South Dakota has very few marinas for a state with large reservoirs and lakes. Census counted five marinas with paid employees in 2023, up from four in 2019, or 0.5 per 100,000 residents against 1.1 nationally, and SBA lenders have made exactly one marina loan in the state since fiscal 2010, a $224,000 7(a) loan in fiscal 2010 to 2016. With so few operating comparables and no recent lending, a new or expanded South Dakota marina has to prove its slip demand from boat owners and waitlists, prove its right to the water through permits and a shoreline or lake lease, and prove it can carry debt through a season that ends when the water freezes.
Data current as of November 2026.
Which program fits a South Dakota marina
| Route | Fit in South Dakota | What to check first |
|---|---|---|
| USDA B&I guarantee | Privately owned marinas, dry storage, ship stores and service operations outside Sioux Falls and Rapid City | Ownership screen and rural parcel (7 CFR 5001.3); lease term against loan term |
| SBA 7(a) | Acquisitions, docks and equipment | One South Dakota marina loan since fiscal 2010; 75% guarantee above $150,000 (13 CFR 120.210) |
| SBA 504 | Owner-occupied marina real estate | No South Dakota marina 504 loans since fiscal 2010 |
| REAP | Efficiency or solar at an operating marina | Rule effective 16 October 2026 |
| Community Facilities | Not for inherently commercial recreation, per the national marina guide's reading of Part 5001 | Test public or nonprofit ownership with the state office first |
| Conventional | Established operators | Bank policy; leasehold collateral limits |
Ownership and the compulsory study
The site's national marina guide reads Part 5001 as making publicly owned or nonprofit recreational facilities that are inherently commercial ineligible for its guarantee programs, so a municipal or nonprofit marina should be tested with the USDA Rural Development state office serving South Dakota before any study is scoped. For a private marina company that is new and borrowing more than $1,000,000 under B&I, an independent study acceptable to the Agency is compulsory (7 CFR 5001.306(a)(3)(i)); the national 7(a) marina average in fiscal 2020 to 2026, $1,281,853, is above that line. Dock replacements and smaller expansions by operating marinas are discretionary (5001.306(a)(3)(ii)).
Marinas in South Dakota: market evidence
South Dakota: marinas, supply and rural footprint
| Measure | South Dakota | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 4 → 5 (+25.0%) | 3,757 → 3,734 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 0.5 | 1.1 |
| Average employees per establishment | 4.8 | 8.7 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $64,542 | $51,262 |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 48.7% |
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
The numbers are small enough that each marina matters. Five marinas employ 24 people in total, 4.8 on average against 8.7 nationally, at $64,542 per employee, 25.9% above the national $51,262; small year-round crews with seasonal help typically produce that pattern. Census does not place the five by county, so the pack cannot show a non-metro share. At half the national density, South Dakota is under-supplied relative to the U.S. per resident, but density is a weak guide for marinas: demand follows boats and water, not population.
Regional comparables (other states' figures)
The comparison below uses each neighbouring state's own pack.
| State | Census count, 2019 → 2023 | Rate per 100k residents, 2023 | Average staff per site | Average annual pay | SBA 7(a) loans, fiscal 2010 to 2026 | SBA 504 loans, fiscal 2010 to 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| South Dakota | 4 → 5 (+25.0%) | 0.5 | 4.8 | $64,542 | 1 ($224,000) | 0 ($0) |
| Minnesota | 59 → 66 (+11.9%) | 1.1 | 4.6 | $62,633 | 8 ($1.6 million) | 4 ($2.3 million) |
| Iowa | 23 → 21 (-8.7%) | 0.7 | 7.1 | $66,678 | 5 ($2.2 million) | 0 ($0) |
| Nebraska | 0 → 0 (n/a) | 0.0 | withheld or none | withheld or none | 1 ($315,000) | 0 ($0) |
| Montana | 6 → 9 (+50.0%) | 0.8 | 1.6 | $51,357 | 1 ($199,000) | 0 ($0) |
| United States | 3,734 in 2023 | 1.1 | 8.7 | $51,262 | 335 ($332.5 million) | 88 ($87.8 million) |
Minnesota, a lake state, supports 66 marinas (1.1 per 100k residents) and Iowa 21 (0.7), while Nebraska has none with paid staff and Montana nine. Pay in Minnesota ($62,633) and Iowa ($66,678) is close to South Dakota's $64,542, which supports using regional wage levels in the pro forma. SBA lending is thin everywhere: eight 7(a) marina loans in Minnesota and five in Iowa since fiscal 2010. A South Dakota study will lean on Minnesota and Iowa operators for slip rates and occupancy, adjusted for the shorter South Dakota boating season on reservoirs.
National benchmarks
SBA made 112 7(a) loans to marinas nationally in fiscal 2020 to 2026, averaging $1,281,853, and 38 504 loans averaging $1,294,079. Of 155 7(a) marina loans approved in fiscal 2010 to 2016, 5.2% were charged off, on average 91 months after approval, the longest time to loss of any asset on this site's South Dakota pages. Marina losses arrive late, often when docks need replacement or water levels fall, which argues for a replacement reserve in the model.
Evidence the study must build when local comparables are thin
- Boat ownership in the market area and the share likely to rent a slip or storage space, from registration data and operator interviews.
- A waitlist, deposits or pre-leases for the subject's slips, by length class.
- Slip, storage and launch rates of every marina and public ramp within reach, including in Minnesota and Iowa if no local comparable exists.
- Water level history at the site and the depth at low water, with any dredging needed.
- The shoreline or lake lease and its term against the loan term, and the reservoir manager's approval.
- Permit status: the national guide lists Corps section 10 authorization for docks and section 404 for dredged or fill discharges.
- Fuel, store, service and rental income from comparable operations.
Rural footprint and B&I eligibility in South Dakota
The pack publishes no county locations for South Dakota marinas, so no non-metro share exists. Eligibility is in any case a parcel test under 7 CFR 5001.3, excluding places of more than 50,000 people and their contiguous urbanized areas, which in South Dakota means Sioux Falls (213,748) and Rapid City (80,589). Almost all realistic marina sites, on reservoirs and lakes far from both cities, will pass the population test; ownership and leasing are the harder screens. The hub for South Dakota shows the two excluded cities and the place list.
Financing benchmarks: USDA B&I next to SBA
South Dakota: SBA lending to marinas
| Period | 7(a) loans | 7(a) dollars | 504 loans | 504 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2010 to FY2016 | 1 | $224,000 | 0 | $0 |
| FY2017 to FY2019 | 0 | $0 | 0 | $0 |
| FY2020 to FY2023 | 0 | $0 | 0 | $0 |
| FY2024 to FY2026 | 0 | $0 | 0 | $0 |
| South Dakota had fewer than 30 seasoned 7(a) loans for marinas; nationally, 5.2% of 155 FY2010 to FY2016 loans were charged off, on average 91 months after approval. |
Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).
The single South Dakota loan in 17 years means lenders have no in-state marina credit history. That raises the weight of the study and of the guarantee.
B&I guaranteed loan terms for loans obligated in fiscal 2026
| Term | Rule and source |
|---|---|
| Guarantee share | 85% for loans under $5 million; 80% from $5 million to $25 million; 80% on the reduced-fee path (91 FR 11272) |
| Upfront guarantee fee | 3.0% of the guaranteed amount, or 1.0% on the reduced-fee path; plus 0.50% if the guarantee issues before construction is complete (91 FR 11272; 5001.454) |
| Annual retention fee | 0.55% (0.50% on the reduced-fee path) of the guaranteed share of principal outstanding on 31 December; the rate is fixed at obligation (5001.455) |
| Loan ceiling | $25 million per borrower (5001.406(c)) |
| Term | Useful life, at most 40 years; no balloon; first full payment within 3 years of the note if interest-only (5001.402) |
| Rate | Negotiated; fixed, variable or combined; no higher than the lender charges on similar non-guaranteed loans; variable rates reset no more than quarterly (5001.401) |
| Equity, existing business | 10% balance sheet equity (or debt to equity of 9:1), 10% of eligible project cost, or the contributed-capital test (5001.105(d)(1)) |
| Equity, new business | 20% balance sheet equity (or 4:1) or 25% of project cost; 10% with sales contracts that cover debt service; 25% (or 3:1) if the guarantee issues before construction ends (5001.105(d)(2) to (4)) |
| Collateral | Appraisal for real estate over $250,000; as-is and prospective values for construction; going-concern value deducted before discounting; appraisals no older than one year (5001.203) |
| Guarantors | Owners of 20% or more guarantee at least their share of the guaranteed amount for the full term (5001.204) |
| Feasibility study | Required from an independent qualified consultant for loans over $1,000,000 to a new business; at the Agency's discretion otherwise (5001.306(a)(3)) |
Two B&I rules bite hardest for marinas. Equity must be cash or earning assets, and a new marina company needs 25% of project cost or 20% balance sheet equity (5001.105(d)(4)). And because docks may sit on leased water or shoreline, the collateral is often a leasehold whose value depends on the lease term, which the lender will discount; the appraisal also deducts going-concern value before discounting (5001.203).
Worked example (illustrative)
South Dakota has no recent marina loans to average, so Loan A uses the national fiscal 2020 to 2026 7(a) average of $1,281,853, rounded to $1,280,000, over 20 years. Loan B, $450,000, is an illustrative dock and ship-store upgrade at an operating marina over 15 years. Each carries an assumed 7.50% fixed rate for illustration (not a lender's offer), compliant with 5001.401 and 5001.402, with fiscal 2026 fees and the marina loan as its only debt.
| Line | Loan A: near the national SBA marina average | Loan B: illustrative dock and store upgrade |
|---|---|---|
| Loan amount | $1,280,000 | $450,000 |
| B&I guarantee share for fiscal 2026 loans (91 FR 11272) | 85% | 85% |
| Guaranteed amount | $1,088,000.00 | $382,500.00 |
| Unguaranteed portion held by the lender | $192,000.00 | $67,500.00 |
| Upfront guarantee fee (3.0% of the guaranteed amount) | $32,640.00 | $11,475.00 |
| First-year retention fee, upper bound (0.55% of the guaranteed share of the full balance) | $5,984.00 | $2,103.75 |
| Retention fee on the balance left after 12 monthly payments | $5,849.77 | $2,024.83 |
| Illustrative rate and amortization (not a quote) | 7.50% fixed, 20 years, monthly | 7.50% fixed, 15 years, monthly |
| Monthly principal and interest | $10,311.59 | $4,171.56 |
| Annual debt service | $123,739.11 | $50,058.67 |
| Net operating income needed for 1.25x coverage | $154,673.89 | $62,573.33 |
| Cushion above 1.00x coverage | $30,934.78 | $12,514.67 |
| Cushion in wages at the South Dakota marina average pay ($64,542) | 0.48 positions | 0.19 positions |
| Interest-only payment for a start-up year, if structured (5001.402) | $96,000.00 | $33,750.00 |
| Annual debt service if the rate is 2.00 points higher | $143,175.35 | $56,388.13 |
| Coverage at that higher rate on the same income | 1.08x | 1.11x |
| Coverage if income lands 10% below plan | 1.125x | 1.125x |
| New business: equity at 25% of project cost (5001.105(d)(4)) | $426,666.67 on a $1,706,666.67 project | $150,000.00 on a $600,000.00 project |
| New business: 20% balance sheet equity test (debt to equity 4:1, loan as the only debt) | $320,000.00 | $112,500.00 |
| Existing business: 10% of project cost (5001.105(d)(1)) | $142,222.22 on a $1,422,222.22 project | $50,000.00 on a $500,000.00 project |
| Reduced-fee path (1.0% fee, 0.50% retention, 80% guarantee): upfront fee | $10,240.00 | $3,600.00 |
| Independent study compulsory for a new business? (5001.306(a)(3)(i)) | Yes, above $1,000,000 | No; the Agency may still require one (5001.306(a)(3)(ii)) |
| Application track (5001.306) | Full 5001.306(a) processing | Streamlined, $600,000 or less |
| SBA 7(a) comparison: guaranteed share and guaranty fee ceiling (13 CFR 120.210, 120.220) | 75%: $960,000.00 guaranteed, fee ceiling $33,600.00 | 75%: $337,500.00 guaranteed, fee ceiling $10,125.00 |
Reading the table. Loan A needs $154,673.89 of net operating income for 1.25x, earned mostly in a season of a few months. Its cushion, $30,934.78, is less than half of one employee's pay at the state's marina average, so a low-water year that closes slips or a late ice-out can erase it. For a new company the equity is $426,666.67 at 25% of cost. Loan B shows the operating-owner path: streamlined processing, $50,000 of equity on a $500,000 project under the 10% test, and a discretionary study.
What a lender-grade marina feasibility study in South Dakota must prove
- Slip demand by length class, with waitlist or deposit evidence.
- Rates and occupancy of competing marinas and ramps, including out-of-state comparables.
- Season length and monthly revenue, with ice-out and freeze-up dates from history.
- Water levels and depth, with a low-water scenario.
- Lease term and rights for any shoreline or lake area, extending beyond the loan term.
- Permits for docks, dredging and fuel storage.
- Ancillary income from fuel, store, service and rentals.
- A dock and equipment replacement reserve.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | Why it bites in South Dakota | How the study tests or mitigates it |
|---|---|---|
| No local comparables | Five marinas and one SBA loan since fiscal 2010 | Regional comparables; boater surveys; pre-leases |
| Water levels | Reservoir drawdowns and drought | Water level history; low-water design and scenario |
| Short season | Ice limits operations | Monthly cash flow; winter storage income |
| Leasehold collateral | Lake or shoreline leases | Lease term beyond loan term; lender consent |
| Late losses | National charge-offs average 91 months after approval | Replacement reserve; conservative amortization |
Process and documents
Before engaging a lender, confirm ownership eligibility and lease status with the reservoir or land manager and the state office. Then choose a B&I-approved lender, which submits the study with the application. Sponsors provide the slip plan, waitlist or deposits, the lease and permits, the dock and building budget, operating history for an existing marina, and financial statements. Marina studies come back for absorption assumed without waitlists, leases shorter than the loan, and no low-water scenario.
Hiring a USDA marina feasibility study consultant in South Dakota
A new private marina company borrowing over $1,000,000 under B&I needs an independent marina feasibility study consultant acceptable to the Agency (5001.306(a)(3)(i)). With only five in-state comparables, the study is mostly primary research, which the site's fees and timelines guide treats as a complex-scope condition ($10,500 to $14,500, 7 to 9 weeks) rather than standard scope ($6,900 to $12,500, 6 to 7 weeks). Permit and engineering work are outside the study fee. Because slip demand is best measured in the boating season, an owner who engages a USDA feasibility study consultant in spring can gather waitlist and competitor occupancy evidence while marinas are open.
Use the contact page to request a proposal, with the lake, slip plan, lease status and loan size; replies come within one business day.
Last updated 2026-11-08
USDA Feasibility, Inc.