How to read this case study. The engagement summary reflects the published record. Client names, actual costs, loan terms and proprietary data are confidential, so the project budget, market sizing and financial projections below are a modeled example built from public data for this project type and location. They show the analysis a lender-grade study performs, not the client's figures.
Data current as of November 2026.
Engagement summary
This engagement paired two projects at one agricultural site in Sidney, Montana: replacing a propane grain dryer with a high-efficiency unit, and adding a roof-mounted solar array. It was prepared in 2024 for a community bank using a REAP guarantee, and it was built on documented historical energy use. The rules have changed twice since then. USDA rescinded the FY2025 to FY2027 REAP funding notice in April 2026 [2], and a new REAP rule took effect on 16 October 2026 [1]. This page therefore describes the engagement type, models a project of this kind in Richland County, and shows how it is financed and what a study must prove under the rule in force now.
| Item | Published record |
|---|---|
| Program | USDA Rural Energy for America Program (REAP) |
| Asset class (as indexed) | Manufacturing |
| Project | Grain dryer efficiency and roof-mount solar |
| Location | Sidney, Montana (Richland County) |
| Region | Mountain West |
| Loan size tier | Under $5M |
| Year prepared | 2024 |
| Lender type | Community bank with REAP guarantee |
| Outcome | Prepared with documented historical energy use |
Sources: the site's engagement index [12]; county from Census place files [6].
The record also describes the deliverables: a baseline energy audit of historical kilowatt-hours and propane use per bushel for the existing dryer, with the projected efficiency change for the replacement, and a solar system sized with NREL's PVWatts method at an average of about 4.5 peak sun-hours a day. Those inputs carry straight into the model below. The record also lists the grant caps and cost-share terms of the FY2025 to FY2027 notice under which the study was written. That notice was rescinded on 15 April 2026 [2], and none of its terms is used here.
The question the lender and USDA needed answered
A grain dryer upgrade and a rooftop array look like small projects, but together they ask a lender three separate questions.
- Are the savings real? A dryer's fuel use swings with the harvest. A wet year can double the propane bill and a dry year can nearly erase it, so savings claimed from a single season prove little. The study has to rebuild the baseline from several years of propane invoices, scale tickets and moisture logs, and express it per bushel and per point of moisture removed.
- Does the solar array fit the load? On a grain farm, electricity demand peaks at harvest in autumn, while solar output peaks in summer. An array sized to annual kilowatt-hours can still export much of its output at a low credit. The study has to show the share of output the site will use itself.
- Who repays the loan? Energy savings rarely cover the debt service on a dryer by themselves. The lender is underwriting the farm, and the study has to show the farm's global cash flow carries the new payment with room to spare.
Why a study at all? Under 7 CFR part 5001, a REAP guaranteed loan for a renewable energy system needs a technical report, and a feasibility study when the lender or the Agency deems one necessary [3]. Since 16 October 2026, a REAP grant needs an energy audit for efficiency projects above $80,000 and a resource assessment, or a feasibility study in its place, for renewable systems [1]. The new rule also turned the simple payback calculation into an eligibility test: a project whose payback exceeds its useful life cannot receive a grant [1]. A dual-component project needs a study that holds the audit, the production model and the lender's credit case together, with the same numbers in each.
What changed for this engagement type on 16 October 2026
| Topic | Rule effective 16 October 2026 [1] | What it means for a dryer-plus-solar project |
|---|---|---|
| Timing | Project Period must end 12 to 24 months before the grant application (12 to 36 months in the first window) | The loan builds the project; a grant can only follow a season of operation |
| Data | 12 months of actual savings or production plus 12 months of pre-installation data | The dryer's first harvest after installation becomes the evidence |
| Award size | $500,000 for renewable systems, $250,000 for efficiency, at most 25% of cost | The efficiency cap binds on dryers costing more than $1 million |
| Combined funding | Grant plus REAP guaranteed loan at most 75% of project cost | A loan at 75% leaves no room for a later grant |
| Loan alone | A REAP guaranteed loan without a grant is capped at 75% of eligible costs, with at least 25% from the borrower (7 CFR 5001.406(d)) | The owner funds at least a quarter even when no grant is planned [3] |
| Cropland | Ground-mount solar or wind on Cropland is ineligible for a grant | Roof mounting keeps the array eligible; a field array would not be |
| Foreign components | Solar systems with any component from a foreign adversary under 15 CFR 791.4 are ineligible | A country-of-origin list for modules, inverters and racking |
| Economics | Simple payback must not exceed useful life | Each component is tested on its own |
| Applicant | One application per federal fiscal year from each highest-level owner | Dryer and solar may need to be sequenced across years |
| Gambling | Any gambling income bars a grant; the loan keeps only the 15% test in 5001.127(b) | A revenue screen before scoping |
Project description (modelled)
The modelled operation dries and stores grain at a single farmstead near Sidney. The project has two components, installed together between harvests so that neither disrupts a fall season.
Component 1, energy efficiency improvement. The existing propane tower dryer is replaced with a dryer of similar capacity (a 1,500-bushel-an-hour class) with heat recovery, variable-speed fans and moisture-based discharge control. The model assumes 500,000 bushels dried a year, taken from 23% to 15% moisture. That removes 5.78 pounds of water from each bushel on the standard 56-pound corn bushel. The existing dryer is assumed to use 2,600 BTU per pound of water removed and the replacement 1,450, a 44.2% fuel cut. The engagement record cites USDA REAP recipient surveys reporting fuel-cost cuts of up to 50% for high-efficiency dryers. We have not verified that figure, and the model stays below it.
Component 2, renewable energy system. A 75 kW (DC) array goes on the roofs of the shop and machine shed, sized to the electricity the site will still buy once the new dryer's fans run on variable-speed drives. The array does not touch cropland, which keeps it outside the new grant rule's ground-mount bar.
Timeline. Audit and design in late winter, bids and loan approval in spring, removal of the old dryer and installation in June and July, commissioning before the first fall harvest, solar energised in August. Under the 2026 rule the grant clock starts when the Project Period ends. The earliest grant application therefore follows twelve months of metered results: the first harvest with the new dryer and a full solar year.
Energy baseline and dryer savings
| Input | Model value | Range tested | How a real study sets it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bushels dried per year | 500,000 | 300,000 to 650,000 | Scale tickets and dryer logs, at least three harvests |
| Crop modelled | Corn, 56 lb per bushel at 15.5% moisture | Small grains dried in wet years | Crop records; each crop modelled separately |
| Average moisture in / out | 23% / 15% | 5 to 10 points removed | Moisture tester logs by load |
| Water removed per bushel (computed) | 5.78 lb | n/a | Computed from moisture in and out |
| Existing dryer fuel use | 2,600 BTU per lb of water | 2,300 to 2,900 | Energy audit: metered propane against bushels and moisture |
| Replacement dryer fuel use | 1,450 BTU per lb of water | 1,300 to 1,700 | Manufacturer rating, adjusted by the auditor |
| Propane heating value | 91,500 BTU per gallon | n/a | Engineering constant (approximate) |
| Propane price, delivered | $1.75 per gallon | $1.25 to $2.50 | Three years of propane invoices |
| Dryer electricity, existing / replacement | 0.30 / 0.24 kWh per bushel | +/- 25% | Utility bills, motor nameplates, fan curves |
| Avoided electricity value | $0.115 per kWh | $0.09 to $0.14 | The serving utility's tariff |
| Line | Existing dryer | Replacement dryer | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Water removed per year (lb) | 2,891,979 | 2,891,979 | 0 |
| Propane (gallons per year) | 82,176 | 45,829 | -36,347 |
| Propane (MMBtu per year) | 7,519 | 4,193 | -3,326 |
| Dryer electricity (kWh per year) | 150,000 | 120,000 | -30,000 |
| Propane cost | $143,809 | $80,201 | -$63,608 |
| Electricity cost | $17,250 | $13,800 | -$3,450 |
| Energy cost per bushel dried | $0.322 | $0.188 | -$0.134 |
| Annual energy savings, year 1 | $67,058 |
The per-bushel line is the one a farm lender reads first. On these assumptions the existing dryer spends about $0.322 in energy per bushel dried and the replacement $0.188, a saving of $0.134 per bushel. The engagement record cites a propane drying cost of about $0.42 a bushel to remove 10 points of moisture, set against a market moisture discount of about $0.65 a bushel for the same wet grain. That spread explains why farms dry at all, and the study should test it against the farm's own sale records. We have not verified those figures. The record also notes that roughly 75% to 80% of Montana producers use propane-fired dryers; that figure is also unverified, and a study should not rest on it.
Solar production and sizing
| Input | Model value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Peak sun-hours per day | 4.5 | Figure cited in the engagement record for the site; a real study runs an hourly production model for the exact roof |
| Performance ratio (losses for temperature, soiling, snow, wiring, inverter) | 0.80 | Assumption; snow cover on low-pitch roofs is tested separately |
| Year-1 output per kW (computed) | 1,314 kWh | Peak sun-hours x 365 x performance ratio |
| Degradation | 0.5% a year | Assumption; module warranty sets it |
| Installed cost | $2.40 per watt plus $20,000 fixed (structural review, interconnection, engineering) | Assumption with a $2.10 to $3.00 range; installer bids set it |
| Site load before / after the dryer project | 245,000 / 215,000 kWh | Assumption; twelve months or more of utility bills set it |
| Value of output used on site | $0.115 per kWh | Assumption; tariff energy and demand charges |
| Value of exported output | $0.040 per kWh | Assumption; the utility's net metering or export tariff |
| Operation and maintenance | $20 per kW a year | Assumption, including an inverter reserve |
| Useful life used for the payback test | 25 years | Assumption tied to module warranty |
Right-sizing is where a grain-farm array is won or lost. The table below runs four sizes through the same assumptions. The share of output used on site falls as the array grows, because summer production meets a load that peaks in autumn.
| Array (DC) | Year-1 output (kWh) | Output as share of post-project load | Assumed share used on site | Installed cost with 5% contingency (model) | Year-1 energy value | Simple payback | Payback within 25-year life? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50 kW | 65,700 | 31% | 80% | $147,000 | $6,570 | 22.4 years | Yes |
| 75 kW | 98,550 | 46% | 70% | $210,000 | $9,116 | 23.0 years | Yes |
| 100 kW | 131,400 | 61% | 60% | $273,000 | $11,169 | 24.4 years | Yes |
| 150 kW | 197,100 | 92% | 45% | $399,000 | $14,536 | 27.4 years | No |
The 75 kW array produces 98,550 kWh in year one, 46% of the site's post-project load of 215,000 kWh, and passes the payback test with two years to spare. At 150 kW the array would cover 92% of annual kilowatt-hours on paper, but more than half its output would be exported at a low credit, and payback would run past the module life. A ground-mounted system would also have to show "commensurate historical energy usage" to be eligible for a grant [1]. The roof system faces no such test, but the economics impose the same discipline. A real study replaces the assumed on-site shares with an hourly match of modelled production against twelve months or more of interval meter data.
Project cost and sources and uses (modelled)
No construction-cost database sits behind these numbers. Each line is an assumption stated with a range, and a real study replaces it with the dryer manufacturer's quote, the installers' bids, the electrician's estimate and the utility's interconnection terms.
| Line item | Model amount | Range | Source in a real study |
|---|---|---|---|
| Efficiency: High-efficiency dryer with heat recovery, delivered (1,500 bushels an hour class) | $620,000 | $540,000 to $720,000 | Equipment quotes |
| Efficiency: Foundation, wet-bin and leg tie-ins, conveyor changes | $85,000 | $60,000 to $120,000 | Contractor bid |
| Efficiency: Electrical service upgrade and variable-speed fan drives | $48,000 | $35,000 to $70,000 | Electrician bid |
| Efficiency: Propane piping, burner controls and moisture sensors | $30,000 | $20,000 to $40,000 | Contractor bid |
| Efficiency: Removal of the existing dryer | $12,000 | $8,000 to $20,000 | Contractor bid |
| Efficiency: Engineering and permits | $14,000 | $8,000 to $20,000 | Engineer proposal |
| Efficiency: contingency (7.5% of hard cost) | $60,675 | 5% to 10% | Lender and engineer judgment |
| Efficiency: energy audit (required above $80,000 for a grant) | $9,000 | $5,000 to $15,000 | Auditor proposal |
| Efficiency subtotal | $878,675 | ||
| Solar: Modules, inverters, racking and installation, 75 kW DC | $180,000 | $157,500 to $225,000 | Installer bids ($2.10 to $3.00 per watt) |
| Solar: Roof structural review and any reinforcement | $6,000 | $3,000 to $25,000 | Structural engineer |
| Solar: Interconnection, metering and utility study | $9,000 | $5,000 to $20,000 | Utility interconnection agreement |
| Solar: Design engineering and production model | $5,000 | $3,000 to $8,000 | Engineer proposal |
| Solar: contingency (5% of hard cost) | $10,000 | 5% to 10% | Lender and engineer judgment |
| Solar subtotal | $210,000 | ||
| Feasibility study (within the cost page band for REAP loans above $600,000) | $9,500 | $7,500 to $11,500 | Fixed-fee proposal |
| Loan closing, legal and lien searches | $6,000 | $4,000 to $10,000 | Lender estimate |
| Total eligible project cost (model) | $1,104,175 |
| Cost outside the eligible budget | Model amount | Who pays and why |
|---|---|---|
| REAP guarantee fee (1.0% of the guaranteed portion, Structure A) | $6,625 | Borrower at closing; FY2026 REAP rate [4] |
| Interest during a four-month installation (half drawn on average, Structure A) | $10,006 | Borrower from operating cash; installation sits between harvests |
| Annual retention fee, year 1 (0.25% of guaranteed principal outstanding) | $1,656 | Lender, usually passed to the borrower [4] |
| Working capital for propane during the first harvest | None added | Fuel spend falls; the farm operating line already carries it |
Two ways to finance it
Structure A borrows the maximum REAP guaranteed loan, 75% of eligible cost, and plans no grant. Structure B borrows less and leaves room under the 75% combined cap for a REAP grant on the dryer, applied for after twelve months of savings data. Under the rule's one-application-per-fiscal-year limit, the solar component is left to a later year or to no grant at all.
| Uses | Amount | Sources: Structure A (loan only) | Amount | Sources: Structure B (loan, later grant) | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dryer efficiency project | $878,675 | REAP guaranteed loan (75% of eligible cost) | $828,100 | REAP guaranteed loan | $608,500 |
| Roof-mount solar | $210,000 | Owner contribution (25%) | $276,075 | Owner cash at construction | $495,675 |
| Feasibility study | $9,500 | REAP grant | $0 | REAP grant applied for 12 to 24 months after completion (efficiency part) | $219,600 |
| Closing and legal | $6,000 | Owner cash returned if the grant is awarded | -$219,600 | ||
| Total eligible project cost | $1,104,175 | Total | $1,104,175 | Total net of grant, if awarded | $1,104,175 |
| Test under the rule effective 16 October 2026 | Efficiency (dryer) | Solar | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Component cost (model) | $878,675 | $210,000 | Budget table |
| 25% of cost | $219,669 | $52,500 | Cost share at least 75% [1] |
| Program maximum | $250,000 | $500,000 | [1] |
| Largest possible grant | $219,669 | $52,500 | Lower of the two lines above |
| Room left under the 75% combined cap if the loan is at 75% (Structure A) | $0 | $0 | Grant plus loan at most 75% [1] |
| Structure B: grant modelled | $219,600 | $0 (one application per fiscal year; solar left to a later year or none) | Applicant rule [1] |
| Earliest application | 12 months after the Project Period ends, with 12 months of savings data | 12 months of production data | Timing rule [1] |
Structure B looks cheaper, but it asks the owner for $495,675 at construction instead of $276,075, and it returns $219,600 only if a competitive national grant is awarded a year or more later. The new rule runs one national competition for requests over $20,000 [1], and as of 7 November 2026 no funding notice under the rule had appeared. A lender should underwrite Structure B on its own debt service, treat the grant as an upside that may never arrive, and test the farm's liquidity for the bridge. For most borrowers Structure A is the base case and Structure B is the option.
Market analysis
A dryer and an array sell nothing, so the market section of this study answers a different question from a hotel or a meat plant study. It asks whether the operation's grain volume, crop mix and moisture history support the savings, and whether the regional energy market makes the avoided costs durable. The demand drivers are the acres the farm or its customers harvest, the moisture at harvest, the price of propane delivered to the farm and the electric tariff. The competitive question is whether the farm's drying cost per bushel keeps it in line with the elevators and neighbours who would otherwise dry or discount its grain.
The site and the rural test
| Measure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Sidney city population, April 2020 estimates base | 6,338 | Census Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [6] |
| Sidney city population, July 2025 estimate | 6,217 | Census Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [6] |
| Richland County population, April 2020 estimates base | 11,488 | Census Vintage 2025 county estimates [6] |
| Richland County population, July 2025 estimate | 11,377 | Census Vintage 2025 county estimates [6] |
| Richland County OMB status, July 2023 delineation | Non-metropolitan | OMB list1_2023 [7] |
| Montana counties that are non-metropolitan | 46 of 56 | OMB list1_2023 [7] |
| Montana cities above 50,000 (2020 estimates base) | Billings (117,147); Missoula (74,190); Great Falls (60,481); Bozeman (53,596) | Census Vintage 2025 subcounty estimates [6] |
| Richland County manufacturing establishments with payroll, 2023 | 12 (368 employees) | County Business Patterns 2023 [5] |
| Of which food manufacturing | 3 (206 employees) | County Business Patterns 2023 [5] |
Sidney is far below the 50,000-person line in 7 CFR 5001.3. Montana's four cities above that line are Billings, Missoula, Great Falls and Bozeman, and none of them, nor any urbanized area around them, reaches Richland County. Under OMB's 2023 delineation, Richland County is one of Montana's 46 non-metropolitan counties out of 56. The rural test is applied to the latest decennial census, so the study should cite the 2020 Census count and a dated USDA eligibility map determination for the parcel. The estimates base above is the same April 2020 benchmark, but it is a proxy for the census count, not the count itself. The engagement record also cites a 46.6% rural population share for Montana. The data pack's measure, residents of non-metro counties, puts the share at 44.7% in 2025. These are different definitions, and the study should say which one it uses.
Rural manufacturing and agricultural processing in Montana
The site indexes this engagement under manufacturing, and the state data pack for Montana manufacturing describes the rural business base the community bank lends to. Grain drying on a farm is agricultural production, which County Business Patterns does not count, so these tables describe the lender's market, not the farm itself.
Montana: manufacturing establishments (all), supply and rural footprint
| Measure | Montana | United States |
|---|---|---|
| Establishments, 2019 → 2023 | 1,358 → 1,393 (+2.6%) | 287,626 → 284,452 |
| Per 100,000 residents (2023) | 123.2 | 84.5 |
| Average employees per establishment | 15.7 | 43.4 |
| Average annual pay per employee | $64,517 | $73,202 |
| Share of establishments in non-metro counties | 45.9% (632 in 30 counties) | |
| Share of state population in non-metro counties (2025) | 44.7% |
Non-metro counties with the most manufacturing establishments (all) (2023): Flathead County (193); Ravalli County (95); Lake County (41); Silver Bow County (37); Lincoln County (29); Park County (28).
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, County Business Patterns 2019 and 2023 (state and county files; establishments with paid employees; employment and payroll suppressed in some cells); Vintage 2025 county population estimates; OMB metropolitan statistical area delineation, July 2023. Non-metro county is a proxy for USDA rural eligibility, not the eligibility test itself.
Montana has more manufacturers per resident than the nation (123.2 per 100,000 against 84.5), but they are small: 15.7 employees on average against 43.4 nationally. Nearly half sit in non-metro counties. Richland County's 12 manufacturing establishments employ 368 people, and 3 food manufacturers account for 206 of them, which ties local industry to the crops grown around it. For this study the useful benchmark is pay. Montana's average manufacturing wage of $64,517 sets the cost of the electricians and millwrights who install and maintain the equipment, and of any seasonal labour the drying operation already carries.
The state data pack for solar and renewable generation shows no Montana establishment with payroll whose main activity is solar generation, in 2019 or 2023. That is expected. A farm array belongs to the farm, not to a separate generating company, and it is why REAP award data, not Census counts, measure rural energy activity in the state.
REAP activity in Montana and its neighbours
| State | REAP grants | REAP grant dollars | Average grant | Dollars per resident | Rank per resident | REAP guaranteed loans | B&I guaranteed loans |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Montana | 74 | $2,959,654 | $39,995 | $2.73 | 34 of 53 | 0 | 1 |
| North Dakota | 55 | $11,261,321 | $204,751 | $14.45 | 4 of 53 | 0 | 2 |
| South Dakota | 78 | $12,309,780 | $157,818 | $13.88 | 5 of 53 | 1 | 3 |
| Wyoming | 37 | $2,881,629 | $77,882 | $5.00 | 18 of 53 | 0 | 3 |
| Idaho | 93 | $21,643,985 | $232,731 | $11.77 | 7 of 53 | 0 | 10 |
USAspending prime awards by place of performance, FY2024 to FY2026, for REAP (10.868) and B&I (10.768); dollars per resident use the population figures in the USAspending data; ranks are among the 53 states and territories with REAP grant dollars [9]. These awards were made under the pre-2026 rules.
Montana's 74 REAP grants averaged $39,995, against $204,751 in North Dakota and $232,731 in Idaho. The state ranks 46th of 53 in REAP grant dollars and 34th per resident. The pattern points to many small efficiency and solar grants and few large ones, and to an untapped share of larger projects like a dryer replacement. No Montana REAP guaranteed loan appears in the period, and the Montana hub notes a single B&I loan award [13]. A Montana reviewer may have little recent in-state precedent for a REAP-guaranteed dryer loan, so the study has to carry its own evidence.
Financing benchmark: SBA lending to Montana manufacturers
Montana: SBA lending to manufacturing establishments (all)
| Period | 7(a) loans | 7(a) dollars | 504 loans | 504 dollars |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2010 to FY2016 | 176 | $60.9 million | 18 | $11.3 million |
| FY2017 to FY2019 | 46 | $11.2 million | 2 | $385,000 |
| FY2020 to FY2023 | 57 | $30.0 million | 9 | $9.4 million |
| FY2024 to FY2026 | 21 | $14.6 million | 2 | $1.8 million |
Average 7(a) loan, FY2020 to FY2026: $571,846. Average 504 loan: $1.0 million. Of the 176 7(a) loans approved in FY2010 to FY2016 for Montana manufacturing establishments (all), 4.0% were charged off (national: 6.4% of 27,078), on average 71 months after approval.
Source: SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan data, as of 30 Sep 2026 (project state; disbursed loans only; cancelled and undisbursed loans excluded).
The modelled REAP loan of $828,100 sits above the average Montana manufacturing 7(a) loan of $571,846. Seasoned losses in the state ran below the national rate (4.0% against 6.4%). Neither figure describes farm lending directly, but both give a community bank's credit committee a frame for a loan of this size outside the state's cities.
Prices the study must source, not assume
The model's propane price ($1.75 a gallon delivered), electricity value ($0.115 a kWh) and export credit ($0.04 a kWh) are labelled assumptions. A lender-grade study uses the farm's own invoices for at least three heating seasons, the serving utility's current tariff and export terms (an investor-owned utility or a rural electric cooperative, depending on the parcel), and a written note on when those tariffs next come up for review. The sensitivity tables below show how far each price can move before the case fails.
Financial feasibility
Five-year pro forma at project level
| Line (Structure A) | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Propane savings (price +2% a year) | $63,608 | $64,880 | $66,177 | $67,501 | $68,851 |
| Dryer electricity savings (+2.5% a year) | $3,450 | $3,536 | $3,625 | $3,715 | $3,808 |
| Solar energy value (0.5% degradation) | $9,116 | $9,268 | $9,423 | $9,581 | $9,742 |
| Total energy benefit | $76,174 | $77,684 | $79,225 | $80,797 | $82,401 |
| Solar operation and maintenance | -$1,500 | -$1,500 | -$1,500 | -$1,500 | -$1,500 |
| Insurance on new equipment (0.35% of hard cost) | -$3,532 | -$3,532 | -$3,532 | -$3,532 | -$3,532 |
| Property tax increment | -$1,500 | -$1,500 | -$1,500 | -$1,500 | -$1,500 |
| Net project benefit (project NOI) | $69,642 | $71,152 | $72,693 | $74,266 | $75,870 |
| REAP loan debt service (7.25%, 15 years) | -$90,713 | -$90,713 | -$90,713 | -$90,713 | -$90,713 |
| Retention fee if passed to borrower | -$1,656 | -$1,593 | -$1,525 | -$1,451 | -$1,372 |
| Project-level coverage (NOI / debt service and fee) | 0.75x | 0.77x | 0.79x | 0.81x | 0.82x |
The project does not pay for itself at the project level, and the study should say so plainly. On the model, energy benefits net of new costs reach $69,642 in year one against $92,369 of debt service and retention fee: 0.75 times coverage, rising to 0.82 times by year five as propane and power prices escalate. That is normal for an efficiency project on a 15-year amortisation. It does not mean the project fails. It means the repayment source is the farm.
Global coverage: the farm carries the loan
| Year | Farm cash flow before project (model) | Project NOI | Cash available | Existing debt service (model) | New REAP debt service and fee | Total debt service | Coverage before project | Global coverage after project |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $640,000 | $69,642 | $709,642 | $390,000 | $92,369 | $482,369 | 1.64x | 1.47x |
| Year 2 | $640,000 | $71,152 | $711,152 | $390,000 | $92,306 | $482,306 | 1.64x | 1.47x |
| Year 3 | $640,000 | $72,693 | $712,693 | $390,000 | $92,238 | $482,238 | 1.64x | 1.48x |
| Year 4 | $640,000 | $74,266 | $714,266 | $390,000 | $92,164 | $482,164 | 1.64x | 1.48x |
| Year 5 | $640,000 | $75,870 | $715,870 | $390,000 | $92,086 | $482,086 | 1.64x | 1.48x |
The farm's cash flow and existing debt service above are modelled placeholders, because they are the client's confidential figures. The method is the point. Part 5001 asks the lender for a global credit evaluation, with historical and projected debt service coverage for the borrower and its affiliates [3]. Here, adding the new loan takes modelled coverage from 1.64 times to 1.47 times in year one, and the dryer savings recover part of the drop every year after.
Term choice
| Term (7.25% fixed, Structure A loan) | Annual debt service | With year-1 retention fee | Project-level coverage, year 1 | Global coverage, year 1 | Useful-life check (5001.402) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 years | $116,664 | $118,320 | 0.59x | 1.40x | Within the dryer and module lives |
| 15 years | $90,713 | $92,369 | 0.75x | 1.47x | Within the dryer and module lives |
| 20 years | $78,541 | $80,197 | 0.87x | 1.51x | Within the dryer and module lives |
The term must stay within useful life, with no balloon, under 5001.402 [3]. A 20-year term lifts project-level coverage to 0.87 times and global coverage to 1.51 times, but it matches the dryer's assumed 20-year life exactly, leaving nothing in reserve if the dryer wears out early. Fifteen years keeps a margin. The study should state the useful life it relies on for each component and cite the manufacturer's evidence for it.
Payback: the grant eligibility test
| Component | Project cost (model) | Year-1 energy value | Simple payback | Useful life assumed | Passes the grant test? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dryer efficiency | $878,675 | $67,058 | 13.1 years | 20 years | Yes |
| Roof-mount solar, 75 kW | $210,000 | $9,116 | 23.0 years | 25 years | Yes |
| Whole project including study and closing costs | $1,104,175 | $76,174 | 14.5 years | n/a | n/a |
Each component passes on the model, but not by the same margin. The dryer pays back in 13.1 years against a 20-year life. The solar array needs 23.0 years against 25. Part 5001 defines simple payback as total project cost divided by the annual dollar value of energy produced or saved, excluding one-time benefits and tax credits [3], and the new REAP rule makes it a hard test for the grant [1]. A thin solar margin is a warning that a lower export credit or a weaker production year could disqualify that component from a grant even though the loan is unaffected.
Break-even and stress tests
| Break-even test (year 1, Structure A) | Value | Model base | Margin |
|---|---|---|---|
| Propane price for project-level 1.00x | $2.38 per gallon | $1.75 | 36% |
| Propane price for project-level 1.25x | $3.01 per gallon | $1.75 | 72% |
| Bushels dried for project-level 1.00x (8 points, $1.75 propane) | 669,459 | 500,000 | 34% |
| Farm cash flow before project for global 1.00x | $412,727 | $640,000 | -36% |
| Farm cash flow before project for global 1.25x | $533,319 | $640,000 | -17% |
| Bushels dried | 5 points removed: NOI (coverage) | 8 points (base) | 10 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| 300,000 | $27,613 (0.30x) | $42,819 (0.46x) | $53,632 (0.58x) |
| 400,000 | $35,956 (0.39x) | $56,231 (0.61x) | $70,648 (0.76x) |
| 500,000 | $44,298 (0.48x) | $69,642 (0.75x) | $87,664 (0.95x) |
| 650,000 | $56,813 (0.62x) | $89,759 (0.97x) | $113,188 (1.23x) |
Harvest moisture is the largest variable in this project. A dry year with 5 points removed on 300,000 bushels cuts project NOI to $27,613. A wet year with 10 points on 650,000 bushels raises it to $113,188. A study that presents one year's savings as permanent will be sent back. The model's 500,000 bushels at 8 points is meant as a multi-year average, and the audit must show the years behind it.
| Propane price per gallon | Replacement dryer at 1,700 BTU/lb | At 1,450 (base) | At 1,300 |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1.25 | $41,591 (0.45x) | $51,468 (0.56x) | $57,395 (0.62x) |
| $1.50 | $48,703 (0.53x) | $60,555 (0.66x) | $67,667 (0.73x) |
| $1.75 | $55,814 (0.60x) | $69,642 (0.75x) | $77,939 (0.84x) |
| $2.10 | $65,770 (0.71x) | $82,364 (0.89x) | $92,320 (1.00x) |
| $2.50 | $77,149 (0.84x) | $96,903 (1.05x) | $108,755 (1.18x) |
| Fixed rate | Budget as modelled | Overrun 10% | Overrun 20% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6.25% | $86,860; owner $276,075; global 1.49x | $95,545; owner $303,692; global 1.46x | $104,240; owner $331,210; global 1.44x |
| 7.25% | $92,369; owner $276,075; global 1.47x | $101,605; owner $303,692; global 1.44x | $110,852; owner $331,210; global 1.42x |
| 8.25% | $98,061; owner $276,075; global 1.45x | $107,866; owner $303,692; global 1.43x | $117,683; owner $331,210; global 1.40x |
| 9.25% | $103,929; owner $276,075; global 1.44x | $114,321; owner $303,692; global 1.41x | $124,725; owner $331,210; global 1.38x |
Because the loan stays at 75% of cost, a 20% overrun raises the owner's share to $331,210 as well as the debt service. With rates at 9.25% and a 20% overrun together, global coverage still holds at 1.38 times on the model. Under 5001.401 the rate is negotiated, fixed or variable [3]. A fixed rate removes one variable from a project whose savings already move with weather and fuel markets.
| Delay case (Structure A, year 1) | Base | Dryer misses first harvest |
|---|---|---|
| Dryer savings in year 1 | $67,058 | $0 |
| Solar value in year 1 | $9,116 | $9,116 |
| Project NOI | $69,642 | $2,584 |
| Debt service and fee | $92,369 | $92,369 |
| Global coverage | 1.47x | 1.33x |
| Extra interest if the loan sits fully drawn for six idle months | $0 | $30,019 |
| REAP grant timing (Structure B) | 12 to 24 months after completion | Grant application moves back one fiscal year |
A missed harvest is the delay that matters. If the dryer is not running by the first fall, year-one project NOI falls to $2,584 and global coverage to 1.33 times. If the loan sits fully drawn through the idle months, another $30,019 of interest accrues. The schedule protects against this by ordering the dryer early, installing in summer and making completion before harvest a condition of the construction contract.
| Export credit per kWh | Output 15% below model | Output as modelled | Output 10% above |
|---|---|---|---|
| $0.02 | $7,246; payback 29.0 years | $8,525; payback 24.6 years | $9,377; payback 22.4 years |
| $0.04 | $7,748; payback 27.1 years | $9,116; payback 23.0 years | $10,027; payback 20.9 years |
| $0.06 | $8,251; payback 25.5 years | $9,707; payback 21.6 years | $10,678; payback 19.7 years |
Equity and loan-size tests
| Test | Requirement | Model result (Structure A) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| REAP guaranteed loan size | At least $5,000 and at most 75% of eligible project costs | $828,100 = 75.0% of $1,104,175 | 7 CFR 5001.406(d) [3] |
| Borrower contribution | At least 25% of total eligible project costs, with or without a grant | $276,075 = 25.0% | 7 CFR 5001.406(d) [3] |
| REAP loans to one borrower | At most $25 million, guaranteed and unguaranteed portions together | $828,100 | 5001.406(d)(1) [3] |
| Grant plus loan | At most 75% of Project Cost | Structure B: $828,100 = 75.0% | 4280.122(b)(20) [1] |
| Studies, technical reports and audits inside the loan | At most 10% of the loan in total | $18,500 = 2.2% of the loan | Part 5001 [3] |
| Closing balance sheet and equity certification | Lender certifies at closing | Pro forma closing balance sheet in the study | 5001.306(a)(2) [3] |
The 25% contribution applies whether or not a grant is ever sought, a point the record's older program summary did not capture. A REAP guaranteed loan on its own may not exceed 75% of eligible project costs, and the borrower must show at least 25% [3]. Separately, grant and loan together may not exceed 75% of project cost [1]. An existing farm meets the equity test with cash or with documented contributions to eligible costs. The lender certifies the equity at closing against a closing balance sheet [3].
Technical and environmental feasibility
The technical case rests on three documents that must agree with one another: the energy audit, the solar production model and the engineer's technical report.
- Dryer. The audit measures the existing dryer's fuel use per pound of water removed from metered propane deliveries, bushel counts and moisture logs, not from a nameplate. The replacement's rating comes from the manufacturer and is adjusted for the site's grain, ambient air and operating practice. The study confirms the new dryer is commercially available new equipment (used equipment is ineligible for a REAP loan [3]), that the wet-holding and leg capacity match its throughput, and that the electrical service can carry the variable-speed fans.
- Solar. A structural review confirms the roofs can carry the array and snow loads. The production model uses the exact azimuth, tilt and shading of each roof. The interconnection agreement and export tariff come from the serving utility. Every module, inverter and racking component needs a country-of-origin record, because a solar system with any component from a foreign adversary cannot receive a grant [1].
- Installer. For a grant, the installer must be licensed in the state and have at least three similar installations, and procurement follows 2 CFR 200.318 to 200.327 [1].
- Environmental. A dryer replacement on an existing pad and a rooftop array disturb little ground, but REAP grants carry environmental review requirements [1], and the study should place that review in the schedule. The engineer's completion certificate is required for projects of $200,000 or more [1].
- Cropland. The rooftop location matters. Had the farm put the array in a field, a ground-mounted system on Cropland as defined in 7 CFR 718.2 would be ineligible for a REAP grant, and a later retrofit of such a system would be too [1]. That bar applies to grants, not to REAP guaranteed loans [3].
Management and governance feasibility
The study assesses whether the operation can run the new dryer at its rated efficiency and keep the records REAP now depends on. Points it covers: who operates the dryer at harvest and how they are trained on the new controls; the maintenance schedule for burners, fans and heat-recovery surfaces; who watches the solar monitoring portal and acts on faults; and who keeps the twelve months of post-installation data a grant application must show [1]. Ownership matters too. A REAP grant counts applications per highest-level owner, including entities its owners own, and requires site ownership or a lease of at least 12 months before the Project Period [1]. If the farm operates through several entities, the study names the applicant, the site owner and any lease between them, and screens all of them under 5001.127 (federal judgments, delinquent federal debt, debarment, and the gambling and other income tests) [3]. Part 5001 treats an applicant as an agricultural producer when at least 50% of its gross income, averaged over five years, comes from agricultural operations [3]; the study shows the income history that supports that status, or treats the applicant as a rural small business instead.
Economic and community impact (modelled)
| Measure (modelled) | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Propane no longer burned each year | 36,347 gallons (3,326 MMBtu) | Dryer savings table |
| Grid electricity displaced each year | 128,550 kWh | Dryer fan savings plus year-1 solar output |
| Energy spending retained by the farm, year 1 | $76,174 | Pro forma, before O&M |
| Energy spending retained over a 15-year loan term | $1,316,061 | 2% propane and 2.5% power escalation, 0.5% solar degradation |
| Construction spend likely to go to regional trades | $244,000 | Site work, electrical, piping, removal, about 30% of solar installation as labour, structural and interconnection |
| Share of eligible cost spent locally | 22% | Of the modelled total eligible cost |
| Permanent jobs added | None claimed | An efficiency and self-supply project keeps an existing operation competitive; it is not a hiring project |
The community case for a project like this is energy dollars kept on the farm and spent locally. On the model, the farm stops buying 36,347 gallons of propane a year, keeps about $1.32 million of energy spending over a 15-year loan term and puts about $244,000 of its construction budget into regional trades. The study should not claim new permanent jobs. Its honest claim is that a lower drying cost keeps an existing operation, and the grain it handles, competitive. REAP's 2026 scoring rewards energy saved per award dollar, the share of energy replaced and environmental benefits [1], and the modelled figures above are the evidence base for those points if a grant is sought later.
Risks and mitigants
| Risk | Effect on the case | Mitigant the study documents |
|---|---|---|
| Dry harvests reduce drying volume | Savings fall by a third or more in a dry year | Multi-year baseline per bushel-point; global coverage test; no reliance on one season |
| Propane price falls | Savings and payback weaken | Price sensitivity; break-even at $2.38 a gallon for project-level 1.00x; farm carries the loan |
| Replacement dryer underperforms its rating | Savings shortfall | Performance guarantee in the purchase contract; commissioning test at first harvest |
| Installation misses harvest | Year-one savings lost, extra interest | Early equipment order, summer installation, completion before harvest in the contract |
| Export credit lower than assumed | Solar payback exceeds module life | Sizing to on-site use; export-credit sensitivity; tariff review date noted |
| Snow or roof structure limits the array | Lower output or added cost | Structural review; snow-loss allowance in the performance ratio |
| Foreign-adversary component in the array | Solar grant ineligible | Country-of-origin list before purchase |
| Grant not awarded or delayed | Owner bridge not repaid | Structure A as base case; grant treated only as upside |
| One-application-per-year rule | Dryer and solar cannot share one grant year | Sequence applications; confirm with the state office |
| Interest rate rises before closing | Higher debt service | Fixed rate; rate sensitivity; Agency approval of any rate change between commitment and closing [3] |
| Gambling or other ineligible income in an affiliated entity | Grant bar | Screen all entities under 5001.127 and the 2026 grant rule |
What the five Part 5001 components showed
The feasibility study elements in Appendix A to subpart D of part 5001 [10] give the study its structure. For a project of this kind, on the model:
| Component | What it tests here | What the modelled study shows |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Inputs (grain volume, moisture, propane, power), contracts and cost against benefit | Savings of $67,058 a year on the dryer and $9,116 from the array; dryer payback 13.1 years |
| Market | Whether the energy has a use and the avoided costs are durable | All solar output offsets site load or is credited under the tariff; drying cost falls by $0.134 a bushel |
| Technical | Commercial availability, installer record, equipment life, construction risk | New commercially available equipment; rooftop array off cropland; installation between harvests |
| Financial | Repayment source, equity, sensitivity | Project-level coverage 0.75x; global coverage 1.47x; 25% owner contribution |
| Management | Operation, maintenance, monitoring and reporting | Named operator, maintenance plan, data retention for a later grant |
Why studies like this are returned
- Savings claimed from a single harvest, usually the wettest on record.
- A baseline built from the dryer nameplate rather than metered propane and bushels.
- Solar output modelled at nameplate or with no snow and soiling losses.
- Export credited at the retail rate without tariff support.
- Debt service shown as covered by the grant, or by energy savings alone.
- A loan sized above 75% of eligible costs, or a grant planned on top of a 75% loan.
- No country-of-origin record for solar components.
- An energy audit, technical report and study that use different costs or outputs.
Program terms that applied
| Term | REAP guaranteed loan (FY2026) | B&I guaranteed loan under $5 million (FY2026) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guarantee | 80% | 85% | 91 FR 11272 [4] |
| Upfront guarantee fee | 1.0% of the guaranteed portion | 3.0% | [4] |
| Annual retention fee | 0.25% of guaranteed principal outstanding | 0.55% | [4] |
| Extra fee if the guarantee issues before construction is complete | 0.50% | 0.50% | [4] |
| Loan size | $5,000 to 75% of eligible project costs; $25 million per borrower | Up to $25 million per borrower | 5001.406(c), (d) [3] |
| Borrower money | At least 25% of eligible project costs | 10% (existing business) to 25% (new business with construction) | 5001.406(d); 5001.105(d) [3] |
| Term | Useful life, at most 40 years, no balloon | Same | 5001.402 [3] |
| Rate | Negotiated; fixed, variable or both | Same | 5001.401 [3] |
| Rural test | Outside cities over 50,000 and their contiguous urbanized areas (latest decennial census) | Same | 5001.3 [3] |
| Gambling screen | More than 15% of gross revenue from gambling bars the loan | Same | 5001.127(b) [3] |
| Feasibility study | When the lender or Agency deems it necessary; technical report required | Required over $1,000,000 to a new business | 5001.306(a)(3), 5001.307 [3] |
Fees are charged on the guaranteed portion: the REAP guarantee fee is the loan times the 80% guarantee times 1.0%, and the annual retention fee is 0.25% of guaranteed principal outstanding at the end of December [4]. These FY2026 rates apply to loans obligated in FY2026 unless a later appropriation changes them [4]. The loan in this engagement was prepared under earlier notices, so a current borrower should confirm the rates for the year of obligation. B&I is shown for comparison only. The 2026 CFR still lists solar and other renewable energy systems as B&I uses where REAP cannot finance them or REAP funds are unavailable (5001.105(b)(21)) [3]. A USDA press release of 19 August 2025 announced a policy on solar on farmland, so ask the Rural Development state office before planning a B&I guarantee for a solar project.
Lessons for sponsors of similar projects
- Lead with the dryer. On these assumptions the efficiency project carries the economics, with a payback of 13.1 years. The array adds a smaller, thinner-margin benefit and should be sized to on-site use, not to roof area.
- Build the baseline from several harvests. Gather three or more years of propane invoices, scale tickets and moisture logs before the audit starts. A per-bushel-point baseline survives a reviewer's questions; a single-season saving does not.
- Plan for 25% of your own money. A REAP guaranteed loan alone stops at 75% of eligible cost, and a later grant cannot be stacked on top of a 75% loan.
- Treat the grant as a later reward. Under the 2026 rule the grant arrives, if at all, after a full season of metered results and a national competition. Underwrite without it.
- Keep the array on a roof, and know its parts. A roof location avoids the cropland bar, and a country-of-origin list avoids the foreign-component bar.
- Install between harvests. The single most costly delay is a dryer that misses the first fall.
- Sequence applications. One grant application per fiscal year per highest-level owner means a dual project may need two years of applications; confirm with the state office.
- Model the farm, not just the project. The lender's decision rests on global coverage, so give the analyst historical financial statements and existing debt schedules at kickoff.
Related pages
- USDA REAP engagements: the program page for this engagement type.
- Renewable energy feasibility study for USDA loans and the USDA REAP feasibility study page: the 2026 rule in full.
- Industrial and manufacturing feasibility study for USDA loans: the national page for the asset class this engagement is indexed under.
- Montana USDA feasibility studies, with the Montana solar energy feasibility study and Montana manufacturing feasibility study pages.
- Case studies and the full engagement index.
- USDA feasibility study cost and timeline.
A REAP study for a loan above $600,000 is listed on the site's cost page at $7,500 to $11,500 and 5 to 7 weeks, and below $600,000 at $4,900 to $8,500 and 4 to 5 weeks, each as a firm fixed fee in a written proposal [11]. For a dryer, solar or combined REAP project in Montana or elsewhere, an independent USDA feasibility study consultant can scope the audit, production model and credit case together.
Request a scoped proposal for your REAP feasibility study at the contact page.
USDA Feasibility, Inc.