1 (80% x 0.50%) | Coverage Year 1 at the adopted rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CF direct (model) | 4.75%, 40 years | $230,704 | none | none | 2.13x |
| CF guaranteed bank loan (illustrative) | 7.50%, 25 years | $367,634 | $40,980 | $16,392 | 1.34x |
A CF guarantee is available to a public body in a town of this size, with an 80% guarantee, a 1.25% fee and a 0.50% annual retention fee in fiscal 2026 [3][4]. On the same loan it costs about $137,000 a year more than the modeled direct loan, and USDA cannot guarantee tax-exempt debt [3][15], so the bank loan would be taxable. For a taxing unit that can also issue tax-exempt bonds or notes, the credit elsewhere certification is a real test: the study's comparison of routes is part of the evidence that the district cannot borrow on reasonable terms without CF direct [1].
The ISO question, framed as a break-even (illustrative)
| Assumed annual homeowner premium | Debt and reserve levy on a $165,000 home | Premium reduction that would offset it |
|---|---|---|
| $1,800 | $19.52 | 1.08% |
| $2,600 | $19.52 | 0.75% |
| $3,400 | $19.52 | 0.57% |
The engagement card describes an ISO rating impact analysis. No rule asks for one, and no premium data are on file here, so this page does not forecast a class change or a premium saving. It asks the narrower question a governing body can use: how large a premium reduction would offset the debt portion of the tax for a typical home? On these assumptions the answer is well under 1.1%. A study that obtains the current class, the deficiency points that drive it and local premium data can say whether the new station is likely to close that gap; this page cannot.
Technical and environmental feasibility
- Site. The study tests drive time from the candidate sites to the incident pattern, access to the highway and the industrial area, apron depth for apparatus, and room for a fourth bay. It also checks whether the parcel is prime or unique farmland, which would raise the CF direct rate under this site's reading of 1942.17(f) [15].
- Building systems. A station runs around the clock with diesel apparatus inside, so exhaust capture, separation of contaminated gear from living space, and standby power are part of the program, not finishes. The model carries each as its own line.
- Hazards in the district. With ten food plants employing 2,480 people [8], the training room and the decontamination area support a hazardous materials and industrial response plan; the study notes what the industrial employers contribute through mutual aid or contracts.
- Environmental review. USDA completes an environmental review under 7 CFR part 1970 before it commits, and construction obligations entered before approval can make costs ineligible (1942.17(d)(1)(v)) [1][15].
- Design and procurement. The architect's estimate at design development replaces the model's per-square-foot rates, and the bid documents carry alternates so the project can be brought back to budget without redesign.
Management and governance feasibility
A tax-supported station is managed by two bodies: the governing board that sets the rate and adopts the budget, and the chief who runs the department. The study reads both. On the board side it looks for audited statements, an adopted budget process that has kept within the levy limit, a fund balance policy, and the legal authority opinion that confirms the district can borrow and pledge its taxes [1]. On the department side it looks for a staffing plan with recruitment evidence, a volunteer retention record, training and certification status, apparatus replacement planning, and the interlocal agreements with the city, the county and neighbouring departments that define who answers which call and who pays. Continuity across board elections matters for a forty-year loan; a written capital and staffing plan adopted by resolution is the usual answer.
Process and documents
| Step | What happens | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Preapplication | Filed with the area office; review notice within 45 days | 1942.2 [1][15] |
| Feasibility and design | Financial feasibility report, preliminary architectural report, environmental review | 1942.17(h) [1][15] |
| Public steps | Public information meeting with ten days' notice where no vote is required | 1942.17(j) [1][15] |
| Letter of conditions | Sets loan amount, rate tier, reserve and conditions | 1942.17 [1] |
| Closing | Applicant funds deposited before loan funds | 1942.17(n) [1][15] |
Texas applications go to the USDA Rural Development state office in Temple [11]. Documents the State Office will look for: the legal authority opinion and organizational documents; three years of audits and the adopted budget; the certified appraisal roll with its largest taxpayers; incident and response-time records; the architect's program and estimate; the staffing plan; interlocal agreements; and the governing body's resolutions. This site's Community Facilities page lists studies at $6,900 to $12,000 and 6 to 8 weeks [10].
Economic and community impact (modeled)
| Measure | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Construction spending (hard costs) | $3,968,245 | Budget above |
| Construction labor share (assumed 35%) | $1,388,886 | Assumption |
| On-site job-years at $68,000 loaded per year (assumed) | 20 | Arithmetic, not a multiplier model |
| Permanent positions added | 3 | Model staffing plan |
| Residents in the county service area, 2025 | 18,626 | Census Vintage 2025 [6] |
| Manufacturing employees in Deaf Smith County, 2023 (of which food manufacturing) | 2,631 (2,480) | Census CBP 2023 [8] |
| Taxable value protected (assumed) | $2,200,000,000 | Assumption; appraisal district roll in a real study |
The impact a State Office reads first is coverage of people and property: a station with a duty crew changes response for the 14,976 people in Hereford and the 3,650 elsewhere in the county [5], and for the food plants whose 2,480 jobs equal 13% of the county's population. Construction adds about 20 job-years on site; the three positions are permanent.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | How it shows up in the model | Mitigant the study tests |
|---|---|---|
| Tax roll concentration | Loss of 10% of value pushes the break-even rate above $0.10 by Year 5 | Top-taxpayer analysis; abatement and appeal history; reserve policy |
| Staffing cost growth | Six positions leave $0.0050 of headroom | Phase positions to the roll; keep volunteer base; interlocal contracts |
| Construction cost | +20% overrun takes the loan to about $4.89 million | Design-development estimate; bid alternates; 7% contingency held to bid |
| Bid delay | 12 months adds about $224,000 | Early environmental review; ready-to-bid documents |
| Rate tier and farmland | 6.75% instead of 4.75% adds $67,800 a year | Site inside town; confirm tier with the State Office |
| Legal ceiling and levy rules | Plan relies on holding $0.096 | Legal authority opinion; levy history; counsel's read of Texas limits |
| Population decline | -0.5% a year still leaves 15,242 people in 2065 | Size the station to today's demand, rough-in for growth |
| Grant uncertainty | Grant not needed in the base case | Plan without it; use the stress cases if requesting one |
What the five Part 5001 components showed
A CF direct file is governed by part 1942, but this site organizes the financial feasibility report around the five components it uses for every USDA study:
| Component | What the model shows | What a reviewer still asks |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Stable county of 18,626; ten food plants with 2,480 jobs | Top taxpayers' share of the roll and their outlook |
| Market and need | 1,118 to 2,049 incidents a year at assumed rates | Actual incident and response-time records by location |
| Technical | 8,600 square feet, three bays, living quarters, exhaust and decontamination | Architect's estimate; site and farmland status |
| Financial | Debt levy about 1.2 cents per $100; Year 1 headroom $0.0151 under $0.10 | Certified roll; adopted rate history; staffing phasing |
| Management | Board budget process and chief's staffing plan | Audits, fund balance policy, interlocal agreements |
Why fire station studies are sent back
- The budget prices the building but leaves out the fixed equipment, the apron, the generator or interest during construction.
- The operating budget ignores the staffing that living quarters invite.
- The tax base is projected from a growth rate, not from the certified roll and its largest taxpayers.
- Coverage is reported without the levy ceiling, so the reviewer cannot see headroom.
- A CF grant is counted before the income test is confirmed, or requested when the base case is already feasible.
- The legal authority opinion does not cover the specific pledge the loan relies on.
- The site turns out to be prime farmland after the rate tier was assumed.
Program terms that applied
| Term | CF direct rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Population limit | City or town of 20,000 or less under the latest decennial census | 1942.17 [1] |
| Borrower | Public body, nonprofit with significant community ties, or tribe; credit elsewhere certification | 1942.17 [1] |
| Interest rate | Poverty (not more than 5%), intermediate (not more than 7%) or market (Bond Buyer index); set at least quarterly; lower of approval or closing on request | 1942.17(f) [1][15] |
| Farmland | Two percentage points more on prime or unique farmland (this site's reading) | 1942.17(f) [15] |
| Term | Useful life, state statute or 40 years, whichever is less; principal deferral up to 36 months | 1942.17(f)(7) [1][15] |
| Construction interest | Eligible until self-supporting, up to three years | 1942.17(d)(1)(iv) [1][15] |
| Reserve | One average installment, built at one tenth a year | 1942.17(i)(2) [1][15] |
| Feasibility evidence | Financial feasibility report by a qualified firm or individual | 1942.17(h)(1) [1] |
| Guarantee and fees | None; USDA is the lender | |
| CF grant | Up to 35% at this population if the income test is met; minimum needed for feasibility; public safety earns 10 scoring points | 3570.53, 3570.61, 3570.63 [2] |
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Price the crew before the building. In this model three positions cost almost as much a year as the loan; six cost nearly twice as much.
- Read the roll, not a growth rate. The certified roll and its largest taxpayers decide headroom. A study without them is guessing.
- Report headroom under the ceiling. Coverage of 2.13 times looks safe; a cent and a half of headroom is the honest measure.
- Keep the site in town. It shortens response to most calls and avoids the farmland rate penalty.
- Hold room in the tier. A loan near $4.1 million leaves space for an overrun; a loan at $4.9 million does not.
- Treat the grant as a stress answer. In a town of 15,000 the grant is 35% at most and only with the income test; the case for it is in the downside, not the base.
Related pages
- The CF direct engagement page lists this program's engagements, including this one.
- The Community Facilities feasibility study page explains the program's direct, guaranteed and grant tracks and the public safety facility category [10], and the Community Facilities program article gives the background.
- The Texas state page carries the state office in Temple, Texas precedents and the state's project guides [11].
- The case studies page lists the site's long-form work, including the rural hospital case study for Community Facilities.
- The USDA rural definition article explains why the CF population line differs from B&I, and USDA funding deadlines shows the lead time a CF filing needs.
- The USDA Feasibility Study Framework and the cost and timeline page set out the method and fees [13].
If you are planning a station, a public safety building or another tax-supported community facility and need a USDA feasibility study consultant, the engagement index describes the process: a fifteen-minute scoping call, a written proposal inside one business day and a firm fixed fee before you sign [12]. Request a proposal for your study [14].
Data current as of November 2026.
USDA Feasibility, Inc.