Hotel and motel projects in South Dakota are underwritten in one of the most heavily roomed states in the country. Census counted 441 hotels and motels in 2023, 48.1 for every 100,000 residents against 16.6 nationally, the second-highest rate of 51 states and DC in this site's state data. A new property therefore enters an existing market rather than an empty one, and the question a USDA lender asks is whose guests it will take, in which months, and at what rate. An independent feasibility study answers that with a named competitive set, a monthly demand model and a debt service test that survives the off-season.
The rest of this page sets out the evidence a South Dakota hotel study starts from: the state's supply and wage data, where the rooms sit relative to the B&I rural test, how SBA lenders have financed the sector, the fiscal 2026 B&I terms, and a worked example sized to the state's own average SBA hotel loan.
Data current as of November 2026.
Which program fits a South Dakota hotel
| Route | Fit for a South Dakota hotel | What to check first |
|---|---|---|
| USDA B&I guarantee | New builds, conversions, acquisitions and refinancing in towns that pass the rural test, such as Aberdeen, Brookings, Watertown, Mitchell or Spearfish; up to $25 million per borrower | Parcel outside Sioux Falls, Rapid City and their contiguous urbanized areas (7 CFR 5001.3) |
| SBA 504 | Owner-occupied hotel real estate; the most used SBA route for South Dakota hotels, with 81 loans since fiscal 2010 | Third-party lender at least 50% and borrower 15% to 20% for new or single-purpose property (13 CFR 120.910, 120.920) |
| SBA 7(a) | Acquisitions, change of flag, renovation and working capital; 27 South Dakota hotel loans since fiscal 2010 | 75% guarantee above $150,000 (120.210); guaranty fee ceilings in 120.220 |
| REAP | Energy work at an operating hotel: heating plant, insulation, lighting, laundry equipment | Rule effective 16 October 2026: grant only after 12 months of operating data |
| Community Facilities | Not a commercial lodging route | Public bodies, nonprofits and tribes only |
| Conventional bank | Strong sponsors with low loan-to-cost | Bank policy; no guarantee fee, usually more equity |
When an independent study is compulsory
For a newly formed hotel company, a B&I-guaranteed loan above $1,000,000 triggers a feasibility study by an independent, qualified consultant acceptable to the Agency, with the scope set by the Agency (7 CFR 5001.306(a)(3)(i)). South Dakota's average SBA 7(a) hotel loan from fiscal 2020 to 2026 was $1,663,343, so a typical new-build or a first-time owner buying a property clears that line. An operating owner expanding or buying a second hotel is not caught by that clause, but at $1,000,000 or less the Agency may still require a study (5001.306(a)(3)(ii)), and the lender's own credit memo must evaluate feasibility and market conditions under 5001.202. A hotel loan of $600,000 or less can use the streamlined application; anything larger goes through full processing under 5001.306(a), including a pro forma balance sheet at closing. SBA lenders may ask for a study too (13 CFR 120.160(b)), and for start-up hotels most do.
Hotels and motels in South Dakota: market evidence
South Dakota: hotels and motels, supply and rural footprint
| Measure | South Dakota | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 447 → 441 (-1.3%) | 54,955 → 55,895 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 48.1 | 16.6 |
| Average employees per establishment | 15.2 | 26.8 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $26,729 | $39,374 |
| Share of establishments in non-metro counties | 51.7% (212 in 23 counties) | |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 48.7% |
Non-metro counties with the most hotels and motels (2023): Lawrence County (35); Brown County (22); Davison County (18); Codington County (15); Fall River County (12); Brookings County (10).
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
The density figure is the place to begin. South Dakota carries 2.90 hotels per 100,000 residents for every one the nation carries, because its rooms serve travellers and visitors rather than residents: interstate traffic, hunters, Black Hills tourism, and business travel into regional towns that serve wide farm trade areas. The count barely moved, from 447 to 441 (-1.3%, a net loss of six), while the national count grew by 940. A flat count in a dense market usually means older motels closing as newer flags open, and the study should name both.
Size and pay set the first pro forma benchmarks. The average property employs 15.2 people against 26.8 nationally and pays $26,729 per employee, 32.1% less than the U.S. average of $39,374. Payroll per property averaged $406,689 in 2023. Those are the figures of a limited-service and economy stock. A reviewer will challenge any model that pays new staff at the state average when the newest competing properties pay more to hold them, and any occupancy figure that ignores how seasonal much of this demand is.
South Dakota hotels and motels by employment size, 2023 (computed from the Census CBP state file)
| Employees per property | Properties | Share of 441 |
|---|---|---|
| Fewer than 5 | 164 | 37.2% |
| 5 to 9 | 61 | 13.8% |
| 10 to 19 | 103 | 23.4% |
| 20 to 49 | 92 | 20.9% |
| 50 to 99 | 16 | 3.6% |
| 100 to 249 | 5 | 1.1% |
Hotel concentration in selected South Dakota counties (pack and CBP county counts; Vintage 2025 county population)
| County (largest town) | OMB status | Hotels and motels, 2023 | Residents, 2025 | Hotels per 100k residents |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Custer (Custer) | Metro (Rapid City area) | 18 | 9,431 | 190.9 |
| Fall River (Hot Springs) | Non-metro | 12 | 7,467 | 160.7 |
| Lawrence (Spearfish) | Non-metro | 35 | 29,459 | 118.8 |
| Davison (Mitchell) | Non-metro | 18 | 20,069 | 89.7 |
| Pennington (Rapid City) | Metro | 90 | 116,792 | 77.1 |
| Brown (Aberdeen) | Non-metro | 22 | 37,561 | 58.6 |
| Codington (Watertown) | Non-metro | 15 | 29,562 | 50.7 |
| Minnehaha (Sioux Falls) | Metro | 61 | 212,691 | 28.7 |
Demand drivers and how the competitive set is built
Half the state's hotels (225 of 441, 51.0%) employ fewer than ten people, and only 21 employ 50 or more. The small end is the independent motel and the economy flag; the 50-plus group is where full-service, conference and resort properties sit, and it is short enough that a study can name every one of them.
The county rates show where rooms follow visitors rather than residents. The Black Hills counties lead: Custer at 190.9 hotels per 100,000 residents, Fall River at 160.7 and Lawrence at 118.8, against 28.7 in Minnehaha County, home to Sioux Falls. Davison County, on the interstate at Mitchell, runs 89.7. In each of those markets the competitive set is large relative to the town, so capture has to be earned on location, brand and product age. A South Dakota study should split demand into at least five segments, each with its own months and rate: interstate transient travel, regional business travel into Aberdeen, Watertown, Brookings and Pierre, leisure travel to the Black Hills and the Badlands, fall hunting parties, and group business from youth sports, weddings and events. Blending them into one annual occupancy hides the winter months that decide whether the loan is paid.
Revenue model, operating costs and capital items
Rooms revenue is available rooms times occupancy times average daily rate, built month by month; food and beverage, meeting space and other income are added only where the concept carries them. Costs follow the departmental structure the industry uses: rooms labour and supplies, administrative and general, sales and marketing, repairs and maintenance, utilities, franchise royalties and reservation fees, management fees, property taxes, insurance and a reserve for furniture, fixtures and equipment. Capital items are land, site work and utilities, the building, furniture and equipment, the brand's opening requirements, technology, pre-opening costs, working capital and an interest reserve. Heating, snow removal and hail exposure belong in a South Dakota budget as local line items, not national averages.
Rural footprint and B&I eligibility in South Dakota
The pack places 212 of 410 county-located hotels (51.7%) in 23 non-metro counties, a little above the 48.7% of residents who live in them. The leading non-metro counties are Lawrence (35), Brown (22), Davison (18), Codington (15), Fall River (12) and Brookings (10).
Non-metro status is only a screen. The B&I test in 7 CFR 5001.3 excludes cities and towns of more than 50,000 people and the urbanized area contiguous to them, and South Dakota has two such places: Sioux Falls (213,748 in 2025) and Rapid City (80,589). No other town is close; the next largest, Aberdeen, had 27,961. That makes the state unusually simple to screen, with one trap on each side of the metro line. Metro status does not disqualify: Custer County sits in the Rapid City metropolitan area under the July 2023 delineation, yet its 18 hotels lie well outside the city, and most will screen eligible. Conversely, a hotel at the edge of Rapid City (Box Elder, Summerset) or of Sioux Falls (Brandon, Harrisburg, Tea) may fall inside the contiguous urbanized area and needs a parcel-level map check before any market work is commissioned. The South Dakota state hub lists the places and the eligibility screen.
Financing benchmarks: USDA B&I next to SBA
South Dakota: SBA lending to hotels and motels
| Period | 7(a) loans | 7(a) dollars | 504 loans | 504 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2010 to FY2016 | 8 | $9.9 million | 33 | $42.6 million |
| FY2017 to FY2019 | 5 | $7.1 million | 18 | $16.0 million |
| FY2020 to FY2023 | 11 | $12.7 million | 18 | $19.5 million |
| FY2024 to FY2026 | 3 | $10.6 million | 12 | $15.4 million |
Average 7(a) loan, FY2020 to FY2026: $1.7 million. Average 504 loan: $1.2 million. South Dakota had fewer than 30 seasoned 7(a) loans for hotels and motels; nationally, 3.0% of 4,928 FY2010 to FY2016 loans were charged off, on average 89 months after approval.
Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).
South Dakota hotel finance is a 504 market. Since fiscal 2010, SBA lenders made 81 hotel 504 loans worth $93.6 million against 27 7(a) loans worth $40.2 million, and in fiscal 2020 to 2026 the 504 share was 30 of 44 loans (68.2%). The state's 7(a) hotel loans are also smaller than the nation's: the fiscal 2020 to 2026 average of $1,663,343 is 35.1% below the national hotel average of $2,561,230. None of the eight South Dakota hotel 7(a) loans approved in fiscal 2010 to 2016 was charged off; nationally 3.0% of 4,928 were, on average 89 months after approval. Eight loans prove little, but they give a reviewer no local reason to discount a well-supported case.
B&I guaranteed loan terms for loans obligated in fiscal 2026
| Term | Rule and source |
|---|---|
| Guarantee share | 85% for loans under $5 million; 80% from $5 million to $25 million; 80% on the reduced-fee path (91 FR 11272) |
| Upfront guarantee fee | 3.0% of the guaranteed amount, or 1.0% on the reduced-fee path; plus 0.50% if the guarantee issues before construction is complete (91 FR 11272; 5001.454) |
| Annual retention fee | 0.55% (0.50% on the reduced-fee path) of the guaranteed share of principal outstanding on 31 December; the rate is fixed at obligation (5001.455) |
| Loan ceiling | $25 million per borrower (5001.406(c)) |
| Term | Useful life, at most 40 years; no balloon; first full payment within 3 years of the note if interest-only (5001.402) |
| Rate | Negotiated; fixed, variable or combined; no higher than the lender charges on similar non-guaranteed loans; variable rates reset no more than quarterly (5001.401) |
| Equity, existing business | 10% balance sheet equity (or debt to equity of 9:1), 10% of eligible project cost, or the contributed-capital test (5001.105(d)(1)) |
| Equity, new business | 20% balance sheet equity (or 4:1) or 25% of project cost; 10% with sales contracts that cover debt service; 25% (or 3:1) if the guarantee issues before construction ends (5001.105(d)(2) to (4)) |
| Collateral | Appraisal for real estate over $250,000; as-is and prospective values for construction; going-concern value deducted before discounting; appraisals no older than one year (5001.203) |
| Guarantors | Owners of 20% or more guarantee at least their share of the guaranteed amount for the full term (5001.204) |
| Feasibility study | Required from an independent qualified consultant for loans over $1,000,000 to a new business; at the Agency's discretion otherwise (5001.306(a)(3)) |
Read against those numbers, a typical South Dakota hotel loan near $1.7 million sits in the 85% guarantee tier and above the $1,000,000 study line for a new company. B&I competes with 504 on term and structure rather than on the guarantee alone: one lender, one note and amortization up to the building's useful life, against 504's two-lien structure. A new-build sponsor should plan on 25% of project cost in cash or earning assets unless the 20% balance sheet test is easier to meet; an operating owner buying another property needs 10%. Because much of a hotel's appraised value is going-concern value, which 5001.203 deducts before discounting, the lender's collateral cover is often short of the loan, and the study carries more of the credit.
Worked example (illustrative)
Inputs. Loan A is $1,700,000, the pack's fiscal 2020 to 2026 South Dakota 7(a) hotel average of $1,663,343, rounded. Loan B is $6,500,000, an illustrative select-service new-build that shows the 80% tier above $5 million. Both use an illustrative 7.25% fixed rate over 25 years of monthly payments, which stays inside the negotiated-rate rule in 5001.401 and the useful-life limit in 5001.402; it is not a quote. Fees follow the fiscal 2026 notice, and the equity lines treat the guaranteed loan as the only debt.
| Line | Loan A: near the South Dakota SBA hotel average | Loan B: illustrative larger new-build |
|---|---|---|
| Loan amount | $1,700,000 | $6,500,000 |
| B&I guarantee share for fiscal 2026 loans (91 FR 11272) | 85% | 80% |
| Guaranteed amount | $1,445,000.00 | $5,200,000.00 |
| Unguaranteed portion held by the lender | $255,000.00 | $1,300,000.00 |
| Upfront guarantee fee (3.0% of the guaranteed amount) | $43,350.00 | $156,000.00 |
| First-year retention fee, upper bound (0.55% of the guaranteed share of the full balance) | $7,947.50 | $28,600.00 |
| Retention fee on the balance left after 12 monthly payments | $7,830.52 | $28,179.02 |
| Illustrative rate and amortization (not a quote) | 7.25% fixed, 25 years, monthly | 7.25% fixed, 25 years, monthly |
| Monthly principal and interest | $12,287.72 | $46,982.45 |
| Annual debt service | $147,452.60 | $563,789.35 |
| Net operating income needed for 1.25x coverage | $184,315.75 | $704,736.69 |
| Cushion above 1.00x coverage | $36,863.15 | $140,947.34 |
| Cushion in full-time wages at the South Dakota hotel average pay ($26,729) | 1.38 positions | 5.27 positions |
| Interest-only payment for a start-up year, if structured (5001.402) | $123,250.00 | $471,250.00 |
| Annual debt service if the rate is 2.00 points higher | $174,701.90 | $667,977.84 |
| Coverage at that higher rate on the same income | 1.06x | 1.06x |
| Coverage if income lands 10% below plan | 1.125x | 1.125x |
| New business: equity at 25% of project cost (5001.105(d)(4)) | $566,666.67 on a $2,266,666.67 project | $2,166,666.67 on a $8,666,666.67 project |
| New business: 20% balance sheet equity test (debt to equity 4:1, loan as the only debt) | $425,000.00 | $1,625,000.00 |
| Existing business: 10% of project cost (5001.105(d)(1)) | $188,888.89 on a $1,888,888.89 project | $722,222.22 on a $7,222,222.22 project |
| Reduced-fee path (1.0% fee, 0.50% retention, 80% guarantee): upfront fee | $13,600.00 | $52,000.00 |
| Independent study compulsory for a new business? (5001.306(a)(3)(i)) | Yes, above $1,000,000 | Yes, above $1,000,000 |
| Application track (5001.306) | Full 5001.306(a) processing | Full 5001.306(a) processing |
| SBA 7(a) comparison: guaranteed share and guaranty fee ceiling (13 CFR 120.210, 120.220) | 75%: $1,275,000.00 guaranteed, fee ceiling $45,312.50 | not shown at this size |
Reading the table. Loan A needs net operating income of $184,315.75 to reach 1.25x, and its cushion above break-even, $36,863.15, equals 1.38 full-time wages at the state's hotel pay. Average payroll per South Dakota property ($406,689) is 2.76 times Loan A's annual debt service, which shows how much of a small hotel's income goes to staff before the lender is paid. A two-point rate rise cuts coverage to 1.06x, and a 10% income shortfall to 1.125x. Loan B moves to the 80% tier, pays $156,000 of upfront fee and needs $2,166,666.67 of new-business equity under the 25% test, or $1,625,000 under the balance sheet test.
What a lender-grade hotel feasibility study in South Dakota must prove
- Monthly demand by segment, with the winter months shown on their own, because a Black Hills or hunting-driven property earns most of its year in a few months.
- A named competitive set: every hotel and motel in the market with rooms, chain scale, age and recent renovation. In Lawrence County that is up to 35 properties; in Davison County 18.
- Fair share and penetration: the subject's occupancy as a share of market demand, with the ramp from opening to stabilization.
- Average daily rate against what the market achieves, with a reason for any premium over the newest comparable property.
- Labour at local wages, checked against the $26,729 state average and against what newer properties pay.
- Quarterly cash flow. 5001.202 requires it for seasonal borrowers, and most South Dakota leisure hotels are seasonal.
- Eligibility: a parcel outside Sioux Falls, Rapid City and their urbanized edges, confirmed on the USDA map.
- Construction, brand and budget: contractor, contingency, the franchise agreement and its opening requirements, and the 5001.205(e)(2) conditions if the guarantee issues before completion.
- Sensitivity: coverage under lower occupancy, lower rate, higher wages and higher interest, with the break-even occupancy stated.
Risks and mitigants specific to South Dakota
| Risk | Why it bites in South Dakota | How the study tests or mitigates it |
|---|---|---|
| Saturation | 48.1 hotels per 100,000 residents, 2.90 times the U.S. rate | Penetration analysis against a full competitive set |
| Seasonality | Black Hills, Badlands and hunting demand cluster in a few months | Monthly model, quarterly cash flow, interest reserve or working capital line |
| Labour | Pay 32.1% below the U.S. average invites wage catch-up | Staffing plan at market wages, sensitivity at higher pay |
| Eligibility edge | Sioux Falls and Rapid City urbanized edges | Parcel check before engagement |
| Weather and insurance | Plains winters, hail and wind | Insurance quotes in the budget; hazard insurance if SBA (13 CFR 120.160(c)) |
| Gaming income | Some Black Hills properties earn revenue from gaming | Report it as a separate line and confirm treatment under Part 5001 with the lender |
Process, documents and why studies come back
The order is lender first, then study. The sponsor chooses a lender approved for B&I guarantees, confirms the lender's current OneRD standing, and the study is scoped to what the lender and the USDA Rural Development state office serving South Dakota will review at the conditional commitment stage. The sponsor provides site control and plans, the franchise agreement or brand letter, a construction budget and contractor proposals, personal and business financial statements, management résumés, any operating history for an acquisition, and a sources-and-uses schedule. Hotel studies come back for predictable reasons: a competitive set that leaves out nearby properties, a rate above anything the market has achieved, stabilized occupancy in year one, a flat seasonal curve, wages below local levels, and franchise fees missing from the costs.
Program context, honestly labelled
There is no South Dakota hotel precedent in this page's inputs, so none is shown. For context, USAspending records 3 B&I guaranteed loans with South Dakota as the place of performance in fiscal 2024 to 2026, 0.47% of the 643 recorded nationally, against the state's 0.27% share of U.S. population; the records used here do not break those loans out by industry. The national guide linked below covers hotel lending across all states and is not a South Dakota project.
Hiring a USDA hotel feasibility study consultant in South Dakota
A first-time hotel company borrowing more than $1,000,000 under a B&I guarantee must use an independent hotel feasibility study consultant acceptable to the Agency (5001.306(a)(3)(i)); below that line, and for operators expanding, the Agency or lender decides, and most hotel lenders ask. The engagement covers the five components the site frames every study to: economic, market, technical, financial and management feasibility, with a five to ten year projection, sensitivity tables, a competitive supply inventory and comparable operator benchmarks.
The site's cost and timeline page prices a standard B&I study, meaning a single-site loan of $1 million to $10 million with adequate comparables, at $6,900 to $12,500 over 6 to 7 weeks, and complex work at $10,500 to $14,500 over 7 to 9 weeks. The data request goes out within 48 hours of signing, one revision round is included, and a written acceptance guarantee covers revisions until USDA or the lender accepts the report. A rush track delivers in 3 to 4 weeks at a 20% to 35% premium, subject to analyst capacity. Environmental assessments, appraisals and engineering are separate engagements.
Engaging a USDA feasibility study consultant before the franchise agreement is signed lets the market chapter test the brand choice instead of defending it. The sponsor brings the site, concept and brand, the budget, financial statements and the lender's contact. To start, request a proposal through the contact page with the town, room count and loan size; the contact page says a senior analyst replies within one business day.
Last updated 2026-11-08
USDA Feasibility, Inc.