How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
In 2025 this practice prepared a feasibility study for a wastewater treatment plant expansion in Dalhart, Texas, under the USDA Water and Waste Disposal (WWD) program in the $5 million to $25 million tier. USDA was the lender, and the study was prepared with load and capacity analysis. This page works through the questions that kind of study answers, using a modeled plant, a modeled sewer utility of about 4,200 equivalent dwelling units (EDUs) and public data for Dalhart, Dallam County and Hartley County.
A wastewater expansion asks a question a water plant upgrade does not: how big? Build too small and the city is back in the design office within a decade; build too large and today's households pay for capacity that tomorrow's users, or one industrial customer, will use. The engineer's preliminary engineering report (PER) designs the plant, and this practice does not prepare PERs. The load and capacity analysis supplies the demand side the PER sizes against: who sends flow and organic load to the plant now, how that changes over a twenty-year design period, which user groups drive the expansion, and what each alternative does to the rate. The model below finds that organic load, not flow, is what fills the plant, and that a single industrial user can decide both the right size and who should pay for it. Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
| Published record | Detail |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Water and Waste Disposal direct loan and grant (filed under WEP on the engagement index) |
| Project | Wastewater treatment plant expansion |
| Location | Dalhart, Texas (Dallam and Hartley counties, Southwest region) |
| Loan size tier | $5 million to $25 million |
| Year | 2025 |
| Lender | USDA direct |
| Outcome | Prepared with load and capacity analysis |
Source: this site's engagement index [11]. The plant, flows, loads, users, budget, rates and projections below are a model, not the city's permit, flows, rates or debt.
The engagement card on the index carried a longer summary. This page keeps what the regulations and data on file support, corrects what they contradict, and marks the rest as the card's own statement.
| Statement in the engagement card | Status on this page |
|---|---|
| The U.S. wastewater sector has $99 billion of annual capital needs against about $30 billion of funding, a $69 billion gap (ASCE 2025 Infrastructure Report Card) | Kept as the card's statement; not checked |
| Renewal and replacement of large capital projects fell from 3% to 2% a decade; collection failures rose from 2.0 to 3.3 per 100 miles of pipe | Kept as the card's statement; not checked |
| Residential wastewater bills rose from $35 to nearly $65 a month between 2010 and 2020 | Kept as the card's statement; not used in the model |
| Texas rural utilities face growth, aging equipment and TCEQ discharge permits that require nutrient removal the original plants cannot provide | Kept as the card's general statement. The model leaves room for nutrient removal but does not assume a permit limit |
| Texas Water Development Board commitment of $125 million for the Eagle Mountain water treatment plant expansion (2024), about $3.57 per gallon of capacity | Kept as the card's statement, but not used as a benchmark: it is a drinking water plant in a metropolitan system, not a rural wastewater plant |
| Fort Bend County MUD 142's 1.2 MGD expansion at $25.7 million (about $21.4 million per MGD) as "a rural MUD cost benchmark" | Kept as the card's statement; the arithmetic is consistent, but Fort Bend County is in the Houston metropolitan area, so this page does not treat it as a rural benchmark |
| Texas construction escalation of 3% to 6% a year | Kept as the card's statement; the model tests a 4% delay case |
| Eligible borrowers are public entities (MUDs, WCIDs) and nonprofits in rural areas | Kept: public bodies and community-controlled nonprofits in areas not in a city or town over 10,000 (1780.3, 1780.7) [1] |
| "At $5M to $25M, this engagement required a full Preliminary Engineering Report per RUS Bulletin 1780-7" with flows, loads, capacity headroom, growth projections and technology selection | Corrected in part. Every WWD application needs a PER regardless of size (1780.33(c)) [1]; the bulletin number was not checked. The PER contents listed are the engineer's; the flow and load projections are where the load and capacity analysis meets the PER |
| The State Environmental Coordinator's environmental review ran concurrently and was completed | Kept as the card's statement; not checked |
| The study modeled loan-only and grant and loan scenarios, with the rate per residential connection in each and the grant level needed to hold rates within USDA's affordability threshold | Consistent with the published outcome. This page shows both in model form |
The question USDA needed answered
For a WWD direct loan Rural Development needs proof that the project is the right size and that users can pay for it. The size question has two rules pulling against each other: facilities must have adequate capacity for present needs and reasonably foreseeable growth (1780.7(c)) and must be modest in size, design and cost (1780.10(a)(1)) [1]. The payment question is the economic feasibility test: taxes, assessments, revenues or fees must cover operation and maintenance, reasonable reserves and debt payment (1780.7(f)), with rates set on realistic users (1780.39(c)(1)) [1]. And when the system depends on a business that is its primary user, that business's viability must be assessed (1780.7(f)), while costs a business would normally bear, such as pretreatment, are not eligible (1780.10(a)(5)) [1].
| Document or task | Rule | Who prepares it | What it decides |
|---|---|---|---|
| Preliminary engineering report | 1780.33(c), 1780.55 | The city's engineer, licensed in Texas (1780.54) | Process, capacity, alternatives, cost estimate |
| Load and capacity analysis | 1780.7(c), 1780.10(a)(1) | Feasibility consultant, with the engineer | Design flows and loads; which alternative is modest yet adequate |
| Environmental report | 1780.33(f), 1780.55 | Environmental professionals under 7 CFR part 1970 | No action that limits alternatives before review ends (1780.57(a)) |
| Operating budget and rate schedule | 1780.33(h)(1), 1780.35(c), 1780.39(c) | Applicant, with its feasibility consultant | Revenue covers O&M, reserves and debt service |
| Business viability assessment | 1780.7(f) | Independent business study when a business is the main user | Whether the system can rely on that business |
| Grant determination | 1780.35(b) | Processing office, from the applicant's numbers | Debt service share of income; similar system cost |
Eligibility and program fit
| Test | Rule | Dalhart result |
|---|---|---|
| Rural area | Not in a city or town over 10,000 under the latest decennial census (1780.3) | Eligible: 8,429 residents in the April 2020 estimates base and 8,377 in July 2025 [4] |
| Applicant | Public body, community-controlled nonprofit or tribe (1780.7(a)) | A city is a public body |
| Credit elsewhere | Cannot finance on reasonable rates and terms (1780.7(d)) | Certified; the study's financing comparison supports it |
| Capacity and growth | Adequate for present needs and reasonable growth; modest in size (1780.7(c), 1780.10(a)(1)) | The sizing alternatives below |
| Business user | Viability assessed if a business is the primary user; pretreatment ineligible (1780.7(f), 1780.10(a)(5)) | The model's industrial user is a minority of flow but 28% of organic load |
| County setting | Non-metro proxy | Dallam and Hartley counties lie outside any metropolitan or micropolitan area in the OMB July 2023 delineation [6] |
WWD guaranteed loans under part 5001 carry a 90% guarantee, a 1.0% fee and no annual retention fee in fiscal 2026, up to $50 million per borrower, and use the broader 50,000 rural test [2][3]. A city of 8,400 eligible for direct loans will usually compare the direct program's 40-year term and income-based rate tiers with state revolving fund financing, which Texas runs through its water development board, rather than with a guaranteed bank loan.
Texas has more places inside the WWD population line than any state but Illinois [8]. The Census file counts 988 incorporated places of 10,000 or fewer, 80.7% of the state's 1,224 [4]:
| Texas incorporated places, April 2020 base | Places | Residents, 2020 base | Residents, July 2025 | Places that lost population | WWD population priority points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1,000 or fewer | 438 | 206,600 | 222,991 | 91 | 25 |
| 1,001 to 2,500 | 263 | 433,876 | 488,546 | 74 | 15 |
| 2,501 to 5,500 | 191 | 729,618 | 843,656 | 53 | 5 |
| 5,501 to 10,000 (Dalhart) | 96 | 721,668 | 816,753 | 26 | 0 |
| 10,001 to 50,000 | 168 | 3,698,371 | 4,213,591 | 43 | Outside the direct rural test |
| Over 50,000 | 68 | 15,331,040 | 16,248,628 | 9 | Outside the direct rural test |
Source: Census Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [4]; points from 1780.17(a) [1].
Dalhart earns no population points. Its score has to come from the health priority, which a plant at its permit limits can earn with 25 points when the PER documents the inadequacy, and from income and other funds.
Project description (modeled)
The model treats Dalhart's plant as a mid-sized activated sludge facility with an assumed permitted average flow of 1.20 million gallons a day (MGD) and an assumed design organic capacity of 2,400 pounds a day of biochemical oxygen demand (BOD). The expansion adds a new aeration basin with zones that can be operated for nutrient removal if a renewed permit requires it, a new secondary clarifier, upgraded headworks and lift station, ultraviolet disinfection, more solids capacity, and the electrical, controls and standby power to run them.
Modeled users and loads today
| User class | Connections | EDUs (flow basis) | Flow (MGD, dry weather) | BOD (lb/day) | Share of BOD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Residential | 3,020 | 3,020 | 0.574 | 1,359 | 58.6% |
| Commercial, institutional and public | 360 | 690 | 0.131 | 310 | 13.4% |
| One significant industrial user (assumed) | 1 | 474 | 0.090 | 650 | 28.0% |
| Total | 3,381 | 4,184 | 0.795 | 2,320 | 100.0% |
The industrial user is an assumption. County Business Patterns show 7 manufacturing establishments with 361 employees in Dallam County and 5 with 31 in Hartley County in 2023 [7]; the published county cells do not show which of them, if any, discharge to the city plant or at what strength. A real study reads the city's industrial user permits and billing records. The model includes one such user because a strong industrial discharge is the most common reason a small plant fills its organic capacity before its hydraulic capacity, and because Part 1780 treats a business user differently.
Existing plant against its permit
| Measure | Today | Permitted or design capacity | Share used |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual average daily flow, including 15% inflow and infiltration | 0.94 MGD | 1.20 MGD | 77.9% |
| Maximum 30-day average flow (1.13 x annual average) | 1.06 MGD | 1.20 MGD | 88.1% |
| Organic load (BOD) | 2,320 lb/day | 2,400 lb/day | 96.6% |
At 88% of permitted flow in the peak month and 97% of organic capacity, the modeled plant is out of room on load and close to it on flow. Texas permits are commonly read with planning and construction triggers at 75% and 90% of permitted flow; the engineer and the state permit writer apply the actual rule, and the model uses those two lines only as analysis thresholds.
Modeled schedule
| Phase | Months from engagement | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Load and capacity analysis with the PER | 0 to 5 | Flow and load records, projections, sizing alternatives, rate work |
| Application and review | 5 to 10 | Completeness within 15 federal working days; eligibility and funding advice within 45 days of a complete file (1780.32) |
| Letter of conditions, design and permits | 10 to 20 | Rate ordinance, industrial user agreement, design, environmental review |
| Bidding and construction | 20 to 38 | Eighteen-month build with interim financing (1780.39(d)) |
| Year 1 of operations | 38 to 50 | New rates and surcharges in force |
Market analysis: who sends flow and load, and how that changes
Population and its geography
Dalhart straddles a county line, and its two halves are moving in opposite directions. The part of the city in Dallam County grew from 5,493 in the April 2020 base to 5,770 in July 2025 (+5.0%); the part in Hartley County fell from 2,936 to 2,607 (-11.2%) [4]. Net, the city lost 52 people (-0.6%). Dallam County as a whole grew 5.2%, from 7,135 to 7,508, with 575 more births than deaths and 625 net international migrants offsetting 837 net domestic departures; Hartley County fell 8.6% [5]. A load study does not average those numbers away. It asks where the growth is happening relative to the sewer system, and whether a fall of that size on one side of town reflects households leaving or a change in group quarters, which counts as population but connects as a single customer.
Regional comparison: the northwest Texas Panhandle
| County | County seat | OMB 2023 status | April 2020 base | July 2025 | Change | Births less deaths | Net international | Net domestic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dallam | Dalhart | Non-metro | 7,135 | 7,508 | +5.2% | +575 | +625 | -837 |
| Hartley | Channing | Non-metro | 5,363 | 4,904 | -8.6% | +108 | +18 | -598 |
| Sherman | Stratford | Non-metro | 2,777 | 2,781 | +0.1% | +110 | +84 | -192 |
| Moore | Dumas | Non-metro | 21,363 | 21,891 | +2.5% | +1,003 | +1,434 | -1,918 |
| Hansford | Spearman | Non-metro | 5,275 | 4,944 | -6.3% | +43 | +80 | -444 |
| Oldham | Vega | Metro | 1,759 | 1,783 | +1.4% | +6 | +47 | -28 |
| Potter | Amarillo | Metro | 118,622 | 114,453 | -3.5% | +704 | +2,828 | -7,736 |
| Randall | Canyon | Metro | 140,670 | 152,351 | +8.3% | +1,695 | +1,037 | +8,967 |
Sources: Census Vintage 2025 county estimates, components summed from April 2020 to July 2025 [5]; OMB July 2023 delineation [6].
The pattern across the northwest Panhandle is the same in every non-metro county: births and international arrivals keep populations roughly level while residents move away within the United States. Dallam and Moore counties are the two that grew. For a plant with a twenty-year design horizon, the honest base case is modest growth, about 0.5% a year in households and businesses, with a low case at the city's own trend and a high case that only an identified industrial expansion would justify.
Flow and load projections
| Scenario | Year 5 | Year 10 | Year 20 (design year) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low: city trend, -0.12% a year; industry flat | 0.93 / 1.05 / 2,311 | 0.93 / 1.05 / 2,303 | 0.92 / 1.04 / 2,287 |
| Base: +0.5% a year households and business; industry +2% a year | 0.97 / 1.09 / 2,429 | 1.00 / 1.13 / 2,547 | 1.07 / 1.21 / 2,810 |
| High: +1.0% a year; industrial user doubles its load in Year 5 | 1.08 / 1.22 / 3,055 | 1.13 / 1.27 / 3,144 | 1.22 / 1.38 / 3,337 |
When the existing plant runs out of room
| Scenario | Max 30-day flow reaches 75% of permit | Max 30-day flow reaches 90% | BOD reaches 90% of design | BOD reaches 100% of design |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low: city trend, -0.12% a year; industry flat | now | beyond Year 40 | now | beyond Year 40 |
| Base: +0.5% a year households and business; industry +2% a year | now | Year 4 | now | Year 4 |
| High: +1.0% a year; industrial user doubles its load in Year 5 | now | Year 3 | now | Year 5 |
In the low case, flows never reach 90% of the permit, but organic load is already at 90% of design and stays there. In the base case, flow and load both reach the 90% line in Year 4. In the high case, flow reaches it in Year 3 and load passes 100% of design when the industrial user doubles in Year 5. The analysis therefore points to an expansion now under any scenario, because of organic load, and leaves the size to be decided by how much of the high case is real.
The commercial base
| County, 2023 | Hotels and motels (establishments / employees) | Restaurants (establishments / employees) | Gasoline stations with stores | Manufacturing (establishments / employees) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dallam | 8 / 65 | 18 / 306 | 5 / 66 | 7 / 361 |
| Hartley | not shown | 3 / 29 | not shown | 5 / 31 |
Source: Census County Business Patterns 2023 [7]. Restaurants combine full-service and limited-service; "not shown" means fewer than three establishments in the county extract.
Dalhart's commercial users are a highway town's: lodging, food service and fuel along the routes through town. They send ordinary-strength wastewater in volumes that follow travel seasons, and the model counts them as 690 EDUs on 360 connections.
Sizing alternatives
| Alternative | Total project cost | Cost per gallon a day of capacity added | Annual installment | Installment per EDU a year | Reaches 90% of capacity, base case | Reaches 90%, high case |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: rehabilitate and expand to 1.5 MGD, 3,100 lb/day | $15,423,155 | $51 | $667,449 | $160 | Year 20 | Year 5 |
| B: expand to 1.8 MGD, 3,800 lb/day (model) | $18,114,472 | $30 | $788,619 | $188 | Year 39 | Year 25 |
| C: expand to 2.2 MGD, 4,600 lb/day | $20,985,210 | $21 | $917,895 | $219 | beyond Year 40 | beyond Year 40 |
This table is the heart of a load and capacity study. Alternative A is cheapest and reaches 90% of capacity in Year 20 in the base case, which is the design year with no margin, but fails in Year 5 if the industrial user expands. Alternative C has the lowest cost per gallon of capacity added and never fills within the loan term, which is the argument a reviewer will challenge under the modest-size rule: households would pay for capacity nobody is projected to use. Alternative B covers the base case for 39 years and the high case for 25, at $28 a year per EDU more than A. The model carries B, with one condition that matters more than the size: if the high case depends on the industrial user, the industrial user should commit to it in writing and pay for it.
Phasing instead of choosing
A fourth answer is to build in phases: size the headworks, lift station, piping and site for alternative C, and build the biological and clarifier capacity of alternative A or B now, with room on the site and in the hydraulic profile for the next train. Phasing moves the decision about the high case to the moment the industrial user actually expands, when it can sign for the capacity it needs. The cost is a larger first phase than A alone, because the parts that are hard to enlarge later are built once, and a second mobilization later. The study prices phasing as its own alternative when the PER shows the site and process allow it, and Part 1780's modest-size rule tends to favor it when growth is uncertain [1].
What the study reads in an industrial user agreement
An agreement that protects the city and the loan carries six things: the reserved capacity in flow and pounds of BOD and suspended solids; a minimum monthly charge for that capacity whether it is used or not; a term at least as long as the share of debt the capacity supports, or a buy-out if the user leaves early; pretreatment limits and the user's duty to pay for pretreatment; sampling and metering rights; and a reopener if the user's discharge changes. Without those terms, the high case in this model is a hope, and a State Office reviewer is right to discount it.
Project cost and sources and uses
| Line item | Amount | Assumed range |
|---|---|---|
| Headworks: screening and grit removal | $1,250,000 | $1,000,000 to $1,500,000 |
| Influent lift station upgrade | $1,100,000 | $850,000 to $1,350,000 |
| Biological treatment: new aeration basin with zones that can be run for nutrient removal | $4,200,000 | $3,400,000 to $5,100,000 |
| Blowers and fine-bubble aeration | $1,050,000 | $850,000 to $1,300,000 |
| Secondary clarifier | $1,600,000 | $1,300,000 to $1,950,000 |
| Ultraviolet disinfection | $750,000 | $600,000 to $950,000 |
| Solids: digester expansion and dewatering | $1,500,000 | $1,200,000 to $1,850,000 |
| Electrical, SCADA and standby power | $1,350,000 | $1,100,000 to $1,650,000 |
| Site work and yard piping | $900,000 | $700,000 to $1,150,000 |
| Laboratory and operations building rehabilitation | $400,000 | $300,000 to $520,000 |
| Construction subtotal | $14,100,000 | |
| Construction contingency, 10% at PER stage | $1,410,000 | 5% to 15% |
| Engineering: PER, design, bidding, construction administration and inspection (12%) | $1,692,000 | Engineer's contract |
| Environmental report and review (7 CFR part 1970) | $60,000 | Environmental consultant |
| Legal and bond counsel | $75,000 | Counsel's engagement letter |
| Fiscal advisory: load, capacity, rate and affordability analysis | $15,000 | Inside the site's $5,000 to $15,000+ range for rate analysis; not this engagement's fee |
| Administration, permits and publication | $40,000 | Assumed |
| Interest on interim construction financing (18 months, 50% average draw, 5.50%) | $722,472 | Interim lender; 1780.39(d) |
| Total project cost | $18,114,472 |
| Use | Amount | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Construction and contingency | $15,510,000 | 85.6% |
| Engineering | $1,692,000 | 9.3% |
| Environmental, legal, fiscal and administration | $190,000 | 1.0% |
| Interim interest | $722,472 | 4.0% |
| Total | $18,114,472 | 100.0% |
| Source | Amount | Share | Terms |
|---|---|---|---|
| USDA Water and Waste Disposal direct loan | $17,514,000 | 96.7% | 40 years at an illustrative 3.25% intermediate rate |
| City wastewater fund reserves | $600,472 | 3.3% | Deposited before loan funds |
| USDA grant | $0 | 0.0% | Not triggered in the base case |
| Total | $18,114,472 | 100.0% |
At $18,114,472 the modeled project sits in the middle of the published tier and costs $4,330 per EDU. Construction-period interest is eligible only from loan funds, and fiscal advisory, engineering and environmental fees are eligible project costs (1780.9(e)) [1]; costs paid before approval need a written request and a finding of compelling reasons (1780.9(f)) [1]. The city's $600,472 of reserves is 3.3% of the project, below the 5% that earns other-funds points (1780.17(d)(4)) [1]. A state revolving fund loan or grant for 20% or more of the cost would earn 10 points and reduce the WWD loan, which is why the funding plan belongs in the feasibility package with commitment letters.
Financial feasibility
Modeled operating budget
| Item | Amount | Per EDU a year |
|---|---|---|
| Personnel: 6.0 FTE (licensed operators, collections, share of billing) at $74,000 loaded | $444,000 | $106 |
| Electricity, mostly aeration | $185,000 | $44 |
| Chemicals | $40,000 | $10 |
| Biosolids hauling and disposal | $95,000 | $23 |
| Laboratory and permit monitoring | $30,000 | $7 |
| Repairs and maintenance, plant and lift stations | $160,000 | $38 |
| Insurance | $45,000 | $11 |
| Billing, administration, audit and allocated overhead | $140,000 | $33 |
| Operation and maintenance before the expansion | $1,139,000 | $272 |
| Added O&M from the expansion (aeration, UV, solids) | $120,000 | $29 |
| Short-lived asset replacement reserve | $160,000 | $38 |
Grant determination: loan only
| Step | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Income ratio | $54,000 / $60,000 (both assumed) | 90.0%: intermediate tier, 45% ceiling, 1.0% threshold |
| 2. Threshold per EDU | 1.0% x $54,000 | $540 a year |
| 3. Proposed debt service | $17,514,000 at 3.25% for 40 years | $788,619 a year |
| 4. Debt service per EDU | $788,619 / 4,184 EDUs | $188 (0.35% of MHI) |
| 5. Grant considered? | $188 vs $540 | No |
| 6. Loan at which the test would start | $540 x 4,184 / 0.04503 | about $50,173,000 |
At an assumed service-area income of $54,000, 90% of an assumed $60,000 Texas statewide non-metro median, the debt service per EDU is $188 a year against a $540 threshold, so no grant is considered and the project proceeds on the loan. The illustrative rates are those this site's national WWD page uses: market 4.125%, intermediate 3.25% and poverty 2.50%; Rural Development publishes the actual rates each quarter [9].
Loan only or grant and loan: the grant level needed to hold the threshold
| Service-area MHI (share of assumed $60,000 state non-metro) | Existing sewer debt service a year (assumed) | Rate tier | Threshold per EDU | Debt service per EDU, loan only | Grant needed | Grant share of project |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $42,000 (70%) | $0 | Poverty (health or sanitary project) | $210 | $167 | $0 | 0.0% |
| $42,000 (70%) | $250,000 | Poverty (health or sanitary project) | $210 | $227 | $1,735,056 | 9.6% |
| $42,000 (70%) | $500,000 | Poverty (health or sanitary project) | $210 | $286 | $8,010,750 | 44.2% |
| $46,000 (77%) | $0 | Poverty (health or sanitary project) | $230 | $167 | $0 | 0.0% |
| $46,000 (77%) | $250,000 | Poverty (health or sanitary project) | $230 | $227 | $0 | 0.0% |
| $46,000 (77%) | $500,000 | Poverty (health or sanitary project) | $230 | $286 | $5,910,308 | 32.6% |
| $54,000 (90%) | $0 | Intermediate | $540 | $188 | $0 | 0.0% |
| $54,000 (90%) | $250,000 | Intermediate | $540 | $248 | $0 | 0.0% |
| $54,000 (90%) | $500,000 | Intermediate | $540 | $308 | $0 | 0.0% |
The engagement record describes loan-only and grant and loan scenarios and the grant needed to hold rates within the affordability threshold. This table shows how that answer depends on two facts this site does not have: the service area's median household income and the debt the sewer system already carries. At 90% of the state non-metro median the threshold is 1.0% of income and no plausible existing debt reaches it. Below 80%, and with a project that corrects a wastewater inadequacy, the threshold falls to 0.5% and the grant ceiling rises to 75%; a system already paying $500,000 a year would then need a grant of $5.9 million to $8.0 million to hold its debt service at the threshold. How existing debt enters the test should be confirmed with the processing office.
Five-year pro forma
| Line | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EDUs (households and business, +0.4% a year, plus the industrial user) | 4,184 | 4,208 | 4,233 | 4,257 | 4,282 |
| Base charge per EDU a month (+3% a year) | $22.87 | $23.56 | $24.27 | $24.99 | $25.74 |
| Volume charge per 1,000 gallons of winter water use (+3% a year) | $4.95 | $5.10 | $5.25 | $5.41 | $5.57 |
| Revenue: households and business | $2,036,532 | $2,106,018 | $2,177,876 | $2,252,185 | $2,329,029 |
| Revenue: industrial user, including strength surcharge | $364,273 | $380,027 | $396,498 | $413,720 | $431,728 |
| Total revenue | $2,400,805 | $2,486,046 | $2,574,374 | $2,665,905 | $2,760,757 |
| Operation and maintenance (+3% a year) | $1,259,000 | $1,296,770 | $1,335,673 | $1,375,743 | $1,417,016 |
| Net revenue before reserves and debt | $1,141,805 | $1,189,276 | $1,238,701 | $1,290,161 | $1,343,741 |
| Short-lived asset reserve | $160,000 | $164,800 | $169,744 | $174,836 | $180,081 |
| WWD loan installment | $788,619 | $788,619 | $788,619 | $788,619 | $788,619 |
| Debt reserve deposit (one tenth of an installment) | $78,862 | $78,862 | $78,862 | $78,862 | $78,862 |
| Surplus | $114,324 | $156,995 | $201,476 | $247,844 | $296,179 |
| Coverage of the installment, before reserves | 1.45x | 1.51x | 1.57x | 1.64x | 1.70x |
| Coverage after the short-lived asset reserve | 1.24x | 1.30x | 1.36x | 1.41x | 1.48x |
| Average monthly residential bill (4,560 gallons billed) | $45.74 | $47.12 | $48.53 | $49.99 | $51.49 |
Households and businesses pay a base charge and a volume charge on winter water use, a common way to bill sewer service without charging for lawn watering; the industrial user pays the same charges plus a surcharge on BOD above domestic strength. Year 1 charges are set to collect about 5% more than the full revenue requirement and rise 3% a year. Coverage after the short-lived asset reserve starts at 1.24 times and improves as the base grows.
Rate design is not neutral. A higher base charge protects the utility against wet years and conservation, because sewer volume billed on winter water use moves with weather and household size; a higher volume charge is easier on small households and single residents. The model splits household and business revenue evenly between the two. A council that wants a lower base charge for affordability can have it, but the study then shows the coverage at a 10% lower billed volume, which in this model falls from 1.24 to about 1.12 times in Year 1 before indexing lifts it back.
Who pays for the plant
| User group | Share of BOD load | Share of flow | Share of revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Households and business | 72.0% | 88.7% | 84.8% |
| Industrial user | 28.0% | 11.3% | 15.2% |
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Industrial user's flow share / BOD share | 11.3% / 28.0% |
| Blended cost-of-service share | 19.7% |
| Revenue at that share, Year 1 | $472,304 |
| Revenue the model's rates collect from it | $364,273 (15.2%) |
| Shortfall carried by households and business | $108,030 |
| BOD above domestic strength, a year | 159,447 lb |
| Strength surcharge: model / cost-of-service | $0.45 / $1.13 per lb |
At a surcharge of $0.45 a pound, the industrial user pays 15.2% of revenue while it causes 28.0% of the organic load and 11.3% of the flow. If half the system's costs follow flow and half follow strength, its fair share is 19.7%, and households and businesses carry about $108,000 a year of its cost. A surcharge near $1.13 a pound closes the gap. The allocation method is a policy choice for the council, but USDA's rule points the same way: costs a business would normally bear are not WWD costs (1780.10(a)(5)) [1].
Residential bill and affordability
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Average monthly residential bill | $45.74 |
| Annual bill | $549 |
| Share of assumed MHI of $54,000 | 1.02% |
| Debt service per EDU (rule's measure) | $188 a year, 0.35% of MHI |
| Threshold at which a grant is considered | $540 a year (1.0%) |
| Item | Per year | Per EDU a month |
|---|---|---|
| Loan installment | $788,619 | $15.71 |
| Debt reserve | $78,862 | $1.57 |
| Added O&M | $120,000 | $2.39 |
| Total | $987,481 | $19.67 |
The modeled bill is 1.02% of the assumed income, and the expansion adds about $19.67 a month per EDU. The rule's measure, debt service per EDU, is 0.35% of income, well under the 1.0% threshold.
Interest rate tier sensitivity
| Rate | Installment | Per EDU a year | Coverage after reserve, Year 1 | Surplus, Year 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Poverty rate 2.50% | $697,692 | $167 | 1.41x | $214,344 |
| Intermediate rate 3.25% (model) | $788,619 | $188 | 1.24x | $114,324 |
| Market rate 4.125% | $901,396 | $215 | 1.09x | -$9,730 |
| Market plus one point, 5.125% | $1,038,212 | $248 | 0.95x | -$160,228 |
The tier matters more here than in a small water upgrade because the loan is larger: the difference between the intermediate and market rates is $112,777 a year, enough to erase the Year 1 surplus. The borrower gets the lower of the rate at approval or closing unless it chooses otherwise (1780.13(a)) [1], so the rate study should show the market-tier case and the increase it would require.
Industrial user and growth sensitivity
| Case | Revenue, Year 1 | Coverage after reserve, Year 3 | Coverage after reserve, Year 5 | Surplus, Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model | $2,400,805 | 1.36x | 1.48x | $296,179 |
| Industrial user leaves in Year 3 | $2,400,805 | 0.85x | 0.93x | -$135,549 |
| Industrial user's load halves | $2,283,674 | 1.19x | 1.29x | $153,478 |
| Household and business growth stalls (0% a year) | $2,400,805 | 1.33x | 1.43x | $259,284 |
| Billed winter volume 10% lower | $2,298,979 | 1.22x | 1.33x | $179,727 |
The industrial user is the largest single risk. If it leaves in Year 3, coverage falls to 0.85 times and the city needs about $195,000 more revenue, a 9.0% increase. Growth stalling barely matters by comparison. The mitigants are contractual: a user agreement with a capacity reservation, a minimum charge for the reserved capacity whether it is used or not, a term that runs with the debt, and a pretreatment requirement the business pays for. Where the business is the primary user and the system depends on it, Part 1780 requires its viability to be assessed [1], which in practice means an independent business study.
Cost overrun and delay
| Case | Added cost | Loan | Installment | Debt and reserve per EDU a month | Coverage after reserve, Year 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model | $0 | $17,514,000 | $788,619 | $17.28 | 1.24x |
| Bids 10% over | $1,410,000 | $18,924,000 | $852,109 | $18.67 | 1.15x |
| Bids 20% over | $2,820,000 | $20,334,000 | $915,598 | $20.06 | 1.07x |
| Twelve-month delay at 4% escalation | $620,400 | $18,134,400 | $816,555 | $17.89 | 1.20x |
A 20% overrun takes the loan to about $20.3 million, still inside the published tier, and adds $2.78 a month per EDU in debt and reserve. A year's delay costs about $620,000 at 4% escalation, but in this plant the larger cost of delay is regulatory: with load at 97% of design, a year without the expansion is a year of permit risk.
Combined stress case
| Stress | Setting |
|---|---|
| Construction bids | +15%, financed |
| Rate tier | Market 4.125% |
| Industrial user | Leaves in Year 3 |
| Household and business growth | 0% a year |
| Fixed O&M | +5% |
| Loan | $19,629,000 |
| Coverage after reserve, Year 1 / Year 3 / Year 5 | 0.92x / 0.59x / 0.62x |
| Revenue increase needed in Year 3 to cover all costs and reserves | 23.9% |
Everything going wrong at once, including losing the industrial user, would require a 23.9% revenue increase in Year 3. That is the case that justifies the user agreement: a minimum charge that survives the user's departure turns the worst line in the table into a much smaller one.
Technical and environmental feasibility
- The PER designs the plant. Process, sizing, alternatives and cost are the engineer's, reviewed by the State staff engineer (1780.33(c), 1780.55) [1]. The load and capacity analysis supplies the flows, loads and growth cases the PER designs against, and the study adopts the PER's cost.
- Effluent standards. Discharge facilities must meet federal and state effluent standards (1780.57(h)) [1]. The model leaves room in the aeration basin for nutrient removal so a tighter renewed permit does not force another project.
- Industrial pretreatment. Pretreatment and other costs a business would normally bear are ineligible (1780.10(a)(5)) [1]; the industrial user agreement should require them.
- Inflow and infiltration. The model assumes 15% of average flow is inflow and infiltration. Capacity spent treating groundwater is capacity households pay for, so the PER should test collection repairs as an alternative to part of the expansion.
- Environmental review. The review under 7 CFR part 1970 must be complete before the city commits to a site or process that would narrow the alternatives (1780.57(a)) [1].
Management and governance feasibility
The study looks for the capability Part 1780 requires: financial, technical and managerial capacity, and evidence that alternatives of ownership, design and shared services were considered (1780.1(j)) [1]. For a plant expansion that means licensed operators at the level the new process requires, a sewer enterprise fund with audited accrual statements (1780.47), a council with a record of adjusting rates, an industrial pretreatment and surcharge program that is enforced, and a capital plan that carries the short-lived asset reserve. The industrial user agreement is a management document as much as a financial one: the city has to be able to measure the user's flow and strength and bill for it.
Priority points the feasibility package documents (modeled)
| Criterion | Points | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Population 5,501 to 10,000 (Dalhart 8,429 in the 2020 base) | 0 | 1780.17(a) |
| Corrects wastewater inadequacies or meets health standards, if the PER documents it | 25 | 1780.17(b)(2) |
| Income 80% to 100% of state non-metro median (assumed) | 15 | 1780.17(c)(3) |
| Public body | 5 | 1780.17(d)(3) |
| Other than RUS funds: city reserves of $600,472 (3.3%) | 0 | 1780.17(d)(4): below 5% |
| Modeled total before discretionary points | 45 | |
| With a state revolving fund or other non-RUS share of 20% to 49% | +10 | 1780.17(d)(4) |
| State program official and National Office points | up to 15 each | 1780.17(e), (g) |
Process and documents
| Stage | What happens | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Early contact and optional PER review | Eligibility discussion; PER may be submitted early | 1780.31, 1780.33(c)(1) |
| Application | SF 424.2, two PER copies, environmental report, credit elsewhere certification | 1780.33 |
| Completeness and eligibility | Missing items within 15 federal working days; advice within 45 days of a complete file | 1780.32 |
| Public notice and meeting | Notice within 60 days of filing; public information meeting unless a vote authorizes the debt | 1780.19 |
| Full application | Operating budget on Form RD 442-7, user agreements, professional service contracts | 1780.39 |
| Letter of conditions and obligation | Issued when funds are available; sets the rate | 1780.39(i), 1780.41 |
| Construction | Interim financing for loans over $500,000 where available | 1780.39(d) |
Sources: [1], summarized from this site's national WWD page [9]. The load study needs: three to five years of daily influent flow and BOD and suspended solids data; the discharge permit; billing records by class with winter water use; industrial user permits and sampling; the PER or its draft; audits; existing debt instruments; and any income survey. This site's engagements typically run 4 to 8 weeks from a signed engagement letter, with a 3 to 4 week rush option [12].
Economic and community impact (modeled)
| Measure | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Residents served | 8,377 | Census Vintage 2025 [4] |
| Realistic users | 4,184 EDUs on 3,381 connections | Model |
| Treatment capacity after the project | 1.8 MGD and 3,800 lb/day BOD | Alternative B |
| Construction spending (construction and contingency) | $15,510,000 | Budget |
| On-site job-years (35% labor share at $70,000 loaded, assumed) | 78 | Arithmetic, not a multiplier model |
| Monthly bill added by the project | $19.67 per EDU | Model |
The community impact is permit compliance and room to grow. A plant at its organic limit cannot take a new restaurant, hotel or processor without risking its permit, and a city in that position effectively has a moratorium on the kinds of business its highway economy depends on.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | How it shows up in the model | Mitigant the study tests |
|---|---|---|
| Industrial user leaves | Coverage 0.85x in Year 3; 9.0% increase needed | Capacity reservation, minimum charge, term with the debt |
| Industrial user under-charged | Households carry about $108,000 a year | Strength surcharge near cost of service |
| Oversizing | Alternative C never fills within the loan | Modest-size test; growth evidence; signed commitments |
| Undersizing | Alternative A fails in Year 5 in the high case | Base and high cases; phasing |
| Interest tier | Market rate erases the Year 1 surplus | Lower of approval or closing rate; income survey if data look wrong |
| Construction cost | +20% bids add $2.78 a month per EDU | Contingency; bid alternates |
| Permit tightening | Nutrient limits in a renewed permit | Basin zones designed for nutrient removal |
| Inflow and infiltration | Capacity spent on groundwater | Collection repairs tested as an alternative |
What the five Part 5001 components showed
WWD direct is governed by part 1780, and the plant design belongs to the PER. This site still organizes the load and capacity work around its five components:
| Component | What the model shows | What a reviewer still asks |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | A highway service town; city flat, Dallam side growing, Hartley side falling | What explains the Hartley-side decline |
| Market (users and loads) | 4,184 EDUs; organic load at 97% of design | Daily flow and load records; industrial sampling |
| Technical | 1.8 MGD, 3,800 lb/day expansion covering the high case to Year 25 | The PER, alternatives and permit outlook |
| Financial | Debt service $188 per EDU against a $540 threshold; bill 1.02% of assumed income | Audits, existing debt, actual income, user agreement |
| Management | Operators, enterprise fund, surcharge program | Pretreatment enforcement and rate history |
Why wastewater expansion studies are sent back
- Growth projected from a regional rate that the city's own trend does not support.
- Flow analyzed and organic load ignored, or the reverse.
- An industrial user's expansion used to size the plant without a signed commitment from that user.
- Pretreatment or other business costs included in eligible project costs (1780.10(a)(5)) [1].
- No assessment of a business the system depends on (1780.7(f)) [1].
- Rates built on all connections including vacant lots, rather than realistic users (1780.39(c)) [1].
- A grant assumed before the threshold test shows one.
Program terms that applied
| Term | WWD direct rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Rural area | Not in a city or town over 10,000 | 1780.3 [1] |
| Rate tiers | Poverty (60% of market, not over 5%), intermediate (80% of market, not over 7%), market; quarterly, nearest one-eighth | 1780.13 [1] |
| Term | Useful life, state statute or 40 years, whichever is less; principal deferral up to 36 months | 1780.13(e) [1] |
| Grant ceiling | 75% (low income, health or sanitary project) or 45% | 1780.10(c) [1] |
| Grant threshold | Debt service per EDU above 0.5% or 1.0% of median household income; similar system cost | 1780.35(b) [1] |
| Business users | Viability assessed when a business is the primary user; pretreatment ineligible | 1780.7(f), 1780.10(a)(5) [1] |
| Reserves | One average installment, built at one tenth a year; short-lived asset reserves | 1780.39(e), 1780.35(c) [1] |
| Guaranteed alternative (FY2026) | 90% guarantee, 1.0% fee, no retention fee; $50 million cap | 91 FR 11272; part 5001 [2][3] |
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Measure load, not just flow. In this model the plant fills on BOD years before it fills on gallons.
- Size to evidence. The base case supports a smaller plant than the high case; only a signed commitment justifies the difference.
- Make the industrial user pay its share. A surcharge at cost of service and a capacity agreement protect households and the loan.
- Read the city's geography. A city flat in total can be growing on one side and shrinking on the other.
- Run the grant test early. At 4,200 EDUs a grant appears only with low income and existing debt.
- Treat delay as permit risk. At 97% of design, waiting costs more than escalation.
Related pages
- The Water and Waste Disposal engagement page lists this program's engagements, including this one.
- The USDA Water and Waste Disposal feasibility study page sets out part 1780, the grant tests and a worked rate example [9], and the Water and Waste Disposal program article explains who leads each piece of an application [10].
- The Texas state page carries the state office in Temple and the state's project guides [13].
- The case studies page lists the site's long-form work, including the water and waste disposal case study for Mississippi.
- The USDA rural definition article explains why the WWD line is 10,000.
- The USDA Feasibility Study Framework and the cost and timeline page set out the method and fees [12].
If your city or district is sizing a wastewater expansion for a WWD application and needs a USDA feasibility study consultant for the load, capacity and rate work alongside your engineer's PER, the engagement index describes the process: a fifteen-minute scoping call, a written proposal inside one business day and a firm fixed fee before you sign [11]. Request a proposal for your study [14].
Data current as of November 2026.
USDA Feasibility, Inc.