How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
This engagement assessed a dairy anaerobic digester near Burley, Idaho, in the Magic Valley. It was prepared in 2025 for a non-regulated lender approved for REAP, in the $5 million to $25 million loan tier, and its distinguishing work was the feedstock and offtake analysis. The record says the engagement was structured for a REAP guaranteed loan rather than a grant. Since then, USDA rescinded the FY2025 to FY2027 REAP funding notice in April 2026 [2] and a new REAP rule took effect on 16 October 2026 [1]. This page describes the engagement type and models a Magic Valley digester that upgrades biogas to renewable natural gas (RNG) for pipeline injection. It then shows how such a project is financed and what a study must prove under the rule in force.
| Item | Published record |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Rural Energy for America Program (REAP) |
| Asset class | Anaerobic digester |
| Project | Dairy anaerobic digester |
| Location | Burley, Idaho (Cassia County) |
| Region | Mountain West |
| Loan size tier | $5M to $25M |
| Year prepared | 2025 |
| Lender type | Non-regulated REAP-approved lender |
| Outcome | Prepared with feedstock and offtake analysis |
Sources: the site's engagement index [12]; county from Census place files [6].
The record adds that the study scoped supply-chain provenance and citizenship attestations under a USDA letter of the time. It also says a January 2026 USDA Unnumbered Letter paused new biodigester REAP grant applications. Neither letter is in the Federal Register, and we have not verified either; both are listed in VERIFY. The April 2026 rescission and the 16 October 2026 rule are what govern now.
The question the lender and USDA needed answered
A digester is a manure-management system attached to an energy business whose revenue mostly comes from environmental credits. That makes the lender's questions sharper than for a solar array:
- Is the feedstock real and committed? How many cows, how much of their manure reaches the digester, and for how long the dairy is contractually bound to supply it. A herd that shrinks or a barn converted to open lots cuts gas output directly.
- Who buys the gas, and the credits? The pipeline interconnection, the RNG purchase agreement and the arrangements for federal renewable fuel credits (RINs) and any state low-carbon fuel credits. These decide most of the revenue.
- What happens when credit prices fall? Credit markets have swung widely. The study has to show coverage at the low end, not the average.
- Can the project be built on budget and on time? A 15-month build, start-up biology and credit registration delay cash flow well after the loan is drawn.
Under 7 CFR part 5001, a REAP guaranteed loan for a renewable energy system needs a technical report, and a feasibility study when the lender or the Agency deems one necessary [3]. On a loan above $13 million to a project company with no operating history, both will. If the lender wants the guarantee issued before construction is complete, Part 5001 adds conditions. The budget and timetable must be confirmed by a qualified independent consultant, there must be a firm fixed-price construction contract, and borrower equity must go in before any guaranteed loan funds (5001.205(e)(2)) [3].
What changed for this engagement type on 16 October 2026
| Topic | Rule effective 16 October 2026 [1] | What it means for a dairy digester |
|---|---|---|
| Timing | Project Period must end 12 to 24 months before the grant application | The loan builds the digester; a grant can follow a year of metered output |
| Award size | At most 25% of cost and $500,000 for a renewable system | On an $18 million project the grant is at most 2.7% of cost |
| Combined funding | Grant plus REAP guaranteed loan at most 75% of project cost | A 75% loan leaves no room for a grant |
| Loan alone | A REAP guaranteed loan without a grant is capped at 75% of eligible costs, with at least 25% from the borrower (7 CFR 5001.406(d)) | Owners fund at least $4.6 million of the modelled project [3] |
| Exclusions | Retail energy dispensing, stand-alone storage and EV chargers are excluded from grants | Pipeline injection fits; selling compressed gas at a fuelling station would not, for the grant |
| Locations | Projects at more than one location ineligible | One digester site per application; a hub collecting manure from several dairies needs care |
| Economics | Simple payback must not exceed useful life | A test the study runs on cost against annual energy value |
| Gambling | Any gambling income bars a grant; the loan keeps the 15% test in 5001.127(b) | A screen of the dairy, the project company and affiliates |
Project description (modelled)
The modelled project collects manure from 7,500 milking cows at one dairy near Burley. It digests the manure in covered lagoons, upgrades the biogas to pipeline-quality RNG and injects it into a utility pipeline through a new gathering line and meter station. A separate project company owns and operates the digester under a 20-year feedstock agreement with the dairy and a site lease, and pays the dairy a host fee. Digested solids return to the dairy for bedding, and the liquid goes back into the dairy's nutrient management system.
The schedule runs: feedstock and offtake agreements, engineering and permits in year zero, a 15-month build, then a ramp-up year. The lagoon biology stabilises in that year, and the federal and state credit registrations are completed before credits can be generated and sold. The model reaches full output in year three.
Feedstock and gas production
| Feedstock and process input | Model value | Range tested | How the study sets it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Milking cows feeding the digester | 7,500 | 5,000 to 9,000 | Herd records and a feedstock agreement for the loan term |
| Volatile solids excreted per cow per day | 8.0 kg | 7.0 to 9.0 | Ration and manure tests |
| Share of manure collected to the digester | 85% | 60% to 90% | Barn and lot layout; flush or scrape records |
| Methane yield | 0.2 m3 per kg of volatile solids | 0.15 to 0.25 | Lab tests and the technology vendor's guarantee |
| Methane heating value | 37.7 MJ per m3 (higher heating value) | n/a | Engineering constant |
| Digester and upgrader availability | 92% | 85% to 95% | Vendor performance guarantee |
| Methane recovery in upgrading | 97% | 95% to 99% | Upgrader specification |
| Gas used on site or flared | 2% | 1% to 5% | Process design |
| Production step (year 3, steady state) | Model value |
|---|---|
| Methane produced | 3,723,000 m3 a year |
| Raw biogas to the upgrader (60% methane, after downtime) | 5,708,600 m3 a year |
| Gross methane energy | 133,032 MMBtu a year |
| RNG injected and sold | 116,344 MMBtu a year |
| RNG sold per cow | 15.5 MMBtu a year |
The model yields 15.5 MMBtu of RNG a year per cow. Collection is the input most specific to Idaho. Free-stall barns with flush or scrape systems capture most manure. Open dry lots, common in arid western dairies, capture much less and deliver manure mixed with soil. A digester study therefore inspects the barns and lots and models collection by group of cows, not by herd total. The engagement record notes that digesters are generally economic mainly on dairies above about 500 cows, and it cites California-funded projects averaging 7,479 cows. The modelled herd is in that range.
The revenue stack
| Revenue stream | Basis (model) | Per MMBtu sold | Year-3 revenue | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Natural gas commodity | $3.25 per MMBtu index (assumption) | $3.25 | $378,117 | 11.6% |
| Federal renewable fuel credits (D3 RINs) | 11.727 RINs per MMBtu at $2.00, project keeps 80% | $18.76 | $2,182,980 | 67.0% |
| Low-carbon fuel credits (where the offtake reaches such a market) | Net value to the project (assumption) | $6.00 | $698,062 | 21.4% |
| Total realised price | $28.01 | $3,259,159 | 100% | |
| Tax credits | Excluded from the base case | $0.00 | $0 |
Two-thirds of modelled revenue comes from RINs and another fifth from low-carbon fuel credits. The gas itself earns only $3.25 per MMBtu, about $50 a cow a year. The engagement record cites a similar figure of about $70 a cow at higher gas prices, and says low-carbon fuel programs have generated $500 to $1,000 a cow a year in strong credit years. The model's total of $435 a cow sits below that range on purpose. A lender underwrites the credit stack at a stressed price, not a strong-year one. Tax credits are excluded from every figure. The record mentions credits for clean fuel production that the study treated only as upside, and we have not verified their current status.
Project cost and sources and uses (modelled)
No construction-cost database sits behind these figures. Each line is a labelled assumption with a range, and a real study replaces it with the technology vendor's proposal, the upgrader quote, the utility's interconnection estimate and an independent engineer's review.
| Line item | Model amount | Range | Source in a real study |
|---|---|---|---|
| Covered lagoon digesters, liners, covers and mixing | $5,200,000 | $4.0M to $6.5M | Technology vendor and earthwork bids |
| Manure handling: separators, pumps, flush system changes | $1,100,000 | $0.7M to $1.6M | Dairy engineer |
| Biogas conditioning and upgrading (H2S removal, compression, membranes), flare | $5,600,000 | $4.5M to $7.0M | Upgrader quotes |
| Pipeline interconnection: gathering line, utility tap and meter station | $2,400,000 | $1.2M to $4.0M | Utility interconnection estimate |
| Site work, electrical service, controls and buildings | $1,300,000 | $0.9M to $1.8M | Contractor bids |
| Engineering, permitting and development | $900,000 | $0.6M to $1.3M | Engineer and permit consultant proposals |
| Contingency (10% of hard cost) | $1,560,000 | 7.5% to 15% | Independent engineer |
| Feasibility study (within the cost page band for complex OneRD engagements) | $15,000 | $9,500 to $18,000 | Fixed-fee proposal |
| Lender, legal and closing costs | $150,000 | $100,000 to $250,000 | Lender estimate |
| Total eligible project cost (model) | $18,225,000 |
The modelled eligible cost is $18,225,000, or $2,430 a cow, including upgrading and a pipeline connection. The engagement record cites California projects averaging $947 a cow, but its own total ($4.4 million) does not match its herd size times that cost, and the figure may exclude upgrading and interconnection. Both points are in VERIFY. Pipeline distance is the largest variable in an RNG budget. A dairy several miles from a suitable pipeline can spend more on the connection than on the digester.
| Uses | Amount | Sources (Structure A) | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eligible project cost | $18,225,000 | REAP guaranteed loan (75% of eligible cost) | $13,668,000 |
| Interest during a 15-month build (outside eligible cost in the model) | $640,688 | Owner equity: 25% of eligible cost | $4,557,000 |
| Debt service reserve (six months) | $773,892 | Owner equity: costs outside eligible cost | $2,178,596 |
| Start-up working capital (opex until credit revenue flows) | $600,000 | ||
| REAP guarantee fee (1.0% of guaranteed portion) and 0.50% fee for a guarantee before completion | $164,016 | ||
| Total | $20,403,596 | Total | $20,403,596 |
Interest during construction, the debt service reserve, start-up working capital and the guarantee fees sit outside eligible cost in this model. Whether the lender can include any of them is a structuring question for the lender and the Agency. Owners therefore fund $6,735,596 of the $20,403,596 total: 25% of eligible cost plus every cost outside it. The 0.50% fee for a guarantee issued before construction is complete is included because a lender funding a 15-month build will usually want the guarantee in place during construction [4].
What a REAP grant could add
| Grant question (rule effective 16 October 2026) | Model | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 25% of eligible project cost | $4,556,250 | [1] |
| Renewable system maximum | $500,000 | [1] |
| Largest possible grant | $500,000 | Lower of the two |
| Largest grant as a share of project cost | 2.7% | Computed |
| Loan if the full grant is planned (grant plus loan at most 75%) | $13,168,000 | [1] |
| Loan if no grant is planned | $13,668,000 | 5001.406(d) [3] |
| Earliest application | 12 to 24 months after the Project Period ends, with 12 months of production data | [1] |
At this scale the grant barely matters. The $500,000 cap is 2.7% of cost, and planning for it cuts the loan by the same amount, because grant plus loan may not exceed 75% [1]. The grant arrives only after a year of operation and a national competition. The study's financing case rests on the loan and the owners' equity, and the grant is shown as a modest later return of owner cash.
Market analysis
The market for a digester has three parts: the dairy feedstock base, the gas and credit markets, and the local economy that the dairy and its processors support.
The site and the rural test
| Measure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Burley city population, April 2020 estimates base | 11,721 | Census Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [6] |
| Burley city population, July 2025 estimate | 12,409 | [6] |
| Cassia County population, July 2025 estimate | 26,397 | Census Vintage 2025 county estimates [6] |
| Cassia and Minidoka counties, OMB status (2023) | Both non-metropolitan | OMB list1_2023 [7] |
| Twin Falls city population, April 2020 estimates base | 51,846 | [6]; the Idaho hub cites 51,807 at the 2020 Census [13] |
| Twin Falls County OMB status | Metropolitan | [7] |
Burley had 11,721 residents in the Census April 2020 estimates base, far below the 50,000 line in 7 CFR 5001.3. Cassia and Minidoka counties are non-metropolitan. Twin Falls is the Magic Valley's one city above 50,000; the Idaho hub cites 51,807 at the 2020 Census [13]. Twin Falls and its urbanized area are excluded, and Twin Falls and Jerome counties form a metropolitan area. A digester near Burley is well outside that line. One on the Twin Falls fringe needs a map check, and the hub flags Kimberly as one such place [13].
The Magic Valley dairy and processing base
The Idaho hub reports 18.26 billion pounds of milk in 2025, third in the nation, from about 350 dairy operations, with more than 70% of the state's milk cows in the Magic Valley [13]. County Business Patterns does not count farms, so the Census data below describe the processing economy the dairies supply.
| Magic Valley county | Population, July 2025 | OMB status (2023) | Food manufacturers with payroll, 2023 | Refrigerated warehouses, 2023 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cassia County | 26,397 | Non-metropolitan | 9 (1,055 employees) | 4 (200) |
| Minidoka County | 22,911 | Non-metropolitan | 15 (794 employees) | Not shown |
| Jerome County | 26,362 | Metropolitan | 12 (1,419 employees) | Not shown |
| Gooding County | 16,446 | Non-metropolitan | 10 (671 employees) | Not shown |
| Twin Falls County | 97,539 | Metropolitan | 24 (3,082 employees) | Not shown |
County Business Patterns 2023 (establishments with paid employees; suppressed cells shown as not shown); OMB 2023; Vintage 2025 county estimates [5][6][7].
Idaho: food manufacturing (excluding meat), supply and rural footprint
| Measure | Idaho | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 193 → 231 (+19.7%) | 24,589 → 27,414 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 11.7 | 8.1 |
| Average employees per establishment | 75.3 | 42.0 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $57,841 | $58,248 |
| Share of establishments in non-metro counties | 34.2% (78 in 13 counties) | |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 25.9% |
Non-metro counties with the most food manufacturing (excluding meat) (2023): Bingham County (11); Minidoka County (10); Payette County (9); Latah County (8); Madison County (7); Blaine County (6).
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
Idaho's food manufacturers are large and growing: 231 plants averaging 75.3 employees, up 19.7% since 2019, with a third of them in non-metro counties. Cassia County's 9 food manufacturers employ 1,055 people, and Minidoka's 15 employ 794. For the digester, this matters in two ways. The milk market that keeps the host dairy in business is local and deep. And the region's processors are a source of food-waste co-substrates that could raise gas output, though the model does not count on them. Idaho's food-manufacturing wage of $57,841 is the benchmark for the project's operators.
Gas and credit markets
The study does not forecast credit prices. It documents the contracts and tests the range. Points it covers:
- the pipeline's capacity and gas-quality specifications at the injection point;
- the RNG purchaser and the term, price formula and any floor in the purchase agreement;
- who registers the project and generates and sells the RINs, and the share the project keeps;
- whether any gas is delivered under a contract that earns state low-carbon fuel credits, and what carbon-intensity score the project expects.
The engagement record cites several market figures we have not verified: 394 dairy digester systems operating nationally in April 2025 and 69 RNG projects under construction in June 2024 (EPA AgSTAR); a D3 RIN value of about $3 per MMBtu, which looks low against the per-RIN conversion used in the model; LCFS credits that peaked near $200 between 2019 and 2021; and natural gas prices projected to rise from $2.21 per MMBtu in 2024 to $4.50 in 2026. The record also notes that the Idaho Dairymen's Association confirms more digesters in development in the state.
REAP activity in Idaho and the West
| State | REAP grants | REAP grant dollars | Average grant | Dollars per resident | Rank: dollars / per resident (of 53) | REAP guaranteed loans | B&I guaranteed loans |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Idaho | 93 | $21,643,985 | $232,731 | $11.77 | 16 / 7 | 0 | 10 |
| Oregon | 106 | $21,311,544 | $201,052 | $5.03 | 17 / 17 | 1 | 14 |
| Washington | 156 | $16,076,249 | $103,053 | $2.09 | 25 / 36 | 0 | 14 |
| Utah | 80 | $11,971,606 | $149,645 | $3.66 | 33 / 28 | 0 | 6 |
| Montana | 74 | $2,959,654 | $39,995 | $2.73 | 46 / 34 | 0 | 1 |
| Nevada | 10 | $2,780,525 | $278,053 | $0.90 | 49 / 48 | 0 | 4 |
USAspending prime awards by place of performance, FY2024 to FY2026, for REAP (10.868) and B&I (10.768) [9]. These awards were made under the pre-2026 rules.
Idaho took 93 REAP grants worth $21,643,985 in three years, an average of $232,731 and seventh in the nation per resident. The hub reports 27 Idaho awards totalling $7,191,103 in a single 2023 round, mostly dairy and farm solar in the Magic Valley [13]. No Idaho REAP guaranteed loan appears in the period. A $13.7 million REAP loan therefore has little recent in-state precedent, which is part of why the lender wanted an independent study.
Financing benchmark: SBA lending to renewable generation in Idaho
Idaho: SBA lending to solar and other renewable power generation
| Period | 7(a) loans | 7(a) dollars | 504 loans | 504 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2010 to FY2016 | 0 | $0 | 0 | $0 |
| FY2017 to FY2019 | 1 | $3.5 million | 0 | $0 |
| FY2020 to FY2023 | 1 | $3.6 million | 0 | $0 |
| FY2024 to FY2026 | 0 | $0 | 0 | $0 |
Average 7(a) loan, FY2020 to FY2026: $3.6 million. Idaho had fewer than 30 seasoned 7(a) loans for solar and other renewable power generation; nationally, 12.9% of 31 FY2010 to FY2016 loans were charged off, on average 51 months after approval.
Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).
The SBA record is thin, but its national loss rate is the useful number. Nearly one in eight seasoned renewable-generation 7(a) loans was charged off, on average about four years after approval. Renewable businesses fail when output or prices fall short, and RNG adds credit-price risk on top.
Financial feasibility
Operating costs
| Operating cost (steady-state volume, today's prices) | Amount | Per MMBtu sold |
|---|---|---|
| Host fee to the dairy ($20 per cow a year) | $150,000 | $1.29 |
| Operations staff (3 full-time) | $225,000 | $1.93 |
| Maintenance (3% of digester, manure and upgrading equipment) | $357,000 | $3.07 |
| Electricity for upgrading and mixing | $119,881 | $1.03 |
| Media, consumables and gas testing | $80,000 | $0.69 |
| Pipeline injection and transport fees ($0.75 per MMBtu) | $87,258 | $0.75 |
| Credit registration, verification and reporting | $60,000 | $0.52 |
| Insurance (0.6% of hard cost) | $93,600 | $0.80 |
| Property tax (placeholder) | $60,000 | $0.52 |
| Administration | $75,000 | $0.64 |
| Major maintenance reserve ($1.00 per MMBtu) | $116,344 | $1.00 |
| Total at today's prices | $1,424,082 | $12.24 |
| Total in year 3 after 2.5% a year escalation | $1,496,176 | $12.86 |
Five-year pro forma
| Line (Structure A) | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Output vs steady state (start-up, pathway approvals) | 70% | 95% | 100% | 100% | 100% |
| RNG sold (MMBtu) | 81,441 | 110,527 | 116,344 | 116,344 | 116,344 |
| Gas commodity revenue (+2% a year) | $264,682 | $366,395 | $393,393 | $401,261 | $409,286 |
| RIN revenue (project share) | $1,528,086 | $2,073,831 | $2,182,980 | $2,182,980 | $2,182,980 |
| Low-carbon fuel credit revenue | $488,644 | $663,159 | $698,062 | $698,062 | $698,062 |
| Total revenue | $2,281,412 | $3,103,386 | $3,274,435 | $3,282,303 | $3,290,328 |
| Operating costs (+2.5% a year) | -$1,327,037 | -$1,443,106 | -$1,496,176 | -$1,533,581 | -$1,571,920 |
| Net operating income | $954,374 | $1,660,280 | $1,778,259 | $1,748,722 | $1,718,408 |
| REAP loan debt service (7.50%, 15 years) | -$1,520,449 | -$1,520,449 | -$1,520,449 | -$1,520,449 | -$1,520,449 |
| Retention fee (0.25% of guaranteed balance) | -$27,336 | -$26,311 | -$25,205 | -$24,015 | -$22,731 |
| Debt service coverage | 0.62x | 1.07x | 1.15x | 1.13x | 1.11x |
On the base assumptions, coverage is 0.62 times in the ramp-up year, reaches 1.15 times in year three and drifts down to 1.11 times as costs escalate faster than gas prices while credit prices are held flat. The project covers its debt, but not with the 1.25 times margin most lenders want for a new business with volatile revenue. That is the central finding of the modelled study. The structure has to change: more equity, a longer term backed by useful-life evidence, a contracted price floor, or some mix of these.
Loan size, term and coverage
| Term at 7.50% | Annual debt service | Coverage, year 3 | Coverage, year 1 (ramp-up) | Useful-life check (5001.402) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 years | $1,730,740 | 1.01x | 0.54x | Within a 20-year equipment life |
| 15 years | $1,520,449 | 1.15x | 0.62x | Within a 20-year equipment life |
| 20 years | $1,321,302 | 1.32x | 0.71x | Equal to the assumed life: no margin |
| Loan as share of eligible cost | REAP loan | Owner share of eligible cost | Year-3 coverage, 15 years | Year-3 coverage, 20 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 75% | $13,668,750 | $4,556,250 | 1.15x | 1.32x |
| 65% | $11,846,250 | $6,378,750 | 1.33x | 1.52x |
| 55% | $10,023,750 | $8,201,250 | 1.57x | 1.80x |
Two moves reach 1.25 times without heroic assumptions. A 20-year term lifts year-three coverage to 1.32 times, but it matches the modelled 20-year equipment life with no margin, so it needs a vendor's life evidence and a funded major-maintenance reserve. Cutting the loan to 65% of eligible cost reaches 1.33 times on 15 years, at the price of $6.4 million of owner equity in eligible cost. The modelled study recommends the second, or a blend of the two. It also recommends a debt service reserve sized to cover the ramp-up shortfall.
Break-even
| Break-even test (year 3, Structure A) | Value | Model base | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|
| RIN price for 1.00x | $1.79 | $2.00 | -11% |
| RIN price for 1.25x | $2.14 | $2.00 | 7% |
| All-in realised price per MMBtu for 1.00x | $26.15 | $28.14 | -7% |
| Cows feeding the digester for 1.00x | 6,872 | 7,500 | -8% |
| Manure collection share for 1.00x | 78% | 85% | -8% |
The margins are thin on every axis. RINs 11% below the base price, an all-in price 7% lower, or 8% fewer cows or less manure collected each take the project to break-even. This is the evidence a reviewer needs to see. The feedstock agreement has to hold the herd for the loan term, collection has to be engineered rather than assumed, and the credit stack has to be tested at prices well below today's.
Credit-price and feedstock stress tests
| RIN price | No low-carbon fuel credit value | $6 per MMBtu (base) | $12 per MMBtu |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1.00 | -0.01x | 0.44x | 0.90x |
| $1.50 | 0.35x | 0.80x | 1.25x |
| $2.00 | 0.70x | 1.15x | 1.60x |
| $2.50 | 1.05x | 1.50x | 1.96x |
| $3.00 | 1.41x | 1.86x | 2.31x |
| Cows feeding the digester | 65% of manure collected | 75% | 85% (base) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5,000 | 0.25x | 0.40x | 0.55x |
| 6,000 | 0.43x | 0.61x | 0.79x |
| 7,500 | 0.70x | 0.93x | 1.15x |
| 9,000 | 0.97x | 1.24x | 1.51x |
The credit table is the most important in the study. If RIN prices fall to $1.00 and no low-carbon fuel credit is earned, the project cannot cover its operating costs. At $3.00 RINs with $12 of low-carbon value, it covers its debt more than twice. A credit committee should decide on the lower rows, and the sponsors should know that the outcome depends on federal and state programs they do not control.
Offtake structure
| Offtake structure (year 3) | RINs at $1.00 | RINs at $2.00 | RINs at $3.00 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Merchant: project sells credits at market | 0.44x | 1.15x | 1.86x |
| Index share with a floor: offtaker guarantees $20.00 per MMBtu all-in | 0.54x | 1.04x | 1.72x |
| Fixed price: $22.00 per MMBtu all-in for 10 years | 0.69x | 0.69x | 0.69x |
The offtake analysis in the record's outcome comes down to this choice. A merchant structure keeps the upside and takes all the credit-price risk. An index share with a floor gives up some upside to protect the low end, though the modelled $20.00 floor is still not enough to cover debt when RINs fall to $1.00. A fixed price removes volatility but, at a modelled $22.00, never covers the debt. A lender-grade study models the actual offer sheets and recommends the structure, or the floor level, that keeps coverage above 1.0 times in the stress cases.
Rate, overrun and delay
| Fixed rate (15 years) | Budget as modelled: year-3 coverage; owner 25% | Overrun 10% | Overrun 20% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6.50% | 1.22x; owner $4,556,250 | 1.11x; owner $5,011,875 | 1.02x; owner $5,467,500 |
| 7.50% | 1.15x; owner $4,556,250 | 1.05x; owner $5,011,875 | 0.96x; owner $5,467,500 |
| 8.50% | 1.08x; owner $4,556,250 | 0.99x; owner $5,011,875 | 0.90x; owner $5,467,500 |
| 9.50% | 1.02x; owner $4,556,250 | 0.93x; owner $5,011,875 | 0.85x; owner $5,467,500 |
| Delay case (year 1) | Base ramp-up | Six-month slip in commissioning or credit registration |
|---|---|---|
| Output vs steady state | 70% | 40% |
| Net operating income | $954,374 | $73,671 |
| Debt service and fee | $1,547,785 | $1,547,785 |
| Coverage | 0.62x | 0.05x |
| Shortfall the reserve and sponsors must cover | $593,411 | $1,474,114 |
| Six-month debt service reserve | $773,892 | $773,892 |
Construction and start-up risk is where digesters most often disappoint. A six-month slip in commissioning or in credit registration cuts year-one output to 40% of steady state and coverage to 0.05 times. That leaves a shortfall of $1,474,114 against a six-month reserve of $773,892. The study should size the reserve, or sponsor support, to that case, not the base case. It should also show the 15-month construction draw schedule with equity going in first, as 5001.205(e)(2) requires when the guarantee is issued before completion [3].
Equity, guarantees and loan-size tests
| Test | Requirement | Model result | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| REAP guaranteed loan size | $5,000 to 75% of eligible project costs | $13,668,000 = 75.0% of $18,225,000 | 5001.406(d) [3] |
| Borrower contribution | At least 25% of eligible project costs | $4,557,000 plus $2,178,596 of costs outside eligible cost = $6,735,596 | 5001.406(d) [3] |
| REAP loans to one borrower | At most $25 million | $13,668,000 | 5001.406(d)(1) [3] |
| Guarantee before construction is complete | Borrower equity injected before any guaranteed loan funds; fixed-price contract; budget and timetable confirmed by an independent consultant | Equity first in the draw schedule | 5001.205(e)(2) [3] |
| Owner guarantees | Owners of 20% or more give guarantees for at least their share | Sponsor guarantees in the term sheet | 5001.204 [3] |
| Closing balance sheet | Lender certifies equity at closing | Pro forma closing balance sheet in the study | 5001.306(a)(2) [3] |
Technical and environmental feasibility
- Technology. The study confirms that the digester and upgrading technology is commercially available and has an operating record on comparable dairies. It also confirms the vendor's guarantees on gas output, methane slip and availability. The engineer's technical report is required for the REAP loan [3], and the study reconciles its output figures with its own.
- Feedstock engineering. Barn and lot layout, flush water volumes, sand or bedding contamination, separators and pumping, and how collection changes by season.
- Gas quality and interconnection. Hydrogen sulfide, carbon dioxide, oxygen and siloxane limits at the pipeline, the utility's interconnection agreement, metering and the cost of off-spec gas.
- Water. A digester uses little water, but it sits on a dairy whose water supply must last the loan term. The Idaho hub explains that new Snake Plain projects cannot rely on a new junior groundwater right. They must document a senior right, a protected municipal supply or membership in a groundwater-district mitigation plan [13]. The study checks the host dairy's position.
- Permits and environment. Air permits for the flare and upgrader, the dairy's nutrient management plan as digestate replaces raw manure, and lagoon liner standards. The study names the state and federal agencies and the permit status. REAP grants carry their own environmental review requirements [1].
- Equipment origin. The 2026 rule's foreign-adversary bar is written for solar and wind components [1]. The record notes that the engagement also documented supply-chain provenance, which remains good practice for any federal file.
Management and governance feasibility
A digester needs operators who understand both the biology and the gas plant. The study names the operating company or O&M contractor, its record on comparable plants, and the staffing plan. In the model that is three full-time operators. It documents the relationships among the dairy, the project company, the gas buyer and the credit marketer, with each party's obligations and default remedies. Owners of 20% or more give guarantees under 5001.204 [3]. Every owner and affiliate is screened under 5001.127, and for any later grant also under the 2026 rule's bar on gambling income [3][1]. The applicant must qualify for REAP as an agricultural producer or a rural small business [3][1]. A project company owned partly by outside investors must show which it is. The study also sets out reporting: monthly gas volumes, credit generation and the 12 months of production data a grant application would need.
Economic and community impact (modelled)
| Measure (modelled) | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| RNG produced at steady state | 116,344 MMBtu a year | Production table |
| Revenue to the project, year 3 | $3,274,435 | Pro forma |
| Host fee paid to the dairy | $150,000 a year | $20 a cow |
| Operating jobs | 3 full-time | Opex table |
| Local operating spending (excluding debt service), year 3 | $1,496,176 | Opex table |
| Construction | A 15-month build with regional earthwork, electrical and pipeline crews | Schedule |
The community case is a new revenue stream for a dairy, three skilled rural jobs, and manure handled in a covered system rather than an open lagoon. The record cites EPA AgSTAR figures on the emissions reductions of dairy digesters nationally. The study should quantify the project's own reduction only from its engineering and the credit pathway's carbon-intensity score.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | Effect | Mitigant the study documents |
|---|---|---|
| Credit prices fall | Coverage falls below 1.0x at RINs under about $1.79 | Floor or index-share offtake; a smaller loan; stress cases |
| Herd shrinks or dairy closes | Gas output falls in proportion | Feedstock agreement for the loan term; minimum herd covenant; replacement-dairy option |
| Manure collection below plan | Output falls | Engineered collection by barn and lot; vendor output guarantee |
| Pipeline interconnection delay or cost | Late revenue, higher cost | Utility agreement and estimate before closing |
| Construction overrun | More equity, lower coverage | Fixed-price contract, 10% contingency, completion guarantee |
| Start-up and registration delay | Year-1 shortfall | Reserve sized to the delay case; sponsor support |
| Program rule changes | Credit value changes | No reliance on tax credits; stress tests at low credit values |
| Water supply for the host dairy | Herd at risk | Water-right or mitigation-plan evidence |
| Equipment failure | Lost output | Vendor guarantees, major-maintenance reserve, spares |
| Gambling or other ineligible income in an affiliate | Grant bar | Screen all entities |
What the five Part 5001 components showed
| Component [10] | What it tests here | What the modelled study shows |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Feedstock, contracts, cost against benefit | 7,500 cows under a 20-year agreement; $18.2 million eligible cost; 116,344 MMBtu a year |
| Market | Gas and credit buyers, price exposure | 88.4% of revenue from credits; merchant, floor and fixed offtakes compared |
| Technical | Technology record, collection, gas quality, interconnection | Commercially available covered-lagoon and upgrading technology; collection engineered by barn |
| Financial | Coverage, equity, sensitivity | 1.15x with a 75% loan on 15 years; 1.33x at 65%; break-even RINs $1.79 |
| Management | Operator, contracts, reporting | Named operator, defined counterparties, guarantees from 20% owners |
Why digester studies are returned
- Gas output from herd totals, not from engineered manure collection.
- A feedstock agreement shorter than the loan, or none.
- Credit revenue at strong-year prices with no low-price case.
- Tax credits counted in the base case.
- No pipeline interconnection estimate, or one for the wrong distance.
- No reserve for the start-up and credit-registration period.
- A technical report and study that use different output or cost.
- A loan above 75% of eligible cost, or a grant planned on top of a 75% loan.
Program terms that applied
| Term | REAP guaranteed loan (FY2026) | B&I guaranteed loan, $5 million to $25 million (FY2026) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guarantee | 80% | 80% | 91 FR 11272 [4] |
| Upfront guarantee fee | 1.0% of the guaranteed portion | 3.0% | [4] |
| Annual retention fee | 0.25% | 0.55% | [4] |
| Extra fee if the guarantee issues before construction is complete | 0.50% | 0.50% | [4] |
| Loan size | $5,000 to 75% of eligible project costs; $25 million per borrower | Up to $25 million per borrower | 5001.406(c), (d) [3] |
| Borrower money | At least 25% of eligible project costs | 10% to 25% by business type | 5001.406(d); 5001.105(d) [3] |
| Term | Useful life, at most 40 years, no balloon | Same | 5001.402 [3] |
| Rate | Negotiated; fixed, variable or both | Same | 5001.401 [3] |
| Rural test | Outside cities over 50,000 and their contiguous urbanized areas | Same | 5001.3 [3] |
| Gambling screen | More than 15% of gross revenue from gambling bars the loan | Same | 5001.127(b) [3] |
| Feasibility study | When the lender or Agency deems it necessary; technical report required | Required over $1,000,000 to a new business | 5001.306(a)(3), 5001.307 [3] |
The 2026 CFR lists renewable energy systems as B&I uses where REAP cannot finance them or REAP funds are unavailable (5001.105(b)(21)) [3]. A digester that qualifies for REAP would normally use the REAP guarantee, with its lower fees. These FY2026 rates apply to loans obligated in FY2026 unless a later appropriation changes them [4]. A loan obligated in a later year uses that year's notice.
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Engineer the feedstock, then contract it. Output follows collected manure, not herd size. Lock the herd and collection into an agreement at least as long as the loan.
- Underwrite the credits at the bottom of the range. Most of the revenue is policy-driven. Show the lender coverage at low credit prices and decide how much floor protection to buy.
- Expect to put in more than 25%. The REAP cap sets the minimum. At realistic coverage targets, owners in the model fund closer to 35% of eligible cost plus every cost outside it.
- Fund the ramp-up. Biology, commissioning and credit registration take months. Size the reserve to a six-month slip, not the plan.
- Price the pipeline early. Interconnection distance can decide feasibility before anything else does.
- Do not plan around the grant. At $500,000 it is a small, late and competitive return on an $18 million project.
- Check the dairy's water. On the Snake Plain the host dairy's water position is part of the digester's credit.
- Keep tax credits as upside. Leave them out of the base case unless tax counsel confirms them for this project and year.
Related pages
- USDA REAP engagements: the program page for this engagement type.
- Renewable energy feasibility study for USDA loans and the USDA REAP feasibility study page: the national pages for digesters and other renewable systems.
- Idaho USDA feasibility studies, with the Idaho renewable energy feasibility study and Idaho food processing feasibility study pages.
- Case studies and the full engagement index.
- USDA feasibility study cost and timeline.
The site's cost page lists REAP studies above a $600,000 loan at $7,500 to $11,500 over 5 to 7 weeks, and complex OneRD engagements at $9,500 to $18,000 over 7 to 10 weeks, each as a firm fixed fee in a written proposal [11]. For a dairy, digester developer or lender weighing an RNG project, an independent USDA feasibility study consultant can build the feedstock, offtake and credit-price case the lender and USDA will test.
Request a scoped proposal for your digester feasibility study at the contact page.
USDA Feasibility, Inc.