How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
In 2023 this practice prepared a feasibility study for sewer collection rehabilitation in Wahpeton, North Dakota, under the USDA Water and Waste Disposal (WWD) program in the under $5 million tier. USDA was the lender, and the study was prepared with system condition and cost analysis. This page works through the questions that kind of study answers, using a modeled 48-mile gravity sewer system, a modeled utility of 4,090 equivalent dwelling units (EDUs) and public data for Wahpeton and Richland County.
Collection system rehabilitation is the least visible WWD project and often the hardest to prioritize. Nothing new gets built, the pipes are underground, and the benefits arrive as things that stop happening: fewer collapses, fewer basement backups, less groundwater pumped and treated, fewer overflows in a wet spring. The engineer's camera inspection, smoke testing and flow monitoring describe the system's condition, and they belong to the preliminary engineering report (PER), which this practice does not prepare. The condition and cost analysis turns those findings into decisions a council and Rural Development can act on: which pipes to fix first, by which method, what that costs against doing nothing, how fast the rest of the system should follow, and what it does to the sewer bill. Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
| Published record | Detail |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Water and Waste Disposal direct loan and grant (filed under WEP on the engagement index) |
| Project | Sewer collection system rehabilitation |
| Location | Wahpeton, North Dakota (Richland County, Great Plains region) |
| Loan size tier | Under $5 million |
| Year | 2023 |
| Lender | USDA direct |
| Outcome | Prepared with system condition and cost analysis |
Source: this site's engagement index [11]. The system inventory, condition grades, flows, budget, rates and projections below are a model, not the city's inspection results, rates or debt.
The engagement card on the index carried a longer summary. This page keeps what the regulations and data on file support, corrects what they contradict, and marks the rest as the card's own statement.
| Statement in the engagement card | Status on this page |
|---|---|
| North Dakota's "755,000 residents" | Corrected from the Census file: 779,136 in the April 2020 estimates base and 799,358 in July 2025 [4][5] |
| More than 350 municipal wastewater systems, most built in the 1960s and 1970s and now 50 to 60 years into roughly 50-year design lives | Kept as the card's statement; not checked. For scale, the Census file lists 355 incorporated places in the state [4], which is a count of towns, not of systems |
| ASCE grades North Dakota infrastructure C, with wastewater systems showing deterioration | Kept as the card's statement; not checked |
| The North Dakota State Water Commission approved $34 million for 23 water and wastewater projects in one 2025 cycle | Kept as the card's statement; not checked |
| EPA allocated $248,000 of Sewer Overflow and Stormwater Reuse Municipal Grant funding to North Dakota in 2023 | Kept as the card's statement; not checked |
| A national $69 billion annual wastewater funding gap and collection failures rising from 2.0 to 3.3 per 100 miles (ASCE 2025) | Kept as the card's statement; not checked |
| An under-$5 million rehabilitation "requires a Preliminary Engineering Report per RUS Bulletin 1780-7" with CCTV condition scoring, I/I in gallons per day per inch-diameter-mile, method selection and a 20-year cost-benefit analysis | Kept in substance: every WWD application needs a PER (1780.33(c)) [1], and the listed analyses are what a rehabilitation PER contains. The bulletin number was not checked, and the field work is the engineer's |
| Lining with cured-in-place pipe at about $25 to $50 per linear foot installed | Kept as the card's figure. The model assumes $50 to $95 a foot because it includes cleaning, bypass pumping and lateral reinstatement; a real study uses the engineer's estimate and bids |
| "USDA WEP grants are available for financially distressed small communities; North Dakota under-$5M sewer rehabilitation is a strong grant candidate" | Corrected. Project size does not decide a grant. Part 1780 sets the grant from service-area income and the debt service per EDU (1780.10, 1780.35(b)) [1]; the modeled project does not reach the threshold |
| Deliverables: a condition assessment, I/I quantification from smoke testing and flow monitoring, lining costs at North Dakota prevailing wages, and rate affordability under a grant and loan structure | Consistent with the published outcome. The inspection and flow monitoring are the engineer's field work; the cost and rate analysis is the study's. Prevailing wage rates were not read for this page |
The question USDA needed answered
Rural Development's tests for a rehabilitation project are the same as for a new plant, applied to a different kind of asset. The applicant must show economic feasibility: revenues covering operation and maintenance, reasonable reserves and debt payment (1780.7(f)), on realistic users (1780.39(c)(1)) [1]. The facility must be modest in size, design and cost and the most economical service practicable (1780.10(a)(1), 1780.57(n)) [1], which for rehabilitation means the study must show why the chosen method and scope beat the alternatives over time. And for an existing system, losses and inflow matter: the rule bars new combined storm and sanitary sewers (1780.10(a)(3)) and expects discharge facilities to meet effluent standards (1780.57(h)) [1], so the case for rehabilitation usually rests on infiltration and inflow (I/I) as well as structural failure.
| Document or task | Rule | Who prepares it | What it decides |
|---|---|---|---|
| Preliminary engineering report, with the CCTV, smoke testing and flow monitoring behind it | 1780.33(c), 1780.55 | The city's engineer, licensed in North Dakota (1780.54) | Condition grades, I/I sources, rehabilitation methods, cost estimate |
| Condition and cost analysis | 1780.10(a)(1), 1780.57(n) | Feasibility consultant, from the engineer's data | Priority of segments, life-cycle comparison of approaches, phasing |
| Environmental report | 1780.33(f), 1780.55 | Environmental professionals under 7 CFR part 1970 | Review before any action that limits alternatives |
| Operating budget and rate schedule | 1780.33(h)(1), 1780.35(c), 1780.39(c) | Applicant, with its feasibility consultant | Revenue covers O&M, reserves and all debt |
| Grant determination | 1780.35(b) | Processing office, from the applicant's numbers | Debt service share of income; similar system cost |
Eligibility and program fit
| Test | Rule | Wahpeton result |
|---|---|---|
| Rural area | Not in a city or town over 10,000 under the latest decennial census (1780.3) | Eligible: 8,013 residents in the April 2020 estimates base and 8,141 in July 2025 [4] |
| Applicant | Public body, community-controlled nonprofit or tribe (1780.7(a)) | A city is a public body |
| Credit elsewhere | Cannot finance on reasonable rates and terms (1780.7(d)) | Certified in the application |
| Design | Modest in size and cost; most economical service practicable (1780.10(a)(1), 1780.57(n)) | The present worth comparison below |
| Population durability | Will not decline below design population (1780.7(c)(1)) | Wahpeton grew 1.6% from 2020 to 2025 |
| County setting | Non-metro proxy | Richland County is part of the Wahpeton, ND-MN Micropolitan Statistical Area, which is non-metro in the OMB July 2023 delineation [6] |
WWD guaranteed loans under part 5001 carry a 90% guarantee, a 1.0% fee and no annual retention fee in fiscal 2026 [2][3]. For a rehabilitation program a city can phase, the direct program's 40-year term matters because lining has a long design life; the term may not exceed the useful life of the facility (1780.13(e)) [1], so the engineer's life estimate for each method belongs in the file.
North Dakota is almost entirely small places. Of the 355 incorporated places in the Census file, 346 (97.5%) had 10,000 or fewer residents in the April 2020 base [4]:
| North Dakota incorporated places, April 2020 base | Places | Residents, 2020 base | Residents, July 2025 | Places that lost population | WWD population priority points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1,000 or fewer | 306 | 68,244 | 67,708 | 205 | 25 |
| 1,001 to 2,500 | 30 | 47,071 | 46,352 | 20 | 15 |
| 2,501 to 5,500 | 6 | 19,993 | 23,721 | 3 | 5 |
| 5,501 to 10,000 (Wahpeton) | 4 | 28,133 | 28,282 | 1 | 0 |
| 10,001 to 50,000 | 6 | 181,887 | 184,624 | 2 | Outside the direct rural test |
| Over 50,000 | 3 | 258,749 | 274,603 | 0 | Outside the direct rural test |
Source: Census Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [4]; points from 1780.17(a) [1].
Two of every three of North Dakota's smallest towns lost population between 2020 and 2025, while Wahpeton grew. That is a quiet advantage for a forty-year loan: the user base is not shrinking under the debt.
Project description (modeled)
The model is a 48-mile gravity sewer system of 8- to 15-inch mains with about 950 manholes, mostly clay and concrete pipe. The engineer's camera inspection grades each segment on a five-level structural scale; Phase 1 rehabilitates every grade 4 and grade 5 segment, rehabilitates the manholes rated poor, and seals lateral connections in the lined segments. Grade 3 segments are left for two later phases.
Modeled condition of the gravity mains
| Structural grade | Share of footage | Linear feet | Miles |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grade 5: collapse, severe deformation or imminent failure | 3.5% | 8,870 | 1.7 |
| Grade 4: severe cracks, joint separation, heavy roots or infiltration | 8.0% | 20,275 | 3.8 |
| Grade 3: moderate defects | 17.0% | 43,085 | 8.2 |
| Grade 2: minor defects | 31.0% | 78,566 | 14.9 |
| Grade 1: no significant defects | 40.5% | 102,643 | 19.4 |
| Total gravity mains | 100.0% | 253,440 | 48.0 |
Modeled flows before and after Phase 1
| Flow component | Before | After Phase 1 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base sanitary flow (190 gallons a day per EDU) | 0.78 MGD | 0.78 MGD | none |
| Groundwater infiltration | 0.30 MGD | 0.20 MGD | -34% |
| Rain and snowmelt inflow, annual average | 0.17 MGD | 0.12 MGD | -30% |
| Annual average flow to the plant | 1.25 MGD | 1.09 MGD | -12% |
| Peak wet-weather flow | 5.6 MGD | 4.7 MGD | -16% |
| Infiltration per inch-diameter-mile (456 inch-diameter-miles) | 658 gpd | 436 gpd | |
| Peak to base sanitary ratio | 7.2 to 1 | 6.0 to 1 |
Flow monitoring and smoke testing tell the engineer where water enters the system; the model's assumption is that the worst 11.5% of footage carries 45% of the groundwater infiltration and that lining removes three quarters of it. That kind of concentration is why condition data matter financially: the first miles rehabilitated remove far more I/I per dollar than the last. A peak wet-weather flow more than seven times the base sanitary flow is the number that drives backups and overflows in a spring thaw, and reducing it is often the strongest health argument the PER can make.
From condition grades to a priority list
A structural grade measures how likely a pipe is to fail; it does not measure what a failure would cost. The study therefore ranks segments on two scores. Likelihood comes from the grade, the defect type and the pipe material. Consequence comes from what sits above and downstream: depth and diameter, which drive repair cost; whether the pipe runs under a main street, a rail line or a building; whether it carries flow from a school, a care home or an employer; and whether a collapse would back sewage into basements. A shallow grade 4 pipe in an alley may rank below a deep grade 3 trunk under the main street. The model's Phase 1 takes every grade 4 and 5 segment for simplicity; a real priority list is ordered by risk, and that order is what the bid's add-or-deduct schedule follows.
Private-side inflow
Part of a town's inflow does not come from public pipe at all. Sump pumps, roof drains and cracked service lines on private property can deliver a large share of the peak flow in a wet spring. The city's ordinance decides who must fix them, and whether WWD funds can pay for any work on private property is a question for the processing office before the scope is set. The study's role is to say how much of the measured peak is likely private-side, so the council does not expect public rehabilitation alone to remove it.
Modeled schedule
| Phase | Months from engagement | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Condition and cost analysis alongside the PER | 0 to 4 | Inspection data graded; methods priced; present worth; rate analysis |
| Application and review | 4 to 9 | Completeness within 15 federal working days; eligibility and funding advice within 45 days of a complete file (1780.32) |
| Letter of conditions and design | 9 to 14 | Rate ordinance; final segment list; environmental review |
| Construction | 14 to 26 | Lining, bursting and open-cut work in one season where possible, with interim financing (1780.39(d)) |
| Year 1 of operations | 26 to 38 | New rates in force; post-construction flow monitoring |
Project cost and sources and uses
| Item | Quantity | Unit cost (assumed) | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cured-in-place pipe lining, 8 to 12 inch, including cleaning, bypass pumping and lateral reinstatement | 25,500 LF | $68 (range $50 to $95) | $1,734,000 |
| Open-cut replacement at collapses and sags, including restoration | 1,400 LF | $310 (range $240 to $420) | $434,000 |
| Pipe bursting where upsizing is needed | 2,246 LF | $165 (range $130 to $210) | $370,524 |
| Manhole rehabilitation (lining, chimney seals, frames and covers) | 120 each | $5,200 (range $3,500 to $7,500) | $624,000 |
| Lateral connection sealing at lined segments | 400 each | $1,150 (range $800 to $1,600) | $460,000 |
| Rehabilitation construction | $3,622,524 | ||
| Mobilization, traffic control and bonds (4%) | $144,901 | ||
| Construction contingency (10%) | $376,742 | ||
| Engineering: CCTV review, design, bidding, inspection (12%) | $452,091 | ||
| Environmental review documentation (7 CFR part 1970) | $15,000 | ||
| Legal and bond counsel | $30,000 | ||
| Fiscal advisory: condition, cost and rate analysis | $12,000 (inside the site's published range; not this engagement's fee) | ||
| Administration and publication | $15,000 | ||
| Interest on interim construction financing (12 months, 50% average draw, 5.50%) | $126,352 | ||
| Total Phase 1 cost | $4,794,610 |
| Use | Amount | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Rehabilitation construction, mobilization and contingency | $4,144,167 | 86.4% |
| Engineering | $452,091 | 9.4% |
| Environmental, legal, fiscal and administration | $72,000 | 1.5% |
| Interim interest | $126,352 | 2.6% |
| Total | $4,794,610 | 100.0% |
| Source | Amount | Share | Terms |
|---|---|---|---|
| USDA Water and Waste Disposal direct loan | $4,595,000 | 95.8% | 40 years at an illustrative 3.25% intermediate rate |
| City sewer fund reserves | $199,610 | 4.2% | Deposited before loan funds |
| USDA grant | $0 | 0.0% | Not triggered (see the grant test) |
| Total | $4,794,610 | 100.0% |
The modeled Phase 1 costs $4,794,610, or $165 for each foot of main rehabilitated once manholes, laterals, engineering, contingency and interim interest are counted, against $68 a foot for the lining itself. That gap is why a per-foot liner price is not a project budget. The WWD loan of $4,595,000 sits inside the published tier with little room: the sensitivity table below shows that higher lining prices or more defective footage would take it past $5 million. Fiscal advisory, engineering, legal and environmental fees are eligible project costs, and construction-period interest is eligible from loan funds (1780.9(e)) [1].
Market analysis: the users and the place
Population and regional context
Wahpeton had 8,013 residents in the April 2020 base and 8,141 in July 2025, a gain of 1.6% [4]. Richland County grew 1.1%, from 16,541 to 16,731, with births exceeding deaths by 131 and small net gains from both international and domestic migration [5]. The rest of the county is small towns: Hankinson (936 in 2025), Lidgerwood (585), Wyndmere (442) and a dozen smaller places [4]. North Dakota as a whole grew 2.6%, but its 45 non-metro counties together lost 0.8% and 34 of them lost population [5].
| County | County seat | OMB 2023 status | April 2020 base | July 2025 | Change | Births less deaths | Net international | Net domestic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Richland, ND | Wahpeton | Micropolitan (Wahpeton, ND-MN) | 16,541 | 16,731 | +1.1% | +131 | +26 | +31 |
| Wilkin, MN | Breckenridge | Micropolitan (Wahpeton, ND-MN) | 6,507 | 6,288 | -3.4% | -108 | +34 | -144 |
| Sargent, ND | Forman | Non-metro | 3,864 | 3,711 | -4.0% | -13 | +5 | -142 |
| Ransom, ND | Lisbon | Non-metro | 5,708 | 5,617 | -1.6% | -93 | +49 | -45 |
| Traverse, MN | Wheaton | Non-metro | 3,363 | 3,130 | -6.9% | -86 | +14 | -155 |
| Roberts, SD | Sisseton | Non-metro | 10,284 | 10,255 | -0.3% | +111 | +31 | -168 |
| Otter Tail, MN | Fergus Falls | Non-metro | 60,094 | 61,041 | +1.6% | -961 | +522 | +1,372 |
| Cass, ND | Fargo | Metro | 184,533 | 201,794 | +9.4% | +5,545 | +5,339 | +6,374 |
Sources: Census Vintage 2025 county estimates, components summed from April 2020 to July 2025 [5]; OMB July 2023 delineation [6].
Wahpeton sits between two patterns: the Fargo metro to the north, growing 9.4%, and the farm counties around it, most of them losing people. Its twin across the Red River, Breckenridge, fell from 3,437 to 3,323 [4]. For a sewer study the conclusion is a stable user base with modest growth, which the model sets at 0.3% a year.
The users
The model counts 3,450 residential and 640 commercial and institutional EDUs. The county's employers are a larger share of the economy than in most towns this size: County Business Patterns show 38 manufacturing establishments with 1,696 employees and $110.0 million of annual payroll in Richland County in 2023, including 7 food manufacturers with 649 employees and 3 wood products plants with 95 [7]. Restaurants (24 establishments, 449 employees) and fuel stations (13 establishments, 123 employees) round out the commercial base [7]. Not all of these are on the city's sewer, and a rehabilitation study does not depend on any one of them; it does check whether an industrial discharge reaches the segments being lined, because some discharges shorten liner life.
Financial feasibility
Three approaches over twenty years
| Approach | Capital | Recurring costs over 20 years | Residual value in Year 20 | Present worth |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: rehabilitate grade 4 and 5 segments now, mostly lining (model) | $4,668,258 | none beyond normal O&M | $2,800,955 | $3,117,438 |
| B: replace the same segments by open cut now | $12,162,445 | none beyond normal O&M | $9,121,834 | $7,111,907 |
| C: defer ten years, repair failures as they occur, then rehabilitate | $5,135,084 in Year 10 | 6.3 emergency repairs a year at $44,000 each, plus treating 56 million gallons of I/I a year | $4,108,067 | $4,091,918 |
This comparison is the core of a condition and cost analysis. Replacing the same segments by open cut costs more than twice as much as lining in present worth, even after crediting the new pipe's longer life, because excavation, restoration and traffic control dominate the cost. Deferral looks cheap until the failures are counted: at the model's failure rates, about six emergency repairs a year plus the cost of pumping and treating water the lined pipe would have kept out make deferral about $974,000 more expensive in present worth than rehabilitating now. The 3% real discount rate, the 50-year design life of lining and the 80-year life of new pipe are assumptions the engineer should confirm.
Deferral case: what the failure assumption does
| Annual failure rate, grade 5 / grade 4 segments | Expected failures a year | Present worth of deferral | Cost of deferral over rehabilitating now |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6% / 2% | 3.1 | $2,918,730 | -$198,707 |
| 12% / 4% | 6.3 | $4,091,918 | $974,481 |
| 20% / 7% | 10.6 | $5,740,723 | $2,623,286 |
The answer depends on how often grade 4 and 5 pipes actually fail. If they fail at half the model's rate, deferral is about $199,000 cheaper in present worth; at a higher rate it costs $2.6 million more. A study should not hide this. The city's own records of emergency repairs and backups over the past five to ten years are the evidence that settles it, and they belong in the file next to the inspection grades.
Modeled operating budget
| Item | Amount | Per EDU a year |
|---|---|---|
| Personnel: 5.0 FTE (collections, lift stations, treatment, share of billing) at $76,000 loaded | $380,000 | $93 |
| Treatment and pumping power | $150,000 | $37 |
| Chemicals and biosolids | $85,000 | $21 |
| Collection system maintenance, cleaning and televising | $95,000 | $23 |
| Lift station repairs | $45,000 | $11 |
| Laboratory and permit monitoring | $25,000 | $6 |
| Insurance | $38,000 | $9 |
| Billing, administration, audit and allocated overhead | $120,000 | $29 |
| Operation and maintenance before Phase 1 | $938,000 | $229 |
| Savings after Phase 1: less I/I to pump and treat, fewer emergency call-outs | -$43,340 | -$11 |
| Short-lived asset reserve (pumps, controls, equipment) | $140,000 | $34 |
| Existing sewer debt service (assumed, for example on the treatment plant) | $260,000 | $64 |
The existing debt service is an assumption, included to show how the grant test treats a utility that already carries debt for its treatment plant; the city's actual debt is not used.
Five-year pro forma
| Line | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EDUs (+0.3% a year) | 4,090 | 4,102 | 4,115 | 4,127 | 4,139 |
| Sewer revenue (charges +3% a year) | $1,583,144 | $1,635,530 | $1,689,650 | $1,745,560 | $1,803,321 |
| Operation and maintenance, net of Phase 1 savings | $894,660 | $921,500 | $949,145 | $977,619 | $1,006,948 |
| Net revenue before reserves and debt | $688,484 | $714,030 | $740,505 | $767,941 | $796,373 |
| Short-lived asset reserve | $140,000 | $144,200 | $148,526 | $152,982 | $157,571 |
| Existing sewer debt service (assumed) | $260,000 | $260,000 | $260,000 | $260,000 | $260,000 |
| Phase 1 WWD installment | $206,903 | $206,903 | $206,903 | $206,903 | $206,903 |
| Debt reserve deposit on the new loan | $20,690 | $20,690 | $20,690 | $20,690 | $20,690 |
| Surplus | $60,890 | $82,237 | $104,385 | $127,366 | $151,208 |
| Coverage of all debt service, before reserves | 1.47x | 1.53x | 1.59x | 1.64x | 1.71x |
| Coverage after the short-lived asset reserve | 1.17x | 1.22x | 1.27x | 1.32x | 1.37x |
| Average monthly sewer bill per EDU | $32.26 | $33.22 | $34.22 | $35.25 | $36.30 |
Charges are set to collect about 4% more than the full revenue requirement in Year 1, covering operations, the short-lived asset reserve, existing and new debt service and the new loan's reserve, and rise 3% a year. Coverage of all debt after the reserve starts at 1.17 times and reaches 1.37 times by Year 5.
Grant determination
| Step | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Income ratio | $58,000 / $66,000 (both assumed) | 87.9%: intermediate tier, 45% ceiling, 1.0% threshold |
| 2. Threshold per EDU | 1.0% x $58,000 | $580 a year |
| 3. Phase 1 debt service per EDU | $206,903 / 4,090 EDUs | $51 a year |
| 4. All sewer debt service per EDU, including the assumed existing debt | ($206,903 + $260,000) / 4,090 | $114 (0.20% of MHI) |
| 5. Grant considered? | $114 vs $580 | No |
| 6. Debt the users could carry at the threshold | $580 x 4,090 / 0.04503 | about $52,683,000 of total debt |
Even counting assumed existing debt, sewer debt service is $114 per EDU a year against a $580 threshold at the assumed income. Project size does not change that picture: the users could carry about $52.7 million of total debt before a grant came into question. That is the correction to the engagement card's statement that an under-$5 million rehabilitation is "a strong grant candidate". A grant depends on income and on the debt service per user, and a town of 8,000 rehabilitating a fraction of its system rarely reaches the threshold [1].
What Phase 1 adds per EDU
| Item | Per year | Per EDU a month |
|---|---|---|
| Loan installment | $206,903 | $4.22 |
| Debt reserve | $20,690 | $0.42 |
| Less operating savings | -$43,340 | -$0.88 |
| Net added by Phase 1 | $184,254 | $3.75 |
On these assumptions Phase 1 adds about $3.75 a month per EDU after the operating savings from less I/I and fewer emergency call-outs. The savings are small next to the installment, which is typical: I/I removal pays for itself mainly through avoided capacity and avoided failures, not through the treatment plant's power bill.
I/I removal: what Phase 1 buys
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Average I/I removed | 0.15 MGD (56 million gallons a year) |
| Peak wet-weather flow removed | 0.9 MGD |
| Phase 1 cost per gallon a day of average I/I removed | $31.49 |
| Phase 1 cost per gallon a day of peak flow removed | $5.33 |
| Treatment and pumping savings a year at $420 per million gallons | $23,340 |
| Years for those savings alone to repay Phase 1 | 205 |
Treatment savings alone would take 205 years to repay Phase 1, so no study should justify rehabilitation on the power bill. The economic case is capacity: Phase 1 removes peak flow at about $5.33 per gallon a day. If the alternative to removing that water is building equalization storage, a larger lift station or more treatment capacity to carry it, and that alternative costs more per gallon of peak capacity, rehabilitation is the cheaper way to buy room. The engineer prices the alternative; the study puts the two numbers side by side, alongside the failure-cost comparison above.
Bid strategy
Rehabilitation bids reward preparation. Unit prices for lining by diameter, a separate price for each manhole and lateral, a ranked list of segments the city can add or deduct, and a requirement that the contractor clean and televise each segment before lining it, give the city control over the final scope. A single construction season is cheaper than two, so the study's schedule aims for bids in late winter and work in the warm months, with the loan closing or interim financing in place before mobilization.
A twenty-year program, not a single project
| Phase | Start | Linear feet | Cost | Annual installment | Per EDU a month | Cumulative new debt per EDU a month |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phase 1 (model): grades 4 and 5 | Year 0 | 29,146 | $4,794,610 | $206,903 | $4.22 | $4.22 |
| Phase 2: worst half of grade 3 | Year 6 | 21,542 | $4,120,020 | $185,516 | $3.78 | $8.00 |
| Phase 3: rest of grade 3 | Year 12 | 21,542 | $4,919,519 | $221,516 | $4.51 | $12.51 |
Phase 1 fixes 11.5% of the footage. Grade 3 pipe is the next generation of grade 4 pipe, and a city that lines it in two later phases adds about $12.51 a month per EDU in new debt service by Year 12, before rate indexation. The council should see that path before it adopts the first rate increase, and the study should show the alternative of funding later phases partly from rates, which avoids interest but raises bills sooner. Either way, the short-lived asset reserve and the inspection program that keeps grades current are part of the plan, not extras.
Unit cost, quantity and delay sensitivity
| Case | Phase 1 cost | Cost per foot of main rehabilitated | Loan | Annual installment | Debt and reserve per EDU a month |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lining at $50 a foot | $4,195,763 | $144 | $3,996,000 | $179,932 | $4.03 |
| Lining at $68 a foot (model) | $4,794,610 | $165 | $4,595,000 | $206,903 | $4.64 |
| Lining at $95 a foot | $5,692,881 | $195 | $5,493,000 | $247,338 | $5.54 |
| Footage 15% higher once cleaning reveals more defects | $5,503,545 | $164 | $5,304,000 | $238,828 | $5.35 |
| Twelve-month delay at 4% escalation | $4,983,659 | $171 | $4,784,000 | $215,414 | $4.83 |
The tier is the constraint. At the high end of the lining range, or with 15% more defective footage found during cleaning, the loan passes $5 million. The mitigants are a bid with unit prices and an add-or-deduct schedule of segments ranked by grade, so the city can trim the lowest-priority segments to stay within the loan, and a contingency that is held until cleaning and pre-lining inspection are done.
Interest rate tier sensitivity
| Rate | Phase 1 installment | Per EDU a month | Coverage after reserve, Year 1 | Surplus, Year 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Poverty rate 2.50% | $183,047 | $3.73 | 1.24x | $87,132 |
| Intermediate 3.25% (model) | $206,903 | $4.22 | 1.17x | $60,890 |
| Market 4.125% | $236,492 | $4.82 | 1.10x | $28,343 |
| Market plus one point | $272,387 | $5.55 | 1.03x | -$11,142 |
Combined stress case
| Stress | Setting |
|---|---|
| Footage | +15% |
| Delay | Twelve months at 4% |
| Rate tier | Market 4.125% |
| Users | -0.5% a year |
| Fixed O&M | +5% |
| Loan | $5,521,000 |
| Coverage after reserve, Year 1 / Year 5 | 0.92x / 0.97x |
| Revenue increase needed in Year 1 to cover all costs and reserves | 4.5% |
With everything going wrong, including a loan $926,000 larger and a market-tier rate, the city needs a 4.5% revenue increase in Year 1. Rehabilitation is a forgiving project financially because the debt is small per user; the risks that matter are scope and timing, not solvency.
Technical and environmental feasibility
- The PER and the field data. Camera inspection, smoke testing and flow monitoring are the engineer's work under customary professional standards, reviewed by the State staff engineer (1780.33(c), 1780.55) [1]. The study uses their grades, footage and I/I estimates.
- Method selection. Lining suits structurally sound host pipe with cracks, joint leaks and roots; pipe bursting suits pipe that must be upsized; open cut is left for collapses, sags and deep failures. The model's split (25,500, 2,246 and 1,400 feet) is an assumption.
- Laterals and manholes. A lined main with leaking laterals and manholes removes less I/I than the model assumes; that is why lateral sealing and manhole work are in Phase 1.
- Standards. Pipe and leakage testing must meet the federal guidelines and industry standards cited in 1780.57(k) and (l) [1].
- Cold-weather construction. A northern construction season is short; a single-season schedule and a winter shutdown plan protect both the price and the contingency.
- Environmental review. Review under 7 CFR part 1970 must end before any action that limits alternatives (1780.57(a)) [1]; most rehabilitation work stays inside existing rights-of-way.
Management and governance feasibility
A rehabilitation program needs an owner who keeps inspecting. The study looks for an asset inventory with condition grades that the city updates, a cleaning and televising budget, a record of emergency repairs and backups, a sewer enterprise fund with audited accrual statements (1780.47) and a council willing to index rates [1]. Part 1780 also asks whether the applicant has the financial, technical and managerial capability to comply with federal and state requirements and whether shared services were considered (1780.1(j)) [1]; across the river, Breckenridge runs its own system, and a joint inspection or lining contract is the kind of shared service a reviewer may ask about.
Priority points the feasibility package documents (modeled)
| Criterion | Points | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Population 5,501 to 10,000 (Wahpeton 8,013 in the 2020 base) | 0 | 1780.17(a) |
| Corrects wastewater inadequacies, if the PER documents overflows or backups | 25 | 1780.17(b)(2) |
| Income 80% to 100% of state non-metro median (assumed) | 15 | 1780.17(c)(3) |
| Public body | 5 | 1780.17(d)(3) |
| Other than RUS funds: city reserves of $199,610 (4.2%) | 0 | 1780.17(d)(4): below 5% |
| Modeled total before discretionary points | 45 | |
| With a state cost-share of 20% to 49% of the project | +10 | 1780.17(d)(4) |
| State program official and National Office points | up to 15 each | 1780.17(e), (g) |
The health priority is the largest score item available to Wahpeton, and it depends on the PER documenting backups, overflows or a permit problem that the rehabilitation corrects. The card mentions state cost-share and state approvals; if a state source supplied 20% or more of the cost, the city would gain 10 points and borrow less.
Process and documents
| Stage | What happens | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Early contact and optional PER review | Eligibility discussion; PER may be submitted early | 1780.31, 1780.33(c)(1) |
| Application | SF 424.2, two PER copies, environmental report, credit elsewhere certification | 1780.33 |
| Completeness and eligibility | Missing items within 15 federal working days; advice within 45 days of a complete file | 1780.32 |
| Public notice and meeting | Notice within 60 days of filing; public information meeting unless a vote authorizes the debt | 1780.19 |
| Full application | Operating budget on Form RD 442-7, professional service contracts | 1780.39 |
| Letter of conditions and obligation | Issued when funds are available; sets the rate | 1780.39(i), 1780.41 |
| Construction | Interim financing for loans over $500,000 where available | 1780.39(d) |
Sources: [1], summarized from this site's national WWD page [9]. The condition and cost analysis needs: the inspection database with grades and footage; smoke testing and flow monitoring results; five to ten years of emergency repair and backup records; treatment plant flow records; the engineer's unit costs; audits, rate ordinance and existing debt instruments. On this site's schedule a study of this kind takes 4 to 8 weeks once the engagement letter is signed, or 3 to 4 weeks on the rush option [12].
Economic and community impact (modeled)
| Measure | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Residents served | 8,141 | Census Vintage 2025 [4] |
| Realistic users | 4,090 EDUs | Model |
| Mains rehabilitated in Phase 1 | 29,146 feet (5.5 miles) | Model |
| I/I removed | about 56 million gallons a year | Model |
| Peak wet-weather flow reduction | 0.9 MGD (16%) | Model |
| Construction spending (construction, mobilization and contingency) | $4,144,167 | Budget |
| On-site job-years (35% labor share at $72,000 loaded, assumed) | 20 | Arithmetic, not a multiplier model |
| Monthly bill added, net of savings | $3.75 per EDU | Model |
The community impact is mostly avoided harm: fewer sewage backups into basements, fewer emergency street excavations, and treatment capacity that is used for sewage instead of groundwater. For a town whose employers depend on reliable service, a collapse under a main street is not only a repair bill.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | How it shows up in the model | Mitigant the study tests |
|---|---|---|
| More defects than inspected | +15% footage takes the loan past $5 million | Ranked add-or-deduct segment schedule; contingency held to pre-lining inspection |
| Bid prices | Lining at $95 a foot takes the loan to about $5.49 million | Unit-price bid; season timing |
| I/I reduction smaller than assumed | Savings and peak reduction shrink | Laterals and manholes in scope; post-construction monitoring |
| Failure rate unknown | Deferral ranges from $199,000 cheaper to $2.6 million dearer | City repair and backup records in the file |
| Later phases | $12.51 a month per EDU of new debt by Year 12 | Phasing plan; partial pay-as-you-go |
| Interest tier | Market plus one point leaves coverage at 1.03x | Lower of approval or closing rate |
| Short season | Delay of a year adds about $189,000 | Single-season schedule; early environmental review |
What the five Part 5001 components showed
WWD direct is governed by part 1780, and the condition findings belong to the PER. This site still organizes the condition and cost analysis around its five components:
| Component | What the model shows | What a reviewer still asks |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | A growing town of 8,141 in a micropolitan county with a manufacturing base | Any industrial discharge to the lined segments |
| Market (users) | 4,090 EDUs; stable user base | Customer list and meter-based EDU counts |
| Technical | 11.5% of footage in grades 4 and 5; lining-led Phase 1 | Inspection database, I/I study and method choices |
| Financial | Present worth favors rehabilitating now; $3.75 a month per EDU | Repair records, existing debt, actual income |
| Management | Inspection program and indexed rates | Asset inventory and maintenance budget |
Why rehabilitation studies are sent back
- A budget built from a per-foot liner price without manholes, laterals, bypass pumping or contingency.
- Segments chosen by age rather than by inspection grade.
- I/I reduction claimed without flow monitoring before and a plan to measure after.
- No comparison of methods, or a comparison that ignores residual life.
- A grant assumed because the project is small, before the threshold test.
- Later phases left out, so the council adopts a rate that does not last.
Program terms that applied
| Term | WWD direct rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Rural area | Not in a city or town over 10,000 | 1780.3 [1] |
| Design | Modest in size, design and cost; most economical service; no new combined sewers | 1780.10(a)(1), (3); 1780.57(n) [1] |
| Rate tiers | Poverty (60% of market, not over 5%), intermediate (80%, not over 7%), market; quarterly, nearest one-eighth | 1780.13 [1] |
| Term | Useful life, state statute or 40 years, whichever is less; principal deferral up to 36 months | 1780.13(e) [1] |
| Grant ceiling and threshold | 75% or 45%; debt service per EDU above 0.5% or 1.0% of median household income | 1780.10(c), 1780.35(b) [1] |
| Reserves | One average installment, built at one tenth a year; short-lived asset reserves | 1780.39(e), 1780.35(c) [1] |
| Interim financing | For loans over $500,000 where available | 1780.39(d) [1] |
| Guaranteed alternative (FY2026) | 90% guarantee, 1.0% fee, no retention fee | 91 FR 11272 [3] |
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Rank by grade, not by age. The worst tenth of the footage carries a large share of the I/I and nearly all the failure risk.
- Budget the whole job. Manholes, laterals, bypass pumping and contingency more than double the per-foot liner price.
- Bring the repair records. The case against deferral rests on how often pipes actually fail.
- Show the twenty-year program. Phase 1 is the first of several, and the rate should be set knowing that.
- Don't count on a grant because the project is small. Income and debt per user decide it.
- Bid with a ranked segment list. It keeps the loan inside the tier if cleaning finds more defects.
Related pages
- The Water and Waste Disposal engagement page lists this program's engagements, including this one.
- The USDA Water and Waste Disposal feasibility study page sets out part 1780, the grant tests and a worked rate example [9], and the Water and Waste Disposal program article explains who leads each piece [10].
- The North Dakota state page carries the state's data and project guides [13].
- The case studies page lists the site's long-form work, including the water and waste disposal case study for Mississippi [8].
- The USDA rural definition article compares the 10,000 WWD line with the 20,000 and 50,000 lines other programs use.
- The USDA Feasibility Study Framework and the cost and timeline page set out the method and fees [12].
If your city is planning a sewer rehabilitation program for a WWD application and needs a USDA feasibility study consultant to turn your engineer's inspection data into a cost, phasing and rate analysis, the engagement index describes the process: a fifteen-minute scoping call, a written proposal inside one business day and a firm fixed fee before you sign [11]. Request a proposal for your study [14].
Data current as of November 2026.
USDA Feasibility, Inc.